LAW

Published on

KembaraXtra - Legal Terms - Words of Severance

1. Introduction

Words of severance are words or expressions used in a conveyance, will, trust instrument, or other legal document to indicate that two or more persons are intended to hold property in separate and distinct shares, rather than jointly with the right of survivorship.

In English land law, words of severance are particularly important in distinguishing a joint tenancy from a tenancy in common.

Traditional examples include:

  • In equal shares.
  • Share and share alike.
  • In equal moieties.
  • In their respective shares.

Such expressions may indicate an intention that the beneficiaries should hold separate beneficial interests.

Words of severance are closely associated with the broader legal doctrine of severance of a joint tenancy.

2. Meaning of Words of Severance

Words of severance are expressions indicating that property is intended to be divided into distinct shares among two or more beneficiaries.

Their purpose is to demonstrate an intention inconsistent with the undivided beneficial ownership characteristic of a joint tenancy.

Where effective, they may support the conclusion that the beneficiaries hold as tenants in common.

3. Legal Definition

In property law, words of severance are words in a legal instrument that indicate an intention to confer separate shares upon co-owners or beneficiaries.

They may prevent the creation of a beneficial joint tenancy by showing that the parties were intended to hold as tenants in common.

The legal effect depends upon the wording of the instrument and the applicable principles of interpretation.

4. Purpose of Words of Severance

Words of severance serve several purposes:

  • Identifying separate beneficial shares.
  • Distinguishing a tenancy in common from a joint tenancy.
  • Excluding the right of survivorship where separate beneficial interests are intended.
  • Clarifying the distribution of property upon death.
  • Reducing uncertainty in conveyances and wills.
  • Assisting courts in determining the nature of co-ownership.

5. Historical Background

The distinction between joint tenancy and tenancy in common developed through English common law and equity.

Historically, a grant to two or more persons could create a joint tenancy unless the wording or circumstances indicated a contrary intention.

Words of severance became important because they demonstrated that the recipients were intended to take separate shares.

6. Joint Tenancy

A joint tenancy is a form of co-ownership in which two or more persons hold an undivided interest together.

The joint tenants are collectively entitled to the property.

A central feature of a beneficial joint tenancy is the right of survivorship.

7. Right of Survivorship

The right of survivorship, also known as jus accrescendi, means that when one joint tenant dies, that person’s interest passes automatically to the surviving joint tenant or tenants.

The deceased joint tenant’s interest does not pass under their will or intestacy in the ordinary way.

This is a defining characteristic of a joint tenancy.

8. Tenancy in Common

A tenancy in common is a form of co-ownership in which each co-owner holds a distinct undivided share in the property.

The shares may be equal or unequal.

Unlike a joint tenancy, a tenancy in common does not carry the right of survivorship.

9. Distinction Between Joint Tenancy and Tenancy in Common

A. Joint Tenancy

  • Co-owners hold an undivided interest together.
  • The right of survivorship applies.
  • A deceased joint tenant’s interest ordinarily accrues to the survivors.
  • The co-owners do not hold separate fractional beneficial shares while the joint tenancy continues.
  • The joint tenancy may be severed in accordance with the applicable law.

B. Tenancy in Common

  • Each co-owner holds a distinct undivided share.
  • The shares may be equal or unequal.
  • The right of survivorship does not apply.
  • A deceased co-owner’s share may pass under their will or intestacy.
  • Each co-owner’s beneficial share is separately identifiable.

10. Importance of Words of Severance

Words of severance may determine whether a beneficiary’s interest passes to surviving co-owners or forms part of the beneficiary’s estate upon death.

Their interpretation can therefore have significant consequences for inheritance and property ownership.

11. Example: In Equal Shares

Consider a gift:

To A and B in equal shares.

The expression “in equal shares” indicates that A and B are intended to have distinct shares.

It is a recognised example of wording supporting a tenancy in common.

12. Example: Share and Share Alike

Consider:

I give my property to A and B, share and share alike.

The expression “share and share alike” ordinarily indicates an intention to divide the beneficial interest equally.

It may therefore operate as words of severance.

13. Example: In Equal Moieties

The word moiety traditionally means one of two equal parts.

A conveyance stating:

To A and B in equal moieties.

indicates that A and B are intended to take separate halves.

This is a traditional example of words of severance.

14. Example: Respective Shares

Consider:

To A and B in their respective shares.

The expression may indicate an intention that each person hold a separate interest.

The precise shares must be determined from the instrument and surrounding legal context.

15. Words of Severance in Conveyances

A conveyance may contain words indicating that multiple transferees are intended to hold distinct beneficial shares.

For example:

To A and B as tenants in common in equal shares.

This wording expressly identifies the intended beneficial co-ownership.

16. Words of Severance in Wills

Words of severance may appear in testamentary gifts.

For example:

I devise my property to my two children in equal shares.

The expression ordinarily indicates that each child is intended to receive a separate beneficial share.

17. Words of Severance in Trust Instruments

Trust instruments may specify that beneficiaries are entitled to separate shares.

For example:

The Trustees shall hold the Property for A and B as tenants in common in equal shares.

This identifies the intended division of the beneficial interest.

18. Legal Ownership and Beneficial Ownership

English land law distinguishes between:

A. Legal Ownership

The ownership of the legal estate.

B. Beneficial Ownership

The equitable interests enjoyed by beneficiaries.

This distinction is particularly important when considering words of severance.

19. Legal Joint Tenancy

Under modern English land law, co-owned legal estates are held jointly.

Section 1(6) of the Law of Property Act 1925 provides that a legal estate is not capable of subsisting or being created in an undivided share in land.

Consequently, co-owners cannot hold the legal estate as tenants in common.

20. Beneficial Tenancy in Common

Although the legal estate is held jointly, the beneficial interest may be held as a tenancy in common.

For example, A and B may be joint legal owners while holding the beneficial interest in equal shares as tenants in common.

Words of severance are particularly relevant to identifying this beneficial arrangement.

21. Law of Property Act 1925

The Law of Property Act 1925 is central to the modern law of co-ownership.

Relevant provisions include:

  • Section 1(6), concerning undivided shares in legal estates.
  • Section 34, concerning co-ownership and trustees.
  • Section 36, concerning joint tenancies and severance.

The Act distinguishes legal ownership from beneficial co-ownership.

22. Section 36 of the Law of Property Act 1925

Section 36 is particularly important in the law governing severance.

It prevents severance of a legal joint tenancy while recognising mechanisms for severing a beneficial joint tenancy.

Section 36(2) provides an important statutory procedure involving written notice.

23. Two Meanings of Severance

The word severance may be used in two related but distinct senses.

A. Words Indicating Separate Shares at Creation

An instrument may use words of severance to create a beneficial tenancy in common from the outset.

B. Subsequent Severance of an Existing Joint Tenancy

An existing beneficial joint tenancy may later be severed through a legally recognised method.

These situations should not be confused.

24. Words of Severance at the Creation of an Interest

Where an instrument grants property to A and B “in equal shares”, the wording may establish a tenancy in common immediately.

There may be no existing beneficial joint tenancy requiring subsequent severance.

The words define the nature of the beneficial interests from the beginning.

25. Subsequent Severance of a Joint Tenancy

An existing beneficial joint tenancy may be severed after its creation.

The effect is to convert the relevant beneficial joint tenancy into a tenancy in common.

The legal estate remains jointly held.

26. Methods of Severance

English law recognises several methods of severing a beneficial joint tenancy.

These include:

  • Written notice under section 36(2) of the Law of Property Act 1925.
  • An act operating upon a joint tenant’s own share.
  • Mutual agreement.
  • A course of dealing demonstrating that the parties treated their interests as separate.

The precise requirements depend upon the method relied upon.

27. Williams v Hensman

The leading historical authority is Williams v Hensman (1861) 1 J & H 546.

The case identified three broad categories of severance:

  • An act operating upon a joint tenant’s own share.
  • Mutual agreement.
  • A course of dealing sufficient to show that the interests were treated as constituting a tenancy in common.

These principles remain important in understanding equitable severance.

28. Severance by Written Notice

Section 36(2) of the Law of Property Act 1925 permits a beneficial joint tenant to give written notice of a desire to sever the joint tenancy.

The notice must satisfy the statutory requirements.

Effective notice can sever the beneficial joint tenancy without requiring agreement from the other joint tenants.

29. Nature of Written Notice

A written notice of severance must communicate a sufficiently clear and immediate intention to sever.

A statement merely expressing a possible future intention may be insufficient.

The wording must be interpreted objectively in its context.

30. Harris v Goddard

In Harris v Goddard 1983 1 WLR 1203, the Court of Appeal considered whether a divorce petition seeking future property arrangements constituted an effective notice of severance.

The court held that the wording did not demonstrate the necessary immediate intention to sever.

The case illustrates the importance of clear language.

31. Re Draper’s Conveyance

In Re Draper’s Conveyance 1969 1 Ch 486, a summons seeking the sale of a jointly owned matrimonial home and division of the proceeds was held sufficient, in the circumstances, to constitute notice of severance.

The decision illustrates that the substance of the communication is important.

32. Kinch v Bullard

In Kinch v Bullard 1999 1 WLR 423, the court considered the effect of service of a notice of severance.

The case illustrates that a validly served notice may be effective even where the recipient does not actually read it.

The statutory rules governing service remain important.

33. Service of Notice

A notice of severance must be served in accordance with the applicable legal requirements.

Section 196 of the Law of Property Act 1925 may be relevant to service.

A failure to establish effective service may affect whether severance has occurred.

34. Severance by Mutual Agreement

A beneficial joint tenancy may be severed where the joint tenants reach a sufficient agreement to treat their interests as separate.

The agreement need not necessarily result in a completed transfer of the property.

However, the circumstances must establish the legally required agreement.

35. Burgess v Rawnsley

In Burgess v Rawnsley 1975 Ch 429, the Court of Appeal considered severance through agreement between joint tenants.

The case demonstrates that an agreement concerning separate interests may be sufficient to sever a beneficial joint tenancy, even though a proposed sale is not completed.

36. Severance by Course of Dealing

A beneficial joint tenancy may be severed where the parties’ conduct demonstrates that they treated their interests as separate.

The conduct must be sufficient to establish the relevant intention under the applicable legal principles.

Mere disagreement between co-owners is not necessarily enough.

37. Severance by an Act Operating on a Share

A joint tenant may sever the beneficial joint tenancy through an act operating upon their own interest.

Examples may include an effective disposition of the beneficial interest.

The legal requirements governing such transactions must be satisfied.

38. Effect of Severance

The principal effect of severance is to terminate the right of survivorship in relation to the severed beneficial interest.

The affected beneficial interest becomes a distinct share held as a tenancy in common.

Severance does not itself require the physical division of the land.

39. Severance Does Not Divide the Land Physically

A tenancy in common involves undivided shares in the property.

For example, A and B may each own a 50% beneficial share in a house.

This does not mean that A owns one particular half of the building while B owns the other half.

Each share relates to the property as a whole.

40. Severance and Death

Suppose A and B hold the beneficial interest as joint tenants.

If A dies before severance, A’s interest ordinarily passes to B by survivorship.

If the beneficial joint tenancy is effectively severed before A’s death, A’s separate share may pass under A’s will or intestacy.

41. Example: Joint Tenancy Without Severance

A and B own a house as beneficial joint tenants.

A dies.

B ordinarily becomes solely beneficially entitled through the right of survivorship.

A’s will does not dispose of the interest that passes by survivorship.

42. Example: Tenancy in Common

A and B hold a house as beneficial tenants in common in equal shares.

A dies.

A’s 50% beneficial interest forms part of A’s estate and may pass under A’s will or intestacy.

B retains B’s separate 50% beneficial interest.

43. Example: Words of Severance in a Will

A testator provides:

I give my house to my daughters, Alice and Rebecca, in equal shares.

The expression “in equal shares” indicates that the daughters are intended to receive separate beneficial shares.

This supports the interpretation that they take as tenants in common.

44. Example: Words of Severance in a Trust

A trust deed states:

The Trustees shall hold the Property for Daniel and Emma as tenants in common in the proportions of 60% and 40% respectively.

The wording expressly identifies separate beneficial shares.

Daniel and Emma are not intended to hold the beneficial interest as joint tenants.

45. Example: Written Notice of Severance

A and B hold the beneficial interest in a house as joint tenants.

A serves a valid written notice stating that A wishes to sever the beneficial joint tenancy with immediate effect.

If the statutory requirements are satisfied, the beneficial joint tenancy is severed.

A and B thereafter hold their beneficial interests as tenants in common.

46. Words of Severance and Equal Shares

Expressions such as “equally” or “in equal shares” may indicate separate beneficial interests.

However, the interpretation of a particular expression depends upon the whole instrument.

The court considers whether the language genuinely demonstrates an intention to create separate shares.

47. Words of Severance and Unequal Shares

Words of severance may also specify unequal beneficial shares.

For example:

To A as to 70% and B as to 30%.

The express allocation of distinct percentages strongly indicates a tenancy in common.

A beneficial joint tenancy does not consist of separately owned fractional shares.

48. Words of Severance and Express Declarations of Trust

An express declaration of trust may identify the beneficial ownership of property.

Where a valid declaration specifies that beneficiaries hold as tenants in common in stated shares, it ordinarily determines their beneficial interests.

The court applies the relevant principles governing declarations of trust.

49. Goodman v Gallant

In Goodman v Gallant 1986 Fam 106, the Court of Appeal emphasised the significance of an express declaration of beneficial ownership.

Where a valid express declaration identifies the beneficial interests, it is ordinarily conclusive between the parties unless a recognised basis for challenging or varying it applies.

This principle is relevant to instruments containing clear words of severance.

50. Words of Severance and Presumed Intention

Where an instrument does not expressly identify the form of beneficial co-ownership, the court may need to consider applicable presumptions and evidence.

The outcome depends upon the circumstances, including whether the property was acquired as a family home or for investment.

Clear words of severance may reduce uncertainty.

51. Stack v Dowden

In Stack v Dowden 2007 UKHL 17, the House of Lords considered beneficial ownership of a jointly owned family home.

The decision illustrates the importance of intention and context in determining beneficial interests.

It does not displace the significance of a valid express declaration of trust.

52. Jones v Kernott

In Jones v Kernott 2011 UKSC 53, the Supreme Court considered the determination of beneficial shares in a jointly owned family home.

The decision illustrates how beneficial ownership may depend upon the parties’ common intention and relevant conduct.

The case is particularly relevant where no conclusive express declaration determines the beneficial shares.

53. Words of Severance and Words of Purchase

Words of purchase identify the person who takes an estate or interest.

Words of severance indicate that multiple recipients are intended to hold separate shares.

For example:

To A and B in equal shares.

The words “to A and B” identify the recipients.

The words “in equal shares” indicate separate beneficial interests.

54. Distinction Between Words of Severance and Words of Purchase

A. Words of Severance

  • Indicate separate shares.
  • Concern the nature of co-ownership.
  • May exclude beneficial survivorship.
  • Are relevant to distinguishing joint tenancy from tenancy in common.

B. Words of Purchase

  • Identify the recipient of an estate.
  • Determine who takes under an instrument.
  • May identify one or more beneficiaries.
  • Do not necessarily establish whether the beneficiaries hold jointly or in common.

55. Words of Severance and Words of Limitation

Words of limitation describe the nature, extent, or duration of an estate.

Words of severance concern the division of beneficial interests between co-owners.

The concepts therefore perform different functions.

56. Distinction Between Words of Severance and Words of Limitation

A. Words of Severance

  • Indicate separate beneficial shares.
  • Concern co-ownership.
  • May establish a tenancy in common.
  • Affect the operation of survivorship.

B. Words of Limitation

  • Define the nature or duration of an estate.
  • Traditionally identify fee simple, fee tail, or life interests.
  • Concern the quantum of an estate.
  • Do not necessarily indicate separate beneficial shares.

57. Words of Severance and Words of Procreation

Words of procreation are traditional expressions identifying the hereditary line associated with an estate tail.

An example is “heirs of his body”.

Words of severance instead indicate separate interests among co-owners.

The two concepts should not be confused.

58. Distinction Between Words of Severance and Words of Procreation

A. Words of Severance

  • Concern separate beneficial ownership.
  • May establish a tenancy in common.
  • Are associated with co-ownership.
  • Affect the right of survivorship.

B. Words of Procreation

  • Concern hereditary succession.
  • Are associated with estates tail.
  • Identify qualifying descendants.
  • Traditionally operate as part of the limitation of an estate.

59. Words of Severance and Partition

Partition refers to the physical or legal division of property between co-owners.

Words of severance do not necessarily partition the property.

They may instead establish separate undivided beneficial shares in the same property.

60. Words of Severance and Sale of Property

Where property is held as a tenancy in common, the co-owners may have separate beneficial entitlements to the proceeds of sale.

For example, A and B may be entitled to 60% and 40% of the net proceeds respectively.

The actual distribution depends upon their beneficial interests and any relevant liabilities or adjustments.

61. Trusts of Land and Appointment of Trustees Act 1996

The Trusts of Land and Appointment of Trustees Act 1996 (TLATA) governs important aspects of trusts of land.

It provides mechanisms for resolving disputes concerning the exercise of trustees’ functions and the sale or management of trust property.

The Act is relevant where beneficial co-owners disagree about jointly owned land.

62. Section 14 of TLATA

Section 14 permits specified persons to apply to the court for orders concerning the exercise of trustees’ functions or the nature or extent of a person’s interest in property subject to a trust of land.

Such applications may arise where co-owners dispute ownership shares or the sale of property.

63. Section 15 of TLATA

Section 15 identifies matters the court must consider in determining certain applications under section 14.

These include the intentions of the persons who created the trust and the purposes for which the property is held.

Additional statutory considerations may apply depending upon the circumstances.

64. Words of Severance and Inheritance

Words of severance can have substantial consequences for inheritance.

If property is held beneficially as a tenancy in common, a deceased co-owner’s share may pass through their estate.

If the property is held beneficially as a joint tenancy, survivorship ordinarily determines the destination of the deceased joint tenant’s interest.

65. Importance in Estate Planning

Estate planning may require consideration of whether property is held as a joint tenancy or tenancy in common.

A person wishing to leave their beneficial share to someone other than the surviving co-owner may need to ensure that the beneficial ownership structure permits this.

Words of severance and effective severance procedures can therefore be important.

66. Importance in Matrimonial Property

Questions of beneficial co-ownership frequently arise in relation to matrimonial homes.

The legal title may be held jointly while the beneficial interests are disputed.

Words of severance or an express declaration of trust may help determine the intended ownership structure.

Family law proceedings may also involve separate statutory powers affecting property arrangements.

67. Importance in Commercial Property

Commercial investors may acquire property together while intending to hold distinct shares.

For example, one investor may contribute 70% of the purchase price and another 30%.

An express declaration of beneficial ownership can clarify their respective interests.

68. Importance in Family Property

Family members may acquire property jointly for residential or investment purposes.

Clear wording concerning beneficial shares may help prevent disputes following death, separation, or sale.

Words of severance are therefore relevant to family property arrangements.

69. Importance in Legal Drafting

Careful drafting should identify:

  • The legal owners.
  • The beneficial owners.
  • Whether the beneficial interest is held jointly or in common.
  • The proportions of any separate shares.
  • Any relevant trust arrangements.

Clear wording can reduce the risk of future litigation.

70. Importance of Express Language

The clearest way to indicate a beneficial tenancy in common is ordinarily to use express language.

For example:

The beneficial interest shall be held by A and B as tenants in common in equal shares.

This avoids reliance upon ambiguous expressions.

71. Ambiguous Wording

Not every reference to equality necessarily constitutes effective words of severance.

The court must interpret the wording in context.

The legal effect depends upon whether the instrument demonstrates an intention to create separate beneficial shares.

72. Words of Severance and Judicial Interpretation

Courts interpreting words of severance consider the instrument as a whole.

Relevant considerations include:

  • The language used.
  • The nature of the transaction.
  • The date of the instrument.
  • The applicable statutory framework.
  • Relevant judicial authorities.
  • Any valid express declaration of trust.

73. Words of Severance as Words of Art

Words of severance are a category of words of art in property law.

They have a specialised meaning connected with co-ownership and beneficial interests.

Their interpretation requires an understanding of joint tenancy, tenancy in common, and the right of survivorship.

74. Common Misunderstanding: Severance Divides the Property Physically

Severance does not necessarily divide land into separate physical portions.

A and B may each hold a 50% beneficial share in the same house.

The property remains undivided physically unless a separate legal process produces a division.

75. Common Misunderstanding: Severance Ends Legal Joint Ownership

Severance of a beneficial joint tenancy does not sever the legal joint tenancy.

The legal estate continues to be held jointly.

The change concerns the beneficial ownership.

76. Common Misunderstanding: Equal Contributions Automatically Determine Ownership

Equal financial contributions do not invariably establish a particular form of beneficial co-ownership.

The court must consider the applicable legal principles and any valid express declaration.

Words of severance may provide clearer evidence of the intended ownership structure.

77. Common Misunderstanding: Severance Requires Consent

Severance by mutual agreement requires the relevant agreement.

However, a beneficial joint tenant may also sever through an effective written notice under section 36(2) of the Law of Property Act 1925.

Consent from the other joint tenants is not necessarily required for that statutory method.

78. Practical Example: Two Friends Purchasing Property

A and B purchase a house together.

The transfer contains a declaration that they hold the beneficial interest as tenants in common in equal shares.

Each has a distinct 50% beneficial interest.

If A dies, A’s share does not automatically pass to B by survivorship.

79. Practical Example: Unequal Investment

C contributes 75% of the purchase price of an investment property, while D contributes 25%.

They execute a declaration of trust stating that they hold the beneficial interest as tenants in common in those proportions.

The declaration identifies their separate shares.

80. Practical Example: Death of a Joint Tenant

E and F hold the beneficial interest as joint tenants.

E dies without severing the joint tenancy.

F ordinarily becomes solely beneficially entitled through survivorship.

E cannot dispose of the extinguished joint tenancy interest by will.

81. Practical Example: Severance Before Death

G and H hold the beneficial interest as joint tenants.

G serves an effective notice of severance.

G subsequently dies.

G’s separate beneficial share may pass under G’s will or intestacy rather than automatically accruing to H.

82. Practical Example: Testamentary Gift

A testator provides:

I give my property to my three children in equal shares.

The words “in equal shares” indicate that the children are intended to receive distinct beneficial interests.

The wording supports a tenancy in common rather than a beneficial joint tenancy.

83. Practical Example: Express Declaration of Trust

A deed states:

The Trustees shall hold the Property for A and B as tenants in common, A being entitled to 40% and B to 60%.

The declaration expressly identifies separate beneficial shares.

It therefore removes uncertainty concerning the intended form of beneficial co-ownership.

84. Relationship with Severance

Words of severance are closely related to the general doctrine of severance.

However, the two concepts should be distinguished.

Words of severance may indicate separate interests from the outset.

Severance of a joint tenancy refers to the subsequent conversion of an existing beneficial joint tenancy into a tenancy in common.

85. Legal Importance

Words of severance are expressions used in conveyances, wills, trusts, and other legal instruments to indicate that two or more persons are intended to hold property in separate beneficial shares.

Common examples include “in equal shares”, “share and share alike”, and “in equal moieties”.

Their principal importance lies in distinguishing a tenancy in common from a joint tenancy.

A joint tenancy carries the right of survivorship, whereas a tenancy in common allows each co-owner to hold a distinct beneficial share capable of passing under a will or intestacy.

The Law of Property Act 1925, particularly sections 1(6) and 36, provides an important statutory framework for understanding legal and beneficial co-ownership and the severance of beneficial joint tenancies.

Relevant authorities include Williams v Hensman (1861), Burgess v Rawnsley 1975, Harris v Goddard 1983, and Kinch v Bullard 1999.

Words of severance must be distinguished from words of purchase, which identify the recipients of property, and words of limitation, which define the nature or extent of an estate.

Ultimately, words of severance are important because they help determine whether co-owners hold a single undivided beneficial interest subject to survivorship or separate beneficial shares capable of independent succession.


Image description
0 Comments