LAW

Published on

KembaraXtra-Case Law – Elliott v C [1983] 1 WLR 939 (QBD)

Facts:

D was a 14-year-old girl of low intelligence. She had stayed out all night and was exhausted.

She entered a garden shed and, in an attempt to keep warm, poured white spirit onto the floor and set fire to it.

The fire destroyed the shed, and D was charged with criminal damage.

The magistrates acquitted D because they considered that the risk of damage would not have been obvious to her because of her age, limited understanding and exhaustion.

Held:

The Divisional Court held that D’s acquittal was wrong.

Applying R v Caldwell, the relevant question was whether the risk would have been obvious to a reasonably prudent person, not whether the risk would have been obvious to D personally.

Therefore, even though D had not considered the risk, and even though her limited intelligence and exhaustion meant that she might never have appreciated it, she could still be regarded as reckless under the Caldwell test.

Legal Principle:

Under Caldwell recklessness, D’s individual characteristics were generally irrelevant when deciding whether the risk was obvious.

If:

  1. the risk would have been obvious to a reasonably prudent person; and
  2. D gave no thought to the possibility of that risk,

D could be reckless even though D personally lacked the ability to appreciate the risk.

Exam Principle:

Elliott v C demonstrates the harshness of the objective Caldwell test.

A defendant could be convicted despite genuinely failing to appreciate a risk because of factors such as:

  • age;
  • limited intelligence;
  • lack of experience; or
  • exhaustion.

Important Development:

This objective approach was later rejected in R v G [2003] UKHL 50, where the House of Lords overruled Caldwell and restored a subjective test of recklessness.

In one line:

Elliott v C = under Caldwell, an obvious risk was judged by the reasonable person standard, even where D personally lacked the capacity to appreciate it.



Image description
0 Comments