- Published on
KembaraXtra – Legal Terms – ProponentA proponent is the party in litigation who bears the evidential burden, and in some situations the persuasive burden, of proof regarding a particular issue before the court. The evidential burden requires the party to produce sufficient evidence to raise an issue for consideration, while the persuasive burden requires convincing the court of the truth of that issue to the required standard of proof. In criminal proceedings, the prosecution is generally the proponent because it must prove the defendant’s guilt beyond reasonable doubt. In civil proceedings, the claimant is usually the proponent and must establish his case on the balance of probabilities. However, the burden may shift during proceedings depending on statutory rules or the nature of the defence raised.
The role of the proponent is fundamental because courts do not normally decide issues without evidence being presented by the party asserting them. If the proponent fails to discharge the burden of proof, the issue will generally be decided against him. In some situations, the law places only an evidential burden on one party while the persuasive burden remains on another. Certain presumptions may also affect the burden borne by the proponent. The concept therefore plays an essential role in determining how disputes are argued and resolved in both civil and criminal litigation.
The role of the proponent is fundamental because courts do not normally decide issues without evidence being presented by the party asserting them. If the proponent fails to discharge the burden of proof, the issue will generally be decided against him. In some situations, the law places only an evidential burden on one party while the persuasive burden remains on another. Certain presumptions may also affect the burden borne by the proponent. The concept therefore plays an essential role in determining how disputes are argued and resolved in both civil and criminal litigation.
0 Comments