- Published on
KembaraXtra-Case Law – R v Caldwell [1982] AC 341 (HL)
Facts:
D worked at a hotel. After a quarrel with his employer, D became intoxicated and set fire to the hotel.
He was charged with criminal damage with intent to endanger life or being reckless as to whether life would be endangered.
D pleaded not guilty on the basis that, because he was intoxicated, he had not appreciated the risk created by setting the fire.
Held:
The House of Lords held that recklessness for criminal damage could be established using an objective test.
Lord Diplock formulated a two-part test. The jury had to consider:
- whether D’s act created an obvious risk that property would be destroyed or damaged; and
- whether D either:
- gave no thought to the possibility of that risk; or
- recognised the risk but nevertheless went on to take it.
Therefore, D could be reckless even though he had not actually appreciated the risk.
His voluntary intoxication did not prevent liability.
Legal Principle:
Caldwell recklessness introduced an objective element into the law of recklessness.
A defendant could be reckless where an obvious risk existed and D either:
- failed to consider the risk at all; or
- recognised the risk and nevertheless took it.
This differed from Cunningham recklessness, which required proof that D actually foresaw the risk.
Exam Principle:
Under the Caldwell test, D could be reckless even without subjective foresight where the risk would have been obvious to an ordinary reasonable person and D had simply failed to consider it.
Important Development:
The Caldwell approach was later overruled by R v G [2003] UKHL 50, which restored a subjective approach to recklessness.
In one line:
Caldwell = objective recklessness: D may be reckless where an obvious risk exists and D either fails to consider it or recognises it and goes ahead anyway.