- Published on
KembaraXtra-Case Law – Parker v British Airways Board [1982] QB 1004 (CA)
Facts:
Parker was a passenger using an executive lounge at Heathrow Airport operated by the British Airways Board.
While in the lounge, he found a gold bracelet lying on the floor.
Parker handed the bracelet to an employee of the Board. He gave his name and address and asked that, if the true owner could not be found, the bracelet should be returned to him.
The original owner was never identified.
Instead of returning the bracelet to Parker, the British Airways Board sold it for £850 and kept the proceeds.
Parker sued for the value of the bracelet.
At first instance, he was awarded £850 plus £50 interest.
The British Airways Board appealed.
Held:
The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal and held that Parker had the better possessory title to the bracelet.
As finder, Parker acquired rights over the bracelet against everyone except:
- the true owner; or
- someone who could show a better prior right to possession.
British Airways could only defeat Parker’s claim if it could prove that, before the bracelet was found, it had manifested an intention to exercise control over the lounge and over items found within it.
The Board had not demonstrated such a sufficiently clear intention.
Accordingly, Parker’s title as finder was superior.
Legal Principle – Finder’s Title:
A finder of a chattel does not become the absolute owner merely by finding it.
However, the finder generally acquires a possessory title which is good against everyone except:
- the true owner; and
- a person with a superior prior right to possession.
Therefore, where the true owner cannot be identified, the finder may be entitled to keep the object.
Legal Principle – Objects Found “On” Land:
Where a chattel is found on the surface of land, the occupier does not automatically have a better title than the finder.
The occupier must show that, before the item was found, they had manifested an intention to exercise control over the premises and over objects found there.
The greater the occupier’s control, the stronger the occupier’s claim.
Why British Airways Lost:
Although British Airways controlled access to the executive lounge, that alone was insufficient.
It had not demonstrated a policy or conduct showing that it intended to exercise control over all lost property within the lounge before Parker found the bracelet.
Parker therefore acquired the better possessory title when he found it.
Duties of the Finder:
A finder who takes possession of a lost object also assumes certain responsibilities.
The finder should take reasonable steps to locate the true owner.
Parker did this by handing the bracelet to the airport staff and making clear that he wanted it returned if the true owner could not be found.
This strengthened his position as an honest finder.
Link to Waverley Borough Council v Fletcher:
The distinction between objects found “on” and “in” land is crucial.
In Parker, the bracelet was lying on the floor.
Therefore, the outcome depended heavily on whether the occupier had demonstrated sufficient control over lost objects.
By contrast, in Waverley Borough Council v Fletcher, the medieval brooch was found buried in the ground.
Where an item is found in or attached to the land, the landowner or lawful occupier will normally have the superior title, regardless of whether they had previously manifested control over lost objects.
Therefore:
Parker → chattel found ON land: finder may have superior title.
Waverley → chattel found IN land: landowner usually has superior title.
Exam Principle:
When a lost object is found on premises, ask:
- Is the true owner known?
- Was the item found on or in the land?
- Did the occupier manifest an intention to control the premises?
- Did the occupier also manifest an intention to control objects found there?
- Does the finder have a better possessory title?
If the object is merely found on the land and the occupier has not sufficiently demonstrated control over lost items, the finder may have the better title.
Connection with Fixtures:
Parker concerns a chattel, meaning an item of personal property which remains separate from the land.
A different issue arises where an object has become sufficiently attached to the land to become a fixture.
The maxim is:
quicquid plantatur solo, solo cedit
meaning:
“whatever is attached to the land becomes part of the land.”
Once a chattel becomes a fixture, it is treated as part of the real property rather than as a separate item of personal property.
Section 62 Law of Property Act 1925:
On a conveyance of land, s 62 of the Law of Property Act 1925 may operate so that the transfer includes buildings, fixtures, easements, rights and other advantages associated with the land, unless the conveyance expresses a contrary intention.
Whether an object has become a fixture is principally determined through the common-law tests concerning:
- the degree of annexation; and
- the purpose of annexation.
In one line:
Parker v British Airways Board = a finder of a chattel lying on land may have a better possessory title than the occupier where the true owner is unknown and the occupier has not manifested sufficient control over items found on the premises.