- Published on
KembaraXtra - Legal Terms - Wednesbury Unreasonableness
1. Introduction
Wednesbury unreasonableness is a principle of English administrative law under which a court may declare a decision of a public authority unlawful because it is so unreasonable that no reasonable authority could have made it.
The principle is an important ground of judicial review.
2. Origin of the Principle
The principle takes its name from the case of Associated Provincial Picture Houses Ltd v Wednesbury Corporation 1948 1 KB 223.
The case established a highly influential standard for reviewing the reasonableness of administrative decisions.
3. Facts of the Wednesbury Case
Wednesbury Corporation granted a cinema permission to open on Sundays, subject to a condition prohibiting the admission of children under the age of 15.
The cinema operator challenged the condition as unreasonable.
4. Decision of the Court
The Court of Appeal upheld the local authority’s decision.
The court concluded that the condition did not exceed the limits of the authority’s lawful discretion.
5. Lord Greene MR
Lord Greene MR formulated the influential principle that a court may intervene where an administrative decision is so unreasonable that no reasonable authority could ever have reached it.
6. High Threshold of Unreasonableness
Wednesbury unreasonableness establishes a demanding standard.
It is not sufficient that the court considers a decision mistaken, harsh, or undesirable.
The decision must fall outside the range of outcomes reasonably open to the decision-maker.
7. Judicial Review
Judicial review is the procedure through which courts examine the lawfulness of decisions made by public authorities.
Wednesbury unreasonableness provides one ground upon which such decisions may be challenged.
8. Administrative Discretion
Public authorities frequently possess statutory discretion to make decisions within specified legal limits.
The Wednesbury principle restricts the exercise of that discretion where a decision is exceptionally unreasonable.
9. Relevant Considerations
A public authority must take account of considerations that the law requires it to consider.
Failure to consider relevant matters may render a decision unlawful.
10. Irrelevant Considerations
A public authority must not base its decision upon considerations that are legally irrelevant.
Taking irrelevant matters into account may constitute an unlawful exercise of discretion.
11. Irrationality
Wednesbury unreasonableness is closely associated with the judicial review ground of irrationality.
A decision may be irrational where it falls outside the range of reasonable responses available to the authority.
12. Council of Civil Service Unions v Minister for the Civil Service
In Council of Civil Service Unions v Minister for the Civil Service 1985 AC 374, commonly known as the GCHQ case, Lord Diplock identified irrationality as one of the principal grounds of judicial review.
His explanation reflected the Wednesbury standard.
13. Judicial Restraint
The Wednesbury principle reflects judicial restraint in reviewing administrative decisions.
Courts generally recognise that Parliament may entrust decisions involving policy, expertise, or judgment to public authorities rather than judges.
14. Merits Versus Legality
Judicial review ordinarily concerns the legality of a decision rather than whether the court would have made the same decision.
Wednesbury unreasonableness does not permit the court simply to substitute its own preferred outcome.
15. Public Authorities
The principle may apply to decisions made by public bodies exercising statutory or other public-law powers.
The applicable intensity of review depends upon the legal context.
16. Proportionality
Proportionality is a related but distinct principle of public law.
It examines whether a measure pursues a legitimate objective and whether the interference involved is justified and appropriately limited.
17. Human Rights Cases
In cases involving rights protected by the Human Rights Act 1998, courts may apply proportionality rather than relying solely upon traditional Wednesbury unreasonableness.
18. Intensity of Judicial Review
The intensity with which courts scrutinise administrative decisions may vary.
Decisions affecting fundamental rights may attract more rigorous examination than decisions involving broad policy or technical discretion.
19. Remedies
Where a decision is unlawful because of Wednesbury unreasonableness, the court may grant an appropriate judicial review remedy.
This may include a quashing order setting aside the decision.
20. Legal Importance
Wednesbury unreasonableness is a foundational principle of English administrative law. It establishes limits on the exercise of public discretion while recognising the distinction between judicial supervision of legality and the merits of administrative decision-making.