KembaraXtra - Legal Terms - Specimen of Breath

⸻

1. Introduction

A specimen of breath is a breath sample provided by a person suspected of committing a drink-driving offence for the purpose of determining the concentration of alcohol in his or her breath. It constitutes the principal evidential test used in prosecutions for offences involving driving or attempting to drive while over the prescribed alcohol limit. The evidential breath specimen should not be confused with the preliminary breath test, which is carried out at the roadside to determine whether further investigation is justified. The evidential specimen is obtained only after the suspect has been taken to a police station and is analysed using an approved evidential breath-testing device. As a result, the specimen of breath forms one of the most important pieces of scientific evidence in drink-driving prosecutions under English road traffic law.

⸻

2. Statutory Framework

The legal rules governing evidential breath specimens are contained principally in the Road Traffic Act 1988, which prescribes the circumstances in which police officers may require suspects to provide breath samples for evidential analysis. A specimen may be required whenever the police are investigating offences relating to driving with excess alcohol, driving while unfit through drink, or related road traffic offences, provided that the suspect is at a police station. In most cases, the suspect will have been arrested following a positive roadside breath test or after refusing to submit to the preliminary test without lawful excuse. Before requesting the evidential specimen, the police officer must inform the suspect that failure to provide the specimen without a reasonable excuse constitutes a separate criminal offence. This statutory framework ensures both the effective investigation of drink-driving offences and the protection of procedural fairness.

⸻

3. Procedure for Taking the Specimen

Once at the police station, the suspect is normally required to provide two separate breath specimens using an approved evidential electronic breath analysis device, which is distinct from the handheld roadside breathalyser used during the preliminary breath test. The machine automatically measures the alcohol concentration contained in each breath sample and produces printed records of the results. For evidential purposes, the lower of the two readings is relied upon during any subsequent prosecution, thereby providing an additional safeguard against inaccurate measurements. A police officer then signs a certificate confirming that the reading relates to the defendant’s breath specimen taken at the specified time in accordance with section 8 of the Road Traffic Act 1988. Copies of both the certificate and the machine print-out must generally be supplied to the defendant at least seven days before trial, ensuring adequate opportunity to prepare a defence.

⸻

4. Failure to Provide a Specimen

A person who, without a reasonable excuse, fails or refuses to provide an evidential breath specimen commits a separate criminal offence under the Road Traffic Act 1988. This offence is punishable by a fine, imprisonment in appropriate cases, endorsement of the driving licence with ten penalty points, and either discretionary or mandatory disqualification from driving depending upon the nature of the underlying allegation. Before liability can arise, however, the police officer must have warned the suspect that refusal without reasonable excuse constitutes a criminal offence. Genuine medical conditions or other lawful justifications may amount to reasonable excuses, but mere unwillingness or inconvenience will not. The offence reflects Parliament’s intention that motorists should not be permitted to frustrate drink-driving investigations by refusing to cooperate with lawful evidential procedures.

⸻

5. Alternative Specimens and Defence Rights

The law recognises that breath testing may not always be appropriate or sufficiently reliable in every situation and therefore permits the use of alternative specimens in specified circumstances. A suspect may, in certain cases, provide a specimen of blood or a specimen of urine instead of a breath specimen, particularly where medical reasons prevent breath testing or where statutory conditions authorise an alternative procedure. Furthermore, if the evidential breath analysis records more than 35 but less than 50 micrograms of alcohol per 100 millilitres of breath, and prosecution is intended, the suspect has the statutory right to request that the breath specimen be replaced by a blood or urine specimen for analysis. During any subsequent trial, the defendant may also present evidence that alcohol consumed after the alleged driving but before providing the specimen accounted for the recorded alcohol level. However, deliberately consuming additional alcohol after driving in order to obstruct the investigation constitutes a separate criminal offence.

⸻

6. Legal Importance

The specimen of breath is the cornerstone of modern drink-driving enforcement because it provides objective scientific evidence capable of establishing whether a driver has exceeded the prescribed legal alcohol limit. The detailed statutory safeguards governing the taking, analysis, certification, and disclosure of breath specimens ensure both the reliability of forensic evidence and the protection of defendants’ procedural rights. By requiring approved equipment, multiple samples, independent documentary evidence, and opportunities for defendants to challenge the prosecution’s case, the law maintains confidence in the fairness and accuracy of criminal proceedings. The availability of alternative blood or urine specimens further reinforces the integrity of the evidential process by accommodating exceptional circumstances where breath analysis may be inappropriate. Consequently, the specimen of breath remains one of the most significant evidential mechanisms within English road traffic law, supporting the effective prosecution of drink-driving offences while safeguarding the principles of due process and justice.