- Published on
KembaraXtra - Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita - Offences Relating to Coin, Currency-Notes, Bank-Notes and Government Stamps
Introduction
Offences relating to coins, currency-notes, bank-notes and Government stamps constitute an important category of offences under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS).
These offences concern the authenticity, integrity and lawful circulation of monetary instruments and Government revenue stamps.
Counterfeiting a coin refers to unlawfully making or altering a coin so that it resembles another coin, with the intention of practising deception or with knowledge that deception is likely to result.
Counterfeiting may involve manufacturing an imitation coin or altering an existing genuine coin.
Methods associated with counterfeiting may include gilding, silvering, washing, colouring, casting over, reducing weight, changing composition or otherwise altering the appearance of coins.
Such techniques may be employed to make an article appear to possess a value, denomination or authenticity that it does not actually possess.
The central concern is not merely the physical alteration of metal.
The law addresses conduct that satisfies the statutory requirements of counterfeiting, including the relevant deception-related elements where expressly required.
Counterfeiting offences are not confined to coins.
They also extend to currency-notes, bank-notes and stamps issued by the Government for revenue purposes.
The BNS addresses different stages of counterfeiting activity, including the actual counterfeiting process, circulation of counterfeit articles, possession with the required intention, and dealings in machinery or materials intended for counterfeiting.
Part I — Meaning and Nature of Counterfeiting
Q1. What is meant by counterfeiting a coin?
Answer:
Counterfeiting a coin involves making or altering a coin in circumstances satisfying the legal requirements of counterfeiting.
It may involve producing a false coin or changing the appearance, weight or composition of an existing coin.
Section 178 BNS expressly recognises certain alterations of genuine coins as forms of counterfeiting.
Q2. What is the principal purpose of laws against counterfeiting?
Answer:
The principal purpose is to protect the authenticity and reliability of monetary instruments and Government revenue stamps.
These laws seek to prevent counterfeit articles from being manufactured, distributed or represented as genuine.
Q3. Why is counterfeiting harmful?
Answer:
Counterfeiting may undermine confidence in money and revenue instruments.
It may expose members of the public to financial loss and interfere with the reliability of ordinary transactions.
Counterfeiting Government revenue stamps may also threaten the integrity of public revenue collection.
Q4. Does counterfeiting always involve manufacturing a completely new coin?
Answer:
No.
Counterfeiting may also involve altering a genuine coin.
Section 178 expressly recognises causing a genuine coin to appear like a different coin with the specified deception-related mental element.
It also includes diminishing the weight, altering the composition or altering the appearance of a coin within the offence of counterfeiting coin.
Part II — Methods of Counterfeiting Coins
Q5. What is gilding in the context of coin counterfeiting?
Answer:
Gilding generally refers to applying a gold-coloured or gold-containing coating to the surface of an object.
In the context of coin counterfeiting, it may be used to make a coin appear to have a different metallic character or value.
Whether a particular act constitutes an offence depends on the applicable statutory requirements.
Q6. What is silvering?
Answer:
Silvering generally refers to applying a silver-coloured or silver-containing coating to an object.
It may be used to alter the appearance of a coin.
Where the alteration forms part of conduct satisfying the statutory requirements of counterfeiting, it may be legally relevant.
Q7. What is washing in the context of coin counterfeiting?
Answer:
In the supplied introductory commentary, washing is identified as one of the methods associated with altering the appearance of coins.
The precise legal significance depends on what the process accomplishes and whether the statutory requirements of counterfeiting are satisfied.
Q8. What is colouring?
Answer:
Colouring refers to changing the visible colour of a coin.
It may be used to make a coin resemble another coin or appear to possess different characteristics.
The alteration must be assessed within the statutory requirements of counterfeiting.
Q9. What is casting over?
Answer:
Casting over refers generally to using a casting process to alter or reproduce the external form of an object.
In the context of counterfeit coins, such a process may be relevant where it is used to produce or alter a coin so that it falsely resembles another coin.
Q10. Is every act of gilding, silvering or colouring automatically an offence?
Answer:
No.
These are physical processes that may have lawful applications.
Their use does not automatically establish a counterfeiting offence.
The prosecution must establish the prohibited conduct and the applicable statutory mental elements.
Part III — Counterfeiting Under Section 178 BNS
Q11. Which BNS provision directly criminalises counterfeiting coins, Government revenue stamps, currency-notes and bank-notes?
Answer:
Section 178 BNS directly addresses counterfeiting these articles.
It punishes a person who counterfeits or knowingly performs any part of the process of counterfeiting a coin, Government revenue stamp, currency-note or bank-note.
Q12. Does Section 178 cover partial participation in counterfeiting?
Answer:
Yes.
Section 178 expressly includes knowingly performing any part of the counterfeiting process.
A person need not complete the entire process personally.
Q13. Does altering the denomination of a genuine Government stamp constitute counterfeiting?
Answer:
Yes.
Explanation (3) to Section 178 states that a person commits counterfeiting Government stamp by causing a genuine stamp of one denomination to appear like a genuine stamp of another denomination.
Q14. Can changing the appearance of a genuine coin constitute counterfeiting?
Answer:
Yes.
Explanation (4) to Section 178 covers causing a genuine coin to appear like a different coin, where the person intends to practise deception or knows that deception is likely to be practised.
Q15. What physical alterations are expressly included in counterfeiting coin?
Answer:
Explanation (5) to Section 178 expressly includes:
- Diminishing the weight of a coin.
- Altering the composition of a coin.
- Altering the appearance of a coin.
Memory Formula:
WEIGHT + COMPOSITION + APPEARANCE
Part IV — Different Stages of Counterfeiting Offences
Q16. Does the BNS address only the manufacture of counterfeit articles?
Answer:
No.
The BNS addresses several stages of counterfeiting activity.
These include counterfeiting, dealing in counterfeit articles, possession with the required mental elements, and dealings in machinery or materials intended for counterfeiting.
Q17. What is the role of Section 178 BNS?
Answer:
Section 178 concerns counterfeiting coins, Government revenue stamps, currency-notes or bank-notes, or knowingly performing any part of the counterfeiting process.
Q18. What is the role of Section 179 BNS?
Answer:
Section 179 concerns importing, exporting, selling, delivering, buying, receiving, otherwise trafficking in or using as genuine forged or counterfeit coins, stamps, currency-notes or bank-notes.
The accused must know or have reason to believe that the articles are forged or counterfeit.
Q19. What is the role of Section 180 BNS?
Answer:
Section 180 concerns possession of forged or counterfeit coins, stamps, currency-notes or bank-notes with knowledge or reason to believe that they are counterfeit and intention that they be used as genuine.
The section also contains an Explanation concerning possession established to be from a lawful source.
Q20. What is the role of Section 181 BNS?
Answer:
Section 181 concerns making, mending, buying, selling, disposing of or possessing machinery, dies, instruments or materials intended for forging or counterfeiting coins, Government revenue stamps, currency-notes or bank-notes.
It also covers performing any part of the process of making or mending the relevant equipment.
Q21. What is the role of Section 182 BNS?
Answer:
Section 182 concerns making, causing to be made, using or delivering documents purporting to be or resembling currency-notes or bank-notes in the manner described by that provision.
It is distinct from the offences involving the counterfeiting of currency-notes or bank-notes themselves.
Part V — Punishment and Classification
Q22. What is the punishment for counterfeiting under Section 178 BNS?
Answer:
Section 178 prescribes imprisonment for life, or imprisonment of either description extending up to ten years, and liability to fine.
Q23. What is the punishment under Section 179 BNS?
Answer:
Section 179 prescribes imprisonment for life, or imprisonment of either description extending up to ten years, and liability to fine.
Q24. What is the punishment under Section 180 BNS?
Answer:
Section 180 prescribes imprisonment of either description extending up to seven years, or fine, or both.
Q25. What is the punishment under Section 181 BNS?
Answer:
Section 181 prescribes imprisonment for life, or imprisonment of either description extending up to ten years, and liability to fine.
Q26. How are Sections 178 to 181 classified?
Answer:
According to the supplied classifications, Sections 178, 179, 180 and 181 are all:
Cognizable.
Non-bailable.
Triable by the Court of Session.
Part VI — Practical Illustrations
Q27. Illustration 1 — Manufacturing counterfeit coins
Answer:
A manufactures counterfeit coins.
The conduct may fall within Section 178 because that provision directly criminalises counterfeiting coins.
Q28. Illustration 2 — Altering the appearance of a genuine coin
Answer:
B causes a genuine coin to appear like a different coin with the intention of practising deception.
The conduct falls within the counterfeiting rule described in Explanation (4) to Section 178.
Q29. Illustration 3 — Changing the denomination of a Government stamp
Answer:
C causes a genuine Government revenue stamp of one denomination to appear like a genuine stamp of another denomination.
The conduct falls within Explanation (3) to Section 178.
Q30. Illustration 4 — Selling counterfeit coins
Answer:
D sells counterfeit coins knowing that they are counterfeit.
The conduct may fall within Section 179.
Q31. Illustration 5 — Possessing counterfeit currency with intention to use it as genuine
Answer:
E possesses counterfeit currency-notes knowing that they are counterfeit and intending that they be used as genuine.
E does not establish possession from a lawful source.
The conduct may fall within Section 180.
Q32. Illustration 6 — Manufacturing counterfeiting equipment
Answer:
F manufactures a die intended for producing counterfeit coins.
The conduct may fall within Section 181.
Q33. Illustration 7 — Making a document resembling a bank-note
Answer:
G makes a document resembling a bank-note in circumstances satisfying Section 182.
The conduct may fall within Section 182 even where the document is not established to be a counterfeit bank-note under Section 178.
Key Provisions (Study Notes)
1. Counterfeiting
Unlawfully making or altering monetary or revenue instruments in circumstances satisfying the applicable statutory requirements.
2. Physical Methods
Gilding, silvering, washing, colouring, casting over and other alterations may be relevant to counterfeiting.
3. Section 178
Counterfeiting or knowingly performing any part of the counterfeiting process.
4. Section 179
Dealing in or using counterfeit articles as genuine.
5. Section 180
Possession of counterfeit articles with the required knowledge or reason to believe and intention.
6. Section 181
Counterfeiting machinery, dies, instruments and materials.
7. Section 182
Documents resembling currency-notes or bank-notes.
8. Alteration of Genuine Coins
May constitute counterfeiting where the statutory requirements are satisfied.
9. Alteration of Genuine Government Stamps
Changing the apparent denomination is expressly treated as counterfeiting.
10. Important Coin Alterations
Diminishing weight.
Altering composition.
Altering appearance.
Quick Revision Notes
Subject: Offences Relating to Coin, Currency-Notes, Bank-Notes and Government Stamps.
Primary Counterfeiting Provision: Section 178 BNS.
Dealing in Counterfeit Articles: Section 179 BNS.
Possession of Counterfeit Articles: Section 180 BNS.
Counterfeiting Equipment and Materials: Section 181 BNS.
Documents Resembling Currency-Notes or Bank-Notes: Section 182 BNS.
Important Physical Alterations: Weight, composition and appearance.
Important Mental Element for Partial Participation Under Section 178: Knowledge.
Important Mental Element Under Section 179: Knowledge or reason to believe.
Important Mental Elements Under Section 180: Knowledge or reason to believe and intention that the article be used as genuine.
Exam Traps
Trap 1 — Counterfeiting always requires manufacturing a completely new coin.
Incorrect.
Certain alterations of genuine coins may constitute counterfeiting.
Trap 2 — Gilding or colouring automatically constitutes counterfeiting.
Incorrect.
The applicable statutory requirements must be satisfied.
Trap 3 — Only the person who completes the counterfeit article can be liable under Section 178.
Incorrect.
Knowingly performing any part of the counterfeiting process is expressly covered.
Trap 4 — Selling counterfeit coins is addressed only under Section 178.
Incorrect.
Section 179 expressly covers selling forged or counterfeit articles with the required knowledge or reason to believe.
Trap 5 — Possession and use as genuine are identical offences.
Incorrect.
Sections 179 and 180 contain different statutory requirements.
Trap 6 — Possession of counterfeiting machinery is the same as possession of counterfeit currency.
Incorrect.
Section 181 addresses machinery and materials, while Section 180 addresses possession of counterfeit articles themselves.
Trap 7 — Changing the denomination of a genuine Government stamp cannot constitute counterfeiting.
Incorrect.
Explanation (3) to Section 178 expressly covers such conduct.
Trap 8 — Only the appearance of a coin matters.
Incorrect.
Explanation (5) also includes diminishing weight and altering composition.
Trap 9 — Counterfeiting offences always require actual financial loss.
Incorrect.
Actual financial loss is not an express requirement under the counterfeiting provisions discussed above.
Trap 10 — All offences relating to counterfeit articles carry identical punishment.
Incorrect.
The punishment depends on the particular statutory provision.
Final Memory Formula
OFFENCES RELATING TO COIN, CURRENCY-NOTES, BANK-NOTES AND GOVERNMENT STAMPS
178 = COUNTERFEITING
179 = DEALING IN OR USING COUNTERFEIT ARTICLES
180 = POSSESSION OF COUNTERFEIT ARTICLES WITH THE REQUIRED INTENTION
181 = COUNTERFEITING MACHINERY AND MATERIALS
182 = DOCUMENTS RESEMBLING CURRENCY-NOTES OR BANK-NOTES
IMPORTANT METHODS OF COUNTERFEITING COIN
GILDING
SILVERING
WASHING
COLOURING
CASTING OVER
DIMINISHING WEIGHT
ALTERING COMPOSITION
ALTERING APPEARANCE
CORE LEGAL DISTINCTION
MAKING COUNTERFEIT ARTICLES
IS DIFFERENT FROM
DEALING IN COUNTERFEIT ARTICLES
WHICH IS DIFFERENT FROM
POSSESSING COUNTERFEIT ARTICLES
WHICH IS DIFFERENT FROM
DEALING IN COUNTERFEITING EQUIPMENT.
Key Takeaway
Offences relating to coins, currency-notes, bank-notes and Government stamps protect the authenticity and reliability of monetary and revenue instruments.
Counterfeiting may involve manufacturing false articles or altering genuine articles so that they falsely resemble other monetary or revenue instruments.
Methods such as gilding, silvering, washing, colouring, casting over and altering the weight, composition or appearance of coins may be relevant to counterfeiting where the applicable statutory requirements are satisfied.
The BNS addresses different stages of counterfeiting activity through separate provisions.
Section 178 deals with counterfeiting itself.
Section 179 deals with the circulation, transfer and use of counterfeit articles.
Section 180 deals with possession accompanied by the required mental elements.
Section 181 deals with equipment and materials intended for counterfeiting.
Section 182 deals with documents resembling currency-notes or bank-notes.
Final Memory Line:
COUNTERFEITING OFFENCES = PRODUCTION + CIRCULATION + POSSESSION + EQUIPMENT + CURRENCY-LIKE DOCUMENTS, EACH GOVERNED BY ITS OWN STATUTORY INGREDIENTS.
