- Published on
Indian Evidence Law – Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023Primary Evidence [Section 57]
Section 57: Meaning of Primary Evidence
Section 57 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 defines primary evidence as the document itself produced before the Court for inspection. The expression “itself” signifies that the original document or original data must be produced by the party relying upon it.
The purpose of producing primary evidence is to enable the Court to directly inspect the originality, authenticity, and contents of the document. This provision is founded on the Best Evidence Rule, which requires that the best available evidence within the power and possession of the party must be placed before the Court.
As a general rule, the contents of a written document must be proved by the document itself so long as it exists. Where documentary evidence is available, oral evidence cannot substitute it and carries no evidentiary weight.
IllustrationWhere the dispute relates to the contents of a contract, sale deed, or gift deed and the document itself is produced before the Court, such document constitutes primary evidence.
(a) Primary Evidence Where a Document Is Executed in Several Parts(Explanation 1)
Where a document is executed in several identical parts, each part constitutes primary evidence of the document. Such execution is generally done for convenience and record-keeping.
Judicially, carbon copies prepared through the same process as the original and signed by the parties have been recognised as original documents and treated as primary evidence.
Examples
(b) Primary Evidence Where a Document Is Executed in Counterparts(Explanation 2)
Where a document is executed in counterparts, each counterpart is signed by one or some of the parties and exchanged between them.
IllustrationAn instrument signed by A and delivered to B is:
(c) Primary Evidence Where Documents Are Made by One Uniform Process(Explanation 3)
Where several documents are produced by one uniform process, such as printing, lithography, or photography, each document is primary evidence of the contents of the others.
However, where all such documents are merely copies of a common original, they do not constitute primary evidence of the original document, though they may be primary evidence inter se.
Examples
(d) Primary Evidence of Electronic or Digital Records Stored in Multiple Files(Explanation 4 – Newly Inserted)
Where an electronic or digital record is created or stored simultaneously or sequentially in multiple files, each such file is treated as primary evidence.
Examples
(e) Primary Evidence Where Electronic or Digital Record Is Produced from Proper Custody(Explanation 5 – Newly Inserted)
Where an electronic or digital record is produced from proper custody, it shall be treated as primary evidence, unless its authenticity is disputed.
Examples
(f) Primary Evidence of Video Recordings Stored and Transmitted Simultaneously(Explanation 6)
Where a video recording is simultaneously stored in electronic form and transmitted, broadcast, or transferred, each stored recording constitutes primary evidence.
Examples
(g) Primary Evidence Where Electronic Record Is Stored in Multiple Storage Spaces(Explanation 7 – Newly Inserted)
Where an electronic or digital record is stored in multiple storage spaces within a computer resource, each automated storage, including temporary files, is treated as primary evidence.
Examples
Conclusion (Exam-Ready)
Primary evidence under Section 57 represents the original and best form of proof of documentary and electronic records, ensuring authenticity, reliability, and direct judicial inspection under the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023.
Section 57: Meaning of Primary Evidence
Section 57 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 defines primary evidence as the document itself produced before the Court for inspection. The expression “itself” signifies that the original document or original data must be produced by the party relying upon it.
The purpose of producing primary evidence is to enable the Court to directly inspect the originality, authenticity, and contents of the document. This provision is founded on the Best Evidence Rule, which requires that the best available evidence within the power and possession of the party must be placed before the Court.
As a general rule, the contents of a written document must be proved by the document itself so long as it exists. Where documentary evidence is available, oral evidence cannot substitute it and carries no evidentiary weight.
IllustrationWhere the dispute relates to the contents of a contract, sale deed, or gift deed and the document itself is produced before the Court, such document constitutes primary evidence.
(a) Primary Evidence Where a Document Is Executed in Several Parts(Explanation 1)
Where a document is executed in several identical parts, each part constitutes primary evidence of the document. Such execution is generally done for convenience and record-keeping.
Judicially, carbon copies prepared through the same process as the original and signed by the parties have been recognised as original documents and treated as primary evidence.
Examples
- Identical copies of agreements (lease, partnership, settlement agreements) signed by all parties
- Duplicate original property deeds executed and sealed by both parties
- Multiple signed copies of a will created for safekeeping
- Identical original copies of powers of attorney
(b) Primary Evidence Where a Document Is Executed in Counterparts(Explanation 2)
Where a document is executed in counterparts, each counterpart is signed by one or some of the parties and exchanged between them.
- Each counterpart is primary evidence against the party who executed it
- As against a party who did not execute it, the same counterpart constitutes secondary evidence
IllustrationAn instrument signed by A and delivered to B is:
- Primary evidence against A
- Secondary evidence against B
(c) Primary Evidence Where Documents Are Made by One Uniform Process(Explanation 3)
Where several documents are produced by one uniform process, such as printing, lithography, or photography, each document is primary evidence of the contents of the others.
However, where all such documents are merely copies of a common original, they do not constitute primary evidence of the original document, though they may be primary evidence inter se.
Examples
- Multiple printed copies made from the same original manuscript are primary evidence of each other.
- Several photocopies of a document are primary evidence of one another but secondary evidence of the original.
- Placards printed at one time from a single original—any placard is primary evidence of the contents of another, but not of the original.
(d) Primary Evidence of Electronic or Digital Records Stored in Multiple Files(Explanation 4 – Newly Inserted)
Where an electronic or digital record is created or stored simultaneously or sequentially in multiple files, each such file is treated as primary evidence.
Examples
- Database entries stored across multiple tables
- Cloud storage files stored across different servers
- Digital receipts generated in multiple formats (PDF, XML, JSON)
- Electronic medical records stored in multiple modules
- Financial statements generated in multiple formats
- Transaction logs stored in main, backup, and audit logs
- Emails stored in separate databases or folders
(e) Primary Evidence Where Electronic or Digital Record Is Produced from Proper Custody(Explanation 5 – Newly Inserted)
Where an electronic or digital record is produced from proper custody, it shall be treated as primary evidence, unless its authenticity is disputed.
Examples
- Call Detail Records produced by telecom authorities
- Electronic bank statements certified by authorized officers
- CCTV footage produced from secure storage
- Certified email records from service providers
- Digital forensic reports from accredited laboratories
- Electronic medical records from hospital databases
- GPS location data from service providers
- Social media records produced by platforms
- ATM transaction records produced by banks
- Digitally signed emails, provided the signature is verified and untampered
(f) Primary Evidence of Video Recordings Stored and Transmitted Simultaneously(Explanation 6)
Where a video recording is simultaneously stored in electronic form and transmitted, broadcast, or transferred, each stored recording constitutes primary evidence.
Examples
- Court proceedings recorded and live-streamed
- Online meetings recorded and transmitted
- Webinars recorded and broadcast live
- Live television broadcasts
- Live sports event recordings
- Reality TV shows recorded and broadcast
- CCTV surveillance footage
- Police body camera recordings
- Traffic monitoring footage
(g) Primary Evidence Where Electronic Record Is Stored in Multiple Storage Spaces(Explanation 7 – Newly Inserted)
Where an electronic or digital record is stored in multiple storage spaces within a computer resource, each automated storage, including temporary files, is treated as primary evidence.
Examples
- Data backups stored in multiple locations
- Data mirroring systems
- Email archiving systems
- Documents stored across multiple cloud platforms
- Distributed databases
- Blockchain-based data storage systems
Conclusion (Exam-Ready)
Primary evidence under Section 57 represents the original and best form of proof of documentary and electronic records, ensuring authenticity, reliability, and direct judicial inspection under the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023.
0 Comments