- Published on
KembaraXtra - Legal Terms - Transferred Malice
1. Introduction
Transferred malice is a doctrine of criminal law under which the defendant's intention to harm one person may, in appropriate circumstances, satisfy the mental element of an offence committed against another person.
The doctrine is particularly associated with offences against the person.
It does not mean that every criminal intention can be transferred between unrelated offences.
2. Basic Principle
Transferred malice may arise where a defendant intends to commit an offence against one person but accidentally causes the same kind of harm to another.
For example, a person who throws a stone intending to strike A but instead strikes B may still possess the relevant mens rea for an offence against B.
3. Actus Reus and Mens Rea
Criminal liability generally requires:
Actus reus: The prohibited conduct or consequence.
Mens rea: The required mental element.
Transferred malice addresses the relationship between the defendant's intention and the actual victim.
4. R v Latimer
In R v Latimer (1886) 17 QBD 359, the defendant struck at one person with a belt but injured another.
The court applied the principle of transferred malice.
The case is a leading authority concerning the doctrine.
5. Unintended Victim
The doctrine allows the relevant intention to attach to the harm caused to an unintended victim.
It prevents a defendant from avoiding liability solely because the wrong person was injured.
6. Limits of the Doctrine
Transferred malice generally requires a sufficient correspondence between the intended offence and the offence actually committed.
It does not permit an intention relating to one type of offence to be transferred indiscriminately to a fundamentally different offence.
7. R v Pembliton
In R v Pembliton (1874) LR 2 CCR 119, the defendant threw a stone intending to strike people but broke a window.
The court declined to transfer the relevant intention to the property damage offence.
The case illustrates the limits of transferred malice.
8. Distinction from Recklessness
Transferred malice concerns the attribution of an existing intention to an unintended victim.
Recklessness concerns the defendant's awareness and unjustified taking of a legally relevant risk.
The doctrines address different mental elements.
9. Legal Importance
Transferred malice helps ensure that criminal liability reflects culpable intentions where the identity of the victim differs from what the defendant anticipated.
It remains an important doctrine in the law of offences against the person.