- Published on
KembaraXtra-Case Law-R v McShane (1977)
Core Principle: It is a common law offense to attempt to assist another person in committing suicide.
Key Facts:
Appellant: McShane (daughter)
Victim: McShane's elderly, infirm mother. The mother had previously expressed suicidal thoughts.
Actions: McShane repeatedly provided her mother with potentially lethal doses of pills. On one occasion, she made a suggestive statement about the combination of whisky and barbiturates.
Charge: Attempting to counsel or procure her mother's suicide.
Legal Issue:
Is attempting to assist suicide an offense in law? McShane argued it was not.
Court Decision:
The Court of Appeal dismissed McShane's appeal, upholding the conviction.
Reasoning: An attempt to commit any offense (whether statutory or common law) is itself a common law offense. This holds true even if the underlying crime is "of the nature of an attempt."
Core Principle: It is a common law offense to attempt to assist another person in committing suicide.
Key Facts:
Appellant: McShane (daughter)
Victim: McShane's elderly, infirm mother. The mother had previously expressed suicidal thoughts.
Actions: McShane repeatedly provided her mother with potentially lethal doses of pills. On one occasion, she made a suggestive statement about the combination of whisky and barbiturates.
Charge: Attempting to counsel or procure her mother's suicide.
Legal Issue:
Is attempting to assist suicide an offense in law? McShane argued it was not.
Court Decision:
The Court of Appeal dismissed McShane's appeal, upholding the conviction.
Reasoning: An attempt to commit any offense (whether statutory or common law) is itself a common law offense. This holds true even if the underlying crime is "of the nature of an attempt."
0 Comments