- Published on
KembaraXtra-Case Law – R v Adomako [1995] 1 AC 171 (HL)
Facts:
D was an anaesthetist during an eye operation.
During the operation, the tube supplying oxygen to the patient became disconnected. D failed to notice the disconnection for several minutes.
As a result, the patient suffered cardiac arrest and died.
D was convicted of manslaughter by gross negligence.
Held:
The House of Lords upheld D’s conviction.
The court held that R v Seymour should no longer be followed. Recklessness under the Caldwell/Lawrence approach was not the correct basis for liability in cases of involuntary manslaughter caused by negligence.
Instead, Andrews v DPP provided the correct approach.
The prosecution had to prove that D’s conduct amounted to gross negligence sufficiently serious to justify criminal liability.
Legal Principle:
Gross negligence manslaughter requires proof that:
- D owed V a duty of care;
- D breached that duty;
- the breach caused V’s death;
- there was an obvious and serious risk of death; and
- the breach was so grossly negligent that it should be regarded as criminal.
Whether the negligence was sufficiently gross was ultimately a question for the jury.
Exam Principle:
A defendant does not need to be subjectively reckless to be guilty of gross negligence manslaughter.
The central question is whether D’s breach of duty was so serious, having regard to the risk of death, that it amounted to a criminal act or omission.
Link to Seymour:
Adomako overruled Seymour and rejected the use of Caldwell/Lawrence recklessness as the mens rea for this form of manslaughter.
Instead, liability is based on gross negligence, following Andrews v DPP.
In one line:
Adomako = gross negligence manslaughter requires a duty of care, breach causing death, an obvious and serious risk of death, and negligence so gross that it deserves criminal punishment.