LAW

Published on

KembaraXtra-Case Law – R v Pigg [1982] 1 WLR 762 (CA)

Facts:

D was convicted of attempted rape.

The issue concerned the meaning of recklessness in relation to whether the woman was consenting.

Held:

The Court of Appeal held that, following R v Caldwell, a defendant could be reckless as to consent in two situations.

According to Lord Lane CJ, D would be reckless if:

  1. D was indifferent and gave no thought to the possibility that the woman might not be consenting, in circumstances where the risk of non-consent would have been obvious if D had considered it; or
  2. D was aware of the possibility that she might not be consenting, but nevertheless continued regardless of whether she consented.

Therefore, recklessness could include both failure to consider an obvious risk and conscious taking of a known risk.

Legal Principle:

Pigg applied the Caldwell approach to recklessness to the issue of consent in rape.

A defendant could therefore be reckless where:

  • he failed to consider an obvious possibility that V was not consenting; or
  • he actually recognised that possibility but proceeded regardless.

Exam Principle:

Under the law at the time, recklessness as to consent did not necessarily require proof that D actually realised that V might not be consenting.

It could be sufficient that D gave no thought to an obvious risk of non-consent.

Link to Caldwell:

Pigg extended Caldwell-style objective recklessness to rape, treating failure to consider an obvious risk of non-consent as capable of amounting to recklessness.

Important Development:

This is now of mainly historical significance. The modern law of rape is governed by the Sexual Offences Act 2003, under which the issue is whether D reasonably believed that V consented, having regard to all the circumstances.

In one line:

Pigg = under the former law of rape, D could be reckless as to consent either by consciously taking the risk of non-consent or by failing to consider an obvious risk that V was not consenting.



Image description
0 Comments