LAW

Published on

KembaraXtra-Case Law – R v Lawrence [1982] AC 510 (HL)


Facts:

D was riding a motorcycle at approximately 77 miles per hour in a built-up area.


He collided with a pedestrian, who was killed.


The prosecution argued that D’s speed was grossly excessive and that his manner of driving was therefore reckless.


D was convicted of causing death by reckless driving.


Held:

The House of Lords followed Lord Diplock’s approach to recklessness in R v Caldwell.


For driving to be reckless, D must drive in a manner that creates an obvious and serious risk of:


  • personal injury; or
  • damage to property.


The jury had to decide whether the risk created by D’s driving was both obvious and serious, judged according to the standards of the ordinary and prudent motorist.


Legal Principle:

Lawrence applied the objective Caldwell test of recklessness to reckless driving.


The focus was on whether D’s manner of driving created a risk that would have been obvious and serious to the ordinary prudent driver.


It was not necessary to prove that D personally appreciated the risk.


Exam Principle:

Under Lawrence, reckless driving required:


  1. D’s driving to create an obvious and serious risk of injury or property damage; and
  2. the risk to be assessed objectively according to the standards of the ordinary and prudent motorist.


Link to Caldwell:

Lawrence applied Caldwell-style objective recklessness in the context of driving offences.


In one line:

Lawrence = reckless driving where D creates an obvious and serious risk, judged objectively by the standard of the ordinary prudent motorist.

Image description
0 Comments