LAW

Published on

KembaraXtra-Case Law -Empress Car Co v National Rivers Authority (1984) HL

Case Summary

  • Parties: Empress Car Co (D) vs. National Rivers Authority (NRA)
  • Facts:
  • D maintained a diesel oil tank in its yard.
  • The tank drained directly into a river (controlled waters).
  • A vandal opened a tap on the tank, releasing diesel into the river.
  • Charge: NRA charged D with "causing" pollution to enter controlled waters.
  • Defense: D argued the vandal, not D, caused the pollution.
  • Outcome: D was convicted.

Legal Principle

  • "Causing" Pollution: For the purpose of pollution offenses, a person "causes" pollution if they:
  • Actively do something to create a situation where polluting matter can escape.
  • This is true even if they are not the immediate cause of the pollution event.
  • Application: D's act of maintaining the diesel oil tank on its land, with a drainage system connected to the river, was sufficient to establish "causation" for the charge, despite the vandal's intervening act.

Key Takeaway

  • Causation in environmental pollution cases can be established through preparatory or facilitative acts, even if an external, immediate cause triggers the release of pollutants.
  • Responsibility extends to creating the circumstances that allow pollution to occur.


Image description
0 Comments