- Published on
KembaraXtra-Case Law-R (A Minor) (Wardship: Consent to Treatment) (1991)
Key Principle: Even if a child lacks the legal competence to consent to medical treatment, their views should still be considered by the doctor. The weight given to these views increases with the child's maturity (intelligence and understanding).
Core takeaway: The doctor needs to consider the child's perspective on treatment, even if the child cannot legally consent, placing emphasis on the child's intelligence and understanding.
Breakdown:
Context: This case concerns a situation where a child is under wardship (legal protection), and the issue is consent to medical treatment.
Incompetence: The child, in this specific scenario, lacks the legal capacity to give valid consent.
Doctor's Duty: The doctor has to decide whether or not to provide treatment.
Child's Views as a Factor: Lord Donaldson emphasizes that the child's views and wishes are a relevant factor in the doctor's decision-making process.
Increasing Importance: The importance of the child's views is directly related to their intelligence and understanding. The more mature and comprehending the child is, the more weight the doctor should give to their perspective.
Key Principle: Even if a child lacks the legal competence to consent to medical treatment, their views should still be considered by the doctor. The weight given to these views increases with the child's maturity (intelligence and understanding).
Core takeaway: The doctor needs to consider the child's perspective on treatment, even if the child cannot legally consent, placing emphasis on the child's intelligence and understanding.
Breakdown:
Context: This case concerns a situation where a child is under wardship (legal protection), and the issue is consent to medical treatment.
Incompetence: The child, in this specific scenario, lacks the legal capacity to give valid consent.
Doctor's Duty: The doctor has to decide whether or not to provide treatment.
Child's Views as a Factor: Lord Donaldson emphasizes that the child's views and wishes are a relevant factor in the doctor's decision-making process.
Increasing Importance: The importance of the child's views is directly related to their intelligence and understanding. The more mature and comprehending the child is, the more weight the doctor should give to their perspective.
0 Comments