KembaraXtra-Case Law-Rampharry (1999) PC - Proportionality in Provocation
KembaraXtra-Case Law-Rampharry (1999) PC - Proportionality in Provocation Case Citation: Rampharry (1999) PC Facts: • The defendant (D) accused his ex-wife of promiscuity. • D alleged his ex-wife thrust a knife in his face, leading to a struggle. • D
KembaraXtra-Horrex (1999) - Provocation & "Characteristics"
KembaraXtra-Horrex (1999) - Provocation & "Characteristics" Case Facts: • Parties: D, V, and G were vagrants residing in Oxford. • Relationship Dynamics: • D had a strong emotional bond with G, viewing her as a "mother figure." • D and V were engage
KembaraXtra-Case Law-Smith (1998) - Provocation & Loss of Control
KembaraXtra-Case Law-Smith (1998) - Provocation & Loss of Control Core Principle: This case clarifies the role of the defendant's individual characteristics in assessing loss of control in the context of provocation (now loss of control under the Coroner
Kembaraxtra- Case Law- Luc Thiet-Thuan (1996)
Kembaraxtra- Case Law- Luc Thiet-Thuan (1996) Citation: Luc Thiet-Thuan (1996) PC Facts: • D robbed his ex-girlfriend (V) with others. • During an altercation, D stabbed and killed V. • Evidence showed D was prone to loss of control when provoked due
Kembaraxtra-Case Law-Morhall (1995) - Provocation & Manslaughter
Kembaraxtra-Case Law-Morhall (1995) - Provocation & Manslaughter Citation: Morhall (1995) Area of Law: Provocation, Manslaughter, Murder, Objective Test Facts: • Defendant (D) was addicted to glue sniffing. • Victim (V) persistently nagged D about hi
KembaraXtra-Case Law-R v Egan (1992) - Intoxication and Abnormality of Mind
KembaraXtra-Case Law-R v Egan (1992) - Intoxication and Abnormality of Mind I. Case Citation: R v Egan (1992) (California, likely referencing a similar common law principle) II. Facts: • Defendant (D): Allegedly mentally unstable and intoxicated. • Cr
KembaraXtra-Case Law- R v Clarke (1991)
KembaraXtra-Case Law- R v Clarke (1991) I. Case Overview • Citation: R v Clarke (1991) • Area of Law: Causation in Criminal Law, Murder II. Facts of the Case • Victim (V): Informed her boyfriend (D) she was having an abortion. • Defendant (D): • R
KembaraXtra-Case Law- Johnson (1989) CA - Provocation
KembaraXtra-Case Law- Johnson (1989) CA - Provocation I. Case Summary: Citation: Johnson (1989) CA (Court of Appeal) Parties: D (Defendant), V (Victim) Facts: D and V were at a nightclub. V's girlfriend taunted D. D threatened both V and his girlfriend. V
Kembaraxtra-Case Law-Doughty (1986) - Provocation & Infanticide
Kembaraxtra-Case Law-Doughty (1986) - Provocation & Infanticide Case Overview: • Citation: Doughty (1986) • Court: CA (Court of Appeal) Facts: • The defendant (D) killed his 17-day-old son. • D's Defense: Provocation stemming from the baby's persis
KembaraXtra-Newell (1980) - Provocation & Intoxication
KembaraXtra-Newell (1980) - Provocation & Intoxication Case Facts: • Defendant (D): Chronic alcoholic. • Victim (V): Friend of D. • Incident: D killed V by battery after V insulted D's former cohabitee. Court Ruling: • D was found guilty of murder.