- Published on
KembaraXtra - Legal Terms - Tracing
1. Introduction
Tracing is a legal process used to identify property or its substitute as it passes through transactions or changes form.
It is particularly important in trust law, restitution, insolvency, and disputes involving misappropriated assets.
Tracing enables a claimant to establish a connection between an original asset and property representing its value.
2. Nature of Tracing
Tracing does not itself create a substantive right to property.
It is a process for identifying the continued existence of value through successive substitutions.
The claimant must establish a legal basis for asserting rights over the identified property.
3. Following and Tracing
Following involves identifying the same asset as it moves between persons.
Tracing involves identifying a substitute asset.
For example, following concerns locating a particular stolen painting, while tracing may concern identifying the money received from its sale.
4. Tracing at Common Law
Common law tracing traditionally operates according to comparatively restrictive rules.
In particular, difficulties arise where money becomes mixed with other money.
The common law approach has historically been less flexible than equitable tracing.
5. Tracing in Equity
Equitable tracing may permit the identification of property through mixed funds.
This is particularly important where misappropriated money is deposited into a bank account containing other funds.
Equitable tracing is subject to its own legal requirements.
6. Mixed Funds
A mixed fund contains money from different sources.
For example, a trustee may wrongfully deposit trust money into a personal bank account.
Equitable tracing principles may enable the beneficiaries to identify an interest in the remaining funds or substitute assets.
7. Fiduciary Relationships
Equitable tracing has traditionally been associated with fiduciary relationships.
However, the precise role of a pre-existing fiduciary relationship has been debated in judicial decisions and academic commentary.
It is therefore too broad to state that equitable tracing invariably requires a pre-existing fiduciary relationship between claimant and defendant.
8. Westdeutsche Landesbank v Islington LBC
In Westdeutsche Landesbank Girozentrale v Islington London Borough Council [1996] AC 669, the House of Lords considered important questions concerning resulting trusts, equitable interests, and restitution.
The decision remains influential in discussions of equitable proprietary claims.
9. Foskett v McKeown
In Foskett v McKeown [2001] 1 AC 102, the House of Lords considered tracing into the proceeds of a life insurance policy.
The decision is particularly important for the distinction between proprietary rights and unjust enrichment.
It also illustrates the operation of tracing through substitute assets.
10. Lowest Intermediate Balance Rule
Where trust money is mixed with personal funds in a bank account, the lowest intermediate balance rule may be relevant.
Broadly, subsequent deposits of the wrongdoer's own money do not automatically replenish previously dissipated trust funds.
The rule is subject to the applicable equitable principles.
11. Backward Tracing
Backward tracing concerns circumstances in which misappropriated funds are used to discharge a liability associated with an earlier acquisition.
In Federal Republic of Brazil v Durant International Corporation [2015] UKPC 35, the Privy Council recognised that backward tracing may be available in appropriate circumstances.
The analysis depends upon the transactional connection.
12. Proprietary Remedies
Successful tracing may support a proprietary claim.
Depending upon the circumstances, a claimant may assert rights to identified assets or their proceeds.
Possible remedies include declarations of beneficial ownership or equitable liens.
13. Bona Fide Purchasers
Proprietary claims may be defeated where property reaches a bona fide purchaser for value without notice of the relevant equitable interest.
The precise rules depend upon the nature of the property and claim.
14. Legal Importance
Tracing is fundamental to the recovery of misappropriated assets.
It enables courts to examine the movement of property and value through transactions, accounts, and substitute assets.