LAW

Published on

KembaraXtra-Case Law – R v Reid [1992] 1 WLR 793 (HL)

Facts:

D was driving in the inside lane of a dual carriageway.

He attempted to overtake another vehicle on its nearside, but there was a hut protruding into the road in that lane.

D’s car struck the hut, and his passenger was killed.

D was convicted of causing death by reckless driving.

Held:

The House of Lords confirmed the approach to recklessness established in R v Lawrence.

Recklessness was not limited to cases where D actually appreciated the risk. It could also include a situation where D failed to appreciate an obvious risk.

However, the jury did not always have to be directed using the precise wording of Lord Diplock’s model direction in Lawrence.

The jury had to consider all the available evidence, including any explanation offered by D for his conduct.

For example, the standard direction might need to be modified where D:

  • acted under an understandable and excusable mistake;
  • had a capacity to appreciate risks adversely affected by a condition for which he was not at fault; or
  • acted in response to a sudden dilemma created by another person.

Legal Principle:

Under the Lawrence/Reid approach, recklessness could include both:

  1. recognising an obvious and serious risk and nevertheless taking it; and
  2. failing to give any thought to an obvious and serious risk.

However, the jury must consider D’s explanation and the circumstances surrounding his conduct before deciding whether he was reckless.

Exam Principle:

The objective test of recklessness should not be applied mechanically.

Even where an obvious risk exists, the jury should consider all the evidence explaining why D acted as he did before concluding that D was reckless.

Link to Lawrence:

Reid confirmed Lawrence but emphasised that Lord Diplock’s model direction was not an inflexible formula and could be adapted to the facts of the case.

In one line:

Reid = Lawrence recklessness includes failure to appreciate an obvious risk, but the jury must consider all the circumstances and any explanation for D’s conduct.



Image description
0 Comments