​KembaraXtra – Indian Evidence Law – Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam – Declaration Relating to Existence of Relationship (Section 26(e))
​
1. Basic Principle of Section 26(e)Under Section 26(e) of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, the law provides that:
Statements made by a person who is dead or cannot be found, relating to the existence of relationship (by blood, marriage, or adoption), are relevant facts, provided certain conditions are fulfilled.

2. Nature of Such Statements

• Statements may be:
  • Oral, or
  • Written, such as:
    • Family correspondence
    • Recitals in deeds or wills
    • Pleadings or depositions
    • School registers

👉 These are accepted because:

• They often come from persons closely connected with the family

3. Essential Conditions (Note Form)For admissibility under Section 26(e):

• ✔ Unavailability of Maker
  • Person must be:
    • Dead, or
    • Cannot be found, or otherwise unavailable
• ✔ Subject Matter
  • Statement must relate to:
    • Relationship by:
      • Blood
      • Marriage
      • Adoption
• ✔ Special Means of Knowledge
  • Maker must have:
    • Special knowledge about the relationship
• ✔ Ante Litem Motam
  • Statement must be made:
    • Before any dispute arose

4. Meaning of “Special Means of Knowledge”

• Refers to:
  • Close family members
  • Persons directly connected with family affairs

👉 Example:

• Parents, relatives, guardians

5. Evidentiary Value

• ✔ Statements are:
  • Relevant evidence

👉 But:

• Weight depends on:
  • Reliability of source
  • Authenticity of record

6. Illustration from Case LawIn State of Punjab v Mohinder Singh:

• Horoscope was considered:
  • ❌ Weak evidence
• Reason:
  • Maker not available
  • No proof of special knowledge

👉 Held:

• Horoscope is inadmissible to prove age

7. Comparison of Evidence (Important Insight)

• School Register Entry
  • ✔ More reliable
  • Based on:
    • Information from parents/guardians
• Horoscope
  • ❌ Less reliable
  • Lacks:
    • Proven authenticity

👉 Therefore:

• School records have greater evidentiary value

8. Key Legal Principle👉 Statements relating to family relationships made by persons with special knowledge before any dispute are relevant, but their weight depends on reliability.

9. Purpose of Section 26(e)

• Facilitates proof of:
  • Family relationships
• Recognizes:
  • Difficulty in producing direct evidence

10. Key Takeaways

• Section 26(e) deals with:
  • Declarations about relationships
• Requirements:
  • Unavailable maker
  • Special knowledge
  • Ante litem motam
• Evidence:
  • ✔ Relevant
  • Depends on credibility

One-Line Summary👉 Statements made by unavailable persons with special knowledge about family relationships, before any dispute, are relevant evidence under Section 26(e).