LAW

Published on

KembaraXtra - Legal Terms - Work Done and Materials Supplied, Contract For

1. Introduction

A contract for work done and materials supplied is a contract under which one party agrees to perform work or provide services for another party and, in carrying out that work, also supplies materials.

The expression is particularly important in English contract law because it describes an arrangement combining labour, skill, and materials.

Traditional examples include:

  • A painter commissioned to produce a portrait.
  • A builder engaged to construct or improve a building.
  • A contractor engaged to manufacture and install fitted windows.
  • A tailor commissioned to make a bespoke garment.
  • A tradesperson engaged to repair property using replacement parts.

Historically, the distinction between a contract for work done and materials supplied and a contract for the sale of goods was important because different legal rules could apply.

The classification remains relevant, although modern legislation expressly regulates many contracts combining goods and services.

2. Meaning of Contract for Work Done and Materials Supplied

A contract for work done and materials supplied is an agreement under which a contractor undertakes to perform work involving labour or skill and to provide materials used in carrying out that work.

The contract may involve both:

  • The performance of services.
  • The transfer of ownership of materials or finished goods.

The relative importance of these elements may determine how the contract is legally classified.

3. Legal Definition

In traditional English contract law, a contract for work done and materials supplied is an agreement whose essential purpose is the performance of work or the exercise of skill, although materials are supplied in the course of performing the contractual obligations.

It is distinguished from a contract whose essential purpose is the sale of goods.

However, the classification depends upon the substance of the transaction rather than merely the terminology used by the parties.

4. Essential Characteristics

A contract for work done and materials supplied commonly contains the following characteristics:

  • A contractual obligation to perform work.
  • The application of labour or professional skill.
  • The provision of materials.
  • Payment or other agreed consideration.
  • An obligation to perform the work according to the contract.
  • A possible transfer of ownership of materials or finished goods.

5. Purpose of the Contract

The principal purpose is to obtain work or services that may require the use or incorporation of materials.

For example, a homeowner who engages a builder to install fitted windows generally expects both the installation work and the necessary windows and fittings.

The agreement therefore contains elements of both goods and services.

6. Historical Development

English contract law traditionally distinguished between contracts for the sale of goods and contracts for work and labour.

The distinction developed through judicial decisions concerning the nature of the parties’ obligations.

It was particularly important where a contractor manufactured or produced an item using materials supplied by the contractor.

7. Contract for the Sale of Goods

A contract for the sale of goods is a contract under which a seller transfers or agrees to transfer property in goods to a buyer for a money consideration called the price.

This definition is reflected in section 2(1) of the Sale of Goods Act 1979.

The central feature is the transfer or agreed transfer of ownership of goods.

8. Contract for Work and Labour

A contract for work and labour is an agreement whose central obligation is the performance of work or the exercise of skill.

The contractor may supply materials, but the contract may remain primarily concerned with services.

The distinction depends upon the contractual obligations and the nature of the transaction.

9. Contract for Work Done and Materials Supplied

This expression describes a contract combining the performance of work with the supply of materials.

It is often used in construction, repair, installation, and bespoke production arrangements.

The materials may be incorporated into the customer’s property or form part of the completed work.

10. Distinction Between Sale of Goods and Work Done and Materials Supplied

A. Contract for Sale of Goods

  • Primarily concerns the transfer of ownership of goods.
  • The seller supplies goods to the buyer.
  • The goods may be existing or future goods.
  • The contractual obligations are principally directed towards the goods supplied.
  • The Sale of Goods Act 1979 may apply, subject to other relevant legislation.

B. Contract for Work Done and Materials Supplied

  • Combines work or services with materials.
  • May place substantial emphasis on labour and skill.
  • May involve manufacturing, construction, repair, or installation.
  • The materials may be incidental to the work or form a substantial part of the transaction.
  • Different statutory provisions may govern the goods and service elements.

11. Importance of the Substance of the Contract

The classification of a contract depends upon its substance.

The parties cannot necessarily determine the legal classification simply by calling an agreement a contract for services.

A court may examine what the contractor actually undertook to provide.

12. Main Object of the Contract

Historically, courts considered whether the principal object of the agreement was the supply of goods or the exercise of work and skill.

Where the essential purpose was the application of skill, the contract might be characterised as one for work and materials.

Where the essential purpose was the delivery of goods, the contract might be characterised as a sale of goods.

This historical distinction remains useful, although modern statutory analysis may require a more detailed examination of the separate obligations.

13. Example: Commissioned Portrait

Suppose a customer commissions an artist to paint a portrait.

The artist supplies the canvas, paint, and other materials.

However, the customer is primarily seeking the artist’s skill and creative work.

Traditionally, this has been used as an example of a contract for work and materials.

14. Robinson v Graves

In Robinson v Graves 1935 1 KB 579, the Court of Appeal considered a contract under which an artist was commissioned to paint a portrait.

The court held that the agreement was essentially a contract for work and labour rather than a contract for the sale of goods.

The decision illustrates the historical distinction between the exercise of skill and the sale of a finished article.

15. Significance of Robinson v Graves

The case demonstrates that the supply of a physical object does not necessarily make an agreement a contract for the sale of goods.

The essential purpose of the transaction may instead be the performance of skilled work.

The classification depends upon the contractual arrangement.

16. Example: Building Work

Suppose a homeowner engages a contractor to construct an extension.

The contractor supplies:

  • Bricks.
  • Cement.
  • Timber.
  • Roofing materials.
  • Labour.
  • Construction expertise.

The agreement combines the supply of materials with substantial work and skill.

It is a typical example of a contract involving work done and materials supplied.

17. Example: Double-Glazing Installation

A homeowner engages a company to manufacture and install double-glazed windows.

The company supplies the windows and undertakes the installation.

The contract contains both goods and service elements.

The legal consequences depend upon the applicable legislation and the precise contractual obligations.

18. Example: Bespoke Furniture

A customer commissions a carpenter to produce a fitted wardrobe.

The carpenter supplies timber, fittings, and labour.

The agreement involves the creation of a finished product and its possible installation.

Depending upon the contractual structure, the transaction may involve obligations relating to goods, services, or both.

19. Example: Vehicle Repairs

A vehicle owner engages a garage to repair an engine.

The garage supplies replacement parts and performs mechanical work.

The contract combines services and materials.

The garage’s obligations may concern both the quality of the parts and the standard of the repair work.

20. Example: Plumbing Work

A plumber is engaged to replace a defective water pipe.

The plumber supplies the replacement pipe and carries out the installation.

The contract involves work done and materials supplied.

The customer expects both appropriate materials and competent workmanship.

21. Example: Electrical Installation

An electrician is engaged to install lighting in a house.

The electrician supplies wiring, switches, fittings, and labour.

The agreement contains both goods and service elements.

The applicable contractual standards may differ between the materials supplied and the work performed.

22. Example: Tailoring

A customer commissions a tailor to produce a suit.

The tailor supplies fabric and applies specialist skill.

The contract may involve the manufacture of goods to the customer’s specifications.

Its legal classification depends upon the substance of the agreement and the relevant statutory framework.

23. Example: Printing Services

A business engages a printer to produce promotional materials.

The printer supplies paper, ink, machinery, and labour.

The agreement may be predominantly concerned with supplying finished printed goods or may involve substantial design and other services.

The precise contractual obligations must be examined.

24. Example: Construction of a Building

A contractor undertakes to construct a commercial building.

The contractor supplies materials, labour, equipment, and technical expertise.

The arrangement is substantially more complex than an ordinary retail sale.

Construction law and the specific contractual terms may be particularly important.

25. Labour Element

The labour element consists of the work performed by the contractor or service provider.

Examples include:

  • Manufacturing.
  • Painting.
  • Repairing.
  • Installing.
  • Building.
  • Assembling.
  • Fitting.
  • Decorating.

The labour element may be central to the contractual bargain.

26. Skill Element

The skill element concerns the expertise required to perform the work.

Examples include:

  • Artistic skill.
  • Technical knowledge.
  • Engineering expertise.
  • Construction experience.
  • Mechanical competence.
  • Specialist craftsmanship.

The importance of skill may influence the classification and interpretation of the contract.

27. Materials Element

The materials element consists of the goods or physical items supplied in performing the work.

Examples include:

  • Timber.
  • Glass.
  • Metal.
  • Paint.
  • Bricks.
  • Replacement parts.
  • Electrical components.
  • Fabric.

The materials may be incorporated into the customer’s property or delivered as part of a finished product.

28. Transfer of Ownership

A contract for work done and materials supplied may involve the transfer of ownership of materials.

For example, materials installed in a building may become part of the property.

The legal consequences depend upon the contract and the applicable principles governing ownership, incorporation, and fixtures.

29. Fixtures

A fixture is an item that has become part of land or a building under the applicable legal principles.

Whether an item is a fixture depends particularly upon the degree and purpose of annexation.

Materials incorporated into a building may cease to be separate goods.

30. Importance of Fixtures

Fixtures are particularly relevant to construction and installation contracts.

For example, windows installed as part of a building will ordinarily become part of the building.

The law governing fixtures may therefore affect ownership of the installed materials.

31. Sale of Goods Act 1979

The Sale of Goods Act 1979 governs contracts for the sale of goods within its scope.

It contains provisions concerning:

  • The transfer of property in goods.
  • Description.
  • Quality.
  • Fitness for purpose.
  • Delivery.
  • Acceptance.
  • Remedies for breach.

Its application depends upon the nature of the transaction and the parties involved.

32. Supply of Goods and Services Act 1982

The Supply of Goods and Services Act 1982 is particularly important to contracts combining work and materials.

Part I addresses certain contracts for the transfer of goods and hire of goods.

Part II addresses certain contracts for the supply of services.

The Act remains relevant to contracts within its scope, particularly non-consumer transactions.

33. Transfer of Goods Under the 1982 Act

Section 1 of the Supply of Goods and Services Act 1982 concerns certain contracts under which property in goods is transferred or agreed to be transferred otherwise than under a contract of sale or hire-purchase.

This may include goods supplied as part of a contract involving work and materials.

The relevant provisions apply subject to their statutory scope and exclusions.

34. Implied Term as to Description

Section 3 of the Supply of Goods and Services Act 1982 provides for an implied term concerning correspondence with description in relevant contracts for the transfer of goods.

Where goods are supplied by description, the statutory requirements may apply.

The precise operation depends upon the type of contract.

35. Satisfactory Quality

Section 4 of the Supply of Goods and Services Act 1982 contains provisions concerning satisfactory quality and fitness for purpose in relevant contracts.

The statutory obligations are subject to the conditions and limitations set out in the legislation.

These provisions may be important where materials supplied under a contract are defective.

36. Reasonable Care and Skill

Section 13 of the Supply of Goods and Services Act 1982 implies a term requiring a supplier to carry out services with reasonable care and skill in contracts to which the provision applies.

This is particularly important where the work involves professional or technical expertise.

37. Reasonable Time

Section 14 of the Supply of Goods and Services Act 1982 concerns performance within a reasonable time where the time for performance is not fixed or determined in the manner specified by the Act.

The requirement applies subject to the statutory conditions.

38. Reasonable Charge

Section 15 of the Supply of Goods and Services Act 1982 concerns payment of a reasonable charge where the consideration for services is not fixed or determined in the manner specified by the Act.

The amount depends upon the circumstances.

39. Consumer Rights Act 2015

The Consumer Rights Act 2015 is central to modern consumer contracts involving goods and services.

It applies to contracts within its scope between traders and consumers.

A contract involving both the supply of materials and the performance of work may engage different provisions of the Act.

40. Consumer Contracts

A consumer under the Consumer Rights Act 2015 is generally an individual acting for purposes wholly or mainly outside their trade, business, craft, or profession.

A trader is generally a person acting for purposes relating to their trade, business, craft, or profession.

The statutory definitions determine whether the consumer protections apply.

41. Goods Under the Consumer Rights Act 2015

Chapter 2 of Part 1 of the Consumer Rights Act 2015 regulates the supply of goods.

Relevant rights include requirements concerning:

  • Satisfactory quality.
  • Fitness for a particular purpose.
  • Correspondence with description.
  • Other applicable statutory requirements.

These protections may apply to materials supplied as part of a consumer contract.

42. Services Under the Consumer Rights Act 2015

Chapter 4 of Part 1 of the Consumer Rights Act 2015 regulates services.

Section 49 requires a trader to perform a service with reasonable care and skill.

The Act also contains provisions concerning information about the trader or service and the time for performance.

43. Mixed Contracts

A mixed contract contains obligations relating to more than one type of supply.

For example, a contract to supply and install fitted kitchen units may contain both goods and service elements.

Modern consumer legislation recognises that different provisions may apply to different aspects of the same contract.

44. Distinction Between Goods and Services Obligations

A. Goods Obligations

  • Concern the goods supplied.
  • May require satisfactory quality.
  • May require fitness for purpose.
  • May require correspondence with description.
  • May give rise to statutory remedies for defective goods.

B. Services Obligations

  • Concern the performance of work.
  • Require reasonable care and skill where the relevant legislation applies.
  • May involve obligations concerning timing.
  • May involve agreed performance standards.
  • May give rise to remedies for defective services.

45. Defective Materials

A contractor may supply materials that are defective.

For example, a window installation company may supply glass that does not satisfy the applicable contractual or statutory standards.

The customer may have remedies relating to the goods supplied.

The applicable remedies depend upon the nature of the contract.

46. Defective Workmanship

A contractor may use satisfactory materials but perform the work negligently or without reasonable care and skill.

For example, a plumber may install a suitable pipe incorrectly, causing water leakage.

The defect concerns workmanship rather than the quality of the material itself.

47. Combined Defects

A contract may involve both defective materials and defective workmanship.

For example, a builder may install unsuitable roofing materials and also perform the installation incorrectly.

The customer may have separate or overlapping contractual rights concerning the materials and services.

48. Contractual Terms

The express terms of a contract may specify:

  • The work to be performed.
  • The materials to be supplied.
  • The standard of workmanship.
  • The completion date.
  • The contract price.
  • Payment arrangements.
  • Inspection procedures.
  • Remedies for defects.

These terms operate alongside applicable statutory and common law obligations.

49. Express Terms

An express term is a contractual provision agreed by the parties.

For example, a building contract may expressly require the contractor to use a specified grade of timber.

Failure to comply may constitute a breach of contract.

50. Implied Terms

An implied term is a contractual obligation that arises by operation of law, statute, custom, or the applicable principles of contractual implication.

Relevant statutes may imply obligations concerning goods and services.

The precise terms depend upon the nature of the contract.

51. Reasonable Care and Skill

The requirement to exercise reasonable care and skill is particularly important in contracts involving services.

It generally concerns the standard of performance reasonably expected from a competent supplier undertaking the relevant work.

The standard must be assessed in context.

52. Reasonable Care and Skill Versus Guaranteed Result

An obligation to exercise reasonable care and skill is not necessarily an absolute guarantee of a particular outcome.

However, a contract may contain an express promise to achieve a specified result.

The contractor’s liability depends upon the obligations undertaken.

53. Fitness for Purpose

Fitness for purpose concerns whether goods are reasonably suitable for a particular purpose in circumstances where the relevant legal requirements apply.

A contract may also contain an express fitness-for-purpose obligation.

Such an obligation may be more demanding than a duty merely to exercise reasonable care and skill.

54. Example: Defective Windows

A company supplies and installs double-glazed windows.

The glass is defective, and the installation is poorly performed.

The customer may have rights concerning both:

  • The defective goods.
  • The inadequate installation services.

The applicable remedies depend upon the statutory and contractual framework.

55. Example: Defective Roof

A contractor installs a new roof using appropriate materials.

However, the roof leaks because the contractor fails to install the materials competently.

The defect primarily concerns workmanship.

The contractor may be liable for breach of the relevant contractual obligation.

56. Example: Unsuitable Materials

A contractor agrees to install flooring suitable for a commercial kitchen.

The contractor supplies materials unsuitable for the intended conditions.

The problem may concern the quality or fitness of the goods supplied.

The legal analysis depends upon the agreed specifications and applicable law.

57. Payment for Work and Materials

A contract may provide for a single price covering both labour and materials.

Alternatively, the price may be divided into:

  • Labour charges.
  • Materials charges.
  • Installation charges.
  • Additional expenses.

The method of pricing does not necessarily determine the legal classification of the agreement.

58. Lump-Sum Contracts

A lump-sum contract provides for payment of an agreed amount for specified work.

The amount may include labour and materials.

Such arrangements are common in construction and installation work.

59. Cost-Plus Contracts

A cost-plus contract provides for payment based upon specified costs, together with an agreed fee or margin.

The costs may include labour and materials.

The contractual terms determine the method of calculation.

60. Variations

A variation is a change to the work or materials required under a contract.

For example, a customer may request additional electrical fittings during a renovation.

The parties’ rights concerning additional payment depend upon the contract and applicable law.

61. Completion of Work

A contract may specify when the work must be completed.

The completion obligation may be affected by:

  • Express deadlines.
  • Agreed extensions.
  • Variations.
  • Delays caused by the parties.
  • Applicable statutory terms.
  • Other contractual provisions.

62. Delay in Performance

A contractor may breach the contract by failing to complete work within the required time.

The consequences depend upon the contractual terms and the seriousness of the delay.

Potential remedies may include damages or, in appropriate circumstances, termination.

63. Breach of Contract

A breach of contract occurs where a party fails to perform a contractual obligation.

In a contract for work done and materials supplied, breaches may include:

  • Failure to perform the work.
  • Defective workmanship.
  • Supply of defective materials.
  • Failure to follow agreed specifications.
  • Unjustified delay.
  • Failure to complete the agreed work.

64. Remedies for Breach

Potential remedies may include:

  • Damages.
  • Repair or replacement where applicable.
  • Repeat performance where applicable.
  • Price reduction where applicable.
  • Termination where legally justified.
  • Other remedies available under the contract or applicable law.

The appropriate remedy depends upon the nature of the breach.

65. Damages

Damages are a monetary remedy intended, broadly, to compensate a claimant for loss caused by a breach of contract.

In defective work cases, damages may be assessed by reference to the reasonable cost of rectification or another appropriate measure.

The assessment is subject to the applicable principles of causation, remoteness, mitigation, and reasonableness.

66. Cost of Rectification

The cost of rectification is the reasonable expense of correcting defective work.

For example, a customer may seek the cost of properly reinstalling defective flooring.

Whether the full rectification cost is recoverable depends upon the circumstances.

67. Ruxley Electronics and Construction Ltd v Forsyth

In Ruxley Electronics and Construction Ltd v Forsyth 1996 AC 344, the House of Lords considered damages arising from a swimming pool constructed to an incorrect depth.

The case illustrates that the cost of rectification is not automatically recoverable where it would be unreasonable or disproportionate.

The appropriate measure of damages depends upon the loss suffered and the relevant legal principles.

68. Consumer Remedies for Goods

Under the Consumer Rights Act 2015, consumers may have statutory remedies where goods fail to conform to the contract.

Depending upon the circumstances, these may include:

  • The short-term right to reject.
  • Repair or replacement.
  • Price reduction.
  • The final right to reject.

The availability of each remedy depends upon the statutory requirements.

69. Consumer Remedies for Services

Under the Consumer Rights Act 2015, consumers may have remedies where services fail to conform to the applicable statutory requirements.

These include:

  • Repeat performance, where available.
  • Price reduction, where the statutory conditions are satisfied.

Other remedies may also remain available under the applicable law.

70. Repeat Performance

Repeat performance may require the trader to perform the service again to the extent necessary to bring it into conformity with the contract.

The remedy is subject to the statutory conditions.

It may be particularly relevant where installation or repair work has been performed inadequately.

71. Price Reduction

A price reduction may be available under the Consumer Rights Act 2015 where the relevant statutory conditions are met.

It may be appropriate where repeat performance is impossible or cannot be provided within the required time and without significant inconvenience.

The amount is determined according to the statutory provisions.

72. Distinction Between Consumer and Commercial Contracts

A. Consumer Contracts

  • Involve a trader and consumer within the statutory definitions.
  • Are substantially governed by the Consumer Rights Act 2015.
  • Provide statutory protections concerning goods and services.
  • Restrict attempts to exclude certain consumer rights.

B. Commercial Contracts

  • May involve businesses contracting with one another.
  • May be governed by the Sale of Goods Act 1979 or Supply of Goods and Services Act 1982.
  • Often contain detailed negotiated terms.
  • May permit certain limitations of liability, subject to applicable law.
  • Require careful analysis of the contractual allocation of risk.

73. Exclusion Clauses

An exclusion clause is a contractual term seeking to exclude or limit liability.

Its effectiveness depends upon the applicable statutory and common law rules.

Relevant legislation may include the Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977 and the Consumer Rights Act 2015.

74. Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977

The Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977 regulates certain attempts to exclude or restrict liability.

It may apply to commercial contracts involving goods or services.

Some clauses are subject to a requirement of reasonableness.

75. Consumer Rights Act 2015 and Exclusion Clauses

The Consumer Rights Act 2015 restricts the ability of traders to exclude or limit specified statutory consumer rights.

For example, section 57 restricts exclusion or limitation of liability arising under the statutory provisions concerning services.

The effectiveness of a contractual term must be assessed under the Act.

76. Distinction Between Work Done and Materials Supplied and Employment Contracts

A. Contract for Work Done and Materials Supplied

  • Usually concerns an independent contractor or service provider.
  • Involves performing specified work.
  • May include the supply of materials.
  • Commonly concerns a particular project or task.
  • Does not automatically create an employment relationship.

B. Contract of Employment

  • Establishes an employment relationship.
  • Is governed by employment law.
  • Involves obligations arising from employee status.
  • May create statutory employment rights.
  • Does not ordinarily concern the employee selling materials to the employer as part of the employment contract.

77. Independent Contractor

An independent contractor is a person or business engaged to perform work or provide services without necessarily becoming an employee.

A contractor may supply labour, materials, or both.

Employment status is determined by the applicable legal tests rather than solely by contractual labels.

78. Distinction Between Work Done and Materials Supplied and Pure Services

A. Work Done and Materials Supplied

  • Involves both services and materials.
  • May involve the transfer of goods.
  • Commonly arises in construction, repair, or installation.
  • May engage statutory rules concerning both goods and services.

B. Pure Services Contract

  • Primarily concerns the performance of services.
  • May involve little or no transfer of goods.
  • Examples include certain consultancy and advisory services.
  • Is principally governed by obligations concerning the performance of services.

79. Distinction Between Work Done and Materials Supplied and Sale of Goods

The central distinction is the nature of the contractual undertaking.

A sale of goods primarily concerns the transfer of ownership of goods.

A contract for work done and materials supplied combines the performance of work with the provision of materials.

However, modern legislation may regulate the goods and service elements of the same transaction separately.

80. Importance in Construction Law

Construction contracts commonly involve extensive work and the supply of materials.

Relevant issues include:

  • Workmanship.
  • Materials specifications.
  • Payment.
  • Delays.
  • Defects.
  • Variations.
  • Completion.
  • Contractual remedies.

The classification of obligations may affect the applicable legal standards.

81. Importance in Repair Contracts

Repair contracts frequently involve replacement parts and labour.

The customer may expect both:

  • Appropriate replacement materials.
  • Competent repair work.

A failure in either respect may give rise to contractual liability.

82. Importance in Installation Contracts

Installation contracts commonly involve the supply of equipment and the work required to install it.

Examples include:

  • Heating systems.
  • Windows.
  • Kitchen fittings.
  • Electrical equipment.
  • Security systems.
  • Flooring.

Different legal obligations may apply to the equipment and installation services.

83. Importance in Bespoke Manufacturing

Bespoke manufacturing involves producing goods according to a customer’s specifications.

Historically, such arrangements raised questions concerning whether the contract was for the sale of goods or for work and materials.

Modern statutory rules may govern the supply of the finished goods even where substantial skill is involved.

84. Importance of Contractual Classification

Correct classification may determine:

  • Which legislation applies.
  • Which terms are implied.
  • The standard of performance required.
  • The remedies available.
  • Whether ownership of goods has transferred.
  • The effect of exclusion clauses.
  • The consequences of defective goods or services.

85. Importance of Clear Drafting

Contracts involving work and materials should clearly identify:

  • The scope of work.
  • The materials to be supplied.
  • Required specifications.
  • The applicable quality standards.
  • Completion dates.
  • Payment arrangements.
  • Responsibility for defects.
  • Procedures for variations.
  • Remedies for breach.

Clear drafting reduces uncertainty concerning the parties’ obligations.

86. Common Misunderstanding: Materials Automatically Make the Contract a Sale

The supply of materials does not automatically mean that the contract is solely a contract for the sale of goods.

The agreement may involve substantial work and skill.

The legal classification depends upon the substance of the contractual obligations and applicable legislation.

87. Common Misunderstanding: Work Contracts Have No Goods Obligations

A contract involving substantial labour may still contain legally enforceable obligations concerning the materials supplied.

Defective materials may give rise to liability even where the workmanship itself is satisfactory.

88. Common Misunderstanding: All Mixed Contracts Are Governed by One Set of Rules

A mixed contract may engage different statutory provisions concerning goods and services.

For example, a consumer contract to supply and install windows may involve obligations under both the goods and services provisions of the Consumer Rights Act 2015.

The contract must be analysed according to its constituent obligations.

89. Practical Example: Commissioned Painting

A customer commissions an artist to paint a portrait.

The artist provides the canvas, paint, and labour.

The principal purpose is the artist’s creative skill.

The arrangement illustrates the historical concept of a contract for work and labour, as discussed in Robinson v Graves.

90. Practical Example: Double-Glazing Contract

A homeowner contracts with a company to supply and install double-glazed windows.

The company supplies the windows and performs the installation.

If the windows are defective, the customer may have rights concerning the goods.

If the installation is defective, the customer may have rights concerning the services.

91. Practical Example: Building Extension

A builder agrees to construct an extension using materials supplied by the builder.

The builder must perform the agreed construction work and supply the specified materials.

Failure to comply with the contractual specifications may constitute a breach.

92. Practical Example: Garage Repair

A garage agrees to repair a vehicle using replacement parts.

The garage installs a defective replacement component.

The vehicle subsequently breaks down.

The customer may have contractual remedies concerning the defective component, the repair work, or both, depending upon the circumstances.

93. Practical Example: Kitchen Installation

A contractor agrees to supply and install fitted kitchen units.

The units are satisfactory, but the installation is performed without reasonable care and skill.

The customer may have a claim concerning the defective service.

The fact that the goods themselves are satisfactory does not necessarily discharge the contractor’s obligations.

94. Practical Example: Defective Building Materials

A contractor agrees to construct a garden wall.

The contractor uses unsuitable bricks that deteriorate prematurely.

The customer may have a claim arising from the failure to supply materials meeting the applicable contractual standards.

95. Practical Example: Failure to Complete

A contractor agrees to renovate a bathroom within six weeks.

The contractor supplies the materials but leaves the work unfinished without lawful justification.

The failure to complete may constitute a breach of contract.

The available remedies depend upon the contractual terms and applicable law.

96. Practical Example: Excessive Rectification Cost

A contractor completes a swimming pool with a minor deviation from the agreed specification.

Correcting the deviation would require extensive demolition and reconstruction.

The court may consider whether the claimed rectification cost is reasonable.

The principles illustrated by Ruxley Electronics and Construction Ltd v Forsyth may be relevant.

97. Relationship with Words of Art

The expression contract for work done and materials supplied is a legal term of art.

It describes a recognised category of contractual arrangements combining labour or services with the supply of materials.

Its historical importance lies particularly in distinguishing contracts for work and labour from contracts for the sale of goods.

98. Legal Importance

A contract for work done and materials supplied is an agreement under which one party undertakes to perform work or exercise skill while also providing materials necessary for that work.

Typical examples include construction, repairs, installation, bespoke manufacturing, and commissioned artistic work.

Historically, the distinction between such contracts and contracts for the sale of goods was important because the legal classification affected the rules governing the transaction.

The decision in Robinson v Graves 1935 illustrates the historical importance of determining whether the essential purpose of a contract is the exercise of skill or the supply of goods.

Modern English law regulates these arrangements through several statutory frameworks, including the Sale of Goods Act 1979, the Supply of Goods and Services Act 1982, and the Consumer Rights Act 2015.

The applicable legislation depends upon the nature of the transaction, the status of the parties, and the obligations undertaken.

In particular, a contract combining goods and services may impose separate obligations concerning the quality of materials and the standard of workmanship.

Ultimately, the legal importance of a contract for work done and materials supplied lies in recognising that the contractor may be responsible both for performing the agreed work properly and for supplying materials that comply with the applicable contractual and statutory requirements.


Image description
0 Comments