- Published on
KembaraXtra - Legal Terms - Without Prejudice
1. Introduction
Without prejudice is a legal expression used in negotiations between parties who are attempting to settle an existing dispute.
In English law, the expression is particularly associated with communications made for the genuine purpose of reaching a settlement.
The without prejudice rule generally prevents such communications from being disclosed or relied upon as evidence of admissions against the party who made them.
Its principal purpose is to encourage parties to negotiate freely and resolve disputes without unnecessary litigation.
2. Meaning of Without Prejudice
The expression without prejudice indicates that a communication is made in the course of settlement negotiations without surrendering the sender’s legal position.
A party may make a concession, offer a compromise, or discuss a possible settlement without necessarily admitting legal liability.
For example, a defendant may offer money to settle a claim while continuing to deny responsibility.
Where the without prejudice rule applies, the settlement communication is generally protected from being used as evidence of liability in the proceedings.
3. Nature of the Without Prejudice Rule
The without prejudice rule is a principle of the law of evidence.
It generally protects communications made in a genuine attempt to settle a dispute.
The protection may apply to written correspondence, oral discussions, and other forms of settlement communication.
It is not limited to documents expressly marked “without prejudice”.
4. Purpose of the Rule
The principal purposes of the without prejudice rule are:
1. Encouraging settlement: Parties can negotiate without fearing that every concession will later be used against them.
2. Promoting frank discussions: Parties may openly discuss weaknesses in their cases.
3. Reducing litigation: Successful negotiations may avoid the need for a trial.
4. Protecting legal positions: Settlement proposals do not ordinarily amount to admissions of liability.
5. Supporting judicial efficiency: Resolving disputes through negotiation reduces the burden on courts.
5. Public Policy Foundation
The without prejudice rule is supported by public policy.
The law recognises that parties should be encouraged to resolve disputes voluntarily.
If settlement discussions could routinely be used as evidence against the participants, parties might be reluctant to negotiate openly.
The rule therefore promotes the effective settlement of disputes.
6. Genuine Settlement Negotiations
The protection applies where communications form part of a genuine attempt to settle a dispute.
The court examines the substance and circumstances of the communication.
Merely describing a letter as “without prejudice” does not automatically make it protected.
7. Existence of a Dispute
The without prejudice rule ordinarily requires an existing dispute between the parties.
The dispute need not necessarily have resulted in court proceedings.
It is sufficient that the parties are genuinely attempting to resolve a disagreement concerning their legal rights or obligations.
8. Attempt to Reach a Compromise
A central requirement is that the communication forms part of an attempt to reach a compromise.
For example, parties may discuss:
- Payment of a reduced amount.
- Settlement of a contractual claim.
- Compensation for alleged wrongdoing.
- Withdrawal of legal proceedings.
- Agreement upon alternative contractual arrangements.
The communication must be assessed in its context.
9. Without Prejudice Correspondence
A without prejudice letter is correspondence sent during genuine settlement negotiations.
It may contain an offer, concession, proposed compromise, or discussion of settlement terms.
Where the rule applies, the letter is generally inadmissible as evidence of admissions concerning the substantive dispute.
10. Oral Communications
The without prejudice rule is not restricted to written documents.
It may also protect oral discussions conducted for the purpose of settlement.
For example, statements made during a genuine settlement meeting may fall within the rule.
11. Without Prejudice Meetings
Parties may arrange meetings specifically to explore settlement.
These meetings may involve the parties themselves, their solicitors, or other representatives.
Communications made during such meetings may be protected where the requirements of the without prejudice rule are satisfied.
12. Without Prejudice and Admission of Liability
A settlement offer does not necessarily constitute an admission of liability.
A defendant may offer compensation for commercial reasons, to avoid litigation costs, or to bring a dispute to an end.
The without prejudice rule helps prevent such an offer from being treated as an admission of wrongdoing.
13. Example of a Without Prejudice Offer
Suppose a claimant alleges that a defendant owes £20,000 under a contract.
The defendant disputes the claim but offers £12,000 to settle the matter.
If the offer forms part of genuine settlement negotiations, it may be protected by the without prejudice rule.
The claimant generally cannot rely upon the offer at trial as proof that the defendant admitted owing £12,000.
14. Protection Against Disclosure
Without prejudice communications are generally protected from disclosure or use as evidence in determining the substantive dispute.
This protection enables parties to discuss possible settlements without exposing their negotiating positions to the trial court.
However, the protection is subject to recognised exceptions.
15. Admissibility of Evidence
Admissibility concerns whether evidence may properly be considered by a court.
The without prejudice rule generally excludes protected settlement communications from being used as evidence of liability or the merits of the dispute.
The rule does not make every statement or document connected with negotiations inadmissible for every possible purpose.
16. Labelling Communications Without Prejudice
Parties commonly place the words “Without Prejudice” at the beginning of settlement correspondence.
The label indicates an intention to negotiate on a protected basis.
However, the legal effect depends upon the substance of the communication rather than the label alone.
17. Communications Not Expressly Labelled
A communication may be protected even if it is not expressly marked “without prejudice”.
If it is genuinely made for the purpose of settling an existing dispute, the rule may apply.
The absence of the label is therefore not necessarily decisive.
18. Improper Use of the Label
A party cannot automatically protect an otherwise admissible communication simply by writing “without prejudice” on it.
For example, an ordinary business letter demanding payment does not become privileged merely because it carries that heading.
The court considers whether the communication was genuinely connected with settlement negotiations.
19. Without Prejudice Privilege
The protection is often described as without prejudice privilege.
It differs from legal professional privilege, which protects certain confidential communications involving legal advice or litigation preparation.
Without prejudice privilege is concerned specifically with genuine settlement negotiations.
20. Relationship with Legal Professional Privilege
Legal professional privilege protects qualifying confidential communications between lawyers and clients or certain communications prepared for litigation.
Without prejudice privilege protects qualifying settlement communications between disputing parties.
The two doctrines have different legal foundations and requirements.
21. Rush & Tompkins Ltd v Greater London Council
In Rush & Tompkins Ltd v Greater London Council 1989 AC 1280, the House of Lords considered the scope of the without prejudice rule.
The decision emphasised the public policy of encouraging parties to settle disputes.
It is an important authority concerning the protection of settlement communications.
22. Unilever plc v Procter & Gamble Co
In Unilever plc v Procter & Gamble Co 2000 1 WLR 2436, the Court of Appeal examined the without prejudice rule and recognised exceptions to its application.
The case illustrates that the rule provides substantial protection but is not absolute.
23. Without Prejudice Save as to Costs
The expression without prejudice save as to costs refers to a settlement communication that is generally protected from consideration when the court determines the substantive dispute but may be disclosed when the court considers costs.
This allows the court to examine the parties’ settlement conduct after the merits have been decided.
24. Purpose of Without Prejudice Save as to Costs
The purpose is to encourage reasonable settlement offers while preserving the possibility of costs consequences.
A party who unreasonably rejects a settlement offer may face an adverse costs decision, depending upon the circumstances and applicable rules.
25. Calderbank Offers
A Calderbank offer is a settlement offer commonly made on a without prejudice save as to costs basis.
The terminology derives from Calderbank v Calderbank 1976 Fam 93.
Such offers may be relevant when the court determines costs.
26. Calderbank v Calderbank
In Calderbank v Calderbank 1976 Fam 93, the Court of Appeal considered the relevance of settlement offers to costs.
The case became associated with offers made without prejudice save as to costs.
The principle allows settlement conduct to be considered at the appropriate stage of proceedings.
27. Distinction Between Without Prejudice and Without Prejudice Save as to Costs
A. Without Prejudice
1. The communication is made for the genuine purpose of settling a dispute.
2. It is generally protected from being used as evidence of liability or the merits of the case.
3. The protection ordinarily continues when costs are considered, unless an exception or other basis for disclosure applies.
4. The principal objective is to encourage open settlement negotiations.
B. Without Prejudice Save as to Costs
1. The communication is also made for the genuine purpose of settlement.
2. It is generally protected while the court determines the substantive dispute.
3. It may be brought to the court’s attention when costs are considered.
4. The principal objective is to encourage settlement while allowing unreasonable refusal of an offer to have potential costs consequences.
C. Principal Distinction
The fundamental difference concerns whether the communication may be considered when the court determines costs.
A communication marked without prejudice save as to costs is intended to preserve that possibility.
28. Relationship with CPR Part 36
Part 36 of the Civil Procedure Rules establishes a formal procedure for making settlement offers with specified potential costs consequences.
A Part 36 offer operates under its own procedural requirements.
Although Part 36 offers and Calderbank offers both encourage settlement, they are legally distinct.
29. Part 36 Offers
A Part 36 offer is a formal settlement offer complying with the requirements of CPR Part 36.
Where the relevant conditions are satisfied, acceptance or rejection of the offer may have significant costs consequences.
Part 36 provides a structured procedural framework rather than relying solely upon the general without prejudice rule.
30. Without Prejudice and Mediation
Mediation is a process in which an independent mediator assists parties in attempting to resolve a dispute.
Communications during mediation may be protected by the without prejudice rule where they satisfy its requirements.
Confidentiality obligations may also arise under the parties’ mediation agreement.
31. Without Prejudice and Alternative Dispute Resolution
Alternative dispute resolution (ADR) includes processes such as mediation and negotiation.
The without prejudice rule supports ADR by encouraging parties to discuss settlement possibilities.
It allows parties to explore compromise without necessarily weakening their positions in subsequent litigation.
32. Exceptions to the Without Prejudice Rule
The without prejudice rule is not absolute.
Recognised exceptions may permit settlement communications to be admitted for particular purposes.
The availability of an exception depends upon the circumstances and the relevant legal principles.
33. Establishing Whether a Settlement Was Reached
Without prejudice communications may be admissible where the court must determine whether the parties concluded a binding settlement agreement.
For example, correspondence may be examined to establish whether an offer was accepted.
Otherwise, the rule could prevent the court from determining whether a settlement contract existed.
34. Interpretation of Settlement Agreements
In certain circumstances, without prejudice negotiations may be relevant to the interpretation of a settlement agreement.
The precise circumstances are governed by the applicable case law.
The general rule remains that protected negotiations cannot ordinarily be used to prove liability in the underlying dispute.
35. Unambiguous Impropriety
The courts recognise a narrow exception where without prejudice protection would conceal unambiguous impropriety.
This may arise where the privilege is being used as a cloak for sufficiently serious misconduct.
The exception is applied cautiously to preserve the policy of encouraging settlement.
36. Threats and Improper Conduct
A communication does not necessarily lose protection merely because it contains forceful negotiating language.
However, serious threats or other clearly improper conduct may, in exceptional circumstances, justify admission under the unambiguous impropriety exception.
The court examines the nature and context of the conduct.
37. Misrepresentation and Fraud
Without prejudice communications may become relevant where a party alleges that a settlement agreement was affected by fraud, misrepresentation, or another recognised ground for setting it aside.
The admissibility of such communications depends upon the legal issue and applicable exceptions.
38. Estoppel
In appropriate circumstances, without prejudice communications may be admissible where they give rise to an estoppel.
Estoppel may prevent a party from denying a representation or assumption where the relevant legal requirements are satisfied.
The rule cannot necessarily be used to prevent the court from considering communications essential to establishing such an estoppel.
39. Waiver of Without Prejudice Protection
Without prejudice protection generally belongs jointly to the parties participating in the protected negotiations.
It ordinarily cannot be waived unilaterally by one party.
Both parties’ agreement may be required before protected communications can be disclosed outside a recognised exception.
40. Confidentiality and Without Prejudice Protection
Confidentiality and without prejudice protection are related but distinct concepts.
A confidential communication is not automatically protected by the without prejudice rule.
Similarly, the legal protection of settlement negotiations depends upon the requirements of the rule rather than confidentiality alone.
41. Without Prejudice in Employment Disputes
Without prejudice negotiations frequently arise in employment disputes.
An employer and employee may discuss a proposed settlement concerning dismissal, contractual rights, or employment-related claims.
Where there is an existing dispute and a genuine attempt at settlement, the rule may apply.
42. Protected Conversations in Employment Law
Section 111A of the Employment Rights Act 1996 provides a separate statutory framework for certain pre-termination negotiations.
The provision may protect qualifying settlement discussions in ordinary unfair dismissal proceedings even where there is no existing dispute.
However, it is subject to limitations and exceptions and should not be confused with the common-law without prejudice rule.
43. Without Prejudice in Contractual Disputes
The rule commonly applies where parties negotiate the settlement of alleged contractual breaches.
For example, a supplier may dispute liability for defective goods while offering a partial refund to resolve the disagreement.
A genuine settlement offer may be protected without amounting to an admission of breach.
44. Without Prejudice in Debt Disputes
A debtor may offer to pay a reduced amount in settlement of a disputed debt.
Where the parties are genuinely negotiating the resolution of a dispute, the communication may fall within the without prejudice rule.
However, an ordinary acknowledgment of an undisputed debt does not become privileged merely because it is labelled without prejudice.
45. Without Prejudice in Personal Injury Claims
Parties to personal injury proceedings may negotiate compensation without admitting liability.
A defendant may offer a sum to settle the claim while maintaining that the alleged negligence is denied.
The without prejudice rule may protect qualifying negotiations from being used to prove liability.
46. Without Prejudice in Commercial Litigation
Commercial disputes frequently involve negotiations concerning substantial financial claims.
The without prejudice rule enables businesses to consider compromise without necessarily making admissible concessions.
This may assist in preserving commercial relationships and reducing litigation costs.
47. Importance of Legal Advice
Parties should distinguish between open correspondence and settlement communications intended to be without prejudice.
Incorrectly labelling a document may create uncertainty concerning its admissibility.
Legal advice may be particularly important where settlement offers could affect costs or other substantive rights.
48. Open Correspondence
Open correspondence refers to communications that are not protected by the without prejudice rule.
Such correspondence may be admissible in court, subject to ordinary evidential rules.
A party may use open correspondence to make formal demands, state its legal position, or provide information intended to be relied upon in proceedings.
49. Distinction Between Open and Without Prejudice Correspondence
A. Open Correspondence
1. It is not automatically protected from disclosure in litigation.
2. It may contain formal allegations, demands, or statements of legal position.
3. It may be relied upon as evidence where admissible.
4. It is appropriate where a party intends the communication to form part of the evidential record.
B. Without Prejudice Correspondence
1. It forms part of genuine settlement negotiations.
2. It is generally protected from being used to prove liability or the merits of the dispute.
3. It may contain settlement offers and concessions.
4. It is intended to facilitate compromise without surrendering legal rights.
50. Practical Example
Suppose a company alleges that a contractor breached a construction agreement and claims £100,000 in damages.
The contractor denies liability but wishes to avoid prolonged litigation.
The contractor sends a letter marked “Without Prejudice”, offering £45,000 in full and final settlement.
If the letter forms part of genuine settlement negotiations, the claimant generally cannot rely upon that offer at trial as evidence that the contractor admitted liability for £45,000.
The parties remain free to negotiate further.
51. Example of Without Prejudice Save as to Costs
Suppose a claimant seeks £50,000 in damages.
The defendant makes a genuine settlement offer of £40,000, expressly marked “Without Prejudice Save as to Costs”.
The claimant rejects the offer and proceeds to trial.
If the claimant subsequently obtains a less favourable judgment, the defendant may seek to rely upon the offer when the court determines costs.
The costs consequences are not automatic and depend upon the applicable rules and circumstances.
52. Limitations of the Rule
The without prejudice rule does not:
- Automatically protect every document bearing the words “without prejudice”.
- Apply to every communication between parties in disagreement.
- Prevent the court from considering communications under recognised exceptions.
- Make unlawful conduct permissible.
- Guarantee that a settlement offer will have no legal consequences.
- Replace the procedural requirements governing formal settlement offers.
53. Legal Importance
Without prejudice is a fundamental concept in English civil litigation and dispute resolution.
It generally protects communications made in genuine settlement negotiations from being used as evidence of admissions against the party who made them.
The rule is founded upon the public policy of encouraging parties to settle disputes voluntarily, openly, and efficiently.
Its protection may apply whether or not the communication is expressly labelled “without prejudice”, provided that the substantive legal requirements are satisfied.
The related expression without prejudice save as to costs allows qualifying settlement communications to be considered when the court determines costs, while ordinarily protecting them during the determination of the substantive dispute.
The rule is subject to recognised exceptions, including circumstances involving the existence of a settlement agreement, estoppel, and unambiguous impropriety.
Ultimately, the without prejudice rule promotes the settlement of disputes by allowing parties to negotiate compromises without ordinarily exposing their concessions and settlement proposals to use against them at trial.