LAW

Published on

KembaraXtra-Case Law – R v Parker [1977] 1 WLR 600 (CA)

Facts:

D unsuccessfully attempted to make a telephone call from a public telephone kiosk. He became angry and slammed the telephone receiver down.

The telephone was made of breakable material and was damaged as a result of D’s actions.

Held:

The Court of Appeal held that D could be regarded as reckless even if he claimed that he had not actually considered the risk of damage.

Lane LJ stated that if D did not know there was a risk of damage, he had effectively deliberately closed his mind to an obvious risk.

Where the risk is obvious and D deliberately refuses to consider it, that deliberate closing of the mind can be treated as the equivalent of knowledge of the risk.

Legal Principle:

A defendant cannot escape liability for recklessness simply by deliberately refusing to think about an obvious risk.

Deliberate closing of the mind to an obvious risk may amount to recklessness.

Exam Principle:

Where D claims not to have foreseen a risk, the court may still find recklessness if D deliberately shut his mind to a risk that was obvious in the circumstances.

In one line:

Parker = deliberately closing one’s mind to an obvious risk can be treated as equivalent to knowledge of that risk.



Image description
0 Comments