LAW

Published on

KembaraXtra-Case Law – R v Cunningham [1957] 2 QB 396 (CA)


Facts:

D stole a gas meter and its contents from a house. In doing so, he fractured a gas pipe. Gas escaped into a bedroom where V was asleep. V inhaled a large quantity of gas and became seriously ill.


D was charged under s 23 of the Offences Against the Person Act 1861 with unlawfully and maliciously causing V to take a noxious thing.


Held:

The Court of Appeal held that the word “maliciously” required proof that D had foreseen the risk of the relevant consequence.


It was not enough that a reasonable person would have foreseen the danger. The prosecution had to prove that D himself actually foresaw the risk and nevertheless went ahead and took it.


The conviction was therefore quashed because the jury had been directed using an objective test rather than the correct subjective test.


Legal Principle:

Recklessness is subjective. D must:


  • foresee a risk that the relevant consequence may occur; and
  • nevertheless deliberately go on to take that risk.


This became known as Cunningham recklessness.


Exam Principle:

A defendant is reckless where they personally foresee a risk of the prohibited consequence but nevertheless continue with their conduct.


In one line:

Cunningham = subjective recklessness: D foresees the risk and goes ahead anyway.

Image description
0 Comments