- Published on
KembaraXtra-Case Law – R v Sangha [1988] 2 All ER 385 (CA)
Facts:
D set fire to a mattress and two armchairs in a flat, causing the flat to be burnt out.
D was charged under s 1(2) of the Criminal Damage Act 1971 with criminal damage, being reckless as to whether life would be endangered.
D argued that there was no danger to life because no one else was in the flat when he started the fire.
Unknown to D, because of the particular construction and design of the building, there was in fact no danger of the fire spreading to the other flats.
Held:
The Court of Appeal upheld D’s conviction.
The test was whether an ordinary prudent bystander, at the time the fire was started, would have perceived an obvious risk that property would be damaged and that life would thereby be endangered.
The ordinary prudent bystander was not assumed to possess expert knowledge about the construction of the building and was not entitled to judge the situation with the benefit of hindsight.
Therefore, the fact that expert knowledge later established that the fire could not have spread to the other flats did not prevent D from being reckless.
Legal Principle:
Under the Caldwell approach to recklessness, the risk was assessed objectively from the perspective of an ordinary prudent bystander.
The question was whether, at the time D acted, such a person would have perceived:
- an obvious risk of damage to property; and
- an obvious risk that life would thereby be endangered.
Specialist knowledge and hindsight were irrelevant to this assessment.
Exam Principle:
When applying the objective Caldwell test, the court considers the circumstances as they appeared at the time D acted.
The reasonable person is not given:
- expert or specialist knowledge; or
- the benefit of hindsight.
Link to Caldwell:
Sangha applied Caldwell-style objective recklessness to aggravated criminal damage under s 1(2) of the Criminal Damage Act 1971.
In one line:
Sangha = the risk is judged through the eyes of an ordinary prudent bystander at the time of D’s act, without expert knowledge or hindsight.