- Published on
KembaraXtra-Case Law – R v Stephenson [1979] QB 695 (CA)
Facts:
D crawled into a haystack to sleep. As he was cold, he lit a fire to keep himself warm.
The fire spread and destroyed the haystack. D suffered from schizophrenia, which affected his ability to appreciate the risk created by his actions.
D was convicted of criminal damage.
Held:
The Court of Appeal held that recklessness required proof that D actually foresaw the risk of damage arising from his conduct and nevertheless went on to take that risk.
Because of D’s mental condition, he was incapable of appreciating the risk of the fire spreading.
As D had not actually foreseen the risk, he could not be regarded as reckless. His conviction was therefore quashed.
Legal Principle:
Recklessness is determined subjectively.
The court must consider whether this particular defendant actually foresaw the relevant risk, rather than whether a reasonable person would have foreseen it.
D’s individual characteristics, including a mental condition affecting his ability to appreciate a risk, may therefore be relevant when deciding whether D was subjectively reckless.
Exam Principle:
For subjective recklessness, the prosecution must prove that:
- D actually foresaw the risk of the relevant consequence; and
- D nevertheless went on to take that risk.
If D genuinely did not appreciate the risk, even because of a mental condition, the necessary recklessness is not established.
In one line:
Stephenson = recklessness requires actual subjective foresight of the risk; if D genuinely cannot appreciate the risk, D is not reckless.