LAW

Published on
KembaraXtra – Indian Evidence Law – Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam – Declaration Made in a Will or Deed Relating to Family Affairs (Section 26(f))

1. Basic Principle of Section 26(f)Under Section 26(f) of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, the law provides that:
Statements made by a person who is dead or cannot be found, relating to the existence of family relationships (by blood, marriage, or adoption), are relevant if they are contained in:
  • A will or deed relating to family affairs, OR
  • A family pedigree, tombstone, family portrait, or similar object
👉 Provided:
  • The statement is made ante litem motam (before any dispute arose)

2. Scope of the Provision
  • Applies to:
    • Family relationships such as:
      • Parentage
      • Marriage
      • Adoption
      • Lineage
  • Covers:
    • Statements found in:
      • Wills
      • Family records
      • Tombstones
      • Family portraits
👉 These are considered reliable as they are:
  • Made in natural family settings
  • Free from litigation bias

3. Essential Conditions (Note Form)For admissibility under Section 26(f):
  • ✔ Maker of statement must be:
    • Dead or cannot be found
  • ✔ Statement must relate to:
    • Family relationship
  • ✔ Statement must be:
    • Contained in:
      • Will, deed, pedigree, tombstone, etc.
  • ✔ Must be made:
    • Ante litem motam (before dispute arose)

4. Meaning of Ante Litem Motam
  • Means:
    👉 Statement made before any litigation or dispute
✔ Ensures:
  • Statement is:
    • Unbiased and trustworthy

5. Evidentiary Value
  • ✔ Statements are:
    • Relevant evidence
👉 Because:
  • They reflect:
    • Natural family declarations
  • Not made with:
    • Motive to mislead

6. Difference Between Section 26(e) and Section 26(f) (Note Form)(i) Persons Concerned
  • Section 26(e):
    • Applies to:
      • Living or deceased persons
  • Section 26(f):
    • Applies only when:
      • Person is dead or cannot be found

(ii) Source of Knowledge
  • Section 26(e):
    • Requires:
      • Person with special means of knowledge
  • Section 26(f):
    • No such requirement explicitly

(iii) Form of Statement
  • Section 26(e):
    • May be:
      • Oral or written
  • Section 26(f):
    • Must be:
      • In documents or physical objects
        (e.g., will, tombstone, pedigree)

(iv) Nature of Evidence
  • Section 26(e):
    • Statement of a person
  • Section 26(f):
    • Statement embodied in:
      • Things or documents

7. Illustration Explained
  • If a will states:
    • “A is the son of B”
👉 And maker is dead
✔ Statement is:
  • Relevant to prove relationship

8. Key Legal Principle👉 Statements relating to family relationships contained in wills, deeds, or family records made before dispute are admissible as relevant evidence.

9. Purpose of Section 26(f)
  • Recognizes:
    • Difficulty in proving:
      • Family lineage
  • Allows:
    • Use of:
      • Traditional and documentary family evidence

10. Key Takeaways
  • Section 26(f) deals with:
    • Family relationship declarations in documents
  • Conditions:
    • Dead/unavailable maker
    • Ante litem motam
  • Evidence must be:
    • In recognized forms (will, pedigree, etc.)

One-Line Summary👉 Statements about family relationships contained in wills, deeds, or similar records made before dispute by deceased persons are relevant evidence.
Picture
0 Comments