- Published on
KembaraXtra-Case Law- Smith (1961) - Implied Malice and Objective Test for Murder
Citation: Smith (1961) HL
Facts:
Issue:
Citation: Smith (1961) HL
Facts:
- Defendant (D), in possession of stolen goods, was driving a car.
- Victim (V), a police officer, signaled D to stop.
- D sped away while V was clinging to the car door.
- V suffered fatal injuries after colliding with another vehicle.
Issue:
- Whether D possessed the requisite mens rea (mental state) for murder, specifically malice aforethought, by committing an act likely to cause grievous bodily harm.
- D was found guilty of murder.
- Definition of Grievous Bodily Harm:
- Lord Chancellor Kilmuir clarified the meaning of "grievous bodily harm."
- "Bodily harm" requires no further explanation.
- "Grievous" means "really serious."
- Objective Test for Intention (Implied Malice):
- The court established an objective test to determine if the defendant possessed the mens rea for murder.
- Focus: Not on what the defendant actually contemplated or foresaw, but on what a reasonable person would have foreseen.
- Test: Was the unlawful and voluntary act of such a kind that grievous bodily harm was the natural and probable result?
- Perspective: What would the ordinary responsible man, in all the circumstances, have contemplated as the natural and probable result?
- Implied Malice: Smith exemplifies the concept of implied malice in murder, where the intent to kill is not explicit, but inferred from the nature of the act and its likely consequences.
- Objective Standard: The case firmly establishes an objective standard for assessing the mens rea in cases involving grievous bodily harm. The defendant's actual state of mind is secondary to what a reasonable person would have foreseen.
- Significance: Smith became a landmark case defining the boundaries of implied malice and the application of an objective standard in English criminal law. Later criticised and overruled by R v Cunningham in regards to the test being subjective for criminal damage.
0 Comments