- Published on
Kembaraxtra-Case Law-Slingsby (1995) - Unlawful Act Manslaughter & Consent
Case Citation: Slingsby (1995)
Legal Issue: Can consent be a valid defense against an unlawful act manslaughter charge when the "unlawful act" is battery during consensual sexual activity? Specifically, if injury results from consensual activity, does that automatically render the act unlawful battery?
Facts:
Case Citation: Slingsby (1995)
Legal Issue: Can consent be a valid defense against an unlawful act manslaughter charge when the "unlawful act" is battery during consensual sexual activity? Specifically, if injury results from consensual activity, does that automatically render the act unlawful battery?
Facts:
- The defendant (D) and the victim (V) engaged in consensual sexual activity.
- D inserted his hand into V's vagina and rectum.
- A ring on D's finger caused cuts to V.
- V was unaware of the severity of the injuries.
- V died from septicaemia (blood poisoning) as a result of the cuts.
- D was charged with unlawful act manslaughter; the prosecution argued the unlawful act was battery.
- D argued that V had consented to the sexual activity, therefore the battery (if any) was not unlawful.
- The court rejected the argument that injury occurring during consensual activity automatically transforms the act into unlawful battery.
- The activity should not be treated as criminal "merely because in the course of the activity an injury occurred".
- Consent to the underlying act negates the unlawfulness.
- Consent and Battery: This case highlights that consent can be a valid defense to battery, even when that battery unintentionally causes harm during consensual activity.
- Unlawful Act Manslaughter: For an unlawful act manslaughter conviction, the unlawful act itself must be established. If the act is rendered lawful due to consent, it cannot serve as the basis for manslaughter.
- Focus on the Act, Not Just the Outcome: The court emphasized that the nature of the act itself must be considered, not just the resulting injury. Injury alone does not automatically make an otherwise consensual act unlawful.
0 Comments