Malaysian Banking Law – Difference Between a Bank and a Financial Service Provider
General Overview
Modern financial systems include both banks and financial service providers. Although both offer financial-related services, they are not legally the same. A bank performs core banking activities such as accepting deposits and granting loans, while a financial service provider usually offers specialised financial services without operating fully as a licensed bank.
Technological development and digital finance have blurred the distinction between these institutions. Therefore, understanding the differences between a bank and a financial service provider is important in Malaysian banking law.


Bank
Definition
A bank is a licensed financial institution that carries on banking business. Its traditional functions include accepting deposits, honouring cheques, and granting loans.


Main Functions

• Accepts deposits from the public.
• Provides loans and financing facilities.
• Operates savings and current accounts.
• Facilitates payments and money transfers.
• Provides trade finance and investment services.

Legal Status
A bank is legally recognised as carrying on banking business and is subject to strict banking laws and financial regulations.


Regulation
Banks in Malaysia are supervised and regulated by Bank Negara Malaysia under laws such as the Financial Services Act 2013.


Examples of Banks
Examples of banks in Malaysia include:

• Malayan Banking Berhad
• CIMB Bank Berhad
• Public Bank Berhad
• RHB Bank Berhad

Financial Service Provider
Definition
A financial service provider is a company that offers financial-related services but may not legally qualify as a bank because it does not perform the full range of banking activities.


Main Functions

• Provides specialised financial services.
• May offer insurance, investments, remittance, or digital payment services.
• Usually does not accept public deposits like traditional banks.
• May provide electronic wallets or online financial platforms.

Legal Status
A financial service provider may carry out financial activities without being legally classified as a bank.


Regulation
These institutions are regulated according to the type of financial service they provide. Some may still fall under the supervision of Bank Negara Malaysia or other regulatory authorities.


Examples of Financial Service Providers
Examples include:

• Boost – digital wallet and e-payment services.
• Touch ’n Go eWallet – mobile and digital payment services.
• AIA Malaysia – insurance and financial protection services.
• Western Union – remittance and money transfer services.
• Rakuten Trade – investment and share trading services.

Key Differences in Note Form
Bank

• Accepts public deposits.
• Provides loans and financing.
• Maintains customer savings and current accounts.
• Forms part of the official banking system.
• Subject to strict banking regulation.
• Provides full banking services.

Financial Service Provider

• Provides selected financial services only.
• Usually does not accept deposits from the public.
• May focus on digital payments, insurance, investments, or remittance.
• May not legally qualify as a bank.
• Regulation depends on the type of service provided.
• Often operates through financial technology platforms.

Application in a Case Scenario
Scenario
A company called PayLink offers mobile payment services, online money transfers, and digital wallets through a smartphone application. Customers can store electronic money and make digital payments using the application. However, PayLink does not accept savings deposits or provide traditional banking accounts.
A legal issue arises regarding whether PayLink should legally be considered a bank. The court may examine whether the company performs core banking activities such as accepting public deposits and lending money. Even though PayLink provides financial services, it may still be classified only as a financial service provider rather than a bank.
This situation shows that not all financial institutions automatically qualify as banks under banking law.


Critical Analysis
The distinction between banks and financial service providers has become increasingly unclear because of technological advancements. Many financial technology companies now provide services similar to banks, including digital payments and financing facilities.
This creates regulatory challenges because some companies may perform banking-like activities without being subject to the same strict legal requirements as licensed banks. As a result, customers may face greater risks when using unregulated or lightly regulated financial platforms.
Another concern is customer confusion. Consumers may assume that all financial institutions provide equal legal protection, even though licensed banks generally offer stronger financial safeguards and regulatory supervision.
The law must therefore balance innovation with consumer protection. Regulators such as Bank Negara Malaysia play an important role in ensuring that financial institutions operate safely and responsibly.


Unresolved Issues
Regulation of FinTech Companies
Many digital financial companies provide banking-like services, but uncertainty remains regarding whether they should legally be treated as banks.


Consumer Protection
Customers may not fully understand the legal differences between banks and financial service providers, especially concerning deposit protection and financial security.


Cryptocurrency and Digital Finance
Cryptocurrency platforms and decentralised finance systems continue to challenge traditional banking concepts and legal regulations.


Conclusion
Banks and financial service providers both contribute to the financial system, but they are legally different institutions. Banks perform core banking activities such as deposit-taking and lending, while financial service providers usually focus on specialised financial services. As technology continues to transform the financial industry, the distinction between these institutions becomes increasingly complex, making legal regulation and interpretation essential in Malaysian banking law.

​

Malaysian Banking Law – Essential Characteristics of Banking Business
General Overview
The courts have recognised that banking is not limited to traditional activities such as collecting cheques or operating current accounts. Instead, the true nature of banking depends on the essential functions carried out by the institution. One important case explaining this principle is State Savings Bank of Victoria, Commissioners v Permewan, Wright & Co Ltd.
In this case, the High Court of Australia explained that a bank acts as a “financial reservoir.” A bank receives money from customers and uses those funds to support commercial, industrial, and other economic activities through lending and financing.
The court further stated that the essential business of banking involves:

• Receiving money through deposits,
• Holding money repayable according to agreement, and
• Using the collected funds by lending them to others.

Therefore, the core function of banking is the collection and utilisation of money rather than the specific methods used to conduct banking transactions.


Essential Characteristics of Banking
Collection of Money Through Deposits
One of the main characteristics of banking is the acceptance of deposits from customers. Customers place money with the bank either for safekeeping or investment purposes.
These deposits may include:

• Savings accounts,
• Fixed deposit accounts,
• Deposit accounts repayable at call, or
• Other agreed forms of deposits.

The court emphasised that banks are not legally required to maintain current accounts only. Banks may operate using various types of deposit arrangements.


Repayment of Deposits
Banks receive money on the understanding that the funds will be repaid according to the agreement between the bank and customer. Repayment may occur:

• On demand,
• At a fixed date,
• In part, or
• According to agreed conditions.

This repayment obligation forms an important legal aspect of the banker–customer relationship.


Utilisation of Deposits Through Lending
Banks do not merely store money. They also utilise deposited funds by lending money to businesses, individuals, and commercial enterprises.
Examples include:

• Housing loans,
• Business financing,
• Personal loans,
• Trade financing, and
• Investment financing.

The court recognised lending as a fundamental banking activity because it supports economic and commercial growth.


Methods of Banking Are Auxiliary
The court explained that many banking methods are merely auxiliary or incidental to the banking business. These methods may differ depending on business needs and technological developments.
Examples include:

• Current accounts,
• Cheques,
• Deposit accounts,
• Secured loans,
• Discounting bills,
• Letters of credit,
• Telegraphic transfers,
• Internet banking,
• Mobile banking,
• Digital payments.

The court stated that the existence or absence of these services does not necessarily determine whether an institution is legally carrying on banking business.


Meaning of “Financial Reservoir”
The court described a bank as a “financial reservoir” because banks collect money from many customers and redistribute those funds into the economy through lending and financing activities.
This process:

• Supports trade and commerce,
• Encourages industrial development,
• Promotes investments, and
• Contributes to economic growth.

Banks therefore play an essential role in the modern financial system.


Note Form – Essential Characteristics of Banking
Banking Business Includes:

• Receiving deposits from customers.
• Holding money repayable under agreement.
• Lending money to individuals and businesses.
• Supporting economic and commercial activities.
• Acting as a financial intermediary.

Banking Methods May Include:

• Current accounts.
• Savings accounts.
• Fixed deposits.
• Cheques.
• Loans and financing.
• Letters of credit.
• Telegraphic transfers.
• Internet banking.
• Digital and mobile payments.

Important Principle
The method used by the institution is not the most important factor. The real test is whether the institution substantially carries on the business of receiving deposits and utilising those funds through lending activities.


Application in a Case Scenario
Scenario
A company called FinServe accepts deposits from customers through digital accounts and later uses the money to provide financing to small businesses. However, the company does not issue cheques or maintain traditional current accounts.
A legal dispute arises regarding whether FinServe is carrying on banking business. The court may apply the principles from State Savings Bank of Victoria, Commissioners v Permewan, Wright & Co Ltd to determine whether the company’s essential activities amount to banking.
Even though FinServe does not provide traditional banking methods such as cheques, it may still legally qualify as carrying on banking business because it receives deposits and lends money.


Critical Analysis
The case demonstrates that banking law focuses on the substance of banking activities rather than the form or method used. This flexible approach allows courts to adapt banking law to changing financial practices and technological developments.
However, modern financial technology creates new legal challenges. Many digital platforms now perform functions similar to banks without operating as traditional banking institutions. This creates uncertainty regarding licensing, regulation, and customer protection.
Another issue is that financial companies may attempt to avoid strict banking regulations by arguing that they do not provide traditional banking services such as current accounts or cheque facilities. Courts must therefore examine the true nature of the business activities carried out.
The decision also highlights the importance of regulation by Bank Negara Malaysia to ensure that institutions engaging in banking-like activities comply with legal and financial requirements.


Unresolved Issues
Digital Banking and FinTech
Modern digital finance companies may perform deposit-taking and lending activities without clearly falling within traditional banking definitions.


Regulatory Gaps
Some financial institutions may carry on banking-like activities without being subject to the same strict regulations imposed on licensed banks.


Consumer Protection
Customers may not fully understand whether their funds are protected when dealing with digital financial institutions that are not licensed banks.


Conclusion
The case of State Savings Bank of Victoria, Commissioners v Permewan, Wright & Co Ltd establishes that the essential characteristics of banking are the receipt of deposits and the utilisation of those funds through lending and financing activities. The methods used by banks, such as cheques or current accounts, are only auxiliary features. This flexible interpretation allows banking law to adapt to changing financial systems while ensuring that institutions performing true banking functions are properly recognised and regulated.

​

KembaraXtra – Legal Terms – Patent
A patent is a legal grant giving an inventor the exclusive right to exploit an invention for a limited period.
In the United Kingdom, patents are granted through the  Intellectual Property Office (IPO).
To obtain a patent, the invention must be new, non-obvious, and capable of industrial application.
A patent normally lasts for 20 years from the filing date, provided renewal fees continue to be paid.
If another person infringes the patent, the patentee may seek remedies such as an injunction, damages, or an account of profits.

​

Malaysian Banking Law – Nature and Business of Banking
Banking as Part of Modern Society
Banking plays an important role in modern trade, commerce, and economic activities. It is an essential part of society because businesses, governments, and individuals depend on banking services for financial transactions, savings, investments, and credit facilities. Without banks, commercial activities and economic growth would be difficult to sustain.
Courts have recognised the importance of banking in supporting economic and social development. Because banking activities are closely connected to trade and commerce, the law treats banking as a significant commercial activity that affects the entire financial system.


Judicial Definitions of Banking Business
Commonwealth of Australia v Bank of New South Wales
In Commonwealth of Australia v Bank of New South Wales, the court stated that the business of banking includes:

• The creation and transfer of credit,
• The granting of loans,
• The purchase and disposal of investments, and
• Other related financial activities.

This definition shows that banking is not limited to accepting deposits. Banks also create financial credit, provide financing facilities, and engage in investment-related activities. Therefore, banking involves a broad range of commercial and financial services.


Commercial Banking Co of Sydney Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation
In Commercial Banking Co of Sydney Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation, the High Court held that the principal business of a bank is the lending of money.
This case highlights the importance of loans and credit facilities in banking operations. Lending money allows banks to support businesses, investments, housing, and consumer spending, which are important for economic development.


Re Securitibank (in liquidation)
In the New Zealand case of Re Securitibank (in liquidation), certain companies described themselves as merchant bankers and were involved in short-term money market activities, bills markets, and various financial services. However, the court decided that these companies were not “carrying on the business of banking” for the purpose of exemption under the Moneylenders Act 1908.
This case demonstrates that not every financial activity automatically amounts to banking business. Even if a company provides financial services or uses the word “banker,” the court may still decide that the company is not legally operating as a bank.


Characteristics of Banking Business
Creation and Transfer of Credit
Banks create credit by lending money to customers. When banks approve loans or financing facilities, they increase the flow of money within the economy. Banks also transfer credit through payment systems, electronic banking, and financial transactions.


Lending of Money
One of the main functions of banks is lending money to individuals and businesses. Loans may include personal loans, housing loans, business financing, and credit card facilities. Lending activities generate profit for banks through interest or financing charges.


Investment Activities
Banks also engage in investment-related activities, including the buying and selling of securities, shares, bonds, and financial instruments. Modern banks may provide investment advice and wealth management services to customers.


Other Related Financial Activities
Modern banks perform many additional activities such as internet banking, mobile payments, foreign exchange transactions, insurance services, and trade financing. These activities show that banking is broader than traditional deposit-taking functions.


Application in a Case Scenario
Scenario
Daniel establishes a financial company that provides short-term financing, investment advice, and foreign exchange services. The company also advertises itself as a “merchant bank.” However, it does not accept public deposits like traditional banks.
A legal dispute arises regarding whether Daniel’s company should legally be classified as a bank. The court may examine the principles established in Re Securitibank (in liquidation) to determine whether the company is truly carrying on banking business or merely engaging in financial activities.
This scenario shows that the legal definition of banking depends on the actual nature of the activities carried out rather than the title used by the company.


Critical Analysis
The cases show that banking is a broad and evolving concept. Modern banks perform many functions beyond accepting deposits and granting loans. Technological advancements and financial innovations continue to expand the meaning of banking business.
However, the absence of a precise definition may create uncertainty. Some financial institutions perform banking-like activities without being fully regulated as banks. This may expose customers to financial risks if such institutions are not properly supervised.
Another issue is the growth of financial technology companies and digital finance platforms. Many of these companies provide services similar to banks, such as electronic payments and lending facilities, but they may not fall clearly within traditional banking definitions.
The courts therefore play an important role in determining whether certain financial activities amount to banking business. At the same time, regulators such as Bank Negara Malaysia must ensure that financial institutions operate safely and comply with banking laws.


Unresolved Issues
One unresolved issue concerns the distinction between banks and financial service providers. Modern financial institutions often provide similar services, making it difficult to determine whether they should legally be treated as banks.
Another issue relates to digital banking and financial technology. Online platforms, digital wallets, and cryptocurrency businesses continue to challenge traditional banking concepts and legal regulations.
There is also concern regarding regulatory gaps. Some companies may perform banking-related activities without being subject to the same strict regulations imposed on licensed banks, potentially creating risks for consumers and the financial system.


Conclusion
Banking is an essential part of modern trade, commerce, and economic development. Courts have recognised that banking includes the creation of credit, lending of money, investment activities, and other related financial services. Cases such as Commonwealth of Australia v Bank of New South Wales, Commercial Banking Co of Sydney Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation, and Re Securitibank (in liquidation) demonstrate that the definition of banking depends on the actual nature of the activities carried out. As financial services continue to evolve, banking law must also adapt to modern economic and technological developments.

​

KembaraXtra – Legal Terms – Payment in Lieu of Notice (PILON)
A payment in lieu of notice (PILON) is a payment made to an employee instead of requiring the employee to work during the notice period after termination of employment.
The payment is intended to compensate the employee for the earnings and benefits that would have been received during the notice period.
PILON clauses are commonly included in contracts of employment to allow employers to terminate employment immediately.
A properly drafted PILON clause should specify the circumstances in which it may be used and what payments are included.
If no contractual PILON clause exists, the payment may potentially amount to damages for breach of contract.

​

​KembaraXtra – Legal Terms – Payment into Court


Payment into court refers to the payment by a defendant into a court-controlled account as settlement of all or part of a claim in civil proceedings.


The procedure is designed to encourage settlement without proceeding to trial.


Under the Civil Procedure Rules, payment into court is now generally dealt with under the Part 36 procedure.


If the claimant rejects the payment and later fails to obtain a better judgment at trial, adverse costs consequences may follow.


The mechanism promotes efficiency and reduces unnecessary litigation expenses.

KembaraXtra – Legal Terms – Patient Lacking Capacity
A patient lacking capacity is a person who is unable to make decisions for himself because of an impairment or disturbance affecting the mind or brain.
The assessment concerns whether the patient can understand, retain, use, or communicate relevant information regarding a decision.
Where a patient lacks capacity, decisions must generally be made in the person’s best interests.
The legal framework governing such decisions is principally contained in the Mental Capacity Act 2005.
Issues commonly arise in relation to medical treatment, financial management, and personal welfare decisions.

​

​KembaraXtra – Legal Terms – Patient with Capacity


A patient with capacity is a person who is legally capable of making his or her own medical and personal decisions.


Capacity requires the ability to understand, retain, and weigh relevant information and communicate a decision.


Adults are generally presumed to have capacity unless proven otherwise.


A patient with capacity has the legal right to consent to or refuse medical treatment.


Healthcare professionals must respect the patient’s autonomous decisions even where refusal may lead to serious consequences.

KembaraXtra – Legal Terms – Paternity Leave
Paternity leave is statutory leave granted to qualifying employees following the birth or adoption of a child.
Eligible employees may usually take one or two consecutive weeks of leave.
To qualify, the employee must generally have worked continuously for the employer for at least 26 weeks before the qualifying date.
Employees on paternity leave are commonly entitled to statutory paternity pay subject to statutory limits and conditions.
The law also protects employees from dismissal or unfair treatment connected with taking paternity leave.

​

KembaraXtra – Legal Terms – Payroll Deduction Scheme
A payroll deduction scheme is an arrangement allowing employees to donate part of their salary directly to charity through deductions made by the employer.
The donation is deducted before income tax is calculated.
This arrangement provides tax relief for charitable contributions.
Employers transfer the deducted amount to approved charitable organizations on behalf of employees.
The scheme is governed by provisions such as the Finance Act 2000.

​