- Published on
KembaraXtra - Legal Terms - Wrong
1. Introduction
A wrong is an act, omission, or state of affairs that infringes a legally recognised right, breaches a legal duty, or otherwise constitutes a violation of law.
In legal terminology, the word wrong has a more specific meaning than its ordinary moral or social meaning.
A person may behave unfairly, dishonestly, or inconsiderately without necessarily committing a legal wrong. Conversely, conduct may constitute a legal wrong even where the person responsible did not intend to cause harm.
Legal wrongs form a fundamental part of the law because they provide the basis for determining liability, granting remedies, imposing sanctions, and protecting legal rights.
They arise across numerous branches of law, including:
- Tort law.
- Contract law.
- Criminal law.
- Equity.
- Property law.
- Employment law.
- Public law.
- Company law.
The central legal question is whether the relevant conduct satisfies the requirements of a recognised legal rule that imposes liability or authorises a remedy or sanction.
2. Definition
A legal wrong is conduct or another legally relevant occurrence that violates a legal duty or infringes a protected legal interest in circumstances recognised by law.
The precise requirements depend upon the particular cause of action, offence, or legal doctrine involved.
3. Essential Characteristics
A legal wrong may involve:
- A legally recognised duty or prohibition.
- An act or omission.
- A breach of the applicable legal standard.
- An infringement of a protected right or interest.
- Harm or loss, where required.
- A legally recognised consequence.
- A remedy, sanction, or other form of liability.
Not every legal wrong requires proof of all these elements.
4. Legal Wrong Versus Moral Wrong
A moral wrong is conduct considered improper according to ethical principles.
A legal wrong is conduct that violates an applicable legal rule.
The two categories overlap but are not identical.
5. Example: Moral Wrong Without Legal Liability
A person makes an unkind remark to a friend.
The remark may be morally objectionable.
However, it does not necessarily constitute a legally actionable wrong.
6. Example: Legal Wrong Without Moral Blame
A person commits a regulatory offence that imposes strict liability.
Liability may arise without proof of an intention to break the law.
7. Legal Rights
A legal right is an interest, entitlement, power, or protection recognised by law.
The infringement of a legal right may give rise to a legal wrong.
8. Legal Duties
A legal duty is an obligation imposed by law.
A breach of duty may constitute a wrong where the applicable legal requirements are satisfied.
9. Relationship Between Rights and Duties
Rights and duties are frequently connected.
For example, one person’s right to bodily integrity corresponds to duties imposed upon others not to interfere unlawfully with that interest.
10. Wrongful Conduct
Wrongful conduct is behaviour that breaches an applicable legal standard.
Its legal consequences depend upon the relevant branch of law.
11. Acts
An act is positive conduct.
Examples include striking another person, damaging property, or making a fraudulent representation.
12. Omissions
An omission is a failure to act.
An omission may constitute a legal wrong where the law imposes a duty to take the relevant action.
13. General Rule Concerning Omissions
English law does not impose a universal duty to prevent harm to others.
Liability for omissions depends upon recognised duties and exceptions.
14. Example: Failure to Act
A person witnesses a stranger in danger.
The mere failure to assist does not automatically create civil or criminal liability under English law.
Additional circumstances may establish a legal duty.
15. Sources of Legal Duties
Legal duties may arise from:
- Statute.
- Common law.
- Contract.
- Equity.
- Property relationships.
- Assumption of responsibility.
- Certain recognised relationships.
- Other established legal principles.
16. Statutory Wrong
A statutory wrong arises where conduct violates a duty or prohibition imposed by legislation.
Its consequences depend upon the statute.
17. Common Law Wrong
A common law wrong arises under principles developed through judicial decisions.
Many torts are examples of common law wrongs.
18. Equitable Wrong
An equitable wrong involves conduct contrary to obligations recognised and enforced by equity.
Examples include certain breaches of fiduciary duty and breach of confidence.
19. Contractual Wrong
A contractual wrong occurs where a party fails to perform an enforceable contractual obligation.
It is generally described as a breach of contract.
20. Criminal Wrong
A criminal wrong is conduct satisfying the elements of an offence.
It may result in criminal prosecution and punishment.
21. Civil Wrong
A civil wrong is a legally actionable violation ordinarily addressed through civil proceedings.
Civil wrongs include torts and breaches of contract.
22. Civil Versus Criminal Wrongs
Civil proceedings generally concern rights, obligations, and remedies between parties.
Criminal proceedings concern offences prosecuted through the criminal justice system.
23. Overlap Between Civil and Criminal Liability
The same conduct may constitute both a civil wrong and a criminal offence.
For example, an unlawful assault may give rise to criminal liability and a civil claim.
24. Example: Assault
A person intentionally strikes another without lawful justification.
The conduct may constitute a criminal offence and the tort of battery.
25. Example: Theft
A person dishonestly appropriates property belonging to another with the intention of permanently depriving the other of it.
Where the statutory elements are satisfied, the conduct constitutes theft under the Theft Act 1968.
It may also involve civil liability.
26. Example: Negligence
A driver breaches a duty of care and causes reasonably foreseeable injury.
The conduct may constitute the tort of negligence.
27. Tort
A tort is a civil wrong recognised by law that gives rise to a civil remedy, subject to the requirements of the particular tort.
28. Tort Law
Tort law addresses civil wrongs involving interests such as personal safety, property, reputation, privacy, and economic interests.
29. Principal Functions of Tort Law
Tort law may serve several functions:
- Compensation.
- Protection of legal interests.
- Deterrence.
- Allocation of responsibility.
- Vindication of rights.
- Prevention of continuing wrongdoing.
30. Negligence
Negligence is a tort involving breach of a legally recognised duty of care causing actionable damage.
31. Elements of Negligence
A negligence claim generally requires:
- A duty of care.
- Breach of that duty.
- Factual causation.
- Legal causation or remoteness.
- Actionable damage.
32. Duty of Care
A duty of care is a legal obligation to exercise appropriate care towards another person in specified circumstances.
33. Donoghue v Stevenson
In Donoghue v Stevenson 1932 AC 562, the House of Lords established influential principles concerning negligence and duties of care.
34. Neighbour Principle
Lord Atkin’s neighbour principle concerns the duty to take reasonable care to avoid acts or omissions likely to injure persons sufficiently closely affected by one’s conduct.
35. Breach of Duty
A breach occurs where conduct falls below the applicable legal standard of care.
36. Reasonable Person Standard
Negligence commonly uses an objective standard of reasonable care.
The precise standard depends upon the circumstances.
37. Blyth v Birmingham Waterworks
In Blyth v Birmingham Waterworks Co (1856) 11 Ex Ch 781, negligence was discussed by reference to failure to do what a reasonable person would do or doing what a prudent person would not do.
38. Causation
Causation concerns the relationship between the defendant’s breach and the claimant’s harm.
39. Factual Causation
Factual causation commonly asks whether the harm would have occurred but for the defendant’s wrongful conduct.
40. Barnett v Chelsea and Kensington Hospital
In Barnett v Chelsea and Kensington Hospital Management Committee 1969 1 QB 428, the court considered factual causation in negligence.
41. Remoteness
Remoteness concerns whether the type of damage is sufficiently connected to the wrong to be legally recoverable.
42. The Wagon Mound
In Overseas Tankship (UK) Ltd v Morts Dock & Engineering Co Ltd (The Wagon Mound No 1) 1961 AC 388, the Privy Council addressed reasonable foreseeability of damage in negligence.
43. Actionable Damage
Some torts require proof of legally recognised damage.
Others may be actionable without proof of actual loss.
44. Actionable Per Se
A wrong is actionable per se where a claimant may sue without proving actual damage.
Examples include certain forms of trespass.
45. Trespass to the Person
Trespass to the person includes:
- Assault.
- Battery.
- False imprisonment.
These torts protect personal autonomy and bodily integrity.
46. Assault in Tort
Civil assault generally concerns conduct causing another person reasonably to apprehend imminent unlawful physical contact.
47. Battery in Tort
Battery involves intentional and unlawful physical contact with another person.
The precise legal analysis depends upon the circumstances.
48. False Imprisonment
False imprisonment involves the unlawful total restraint of a person’s freedom of movement.
49. Trespass to Land
Trespass to land involves unjustified interference with another person’s possession of land.
50. Example: Trespass to Land
A person enters privately possessed land without permission or other lawful authority.
The conduct may constitute trespass.
51. Trespass to Goods
Trespass to goods concerns direct wrongful interference with goods in another person’s possession.
52. Conversion
Conversion involves dealing with goods in a manner inconsistent with the rights of a person entitled to possession.
53. Torts (Interference with Goods) Act 1977
The Torts (Interference with Goods) Act 1977 provides important rules and remedies concerning wrongful interference with goods.
54. Nuisance
Nuisance concerns certain unlawful interferences with rights relating to land or, in the case of public nuisance, interests protected by that distinct doctrine.
55. Private Nuisance
Private nuisance generally involves an unlawful interference with a person’s use or enjoyment of land or certain rights over land.
56. Public Nuisance
Public nuisance is a distinct legal concept concerning interference with rights or interests of the public.
Its modern criminal and civil treatment must be distinguished.
57. Defamation
Defamation concerns publication of statements that harm another person’s reputation in circumstances satisfying the applicable legal requirements.
58. Defamation Act 2013
The Defamation Act 2013 governs important aspects of defamation law in England and Wales.
59. Serious Harm
Section 1 of the Defamation Act 2013 requires serious harm to reputation or its likelihood.
For bodies trading for profit, serious harm requires serious financial loss or its likelihood.
60. Malicious Falsehood
Malicious falsehood is a distinct tort concerning false statements made maliciously that cause or are likely to cause legally relevant financial harm in the circumstances recognised by law.
61. Deceit
The tort of deceit concerns fraudulent misrepresentation causing loss.
62. Fraudulent Misrepresentation
Fraudulent misrepresentation involves a false representation made knowingly, without belief in its truth, or recklessly as to its truth, together with the other requirements of the tort.
63. Derry v Peek
In Derry v Peek (1889) 14 App Cas 337, the House of Lords addressed the meaning of fraud in the context of deceit.
64. Intentional Wrongs
Certain wrongs require intention.
Examples may include battery, deceit, and particular criminal offences.
65. Negligent Wrongs
Other wrongs arise through failure to exercise legally required care.
66. Strict Liability
Strict liability may arise where liability does not require proof of fault in the ordinary sense.
The precise requirements depend upon the applicable legal rule.
67. Rylands v Fletcher
In Rylands v Fletcher (1868) LR 3 HL 330, the House of Lords recognised a principle concerning liability for the escape of certain dangerous things from land.
Its modern scope is restricted and closely connected to nuisance.
68. Transco plc v Stockport MBC
In Transco plc v Stockport Metropolitan Borough Council 2003 UKHL 61, the House of Lords considered the modern scope of the rule in Rylands v Fletcher.
69. Vicarious Liability
Vicarious liability may impose responsibility upon one person for a wrong committed by another.
70. Employer Liability
An employer may be vicariously liable for certain torts committed by an employee in the course of employment.
71. Various Claimants v Catholic Child Welfare Society
In Various Claimants v Catholic Child Welfare Society 2012 UKSC 56, the Supreme Court considered principles governing vicarious liability.
72. Barclays Bank plc v Various Claimants
In Barclays Bank plc v Various Claimants 2020 UKSC 13, the Supreme Court examined the distinction between relationships capable of giving rise to vicarious liability and independent contracting.
73. Non-Delegable Duties
A non-delegable duty is a duty that remains with the person owing it even where performance is entrusted to another.
74. Woodland v Swimming Teachers Association
In Woodland v Swimming Teachers Association 2013 UKSC 66, the Supreme Court considered circumstances in which a non-delegable duty of care may arise.
75. Contractual Wrongs
A contractual wrong generally occurs where a party fails to perform an enforceable contractual obligation.
76. Breach of Contract
A breach of contract occurs where a party fails to perform a contractual duty without lawful justification.
77. Example: Failure to Deliver Goods
A seller agrees to deliver goods by a contractual deadline.
The seller fails to deliver.
The failure may constitute a breach of contract.
78. Example: Failure to Pay
A buyer receives goods but fails to pay the agreed price.
The failure may constitute a contractual wrong.
79. Contractual Damages
Damages for breach of contract generally seek to place the innocent party in the position they would have occupied had the contract been performed, subject to the applicable limitations.
80. Robinson v Harman
In Robinson v Harman (1848) 1 Ex 850, the court stated an influential principle concerning compensation for breach of contract.
81. Contractual Remoteness
Not every loss following a breach is recoverable.
Contract law imposes rules concerning remoteness.
82. Hadley v Baxendale
In Hadley v Baxendale (1854) 9 Exch 341, the court established influential principles governing remoteness of contractual damages.
83. Mitigation
A claimant may be required to take reasonable steps to mitigate recoverable loss.
The doctrine does not ordinarily impose an independent duty actionable by the defendant.
84. Specific Performance
Specific performance is an equitable remedy requiring performance of a contractual obligation.
It may be granted where the applicable legal requirements are satisfied.
85. Injunction
An injunction is a court order requiring a person to act or refrain from acting.
It may prevent or remedy certain wrongs.
86. Contractual Wrong Versus Tortious Wrong
A contractual wrong arises from breach of a contractual obligation.
A tortious wrong arises from a duty imposed by tort law.
87. Concurrent Liability
The same conduct may give rise to both contractual and tortious liability.
The availability of concurrent claims depends upon the relevant legal principles.
88. Henderson v Merrett Syndicates
In Henderson v Merrett Syndicates Ltd 1995 2 AC 145, the House of Lords considered concurrent duties in contract and tort.
89. Equitable Wrongs
Equity recognises duties and obligations distinct from those arising solely under common law.
Their breach may result in equitable remedies.
90. Breach of Fiduciary Duty
A fiduciary may breach legal obligations of loyalty by acting contrary to duties owed to another.
91. Fiduciary
A fiduciary is a person subject to particular duties of loyalty in relation to another person’s interests.
92. Examples of Fiduciaries
Fiduciary relationships may arise involving:
- Trustees.
- Company directors.
- Agents.
- Partners.
- Other persons in qualifying relationships.
93. Duty of Loyalty
The duty of loyalty generally requires a fiduciary to act consistently with the obligations arising from the fiduciary relationship.
94. No-Conflict Rule
A fiduciary must generally avoid unauthorised conflicts between duty and personal interest.
95. No-Profit Rule
A fiduciary must generally not obtain unauthorised profits from the fiduciary position.
96. Boardman v Phipps
In Boardman v Phipps 1967 2 AC 46, the House of Lords considered fiduciary duties and liability to account for profits.
97. Account of Profits
An account of profits is a remedy requiring a defendant to surrender profits obtained through certain wrongful conduct.
98. Equitable Compensation
Equitable compensation may be awarded for certain breaches of equitable duty.
Its requirements differ according to the nature of the obligation.
99. Breach of Trust
A breach of trust occurs where a trustee fails to comply with obligations imposed by the trust.
100. Trustee Duties
Trustees must administer trust property in accordance with the trust and applicable law.
101. Trust Property
Trust property is property held subject to trust obligations.
Misapplication of trust property may constitute a breach of trust.
102. Dishonest Assistance
Dishonest assistance is an equitable basis of liability involving dishonest assistance in another person’s breach of trust or fiduciary duty.
103. Royal Brunei Airlines v Tan
In Royal Brunei Airlines Sdn Bhd v Tan 1995 2 AC 378, the Privy Council considered liability for dishonest assistance.
104. Knowing Receipt
Knowing receipt concerns personal equitable liability arising from receipt of property transferred in breach of trust or fiduciary duty, where the applicable requirements are satisfied.
105. Breach of Confidence
Breach of confidence concerns unauthorised use or disclosure of information protected by an obligation of confidence.
106. Confidential Information
Confidential information may include trade secrets, commercial information, and other material protected by law.
107. Wrongful Disclosure
Unauthorised disclosure of confidential information may constitute a legal wrong.
108. Misuse of Private Information
Misuse of private information is a recognised cause of action protecting privacy interests.
109. Campbell v MGN Ltd
In Campbell v MGN Ltd 2004 UKHL 22, the House of Lords considered privacy and the protection of private information.
110. Criminal Wrongs
A criminal wrong consists of conduct satisfying the elements of an offence.
Criminal liability is governed by statutory provisions and common law principles where applicable.
111. Actus Reus
Actus reus refers to the external elements of a criminal offence.
It may involve conduct, circumstances, or consequences.
112. Mens Rea
Mens rea refers to the mental elements required for an offence.
These may include intention, knowledge, recklessness, or other specified states of mind.
113. Coincidence of Elements
Criminal liability commonly requires the relevant physical and mental elements to coincide.
The precise requirements depend upon the offence.
114. Intention
Intention may be a required mental element of an offence.
Its meaning depends upon the statutory provision and relevant case law.
115. Recklessness
Recklessness generally concerns conscious taking of an unjustified risk under the applicable criminal law test.
116. R v G
In R v G 2003 UKHL 50, the House of Lords addressed the meaning of recklessness in criminal damage.
117. Criminal Negligence
Certain offences may be committed through conduct amounting to criminal negligence.
The relevant threshold is determined by the particular offence.
118. Gross Negligence Manslaughter
Gross negligence manslaughter may arise where a sufficiently serious breach of duty causes death and satisfies the other legal requirements.
119. R v Adomako
In R v Adomako 1994 UKHL 6, the House of Lords addressed gross negligence manslaughter.
120. Strict Liability Offences
Some criminal offences do not require proof of mens rea for one or more elements.
The statutory construction determines whether strict liability applies.
121. Criminal Defences
Conduct satisfying the apparent elements of an offence may be justified or excused by an applicable defence.
122. Self-Defence
Self-defence may justify otherwise unlawful force where the relevant requirements are satisfied.
123. Necessity
Necessity may be relevant in limited legal circumstances.
Its availability and scope vary across legal contexts.
124. Duress
Duress may provide a defence to certain offences where the applicable requirements are met.
125. Consent
Consent may affect whether conduct constitutes a wrong.
Its legal effect depends upon the particular offence or civil cause of action.
126. Public Law Wrongs
Public law wrongs concern unlawful exercises of public power or failures to comply with public law duties.
127. Judicial Review
Judicial review is a procedure through which courts supervise the lawfulness of decisions and actions of public bodies and other persons exercising public functions.
128. Illegality
Illegality in judicial review concerns acting outside legal powers or otherwise contrary to law.
129. Procedural Impropriety
Procedural impropriety may arise where a decision-maker fails to comply with legally required procedures or standards of fairness.
130. Irrationality
Irrationality is a recognised ground of judicial review.
The applicable threshold depends upon the legal context.
131. Council of Civil Service Unions v Minister for the Civil Service
In Council of Civil Service Unions v Minister for the Civil Service 1985 AC 374, the House of Lords discussed important grounds of judicial review.
132. Ultra Vires
Ultra vires means acting beyond legal powers.
It is a central concept in public law.
133. Abuse of Power
Abuse of power may arise where public authority is exercised for an improper purpose or otherwise unlawfully.
134. Breach of Natural Justice
Breach of natural justice concerns failure to observe fundamental requirements of procedural fairness.
135. Right to Be Heard
The right to be heard is an important aspect of procedural fairness.
Its content depends upon the circumstances.
136. Rule Against Bias
Decision-makers must comply with applicable rules concerning impartiality.
137. Remedies in Judicial Review
Available remedies may include:
- Quashing orders.
- Mandatory orders.
- Prohibiting orders.
- Declarations.
- Injunctions.
- Damages where a separate legal basis exists.
138. Wrongful Dismissal
Wrongful dismissal is a contractual wrong arising where an employer dismisses an employee in breach of the employment contract.
139. Wrongful Dismissal Versus Unfair Dismissal
Wrongful dismissal is primarily a contractual claim.
Unfair dismissal is a statutory employment law claim.
140. Employment Rights Act 1996
The Employment Rights Act 1996 provides important statutory employment protections, including rights concerning dismissal.
141. Workplace Discrimination
Unlawful discrimination may constitute a statutory wrong.
142. Equality Act 2010
The Equality Act 2010 prohibits specified forms of discrimination, harassment, and victimisation in circumstances covered by the Act.
143. Direct Discrimination
Direct discrimination generally involves less favourable treatment because of a protected characteristic, subject to the statutory framework.
144. Indirect Discrimination
Indirect discrimination may arise where a provision, criterion, or practice produces a particular disadvantage and cannot be justified under the applicable statutory test.
145. Harassment
Harassment under the Equality Act 2010 concerns specified unwanted conduct related to a protected characteristic or of another type covered by the Act.
146. Victimisation
Victimisation may arise where a person is subjected to a detriment because of a protected act under the Equality Act 2010.
147. Company Law Wrongs
Company law recognises wrongs involving breaches of directors’ duties, unlawful distributions, and other violations of corporate obligations.
148. Directors’ Duties
Directors owe statutory and other duties concerning the management of companies.
149. Companies Act 2006
The Companies Act 2006 contains important provisions governing directors’ duties and corporate governance.
150. Sections 171–177
Sections 171–177 establish important general duties of directors.
151. Breach of Directors’ Duties
A director who breaches an applicable duty may face civil consequences.
The remedies depend upon the nature of the breach.
152. Wrongful Trading
Wrongful trading is a statutory insolvency concept concerning specified conduct by directors in connection with insolvent liquidation or administration.
153. Insolvency Act 1986
The Insolvency Act 1986 contains provisions governing wrongful trading and related insolvency liabilities.
154. Fraudulent Trading
Fraudulent trading is distinct from wrongful trading.
It involves conduct carried on with intent to defraud creditors or for another fraudulent purpose under the applicable statutory provisions.
155. Property Wrongs
Property wrongs concern unlawful interference with rights to land, goods, or other protected property interests.
156. Wrongful Interference with Goods
Wrongful interference with goods may include conversion and trespass to goods.
157. Wrongful Occupation
Unlawful occupation of land may constitute trespass or give rise to other legal consequences.
158. Wrongful Eviction
Wrongful eviction may involve unlawfully depriving a person of occupation of premises.
It may give rise to statutory or common law remedies.
159. Wrongful Possession
The expression wrongful possession may describe possession inconsistent with another person’s legal rights.
Its precise consequences depend upon the legal context.
160. Wrongful Detention
Wrongful detention may concern unlawful restraint of a person or wrongful retention of property.
The legal meaning depends upon the context.
161. Injuria
The Latin term injuria may refer to a legal wrong or infringement of a right.
Its meaning varies according to the doctrine in which it is used.
162. Damnum
Damnum refers to damage or loss.
It is important in traditional distinctions between legal injury and factual harm.
163. Damnum Sine Injuria
Damnum sine injuria means damage without legal injury.
It describes situations where a person suffers loss without infringement of a legally protected right.
164. Example: Lawful Competition
A business loses customers because a competitor lawfully offers better prices.
The business suffers economic loss, but the competitor has not necessarily committed a legal wrong.
165. Gloucester Grammar School Case
The Gloucester Grammar School Case (1410) YB 11 Hen IV 47 is traditionally associated with the principle that loss caused by lawful competition does not necessarily create liability.
166. Injuria Sine Damno
Injuria sine damno means legal injury without actual damage.
It describes infringement of a legal right even where measurable loss is absent.
167. Ashby v White
In Ashby v White (1703) 2 Ld Raym 938, the court recognised the significance of infringement of a legal right even without proof of substantial financial loss.
168. Importance of Ashby v White
The case illustrates that infringement of a protected right may itself justify a legal remedy.
169. Legal Injury Versus Actual Damage
Legal injury concerns infringement of a protected right.
Actual damage concerns the factual harm suffered.
The two do not always coincide.
170. Actionable Wrong
An actionable wrong is one for which the law provides a basis for bringing proceedings.
171. Non-Actionable Conduct
Conduct may be objectionable without giving rise to a recognised cause of action.
172. Cause of Action
A cause of action consists of the material facts necessary to establish a legally recognised claim.
173. Elements of a Cause of Action
Each cause of action has its own legal elements.
A claimant must establish the applicable requirements.
174. Burden of Proof
The burden of proof determines which party must establish particular facts or legal elements.
175. Civil Standard of Proof
In ordinary civil proceedings, facts are generally established on the balance of probabilities.
176. Criminal Standard of Proof
In criminal proceedings, the prosecution generally must prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt.
177. Presumption of Innocence
The presumption of innocence is a fundamental principle of criminal justice.
178. Evidence
Evidence is used to establish the facts relevant to an alleged wrong.
179. Documentary Evidence
Documentary evidence may include contracts, correspondence, records, and other documents.
180. Witness Evidence
Witness evidence may establish what occurred and whether the applicable legal requirements are satisfied.
181. Expert Evidence
Expert evidence may assist the court with specialised matters requiring expertise.
182. Defences
A defendant may avoid or reduce liability by establishing an applicable defence.
183. Consent as a Defence
Consent may provide a defence to certain torts.
Its availability depends upon the nature of the wrong.
184. Volenti Non Fit Injuria
The Latin maxim volenti non fit injuria broadly means that no legal injury is done to a person who validly consents to the relevant risk or conduct.
185. Contributory Negligence
Contributory negligence may reduce damages where the claimant’s own fault contributed to the damage.
186. Law Reform (Contributory Negligence) Act 1945
The Law Reform (Contributory Negligence) Act 1945 provides for apportionment of damages in qualifying cases.
187. Illegality Defence
The illegality defence may prevent or restrict recovery where the claim is sufficiently connected to the claimant’s unlawful conduct.
188. Patel v Mirza
In Patel v Mirza 2016 UKSC 42, the Supreme Court considered the modern approach to the illegality defence in civil claims.
189. Limitation
Limitation rules determine the periods within which proceedings must ordinarily be commenced.
190. Limitation Act 1980
The Limitation Act 1980 governs limitation periods for many civil claims in England and Wales.
191. Expiry of Limitation
Expiry of a limitation period may provide a defence or otherwise restrict proceedings, depending upon the applicable statutory provision.
192. Remedies
A remedy is the legal relief available in response to a wrong.
193. Damages
Damages are monetary compensation awarded according to the applicable legal principles.
194. Compensatory Damages
Compensatory damages seek to compensate for legally recoverable loss.
195. Nominal Damages
Nominal damages may be awarded where a legal right has been infringed but substantial loss is not proved.
196. Aggravated Damages
Aggravated damages may be available in certain circumstances to compensate for additional injury arising from the manner of the wrongdoing.
197. Exemplary Damages
Exemplary damages are punitive damages available only in limited circumstances recognised by law.
198. Rookes v Barnard
In Rookes v Barnard 1964 AC 1129, the House of Lords addressed the circumstances in which exemplary damages may be awarded.
199. Restitution
Restitution concerns reversing certain unjust enrichments or requiring restoration under recognised legal principles.
It is not identical to compensation for wrongdoing.
200. Restitution for Wrongs
Certain wrongs may give rise to gain-based remedies.
The applicable basis and measure depend upon the cause of action.
201. Account of Profits
An account of profits may require a wrongdoer to surrender gains obtained through particular breaches of duty.
202. Injunctions
Injunctions may restrain threatened or continuing wrongs.
203. Prohibitory Injunction
A prohibitory injunction requires a person to refrain from specified conduct.
204. Mandatory Injunction
A mandatory injunction requires a person to take specified positive action.
205. Declaration
A declaration is a judicial statement concerning the parties’ legal rights or obligations.
206. Specific Performance
Specific performance may compel performance of a contractual obligation in appropriate circumstances.
207. Rescission
Rescission may set aside a transaction where the relevant legal grounds are established.
208. Rectification
Rectification may correct a written instrument that fails to reflect the parties’ legally relevant agreement or intention in circumstances recognised by law.
209. Delivery of Goods
A court may order delivery of goods in qualifying cases.
The Torts (Interference with Goods) Act 1977 provides important remedies.
210. Writ of Delivery
A writ of delivery may enforce a judgment or order requiring delivery of specified goods.
211. Writ of Possession
A writ of possession may enforce an order requiring possession of land to be delivered.
212. Writ of Control
A writ of control may enforce qualifying money judgments against goods.
213. Criminal Sanctions
Criminal wrongs may result in sanctions including fines, imprisonment, or other orders authorised by law.
214. Civil Remedies Versus Criminal Punishment
Civil remedies commonly seek compensation, protection, restitution, or enforcement of rights.
Criminal punishment serves public justice objectives, including punishment, deterrence, and rehabilitation.
215. Multiple Remedies
A single wrong may potentially support more than one remedy.
However, the law regulates double recovery and the interaction of remedies.
216. Double Recovery
A claimant is generally not entitled to recover compensation twice for the same loss.
217. Election of Remedies
In certain circumstances, a claimant may need to elect between inconsistent remedies.
218. Continuing Wrong
A continuing wrong involves conduct or interference persisting over time.
The legal consequences depend upon the cause of action.
219. Repeated Wrongs
Repeated wrongful acts may give rise to separate causes of action.
220. Anticipatory Wrong
Certain legal doctrines address threatened or anticipated breaches.
For example, anticipatory repudiation may arise before the time for contractual performance.
221. Threatened Wrong
A threatened wrong may justify preventive relief where the applicable legal requirements are satisfied.
222. Preventive Justice
Preventive remedies seek to stop unlawful conduct before further harm occurs.
223. Wrong Without Fault
Some legal regimes impose liability without requiring proof of negligence or intention.
224. Wrong Without Damage
Certain infringements are actionable without proof of actual damage.
225. Damage Without Wrong
A person may suffer loss without possessing a legal claim against another.
226. Wrong Without a Private Remedy
A breach of law does not always create a private right to sue.
The consequences depend upon the applicable legal framework.
227. Breach of Statutory Duty
A breach of statutory duty may give rise to a civil claim where the statute, properly interpreted, provides for such liability.
228. Statutory Interpretation
The court may need to determine whether Parliament intended a statutory provision to create a private cause of action.
229. Regulatory Breaches
A regulatory breach may result in administrative or criminal consequences without necessarily creating a private claim for damages.
230. Public Wrong Versus Private Wrong
A public wrong affects interests protected through public law or criminal law.
A private wrong generally involves infringement of rights enforceable by an individual or other private party.
231. Wrong Against the State
Certain offences and public law violations concern interests protected by the state.
232. Wrong Against an Individual
A civil wrong may infringe an individual’s property, personal, contractual, or other legally protected rights.
233. Collective Harm
Some wrongs affect groups or the public.
Their treatment depends upon the applicable statutory and common law framework.
234. Environmental Wrongs
Environmental wrongdoing may involve breaches of statutory duties, nuisance, negligence, or other legal obligations.
235. Consumer Protection Wrongs
Consumer protection law regulates specified unfair commercial practices and contractual conduct.
236. Consumer Rights Act 2015
The Consumer Rights Act 2015 provides important rights and remedies concerning consumer contracts.
237. Data Protection Wrongs
Unlawful processing of personal data may give rise to regulatory consequences and, in qualifying circumstances, compensation claims.
238. UK GDPR
The UK General Data Protection Regulation forms part of the United Kingdom’s data protection framework.
239. Data Protection Act 2018
The Data Protection Act 2018 supplements the UK data protection framework.
240. Intellectual Property Wrongs
Intellectual property law recognises wrongs involving infringement of protected rights.
241. Copyright Infringement
Copyright infringement may arise through unauthorised acts restricted by copyright law.
242. Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988
The Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 provides the principal statutory framework for copyright protection in the United Kingdom.
243. Trade Mark Infringement
Trade mark infringement may arise through unauthorised use of protected signs in circumstances covered by the law.
244. Trade Marks Act 1994
The Trade Marks Act 1994 governs registered trade mark rights and infringement in the United Kingdom.
245. Patent Infringement
Patent infringement concerns unauthorised exploitation of a patented invention in circumstances prohibited by law.
246. Patents Act 1977
The Patents Act 1977 governs important aspects of patent protection and infringement.
247. Wrongful Conduct in Equity
Equity may impose remedies for breaches of confidence, fiduciary duties, and trust obligations.
248. Wrongful Conduct in Contract
Contract law protects the performance interests created by enforceable agreements.
249. Wrongful Conduct in Tort
Tort law protects interests recognised independently of contractual obligations.
250. Wrongful Conduct in Criminal Law
Criminal law identifies prohibited conduct and imposes sanctions where the offence elements are proved.
251. Comparative Perspective: Malaysia
Malaysian law also distinguishes between civil wrongs, criminal offences, contractual breaches, and equitable obligations.
Its legal system incorporates common law principles subject to Malaysian legislation and judicial development.
252. Civil Law Act 1956
The Civil Law Act 1956 is relevant to the reception and application of English common law and equity in Malaysia, subject to its statutory conditions and limitations.
253. Malaysian Tort Law
Malaysian tort law recognises causes of action including negligence, nuisance, trespass, and defamation.
The applicable principles depend upon Malaysian law.
254. Malaysian Contract Law
The Contracts Act 1950 governs important aspects of contractual obligations in Malaysia.
A breach of contract may give rise to civil remedies.
255. Malaysian Criminal Law
The Penal Code establishes numerous criminal offences in Malaysia.
Criminal liability depends upon the elements of the relevant offence.
256. Malaysian Company Law
The Companies Act 2016 governs important aspects of directors’ duties and corporate obligations.
Breaches may result in civil or statutory consequences.
257. Malaysian Employment Law
Employment disputes may involve contractual wrongs and statutory employment protections.
The relevant framework includes the Employment Act 1955 and the Industrial Relations Act 1967, where applicable.
258. Malaysian Judicial Remedies
Malaysian courts may grant remedies for recognised civil wrongs in accordance with applicable substantive and procedural law.
259. Comparative Importance
Although English and Malaysian law share common law influences, their statutory frameworks and judicial developments are not identical.
The governing jurisdiction must always be identified.
260. Practical Example: Negligence
A driver fails to exercise reasonable care and injures a pedestrian.
The driver may be liable in negligence if the necessary elements are established.
261. Practical Example: Breach of Contract
A contractor agrees to complete work by a specified date.
The contractor fails to perform without lawful justification.
The failure may constitute a contractual wrong.
262. Practical Example: Conversion
A person wrongfully sells another person’s machinery.
The conduct may constitute conversion.
263. Practical Example: Trespass
A person enters land without permission or lawful authority.
The conduct may constitute trespass to land.
264. Practical Example: Defamation
A person publishes a false statement damaging another person’s reputation.
Liability may arise if the legal elements of defamation are satisfied and no defence applies.
265. Practical Example: Breach of Fiduciary Duty
A director secretly profits from a corporate opportunity in breach of applicable duties.
The company may seek appropriate relief.
266. Practical Example: Criminal Wrong
A person dishonestly steals property.
The conduct may constitute a criminal offence and also involve civil liability.
267. Practical Example: Moral Wrong Without Legal Wrong
A person refuses to attend a friend’s celebration.
The decision may be inconsiderate but does not ordinarily constitute a legal wrong.
268. Practical Example: Damage Without Legal Injury
A new shop attracts customers away from an existing business through lawful competition.
The existing business suffers loss but may have no legal claim.
269. Practical Example: Legal Injury Without Financial Loss
A person unlawfully enters another’s land without causing measurable damage.
The trespass may still be actionable.
270. Practical Example: Public Law Wrong
A public authority exercises a statutory power for an improper purpose.
The decision may be challenged through judicial review.
271. Practical Example: Employment Wrong
An employer dismisses an employee without providing contractually required notice.
The employee may have a wrongful dismissal claim.
272. Practical Example: Statutory Discrimination
An employer unlawfully discriminates against an employee because of a protected characteristic.
The employee may have a statutory claim.
273. Practical Example: Breach of Confidence
An employee unlawfully discloses confidential commercial information.
The conduct may give rise to a civil claim.
274. Common Misunderstanding: Every Moral Wrong Is a Legal Wrong
Moral wrongdoing does not automatically create legal liability.
275. Common Misunderstanding: Every Legal Wrong Is a Crime
Many legal wrongs are civil rather than criminal.
276. Common Misunderstanding: Every Wrong Requires Intention
Some wrongs arise through negligence or strict liability.
277. Common Misunderstanding: Every Wrong Requires Actual Damage
Certain wrongs are actionable without proof of measurable loss.
278. Common Misunderstanding: Every Loss Results from a Wrong
A person may suffer loss through lawful conduct by another.
279. Common Misunderstanding: Every Breach of Statute Creates a Damages Claim
A statutory breach does not necessarily create a private right of action.
280. Common Misunderstanding: Civil and Criminal Liability Cannot Coexist
The same conduct may give rise to both civil and criminal consequences.
281. Common Misunderstanding: A Wrong Always Produces Compensation
Some wrongs result in injunctions, declarations, restitution, punishment, or other consequences rather than compensatory damages.
282. Common Misunderstanding: A Defendant Is Liable Whenever Harm Is Foreseeable
Foreseeability alone does not establish every element of liability.
A legally recognised duty and the other requirements must be satisfied.
283. Common Misunderstanding: Wrongfulness Automatically Establishes Causation
A claimant may still need to prove that the wrong caused the claimed loss.
284. Common Misunderstanding: All Wrongs Have the Same Defences
Defences vary according to the cause of action or offence.
285. Common Misunderstanding: Every Wrong Is Enforced Through the Same Procedure
Different wrongs require different proceedings and remedies.
286. Relationship with Liability
Liability concerns the legal responsibility arising from conduct or circumstances.
A wrong may establish liability where the relevant requirements are satisfied.
287. Relationship with Fault
Fault concerns blameworthiness or failure to meet an applicable standard.
Not all forms of liability require proof of fault.
288. Relationship with Causation
Causation connects wrongful conduct with legally relevant consequences.
Its importance depends upon the claim.
289. Relationship with Damage
Damage may be an essential element of some wrongs but not others.
290. Relationship with Rights
Legal wrongs frequently involve infringements of legally protected rights.
291. Relationship with Duties
Many wrongs arise from breach of legal duties.
292. Relationship with Remedies
Remedies provide legal responses to established wrongs.
293. Relationship with Justice
The law of wrongs contributes to the protection of rights, allocation of responsibility, and maintenance of legal order.
294. Importance for Claimants
Claimants should identify:
- The legal right or duty involved.
- The relevant cause of action.
- The elements requiring proof.
- The evidence available.
- Any loss or injury.
- The appropriate remedy.
- The applicable limitation period.
295. Importance for Defendants
Defendants should consider:
- Whether a legal duty existed.
- Whether the alleged conduct occurred.
- Whether the legal standard was breached.
- Whether causation is established.
- Whether damage is required and proved.
- Whether a defence applies.
- Whether the claim is procedurally valid.
296. Importance for Legal Practitioners
Legal practitioners must distinguish moral wrongdoing from actionable legal wrongs.
They must also identify the correct branch of law, elements of liability, available defences, and remedies.
297. Practical Legal Checklist
When analysing an alleged wrong:
- Identify the jurisdiction.
- Determine whether the matter is civil, criminal, equitable, contractual, or public law.
- Identify the applicable legal rule.
- Establish the relevant right or duty.
- Identify the alleged act or omission.
- Determine whether the legal standard was breached.
- Consider intention, negligence, or strict liability.
- Examine causation where required.
- Determine whether actionable damage is necessary.
- Identify the evidence.
- Consider available defences.
- Check limitation and procedural requirements.
- Determine the appropriate remedy or sanction.
- Consider whether multiple forms of liability arise.
- Avoid assuming that moral blame alone establishes legal responsibility.
298. Legal Importance
A wrong is a legally recognised violation of a right, duty, prohibition, or other protected legal interest.
The concept extends across tort law, contract law, criminal law, equity, property law, employment law, company law, and public law.
Legal wrongs may arise through intentional conduct, negligence, strict liability, or other legally recognised circumstances.
Some wrongs require proof of damage, while others are actionable without measurable loss.
The traditional distinctions between damnum sine injuria and injuria sine damno demonstrate that factual harm and legal injury are not necessarily the same.
A legal wrong may give rise to damages, injunctions, declarations, restitutionary relief, criminal sanctions, or other consequences.
However, the existence of wrongdoing does not automatically establish every element of liability or entitle the claimant to a particular remedy.
Ultimately, the legal importance of the term wrong lies in its function as a foundational concept identifying conduct or circumstances that violate legally recognised obligations or protected interests and thereby justify an appropriate legal response under the applicable rules of liability and remedies.