LAW

Published on

KembaraXtra - Legal Terms - Witness

1. Introduction

A witness is a person who either observes and attests to the execution of a legal document or provides evidence concerning facts relevant to legal proceedings.

The term has two principal meanings in English law:

  • Attesting witness: A person who witnesses the signing of a legal document and may sign it to confirm that the relevant act occurred.
  • Evidential witness: A person who gives evidence in court, either orally or in an admissible written form.

Witnesses play an essential role in the administration of justice because they help establish facts, authenticate documents, and assist courts in resolving disputes.

2. Meaning of Witness

In legal terminology, a witness is a person who performs a legally recognised function by observing the execution of a document or supplying evidence relevant to a dispute.

The meaning depends upon the context.

In the execution of a will or deed, the witness may confirm that a signature was made or acknowledged in the required circumstances.

In litigation, the witness provides evidence that may assist the court in determining disputed facts.

3. Principal Categories of Witness

The two principal categories are:

A. Attesting Witness

A person who witnesses the execution of a legal document and signs an attestation where required.

B. Evidential Witness

A person who provides evidence relevant to legal proceedings.

An evidential witness may testify orally, provide a witness statement, or give expert opinion evidence where legally permitted.

4. Attesting Witness

An attesting witness is a person who observes the signing or acknowledgment of a legal document and confirms the relevant event through their own signature.

Attestation may be required for certain documents to be validly executed.

The witness’s function is to provide evidence that the execution formalities were observed.

5. Witnessing a Signature

Witnessing a signature generally involves observing the person sign the document.

Where the relevant law requires physical presence, the witness must comply with that requirement.

The precise formalities depend upon the type of document and applicable legislation.

6. Attestation

Attestation is the act of witnessing and formally confirming the execution of a document.

An attesting witness commonly signs an attestation clause or another appropriate part of the document.

The witness’s signature may later provide evidence that the document was properly executed.

7. Attestation Clause

An attestation clause is a provision in a legal document recording the circumstances in which it was executed and witnessed.

For example, a will may contain wording confirming that the testator signed in the presence of two witnesses who then signed in the required circumstances.

An attestation clause may assist in establishing due execution.

8. Witnessing a Will

Under section 9 of the Wills Act 1837, a valid will must satisfy specified formalities.

These generally include:

  • The will must be in writing.
  • The testator must sign it, or another person must sign on the testator’s behalf in the testator’s presence and by their direction.
  • The testator must intend the signature to give effect to the will.
  • The testator must sign or acknowledge the signature in the presence of two or more witnesses present at the same time.
  • Each witness must attest and sign, or acknowledge their signature, in the testator’s presence.

Special statutory provisions have applied in particular circumstances, but the ordinary requirements remain fundamental.

9. Importance of Witnesses to a Will

Witnesses help establish that the will was executed in accordance with the required legal formalities.

Their evidence may become important if the will is challenged after the testator’s death.

For example, a witness may be asked whether the testator signed or acknowledged the will in the required circumstances.

10. Beneficiary Acting as Witness

Section 15 of the Wills Act 1837 contains an important rule concerning gifts to attesting witnesses.

Generally, a gift under a will to an attesting witness, or to the witness’s spouse or civil partner, may be void, subject to the applicable statutory provisions and exceptions.

The will itself does not necessarily become invalid merely because a beneficiary acted as a witness.

11. Witnessing a Deed

A deed is a formal legal instrument that must satisfy particular execution requirements.

Under section 1 of the Law of Property (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1989, execution by an individual ordinarily involves signing in the presence of a witness who attests the signature, or another legally permitted method.

The witness helps establish that the deed was properly executed.

12. Evidential Witness

An evidential witness is a person who gives evidence relevant to a legal dispute or investigation.

The evidence may concern events personally observed, facts within the witness’s knowledge, or matters about which the witness is qualified to express an expert opinion.

The court determines the relevance, admissibility, and weight of the evidence.

13. Role of Witnesses in Court

Witnesses assist courts by providing information concerning disputed facts.

Their evidence may help establish:

  • What happened.
  • When and where an event occurred.
  • Who was involved.
  • What a person said or did.
  • Whether a document or object is authentic.
  • Whether particular circumstances existed.

The court evaluates the evidence according to the applicable legal principles.

14. Witnesses in Civil Proceedings

In civil proceedings, witnesses commonly provide evidence through written witness statements and, where required, oral testimony.

Their evidence may concern contractual dealings, accidents, property disputes, employment matters, or other civil claims.

The applicable procedures are principally governed by the Civil Procedure Rules.

15. Witnesses in Criminal Proceedings

In criminal proceedings, witnesses may provide evidence concerning the alleged offence, the identity of the accused, surrounding circumstances, or other relevant matters.

Witnesses may be called by the prosecution or the defence.

Their evidence is subject to the rules of criminal evidence and procedure.

16. Witness Statement

A witness statement is a written account of evidence that a person is able to give.

In civil proceedings, witness statements are governed principally by CPR Part 32 and the applicable practice directions.

A witness statement ordinarily contains a statement of truth.

17. Statement of Truth

A statement of truth is a formal confirmation that the person making a statement believes the facts stated to be true.

It is used in civil proceedings for witness statements and other specified documents.

Knowingly making a false statement in a document verified by a statement of truth may have serious consequences, including contempt of court.

18. Oral Evidence

Oral evidence is testimony given verbally before a court or tribunal.

A witness may be questioned about relevant events and circumstances.

Oral evidence ordinarily allows the opposing party to test the witness’s account through cross-examination.

19. Evidence on Oath

A witness may be required to give evidence under oath.

An oath is a formal undertaking to tell the truth, made in accordance with the applicable legal requirements.

Giving deliberately false material evidence under oath may constitute perjury.

20. Affirmation

An affirmation is a solemn declaration to tell the truth without taking a religious oath.

A witness who affirms is subject to the same obligation of truthfulness as a witness who takes an oath.

The law recognises affirmation as an alternative to an oath.

21. Witness’s Oath

The witness’s oath is the formal undertaking made by a witness before giving sworn evidence.

Its purpose is to emphasise the witness’s obligation to tell the truth.

A witness may instead make an affirmation where permitted.

22. Competency of Witnesses

Competency concerns whether a person is legally capable of giving evidence.

The applicable rules differ between civil and criminal proceedings.

In criminal proceedings, section 53 of the Youth Justice and Criminal Evidence Act 1999 provides a general presumption of competency, subject to the statutory test.

23. Test of Competency in Criminal Proceedings

Under section 53 of the Youth Justice and Criminal Evidence Act 1999, a person is not competent to give evidence if they cannot:

  • Understand questions put to them as a witness; and
  • Give answers that can be understood.

The court determines competency where the issue arises.

A witness need not necessarily understand every question or communicate in an ordinary manner to be competent.

24. Compellability of Witnesses

Compellability concerns whether a person may legally be required to give evidence.

A witness may be competent to testify but not compellable in particular circumstances.

Competency and compellability must therefore be distinguished.

25. Distinction Between Competency and Compellability

A. Competency

  • Concerns the legal capacity to give evidence.
  • Determines whether the witness is permitted to testify.
  • May depend upon the witness’s ability to understand questions and communicate answers.
  • Does not necessarily mean the witness can be forced to attend.

B. Compellability

  • Concerns whether the witness can legally be required to testify.
  • Determines whether compulsory legal procedures may be used.
  • May be subject to statutory exceptions and privileges.
  • Does not itself establish that the witness is competent.

26. Compellable Witness

A compellable witness is a person who may legally be required to attend court and give evidence.

A witness summons may be issued where the relevant requirements are satisfied.

Failure to comply without lawful excuse may result in legal consequences.

27. Non-Compellable Witness

A non-compellable witness is a person who cannot be required to testify in particular circumstances.

The position depends upon the nature of the proceedings and applicable statutory or common-law rules.

Non-compellability does not necessarily prevent a person from giving evidence voluntarily.

28. Child Witnesses

Children may give evidence in legal proceedings.

Their age alone does not automatically make them incompetent.

The court considers the applicable competency requirements and any measures necessary to assist the child in giving evidence.

29. Child Witnesses in Criminal Proceedings

Under the Youth Justice and Criminal Evidence Act 1999, children may be competent witnesses if they satisfy the statutory requirements.

Special measures may be available to assist eligible child witnesses.

These measures seek to improve the quality of evidence and reduce unnecessary distress.

30. Special Measures for Witnesses

Special measures are arrangements intended to assist eligible vulnerable or intimidated witnesses in criminal proceedings.

They may include:

  • Screens shielding the witness from the accused.
  • Giving evidence by live video link.
  • Evidence given in private in specified circumstances.
  • Removal of wigs and gowns where authorised.
  • Video-recorded evidence-in-chief.
  • Video-recorded cross-examination where the statutory scheme applies.
  • Assistance from an intermediary.
  • Communication aids.

The availability of a particular measure depends upon statutory requirements and judicial directions.

31. Vulnerable Witnesses

A vulnerable witness is a witness who may require additional assistance because of age, disability, or another legally relevant circumstance.

The court may consider appropriate measures to enable the witness to give their best evidence.

32. Intimidated Witnesses

An intimidated witness may experience fear or distress in connection with giving evidence.

In criminal proceedings, eligible witnesses may receive special measures under the relevant statutory framework.

The court considers whether the proposed measures are justified.

33. Witness Summons

A witness summons is a formal court document requiring a person to attend court to give evidence or produce specified documents.

In civil proceedings, witness summonses are governed by CPR Part 34.

Criminal proceedings have separate statutory and procedural rules.

34. Failure to Attend Court

A witness who has been lawfully summoned may face legal consequences for failing to attend without sufficient justification.

The court’s powers depend upon the nature of the proceedings and the applicable law.

35. Examination-in-Chief

Examination-in-chief is the questioning of a witness by the party who called them.

Its purpose is to obtain the witness’s relevant evidence.

Leading questions are generally restricted during examination-in-chief, subject to recognised exceptions.

36. Cross-Examination

Cross-examination is the questioning of a witness by an opposing party.

It allows the witness’s evidence to be tested.

Cross-examination may address accuracy, consistency, credibility, perception, memory, and other relevant matters.

37. Re-Examination

Re-examination occurs when the party who called a witness questions them again after cross-examination.

Its purpose is generally to clarify matters arising during cross-examination.

New matters may require the court’s permission.

38. Leading Questions

A leading question is a question that suggests the answer sought.

Leading questions are generally permitted during cross-examination.

They are ordinarily restricted during examination-in-chief, subject to the applicable rules and exceptions.

39. Hostile Witness

A hostile witness is a witness whom the court permits the calling party to treat as hostile under the applicable evidential rules.

This may occur where the witness demonstrates an unwillingness to tell the truth for the party who called them.

The court’s permission may allow the calling party to use questioning techniques ordinarily associated with cross-examination.

40. Adverse Witness

An adverse witness is a witness whose evidence is unfavourable to the party who called them.

A witness does not become hostile merely because their evidence is adverse.

The distinction is important because different evidential rules may apply.

41. Distinction Between Adverse and Hostile Witnesses

A. Adverse Witness

  • Gives evidence unfavourable to the calling party.
  • May contradict the calling party’s expectations.
  • Is not necessarily dishonest or unwilling to tell the truth.
  • Does not automatically become subject to hostile-witness questioning.

B. Hostile Witness

  • Is treated as hostile following the relevant judicial determination.
  • May demonstrate an unwillingness to give truthful evidence for the calling party.
  • May be questioned using procedures permitted for hostile witnesses.
  • Is subject to the applicable evidential rules.

42. Expert Witness

An expert witness is a person with specialised knowledge, training, skill, or experience who provides opinion evidence within their field of expertise.

Expert witnesses may assist courts in understanding technical or specialised matters.

Examples include medical practitioners, engineers, accountants, and forensic specialists.

43. Duty of Expert Witnesses

An expert witness owes an overriding duty to assist the court on matters within their expertise.

In civil proceedings, this principle is reflected in CPR Part 35.

The expert’s duty to the court overrides any obligation to the party instructing or paying them.

44. Lay Witness

A lay witness is a witness who gives evidence primarily concerning facts within their personal knowledge rather than specialised expert opinion.

Lay witnesses commonly describe what they saw, heard, experienced, or did.

Their evidence is generally subject to rules concerning relevance, admissibility, and personal knowledge.

45. Eyewitness

An eyewitness is a person who directly observes an event.

Eyewitness testimony may be important in both civil and criminal proceedings.

However, the accuracy of such evidence may be affected by perception, memory, lighting, distance, stress, and other circumstances.

46. Character Witness

A character witness gives evidence concerning another person’s character or reputation where such evidence is legally admissible.

Character evidence is governed by specific rules, particularly in criminal proceedings.

The court must determine whether the proposed evidence is relevant and admissible.

47. Credibility of Witnesses

Credibility concerns whether a witness’s evidence should be believed.

The court may consider:

  • Consistency of the account.
  • Opportunity to observe events.
  • Memory and perception.
  • Possible bias or personal interest.
  • Contradictions with other evidence.
  • The overall reliability of the testimony.

Credibility and reliability are related but distinct considerations.

48. Reliability of Witness Evidence

Reliability concerns the accuracy and dependability of the evidence.

A witness may be honest but mistaken.

For example, an eyewitness may sincerely believe they identified a person correctly while having made an error.

The court must therefore distinguish honesty from accuracy.

49. Witness Bias

Bias refers to a tendency or interest that may influence a witness’s evidence.

A witness may favour one party because of personal relationships, financial interests, hostility, or other circumstances.

Evidence of bias may be relevant to the weight attached to the testimony.

50. Zealous Witness

A zealous witness is a witness who displays undue favouritism towards one party in the proceedings.

Such a witness may appear excessively eager to support that party’s case.

The court may consider this behaviour when assessing credibility and reliability.

51. Inconsistent Statements

A witness may make statements that differ from earlier accounts.

An inconsistency may affect the assessment of credibility or reliability.

However, not every inconsistency establishes dishonesty.

The court must consider its significance and surrounding circumstances.

52. Hearsay Evidence

Hearsay generally concerns a statement made outside the proceedings that is relied upon as evidence of the truth of the matter stated.

The rules governing hearsay differ between civil and criminal proceedings.

In civil proceedings, the Civil Evidence Act 1995 provides the principal statutory framework.

In criminal proceedings, the Criminal Justice Act 2003 contains important provisions governing admissibility.

53. Privilege Against Self-Incrimination

The privilege against self-incrimination is a legal protection against being compelled to provide certain evidence that may expose a person to criminal liability.

The privilege is subject to statutory provisions, exceptions, and limitations.

Its application depends upon the proceedings and circumstances.

54. Witnesses and Self-Incrimination

A witness may be required to attend court but may nevertheless have a lawful basis for refusing to answer particular questions.

This illustrates the distinction between the obligation to attend and the obligation to answer every question.

The applicable law determines whether the privilege may be claimed.

55. Legal Professional Privilege

Legal professional privilege protects certain confidential communications involving legal advice or litigation preparation.

A witness may be unable or not required to disclose privileged material, depending upon the circumstances.

The privilege belongs to the person legally entitled to claim it.

56. Perjury

Perjury is a criminal offence involving the making of a knowingly false material statement under oath in judicial proceedings, subject to the statutory requirements.

The principal legislation is the Perjury Act 1911.

The offence reflects the importance of truthful testimony in the administration of justice.

57. Witness Intimidation

Witness intimidation involves improper conduct intended to interfere with a person’s participation in legal proceedings.

Section 51 of the Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 1994 creates offences concerning intimidation of witnesses and others in specified circumstances.

The law seeks to protect the integrity of judicial proceedings.

58. Witness Protection

Witness protection measures may be used where a witness faces serious threats or risks arising from their involvement in legal proceedings.

Such measures may include protective arrangements, confidentiality measures, or other assistance authorised by law.

59. Witness Expenses

Witnesses may be entitled to reimbursement of certain expenses incurred in attending court.

The applicable arrangements depend upon whether the proceedings are civil or criminal and the relevant rules.

Expenses may include travel and other qualifying costs.

60. Witness Evidence and Burden of Proof

Witness testimony may assist a party in discharging the relevant burden of proof.

In ordinary civil proceedings, the standard is generally the balance of probabilities.

In criminal proceedings, the prosecution must establish guilt so that the court or jury is sure of the defendant’s guilt.

The court evaluates witness evidence together with the other admissible evidence.

61. Example: Witness to a Will

Suppose a person signs a will in the presence of two witnesses.

The witnesses observe the required act and sign the document in accordance with the statutory formalities.

If the will is later challenged, the witnesses may be asked to provide evidence concerning its execution.

Their evidence may help establish whether the will was validly executed.

62. Example: Eyewitness in Criminal Proceedings

Suppose a person observes an alleged assault.

The witness may be called to describe what they saw.

The prosecution may question the witness during examination-in-chief, and the defence may test the account through cross-examination.

The court or jury assesses the evidence according to the applicable legal principles.

63. Example: Expert Witness in Civil Proceedings

Suppose a claimant alleges that negligent construction work caused structural damage to a building.

A structural engineer may be instructed to provide expert evidence concerning the cause and extent of the damage.

The expert must provide an independent opinion within their expertise and comply with the applicable procedural duties.

64. Distinction Between Witness and Party

A party is a person or entity directly involved in legal proceedings as a claimant, defendant, applicant, or respondent.

A witness is a person who provides evidence.

A party may also act as a witness by giving evidence in their own proceedings.

The concepts are therefore distinct but may overlap.

65. Distinction Between Witness and Advocate

A witness provides evidence concerning relevant facts or specialised matters.

An advocate presents legal arguments and represents a party before the court.

The roles are different because witnesses provide evidence while advocates advance the parties’ cases.

66. Importance of Witness Testimony

Witness testimony is important because many disputes depend upon events that cannot be established solely through documents or physical evidence.

Witnesses may provide direct accounts of relevant circumstances.

Their evidence may also explain, authenticate, or place documentary evidence in context.

67. Judicial Assessment of Witnesses

Judges must assess witness evidence fairly and carefully.

They should consider the substance of the evidence, its consistency with other material, and the witness’s opportunity to know the relevant facts.

The assessment should not depend solely upon superficial impressions of a witness’s demeanour.

68. Legal Importance

A witness is fundamental to the operation of the legal system because witnesses perform two important functions: attesting to the execution of legal documents and providing evidence in legal proceedings.

Attesting witnesses help establish compliance with formal requirements governing documents such as wills and deeds.

Evidential witnesses assist courts in determining disputed facts through oral testimony, witness statements, and, where appropriate, expert evidence.

The law distinguishes between competency and compellability and recognises special rules concerning children, vulnerable witnesses, hostile witnesses, adverse witnesses, and the privilege against self-incrimination.

Witnesses are subject to obligations concerning truthfulness, and the legal system provides mechanisms to compel attendance, test evidence through cross-examination, and protect witnesses from intimidation.

Ultimately, witnesses are essential to the establishment of facts, the authentication of legal documents, and the fair administration of justice.


Image description
0 Comments