LAW

Published on

KembaraXtra-Case Law – McCausland v Duncan Lawrie Ltd [1997] 1 WLR 38 (CA)

Facts:

Mr and Mrs McCausland agreed to purchase 1 Beechmore Road, London SW11 from SIS Securities Ltd, which was associated with Duncan Lawrie Ltd.

A valid written contract dated 26 January 1995 provided for the property to be sold for £210,000.

The contract stated that completion was to take place on 26 March 1995.

A few days later, the seller’s solicitor realised that 26 March 1995 was a Sunday.

The solicitor therefore wrote to the purchasers’ solicitors proposing that completion should instead take place on Friday 24 March 1995.

The purchasers’ solicitors replied in writing confirming that completion could take place on 24 March.

However, the proposed variation was not embodied in a new document satisfying all the formal requirements of s 2 of the Law of Property (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1989.

The purchasers failed to provide the completion money on 24 March.

Later that day, the seller served a notice to complete, treating 24 March as the contractual completion date.

The notice required completion by 7 April 1995.

The purchasers were unable to complete by that date and sought a short extension. The seller refused and purported to rescind the contract on 7 April.

The purchasers argued that the attempted change from 26 March to 24 March had not complied with s 2 LP(MP)A 1989.

Therefore, the variation was invalid.

If 24 March had never become the contractual completion date, the seller’s notice to complete had been served too early and its subsequent purported rescission was consequently defective.

The purchasers sought specific performance of the original contract.


Decision at First Instance:

Knox J held that a variation of an existing valid land contract did not itself need to comply with s 2.

He considered that the correspondence between the solicitors had effectively varied the completion date to 24 March.

Accordingly, the notice to complete and subsequent rescission were treated as valid.

The purchasers’ claim for specific performance was struck out.

They appealed.


Held:

The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal.

A material variation of a contract for the sale or other disposition of an interest in land must itself comply with the formalities in s 2 LP(MP)A 1989.

Changing the completion date was a material variation.

The correspondence between the solicitors did not satisfy s 2 because the varied contract was not embodied in the required written and signed form incorporating the relevant contractual terms.

The attempted variation from 26 March to 24 March was therefore ineffective.

The original contract remained in force according to its original terms.

The purchasers’ claim was therefore reinstated.


Legal Principle – Variations Must Also Comply with s 2

Section 2 does not apply only when the original contract is first created.

If the parties subsequently agree to alter a material term of a land contract, the varied agreement must also satisfy the statutory formalities.

Those formalities require that:

  1. the agreement is in writing;
  2. all expressly agreed terms are contained in or properly incorporated into the relevant document; and
  3. the document is signed by or on behalf of each party.

A material variation which fails to comply with these requirements is ineffective.


What Counts as a Material Variation?

The Court of Appeal treated the completion date as a material contractual term.

It mattered because the completion date affected when important contractual rights arose, including the right to serve a notice to complete and thereby make time of the essence.

Other obvious examples of material terms would include:

  • the purchase price;
  • the property or interest being sold; and
  • other substantial obligations affecting the parties’ rights.

The principle is therefore:

Material variation → must comply with s 2.

An entirely trivial or immaterial administrative alteration may not necessarily attract the same requirement.


Why the Change of Date Mattered

The difference between 24 March and 26 March was not simply a clerical matter.

Under the contract, a party could serve a notice to complete only on or after the contractual completion date.

If the attempted variation was invalid, then 24 March was not the contractual completion date.

Therefore, the seller could not simply rely upon the purchasers’ failure to complete on that date as though it were a breach of the properly documented contract.

That is why the validity of the variation was crucial to the seller’s attempted rescission.


Original Contract Remains in Force

Another important point is that the invalid variation did not destroy the original contract.

The original written contract satisfied s 2 and therefore remained binding.

What failed was only the attempted alteration of its completion date.

Therefore:

valid original contract + invalid variation = original contract continues according to its original terms.

This is an important exam point.


Purpose of s 2 LP(MP)A 1989

The Court of Appeal emphasised the strict nature of s 2.

Section 2 represented a major departure from the earlier law and was intended to promote:

  • certainty;
  • clarity;
  • reduction of disputes about orally agreed terms; and
  • reduction of fraud.

Allowing parties freely to vary important contractual terms informally would undermine those objectives.

If the original contract had to comply with strict statutory formalities but major amendments could subsequently be made orally or by informal correspondence, the protection created by s 2 would be substantially weakened.


Link to Firstpost Homes Ltd v Johnson

Firstpost Homes Ltd v Johnson established that the original contract for the sale of land must comply strictly with the formalities of s 2, including the requirement for signature.

McCausland extends the same philosophy to later amendments.

Therefore:

Firstpost Homes → creation of the land contract must comply with s 2.

McCausland → material variation of that contract must also comply with s 2.

Together, the cases demonstrate the strict approach adopted towards land-contract formalities.


Link to the Old s 40 Law of Property Act 1925

Under the former s 40 LPA 1925, an oral contract for the sale of land could exist but might simply be unenforceable unless supported by sufficient signed written evidence.

Section 2 LP(MP)A 1989 introduced a much stricter regime.

The contract itself must comply with the statutory requirements.

The Court of Appeal in McCausland emphasised that s 2 marked a significant change from the previous law.

This stricter philosophy also explains why material variations must themselves satisfy s 2.


Possible Estoppel Issue

The Court of Appeal also recognised that, in an appropriate case, an argument based on estoppel might arise where one party had clearly agreed to a variation and the other had acted upon it.

However, estoppel could not simply be assumed to validate every informal variation.

Its application would depend upon the particular facts and evidence.

The principal rule from McCausland remains:

a material variation to a land contract must comply with s 2.


Exam Principle

When a land contract is altered after it has been validly concluded, ask:

  1. Is there already a valid contract complying with s 2?
  2. Has one of its terms subsequently been changed?
  3. Is that term material?
  4. Does the variation itself satisfy s 2?
  5. If it does not, does the original contract remain operative?

The usual answer under McCausland is:

Material variation + failure to comply with s 2 = variation ineffective, original contract remains in force.


Comparison

Firstpost Homes v Johnson

→ Original land contract must satisfy s 2 formalities.

McCausland v Duncan Lawrie

→ Material variations to an existing land contract must also satisfy s 2.

Shah v Shah

→ Concerned defective execution of a deed under s 1, not a land contract under s 2.

These cases should therefore be kept conceptually separate.


In one line:

McCausland v Duncan Lawrie = a material variation of a contract for the sale of land, such as changing the completion date, must itself comply with s 2 LP(MP)A 1989; otherwise the variation is ineffective and the original contract continues to govern the parties.



Image description
0 Comments