- Published on
KembaraXtra - Legal Terms - Whole Life Order
1. Introduction
A Whole Life Order is a sentencing order made by a court in England and Wales requiring an offender sentenced to life imprisonment to serve the whole of their remaining life in prison, subject to the limited statutory power of release on compassionate grounds.
It represents the most severe punishment available under the criminal law of England and Wales.
A Whole Life Order is generally reserved for cases involving murder of exceptionally high seriousness.
2. Meaning of a Whole Life Order
A Whole Life Order means that the offender is not given a minimum custodial term after which they may ordinarily be considered for release by the Parole Board.
Unlike most prisoners serving life sentences, a person subject to a Whole Life Order has no ordinary prospect of release through the parole system.
3. Statutory Basis
The principal statutory framework governing Whole Life Orders is contained in the Sentencing Act 2020, particularly Schedule 21, as amended.
The legislation provides principles for determining the appropriate minimum term or whole life order for offenders convicted of murder.
4. Mandatory Life Sentence for Murder
In England and Wales, murder carries a mandatory sentence of life imprisonment.
However, a mandatory life sentence does not necessarily mean that the offender will remain in prison for the rest of their life.
The court must determine whether the offender should receive a minimum term or a Whole Life Order, according to the applicable statutory provisions.
5. Distinction Between Life Imprisonment and a Whole Life Order
A life sentence ordinarily continues for the remainder of the offender’s life, even if the offender is eventually released on licence.
A Whole Life Order is different because it ordinarily excludes release through the parole process.
The distinction concerns the possibility of release, rather than the legal duration of the life sentence.
6. Minimum Term
For an ordinary life sentence, the court generally specifies a minimum term, sometimes called a tariff.
The minimum term represents the period that must be served before the offender can become eligible for consideration for release.
Release is not automatic when the minimum term expires.
7. Absence of an Ordinary Minimum Term
Where a Whole Life Order is imposed, the offender does not receive an ordinary minimum term leading to parole eligibility.
Instead, the court orders that the life sentence is to be served without the ordinary possibility of release.
8. Exceptional Seriousness
Whole Life Orders are associated with murder cases involving exceptionally high seriousness.
The court considers the circumstances of the offence, the offender’s culpability, and the statutory sentencing framework.
9. Schedule 21 of the Sentencing Act 2020
Schedule 21 establishes starting points and principles for sentencing offenders convicted of murder.
It identifies circumstances in which a whole life starting point may apply.
The court must consider the relevant aggravating and mitigating factors and any other applicable statutory requirements.
10. Multiple Murders
A Whole Life Order may be appropriate in cases involving the murder of two or more persons where the circumstances meet the statutory criteria for exceptional seriousness.
Relevant factors may include substantial premeditation, abduction, or sexual or sadistic conduct.
11. Murder of a Child
Certain murders of children may attract a whole life starting point under Schedule 21.
The applicable statutory provisions distinguish particular circumstances, including specified forms of serious violence or abuse.
12. Murder of Police or Prison Officers
The murder of a police officer or prison officer acting in the course of their duty may fall within the statutory categories attracting a whole life starting point.
Such offences are treated with particular seriousness because they involve attacks upon persons performing important public functions.
13. Terrorism-Related Murder
Certain murders committed for the purpose of advancing a political, religious, racial, or ideological cause may attract a whole life starting point.
The statutory framework also contains provisions concerning murders connected with terrorism.
14. Murder by an Offender Previously Convicted of Murder
A whole life starting point may apply where an offender commits murder after having previously been convicted of murder.
The court must apply the relevant statutory provisions to the circumstances of the case.
15. Aggravating Factors
Aggravating factors increase the seriousness of an offence.
They may include substantial planning, particular cruelty, vulnerability of the victim, or other circumstances identified by the legislation.
16. Mitigating Factors
Mitigating factors may reduce the seriousness of an offence or the appropriate punishment.
The court must consider relevant mitigation in accordance with the applicable sentencing framework.
17. Judicial Discretion
Although legislation identifies cases in which a whole life starting point applies, the sentencing court must consider the offence as a whole.
The final sentence must reflect the statutory requirements and the particular circumstances of the case.
18. Age of the Offender
The age of the offender is legally significant.
Under the statutory framework, Whole Life Orders are not available for offenders who were under 18 when the offence was committed.
For offenders aged 18 to 20 at the time of the offence, special statutory restrictions apply to the imposition of a Whole Life Order.
19. Role of the Sentencing Judge
The sentencing judge determines whether the statutory requirements for a Whole Life Order are satisfied.
The judge must explain the reasons for imposing the sentence.
20. Appeal Against a Whole Life Order
A Whole Life Order may be challenged through the applicable criminal appeal procedures.
An appellate court may examine whether the sentencing judge applied the law correctly and whether the sentence was appropriate.
21. Human Rights Considerations
Whole Life Orders raise important questions under Article 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights, which prohibits torture and inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment.
The compatibility of whole life imprisonment with Article 3 has been considered by both domestic courts and the European Court of Human Rights.
22. Vinter and Others v United Kingdom
In Vinter and Others v United Kingdom (2013), the European Court of Human Rights considered whether whole life sentences were compatible with Article 3.
The Court emphasised the importance of a legally recognisable possibility of review and release in appropriate circumstances.
23. R v McLoughlin
In R v McLoughlin 2014 EWCA Crim 188, the Court of Appeal considered the compatibility of Whole Life Orders with Article 3.
The Court explained the significance of the statutory power permitting release in exceptional circumstances.
24. Hutchinson v United Kingdom
In Hutchinson v United Kingdom (2017), the Grand Chamber of the European Court of Human Rights accepted that the English system of Whole Life Orders was compatible with Article 3.
The Court considered the availability of exceptional release and the relevant domestic legal safeguards.
25. Compassionate Release
Section 30 of the Crime (Sentences) Act 1997 provides a power for the Secretary of State to release a life prisoner on compassionate grounds where the statutory requirements are satisfied.
This power may apply to prisoners serving Whole Life Orders.
26. Exceptional Circumstances
Compassionate release is exceptional.
A prisoner subject to a Whole Life Order cannot ordinarily obtain release merely because they have served a lengthy period in prison or demonstrated good behaviour.
27. Role of the Secretary of State
The Secretary of State has a statutory role in considering compassionate release.
Any decision must be made in accordance with the applicable legislation and public law requirements.
28. Role of the Parole Board
The Parole Board ordinarily assesses whether eligible life-sentenced prisoners can safely be released after serving their minimum terms.
However, a prisoner subject to a Whole Life Order does not ordinarily become eligible for Parole Board consideration.
29. Public Protection
One purpose of a Whole Life Order is to protect the public from offenders responsible for exceptionally serious crimes.
The sentence also reflects the gravity of the offence and the punishment considered appropriate by law.
30. Retribution and Deterrence
Whole Life Orders reflect the sentencing objectives of punishment and, where relevant, deterrence.
They express society’s condemnation of the most serious forms of criminal wrongdoing.
31. Rehabilitation
Rehabilitation remains a general objective of the criminal justice system.
However, a Whole Life Order places particular emphasis on the seriousness of the offence and the absence of ordinary eligibility for release.
32. Distinction from a Determinate Sentence
A determinate sentence is a sentence of imprisonment imposed for a specified period.
A Whole Life Order, by contrast, is imposed as part of a life sentence and ordinarily requires imprisonment for the offender’s remaining lifetime.
33. Distinction from a Discretionary Life Sentence
A discretionary life sentence may be imposed for certain serious offences where the statutory conditions are satisfied.
A Whole Life Order is a particular sentencing arrangement associated with life imprisonment for murder under the applicable statutory framework.
34. Legal Importance
A Whole Life Order is one of the most significant sentencing measures in the criminal law of England and Wales.
Its legal importance lies in providing the courts with a means of imposing the most severe custodial punishment for murders of exceptionally high seriousness.
The order ordinarily removes the possibility of release through the parole system while preserving a narrowly defined statutory mechanism for compassionate release.
Whole Life Orders also illustrate the relationship between criminal punishment, judicial discretion, public protection, and the human rights principles governing life imprisonment.