- Published on
Equity and Trust – Can Multiple Personal Remedies Be Claimed Together?
Case Scenario
The trustees of the Morgan Family Trust hold:
£2 million
for the benefit of several beneficiaries.
One trustee, Daniel, improperly transfers:
£500,000
from the trust into an overseas investment account in breach of trust.
Daniel works together with:
£300,000
knowing it came from a breach of trust.
Michael invests the money and later earns:
£120,000 profit.
The remaining:
£200,000
is lost completely in a failed investment and cannot be traced.
The beneficiaries want to know:
Short Answer
Yes — beneficiaries may often claim multiple personal remedies together.
However:
Main Principle
A claimant may simultaneously plead:
✅ full restoration of the trust
❌ no overcompensation
1. Equitable Compensation
Definition
Equitable compensation is a personal remedy designed to restore beneficiaries to the position they would have occupied had the breach not occurred.
It focuses on:
the claimant’s loss.
Application to the Scenario
The trust lost:
£500,000
However:
£200,000
because that portion of the trust fund is permanently lost.
Purpose of Equitable Compensation
The aim is to:
2. Knowing Receipt
Definition
Knowing receipt arises where a third party receives trust property knowing it was transferred in breach of trust.
Application to the Scenario
Michael knowingly received:
£300,000
from the trust.
The beneficiaries may sue Michael personally for knowing receipt.
Possible Recovery
Michael may be personally liable to restore:
£300,000
to the trust.
3. Account of Profits
Definition
An account of profits strips profits made from misuse of trust property.
It focuses on:
the defendant’s gain.
Application to the Scenario
Michael used the trust money to earn:
£120,000 profit.
The beneficiaries may claim:
Why?
Because the profit arose entirely from misuse of trust assets.
Equity prevents fiduciaries and knowing recipients from retaining unauthorised gains.
4. Dishonest Assistance
Definition
Dishonest assistance arises where a third party dishonestly assists a breach of trust.
Application to the Scenario
Sarah, the solicitor, helped conceal the breach.
Even though she never received the money personally, she may still be personally liable for dishonest assistance.
Can All These Remedies Be Claimed Together?
Yes — Procedurally
The beneficiaries may plead all claims together:
But Recovery Is Controlled
The court prevents duplicate recovery.
The beneficiaries cannot recover:
❌ £300,000 twice from different defendants.
Practical Calculation
Trust Loss
Total improperly transferred:
£500,000
Amount Recoverable From Michael
Knowing Receipt
£300,000
Account of Profits
£120,000
Total From Michael
£420,000
because:
Amount Recoverable From Daniel
Equitable Compensation
£200,000
for the irrecoverable portion of the trust fund.
Possible Liability of Sarah
Sarah may also be personally liable for dishonest assistance regarding the losses caused.
However:
Why These Remedies Can Operate Together
The remedies address different wrongs:
Equitable Compensation
Restores loss suffered by the trust.
Account of Profits
Strips wrongful gains from the defendant.
Knowing Receipt
Imposes liability for receiving trust property knowingly.
Dishonest Assistance
Imposes liability for dishonest participation in breach.
Example of Double Recovery Not Allowed
Suppose beneficiaries recover:
£300,000
from Michael.
They cannot then recover another identical:
£300,000
from Daniel for the exact same loss.
That would overcompensate the trust.
Simple Rule
Claimants May:
✅ combine remedies
✅ sue multiple defendants
✅ recover losses and profits
Claimants Cannot:
❌ recover identical sums twice
❌ obtain double compensation
❌ profit from the litigation
Key SQE Principle
Equity distinguishes between:
Compensation for Loss
and
Disgorgement of Profit.
These remedies may coexist where they remedy different consequences of wrongdoing.
Conclusion
Multiple personal remedies may often be claimed together in equity, including equitable compensation, account of profits, knowing receipt, and dishonest assistance. However, although several remedies may coexist, courts carefully prevent double recovery. Equitable compensation restores losses suffered by the trust, while account of profits strips wrongful gains obtained from misuse of trust property. Together, these remedies ensure both restoration of trust assets and fiduciary accountability without overcompensating beneficiaries.
Case Scenario
The trustees of the Morgan Family Trust hold:
£2 million
for the benefit of several beneficiaries.
One trustee, Daniel, improperly transfers:
£500,000
from the trust into an overseas investment account in breach of trust.
Daniel works together with:
- Michael, who knowingly receives part of the trust money;
- and a solicitor, Sarah, who dishonestly helps conceal the transaction.
£300,000
knowing it came from a breach of trust.
Michael invests the money and later earns:
£120,000 profit.
The remaining:
£200,000
is lost completely in a failed investment and cannot be traced.
The beneficiaries want to know:
- whether they can claim several remedies together;
- whether they must choose only one;
- and how equitable compensation, account of profits, and other personal remedies operate.
Short Answer
Yes — beneficiaries may often claim multiple personal remedies together.
However:
- they cannot recover the same loss twice;
- courts prevent double recovery;
- remedies may overlap but serve different purposes.
Main Principle
A claimant may simultaneously plead:
- equitable compensation;
- account of profits;
- knowing receipt;
- dishonest assistance;
- proprietary claims.
✅ full restoration of the trust
❌ no overcompensation
1. Equitable Compensation
Definition
Equitable compensation is a personal remedy designed to restore beneficiaries to the position they would have occupied had the breach not occurred.
It focuses on:
the claimant’s loss.
Application to the Scenario
The trust lost:
£500,000
However:
- £200,000 cannot be traced or recovered because it disappeared in the failed investment.
£200,000
because that portion of the trust fund is permanently lost.
Purpose of Equitable Compensation
The aim is to:
- restore the trust fund;
- compensate beneficiaries for loss caused by breach of trust.
2. Knowing Receipt
Definition
Knowing receipt arises where a third party receives trust property knowing it was transferred in breach of trust.
Application to the Scenario
Michael knowingly received:
£300,000
from the trust.
The beneficiaries may sue Michael personally for knowing receipt.
Possible Recovery
Michael may be personally liable to restore:
£300,000
to the trust.
3. Account of Profits
Definition
An account of profits strips profits made from misuse of trust property.
It focuses on:
the defendant’s gain.
Application to the Scenario
Michael used the trust money to earn:
£120,000 profit.
The beneficiaries may claim:
- the original £300,000;
PLUS - the £120,000 profit.
Why?
Because the profit arose entirely from misuse of trust assets.
Equity prevents fiduciaries and knowing recipients from retaining unauthorised gains.
4. Dishonest Assistance
Definition
Dishonest assistance arises where a third party dishonestly assists a breach of trust.
Application to the Scenario
Sarah, the solicitor, helped conceal the breach.
Even though she never received the money personally, she may still be personally liable for dishonest assistance.
Can All These Remedies Be Claimed Together?
Yes — Procedurally
The beneficiaries may plead all claims together:
- equitable compensation;
- knowing receipt;
- account of profits;
- dishonest assistance.
But Recovery Is Controlled
The court prevents duplicate recovery.
The beneficiaries cannot recover:
❌ £300,000 twice from different defendants.
Practical Calculation
Trust Loss
Total improperly transferred:
£500,000
Amount Recoverable From Michael
Knowing Receipt
£300,000
Account of Profits
£120,000
Total From Michael
£420,000
because:
- £300,000 restores trust property;
- £120,000 removes wrongful profit.
Amount Recoverable From Daniel
Equitable Compensation
£200,000
for the irrecoverable portion of the trust fund.
Possible Liability of Sarah
Sarah may also be personally liable for dishonest assistance regarding the losses caused.
However:
- beneficiaries cannot recover the same £200,000 twice.
Why These Remedies Can Operate Together
The remedies address different wrongs:
Equitable Compensation
Restores loss suffered by the trust.
Account of Profits
Strips wrongful gains from the defendant.
Knowing Receipt
Imposes liability for receiving trust property knowingly.
Dishonest Assistance
Imposes liability for dishonest participation in breach.
Example of Double Recovery Not Allowed
Suppose beneficiaries recover:
£300,000
from Michael.
They cannot then recover another identical:
£300,000
from Daniel for the exact same loss.
That would overcompensate the trust.
Simple Rule
Claimants May:
✅ combine remedies
✅ sue multiple defendants
✅ recover losses and profits
Claimants Cannot:
❌ recover identical sums twice
❌ obtain double compensation
❌ profit from the litigation
Key SQE Principle
Equity distinguishes between:
Compensation for Loss
and
Disgorgement of Profit.
These remedies may coexist where they remedy different consequences of wrongdoing.
Conclusion
Multiple personal remedies may often be claimed together in equity, including equitable compensation, account of profits, knowing receipt, and dishonest assistance. However, although several remedies may coexist, courts carefully prevent double recovery. Equitable compensation restores losses suffered by the trust, while account of profits strips wrongful gains obtained from misuse of trust property. Together, these remedies ensure both restoration of trust assets and fiduciary accountability without overcompensating beneficiaries.
0 Comments