LAW

Published on

KembaraXtra - Legal Terms - Wrongful Dismissal

1. Introduction

Wrongful dismissal occurs where an employer terminates an employee’s employment in breach of the employment contract.

It is principally a contractual cause of action, concerned with whether the employer complied with the contractual and legal obligations governing termination.

Wrongful dismissal commonly arises where an employer:

  • Dismisses an employee without giving the required notice.
  • Fails to make a payment in lieu of notice where legally required.
  • Dismisses an employee summarily without sufficient justification.
  • Breaches an enforceable contractual procedure governing dismissal.
  • Terminates a fixed-term employment contract prematurely without a contractual or other lawful basis.

Wrongful dismissal must be distinguished from unfair dismissal, which is primarily a statutory employment law claim.

A dismissal may be wrongful without being unfair, unfair without being wrongful, or both wrongful and unfair.

In England and Wales, wrongful dismissal is governed principally by common law contract principles, the employment contract, and relevant statutory provisions, particularly the Employment Rights Act 1996.

2. Definition

Wrongful dismissal is the termination of an employment contract by an employer in breach of an express or implied contractual obligation.

The breach commonly concerns notice, but it may involve another enforceable contractual term.

3. Essential Characteristics

Wrongful dismissal generally involves:

  • An employment contract.
  • Termination by the employer.
  • A contractual obligation governing termination.
  • Breach of that obligation.
  • A legally recognised basis for relief.
  • Proof of recoverable loss where substantial damages are claimed.

4. Legal Nature

Wrongful dismissal is a civil claim for breach of contract.

Its central concern is contractual legality rather than the general fairness of the employer’s decision.

5. Purpose

The law of wrongful dismissal protects employees against termination that fails to comply with their contractual rights.

It also establishes the financial consequences of an employer’s breach.

6. Principal Legal Sources

The relevant sources include:

  • Common law principles of contract.
  • The express employment contract.
  • Implied contractual terms.
  • The Employment Rights Act 1996.
  • The Employment Tribunals Act 1996.
  • The Employment Tribunals Extension of Jurisdiction (England and Wales) Order 1994.
  • Relevant judicial decisions.

7. Employment Contract

An employment contract establishes the legal relationship between employer and employee.

It contains the obligations governing work, remuneration, and termination.

8. Express Terms

Express terms are provisions agreed by the parties.

They may be written, oral, or established through other legally recognised means.

9. Implied Terms

Implied terms are obligations incorporated into the employment contract by law, necessity, custom, or other recognised principles.

10. Statutory Terms

Legislation may establish minimum employment rights that affect the contractual relationship.

For example, statutory minimum notice requirements may apply.

11. Termination of Employment

Termination brings the employment relationship to an end.

It may occur through dismissal, resignation, expiry of a fixed term, or other legally recognised circumstances.

12. Dismissal

Dismissal generally refers to termination of employment by the employer.

Its legal meaning may vary according to the statutory or contractual context.

13. Lawful Dismissal

A dismissal may be contractually lawful where the employer complies with the applicable termination provisions or possesses a lawful basis for summary dismissal.

14. Wrongful Dismissal

A dismissal is wrongful where the employer breaches the employment contract in terminating the employment.

15. Fairness Versus Contractual Legality

A dismissal may be contractually lawful even though the employee considers it unreasonable.

Conversely, a dismissal may breach the contract even where the employer has a legitimate business reason for termination.

16. Wrongful Dismissal Versus Unfair Dismissal

Wrongful dismissal concerns breach of contract.

Unfair dismissal concerns statutory protection against dismissal that fails to satisfy the applicable fairness requirements.

17. Employment Rights Act 1996

The Employment Rights Act 1996 contains important provisions governing termination, notice, and unfair dismissal.

18. Section 86

Section 86 establishes statutory minimum notice periods for qualifying employment relationships.

19. Statutory Minimum Notice

An employer must ordinarily provide at least the statutory minimum notice unless a recognised exception applies.

20. Employer’s Minimum Notice Obligations

Under section 86, the employer’s minimum notice obligations generally depend upon the employee’s continuous service.

21. One Month to Less Than Two Years

An employee continuously employed for at least one month but less than two years is generally entitled to at least one week’s notice.

22. Two Years to Less Than Twelve Years

An employee with at least two years but less than twelve years of continuous service is generally entitled to one week’s notice for each completed year of service.

23. Twelve Years or More

An employee with twelve or more years of continuous service is generally entitled to at least twelve weeks’ notice.

24. Statutory Notice Table

Continuous employment

Employer’s minimum notice

Less than 1 month

No general statutory minimum under section 86

1 month to less than 2 years

1 week

2 completed years

2 weeks

5 completed years

5 weeks

10 completed years

10 weeks

12 years or more

12 weeks

These are statutory minimum periods. A longer contractual entitlement may apply.

25. Contractual Notice

The employment contract may specify the notice required to terminate employment.

The contractual period may exceed the statutory minimum.

26. Longer Contractual Notice

Where the contract provides a longer notice period, the employer must ordinarily comply with it.

27. Shorter Contractual Notice

A contractual term generally cannot deprive an employee of the applicable statutory minimum notice entitlement.

28. Example: Contractual Notice

An employee’s contract requires three months’ notice.

The employer dismisses the employee immediately without lawful justification or an effective payment-in-lieu provision.

The employee may have a wrongful dismissal claim.

29. Example: Statutory Notice

An employee has worked continuously for six years.

The contract specifies only two weeks’ notice.

The employer must ordinarily comply with the longer statutory minimum of six weeks.

30. Notice of Termination

Notice is a communication informing the other party that the employment contract will terminate.

Its validity depends upon the applicable contractual and legal requirements.

31. Clear Notice

Notice should clearly communicate the intention to terminate employment.

Ambiguous communications may create disputes.

32. Effective Date of Termination

The effective date of termination is important for determining employment rights and procedural deadlines.

Its meaning may differ between contractual and statutory contexts.

33. Gisda Cyf v Barratt

In Gisda Cyf v Barratt 2010 UKSC 41, the Supreme Court considered when dismissal takes effect for statutory unfair dismissal purposes.

34. Importance of Gisda Cyf

The decision illustrates that the timing of dismissal may depend upon the legal context and the communication of the decision.

35. Summary Dismissal

Summary dismissal means termination without notice.

It may be lawful where the employee has committed a sufficiently serious breach justifying immediate termination.

36. Gross Misconduct

Gross misconduct refers to conduct sufficiently serious to justify summary dismissal under the applicable contractual and common law principles.

37. Examples of Potential Gross Misconduct

Depending upon the circumstances, examples may include:

  • Serious dishonesty.
  • Theft.
  • Serious violence.
  • Deliberate serious breaches of safety requirements.
  • Serious insubordination.
  • Grave breaches of trust.

38. Gross Misconduct Is Contextual

Not every allegation labelled gross misconduct justifies summary dismissal.

The legal assessment depends upon the nature and seriousness of the conduct.

39. Repudiatory Breach

A repudiatory breach is a breach sufficiently serious to entitle the innocent party to treat the contract as terminated.

40. Employee’s Repudiatory Breach

An employee’s repudiatory breach may justify termination without notice.

41. Employer’s Burden

Where an employer relies upon serious misconduct to justify summary dismissal, the employer may need to establish the conduct relied upon.

42. Actual Misconduct

In a wrongful dismissal claim, the court or tribunal may consider whether the employee actually committed conduct sufficient to justify summary dismissal.

This differs from the statutory unfair dismissal inquiry into the employer’s decision-making.

43. Wrongful Summary Dismissal

A summary dismissal may be wrongful where the employee’s conduct did not justify termination without notice.

44. Example: Minor Misconduct

An employee makes a minor administrative mistake.

The employer dismisses the employee immediately without notice.

Unless the circumstances establish a sufficient contractual justification, the dismissal may be wrongful.

45. Example: Serious Theft

An employee deliberately steals substantial property from the employer.

The conduct may justify summary dismissal without notice.

46. Disciplinary Procedure

An employer may operate a disciplinary procedure before dismissal.

Its contractual status is important.

47. Contractual Disciplinary Procedure

A disciplinary procedure may form part of the employment contract.

Failure to follow an enforceable contractual procedure may constitute a breach.

48. Non-Contractual Disciplinary Procedure

A disciplinary policy may be expressly or otherwise legally non-contractual.

Breach of such a policy does not necessarily establish wrongful dismissal.

49. Importance of Incorporation

The question is whether the relevant procedure is contractually binding.

A policy’s mere existence does not automatically make every provision contractual.

50. Express Incorporation

A contract may expressly incorporate a disciplinary procedure.

The wording determines the extent of incorporation.

51. Implied Incorporation

In appropriate circumstances, contractual obligations may arise through implication.

The applicable legal tests must be satisfied.

52. Procedural Breach

Failure to comply with a contractual dismissal procedure may support a wrongful dismissal claim.

53. Procedural Damages

Damages for breach of a contractual procedure depend upon the loss legally caused by the breach.

They are not automatically equivalent to compensation for unfair dismissal.

54. Gunton v Richmond-upon-Thames LBC

In Gunton v Richmond-upon-Thames London Borough Council 1980 ICR 755, the Court of Appeal considered damages arising from breach of contractual dismissal procedures.

55. Importance of Gunton

The case is associated with the assessment of damages where contractual dismissal procedures have not been followed.

56. Fixed-Term Contracts

A fixed-term contract provides for employment over a specified period.

Its termination provisions must be examined carefully.

57. Early Termination

Premature termination of a fixed-term contract may constitute wrongful dismissal where no valid early termination right exists.

58. Break Clause

A break clause permits early termination in accordance with specified conditions.

59. Example: Fixed-Term Employment

An employee has a two-year fixed-term contract without a relevant early termination provision.

The employer terminates after six months without lawful justification.

The employee may claim damages for breach, subject to mitigation and other applicable principles.

60. Indefinite Employment

An indefinite employment contract generally continues until terminated in accordance with its terms and applicable law.

61. Implied Reasonable Notice

Where a contract does not specify a valid notice period, the common law may imply an obligation to provide reasonable notice, subject to statutory requirements.

62. Reasonable Notice

Reasonable notice depends upon the contractual context and relevant circumstances.

63. Relevant Factors

Factors potentially relevant to reasonable notice include:

  • Seniority.
  • Length of service.
  • Nature of employment.
  • Industry practice.
  • Remuneration.
  • Contractual circumstances.

64. Senior Employees

Senior employees may have express or implied notice entitlements reflecting their position.

The legal outcome depends upon the contract and circumstances.

65. Junior Employees

Junior employees are also protected by contractual and statutory notice requirements.

66. Probationary Employees

Employees serving probation may have different contractual notice periods.

Statutory minimum requirements remain relevant.

67. Probation Clause

A probation clause may provide for shorter notice during a specified probationary period.

The clause must be interpreted according to ordinary contractual principles.

68. Payment in Lieu of Notice

A payment in lieu of notice, commonly called PILON, is a payment made instead of requiring the employee to work through the notice period.

69. Contractual PILON Clause

A contract may expressly permit termination by making a payment in lieu of notice.

70. Effect of a Valid PILON Clause

Where an employer properly exercises a valid contractual PILON clause, immediate termination may be contractually lawful.

71. Absence of PILON Clause

Where no contractual PILON right exists, an employer’s immediate termination and payment of money may still constitute a breach of contract.

The payment may nevertheless reduce or satisfy the employee’s recoverable financial loss.

72. PILON Versus Damages

A contractual PILON is a payment made under the contract.

Damages for wrongful dismissal compensate for breach of contract.

73. Importance of Distinction

The distinction may affect contractual entitlements, restrictive covenants, tax treatment, and other legal consequences.

74. Societe Generale v Geys

In Société Générale, London Branch v Geys 2012 UKSC 63, the Supreme Court considered the contractual effect of a purported termination and payment in lieu of notice.

75. Importance of Geys

The decision illustrates that the timing and legal effect of termination may depend upon the contract and the employer’s compliance with its terms.

76. Garden Leave

Garden leave involves an employee remaining employed during notice while being instructed not to perform ordinary duties.

77. Garden Leave Clause

A contractual garden leave provision may authorise the employer to exclude the employee from active duties during the notice period.

78. Garden Leave Versus PILON

Garden leave ordinarily preserves the employment relationship during notice.

PILON generally involves termination without requiring the employee to work through the notice period.

79. Salary During Garden Leave

An employee on garden leave ordinarily remains entitled to contractual remuneration, subject to the terms of employment.

80. Wrongful Exclusion from Work

An employee may have contractual rights concerning the opportunity to work.

Unlawful exclusion may raise separate contractual issues.

81. William Hill Organisation Ltd v Tucker

In William Hill Organisation Ltd v Tucker 1999 ICR 291, the Court of Appeal considered an employee’s right to work in the context of contractual obligations.

82. Importance of Tucker

The case illustrates that an employer’s ability to prevent an employee from working may depend upon the circumstances and contractual rights.

83. Constructive Dismissal

Constructive dismissal occurs where an employee resigns in response to an employer’s repudiatory breach of contract.

84. Constructive Wrongful Dismissal

An employee may have a contractual claim where resignation results from an employer’s repudiatory breach.

The legal analysis depends upon the breach and the employee’s response.

85. Employer’s Repudiatory Breach

Examples may include:

  • Serious non-payment of wages.
  • Unilateral substantial reduction of contractual pay.
  • Serious breach of mutual trust and confidence.
  • Other fundamental contractual breaches.

86. Acceptance of Repudiation

An employee relying upon constructive dismissal must ordinarily accept the employer’s repudiatory breach by terminating the contract.

87. Affirmation

An employee who unequivocally affirms the contract after becoming aware of the breach may lose the right to terminate in reliance upon that breach.

88. Western Excavating v Sharp

In Western Excavating (ECC) Ltd v Sharp 1978 QB 761, the Court of Appeal explained important principles concerning constructive dismissal.

89. Importance of Western Excavating

The case established that constructive dismissal is founded upon contractual principles of repudiatory breach.

90. Implied Term of Mutual Trust and Confidence

Employment contracts generally contain an implied obligation that neither party will, without reasonable and proper cause, conduct itself in a manner calculated or likely seriously to damage mutual trust and confidence.

91. Malik v BCCI

In Malik v Bank of Credit and Commerce International SA 1997 UKHL 23, the House of Lords considered the implied term of mutual trust and confidence.

92. Importance of Malik

The decision is important in understanding contractual obligations arising from the employment relationship.

93. Breach of Trust and Confidence

Serious employer misconduct may breach the implied term.

The consequences depend upon the nature and timing of the breach.

94. Bullying and Harassment

Workplace bullying or harassment may, in appropriate circumstances, constitute a breach of contract or give rise to separate statutory or tortious claims.

95. Unilateral Reduction of Salary

An employer’s unilateral reduction of contractual salary may constitute a serious breach of contract.

96. Unilateral Demotion

An unjustified demotion may breach express or implied contractual terms.

97. Unilateral Change of Duties

A substantial unilateral change in duties may constitute a contractual breach, depending upon the employment contract.

98. Constructive Dismissal Versus Express Dismissal

Express dismissal occurs where the employer terminates employment.

Constructive dismissal involves the employee resigning in response to the employer’s repudiatory breach.

99. Wrongful Dismissal Damages

The principal remedy for wrongful dismissal is damages for breach of contract.

100. Compensatory Principle

Damages generally seek to place the employee in the financial position they would have occupied had the employer complied with the contract.

101. Notice Period Damages

Damages commonly reflect the remuneration and benefits the employee would have received during the contractual notice period.

102. Salary Loss

Recoverable loss may include salary that would have been payable during the relevant period.

103. Contractual Benefits

Damages may include the value of contractual benefits lost because of the wrongful termination.

104. Pension Benefits

Loss of qualifying pension contributions or benefits may form part of recoverable contractual loss.

105. Health Insurance

The value of contractual medical insurance or similar benefits may be relevant.

106. Company Car

Where use of a company car is a contractual benefit, its loss may be relevant to damages.

107. Bonus Payments

A bonus may be recoverable where the employee establishes the relevant contractual entitlement and loss.

108. Discretionary Bonuses

Discretionary bonus arrangements require careful contractual analysis.

An employer’s discretion may be subject to legal limits.

109. Commissions

Lost contractual commission may be recoverable where the relevant requirements are satisfied.

110. Holiday Pay

Accrued holiday entitlements may be relevant to termination payments and associated claims.

111. Employment Rights Act 1996 Section 13

Section 13 provides protection against unauthorised deductions from wages.

Such claims are distinct from, though they may overlap with, wrongful dismissal claims.

112. Working Time Regulations 1998

The Working Time Regulations 1998 govern important rights concerning paid annual leave.

113. Accrued Holiday

An employee may be entitled to payment for accrued but untaken statutory leave upon termination, subject to the applicable rules.

114. Contractual Holiday

Additional contractual holiday entitlements depend upon the terms of the employment contract.

115. Loss of Future Earnings

Damages for wrongful dismissal are not ordinarily an open-ended award for all future earnings.

They are generally limited by the contractual rights that would have existed had lawful termination occurred.

116. Minimum Lawful Termination Period

A key principle is that damages are generally assessed by reference to the period and terms upon which the employer could lawfully have terminated the employment.

117. Example: Three-Month Notice

An employee earns £4,000 per month and is entitled to three months’ notice.

The employer dismisses the employee immediately without lawful justification.

Subject to mitigation and other adjustments, the employee’s basic salary loss may be £12,000.

118. Example: New Employment

The employee obtains equivalent employment one month after wrongful dismissal.

Earnings from the new employment may reduce recoverable loss.

119. Mitigation of Loss

An employee claiming damages must take reasonable steps to mitigate loss.

120. Meaning of Mitigation

Mitigation concerns reasonable efforts to avoid or reduce loss following breach of contract.

121. Seeking Alternative Employment

Reasonable efforts to obtain suitable alternative employment may be relevant to mitigation.

122. Suitable Employment

The employee is not necessarily required to accept any available job regardless of its terms or suitability.

123. Reasonableness

The employee’s conduct is assessed according to the applicable legal standard of reasonableness.

124. Burden Concerning Mitigation

The employer generally bears the burden of establishing a failure to mitigate where relying upon that argument.

125. British Westinghouse v Underground Electric Railways

In British Westinghouse Electric and Manufacturing Co Ltd v Underground Electric Railways Co of London Ltd 1912 AC 673, the House of Lords considered general principles of mitigation of damages.

126. Importance of Mitigation

Mitigation prevents a claimant from recovering avoidable losses attributable to an unreasonable failure to reduce damage.

127. Remoteness of Damage

Contractual damages are subject to rules concerning remoteness.

Not every consequence of wrongful dismissal is recoverable.

128. Hadley v Baxendale

In Hadley v Baxendale (1854) 9 Exch 341, the court established influential principles governing remoteness of contractual damages.

129. Emotional Distress

Damages for distress, injured feelings, or humiliation are not ordinarily recoverable merely because dismissal breached the employment contract.

130. Addis v Gramophone Co Ltd

In Addis v Gramophone Co Ltd 1909 AC 488, the House of Lords considered damages for wrongful dismissal.

131. Principle from Addis

The decision is associated with the general restriction against awarding damages for injured feelings or the manner of dismissal in an ordinary wrongful dismissal claim.

132. Limits of Addis

The principle must be considered alongside subsequent authorities concerning distinct contractual breaches and recognised heads of loss.

133. Reputation Damage

Loss of reputation arising from dismissal does not automatically create a recoverable wrongful dismissal claim.

134. Stigma Damages

In particular circumstances, a separate breach of contractual duty may support damages for loss caused by stigma.

135. Malik v BCCI and Stigma

In Malik v BCCI, the House of Lords recognised the possibility of damages arising from breach of the implied term of trust and confidence where the necessary loss was established.

136. Johnson v Unisys

In Johnson v Unisys Ltd 2001 UKHL 13, the House of Lords considered claims for damages arising from the manner of dismissal.

137. Johnson Exclusion Area

The Johnson exclusion area refers to the principle restricting common law damages claims that would effectively circumvent the statutory unfair dismissal regime by seeking compensation for the manner of dismissal.

138. Importance of Johnson

The decision establishes an important boundary between contractual remedies and statutory unfair dismissal protection.

139. Eastwood v Magnox Electric

In Eastwood v Magnox Electric plc 2004 UKHL 35, the House of Lords considered the distinction between losses arising before dismissal and losses associated with dismissal itself.

140. Importance of Eastwood

The decision recognised that certain causes of action accruing independently before dismissal may fall outside the restriction identified in Johnson.

141. Pre-Dismissal Breach

An employer may commit a contractual breach before dismissal.

A resulting claim may require separate analysis from the dismissal itself.

142. Post-Dismissal Loss

The fact that loss continues after dismissal does not necessarily mean that it arose from the dismissal.

The underlying cause of action must be identified.

143. Edwards v Chesterfield Royal Hospital

In Edwards v Chesterfield Royal Hospital NHS Foundation Trust 2011 UKSC 58, the Supreme Court considered contractual claims relating to disciplinary procedures and dismissal.

144. Importance of Edwards

The case illustrates the limitations upon recovering damages for the consequences of dismissal through contractual claims concerning disciplinary procedures.

145. Procedural Wrongful Dismissal

An employer’s failure to comply with a contractual disciplinary procedure may constitute breach of contract.

However, recoverable damages are subject to the relevant authorities and principles.

146. Loss of Chance

In appropriate contractual contexts, damages may involve assessment of a lost chance.

The availability of such damages in dismissal-related claims must be considered alongside the Johnson and Edwards principles.

147. Nominal Damages

Nominal damages may be awarded where breach of contract is established but substantial recoverable loss is not proved.

148. Declaratory Relief

A court may grant declaratory relief concerning contractual rights in appropriate circumstances.

149. Injunction

An injunction may sometimes be sought to prevent a threatened contractual breach.

Its availability in employment disputes is limited by relevant legal principles.

150. Specific Performance

Courts are generally reluctant to compel the continuation of personal employment relationships through specific performance.

151. Employment Relationship and Trust

The personal nature of employment and the importance of mutual confidence affect the availability of equitable remedies.

152. Hill v C A Parsons & Co Ltd

In Hill v C A Parsons & Co Ltd 1972 Ch 305, the Court of Appeal considered injunctive relief in an employment termination dispute.

153. Importance of Hill

The decision illustrates that injunctive relief may be available in exceptional employment circumstances.

154. Chhabra v West London Mental Health NHS Trust

In Chhabra v West London Mental Health NHS Trust 2013 UKSC 80, the Supreme Court considered contractual disciplinary procedures and injunctive relief.

155. Importance of Chhabra

The case demonstrates that contractual disciplinary rights may sometimes be protected before dismissal occurs.

156. Wrongful Dismissal in the Civil Courts

Wrongful dismissal may be pursued as a breach of contract claim in the ordinary civil courts.

157. County Court

The County Court may hear contractual employment claims within its jurisdiction.

158. High Court

The High Court may hear qualifying contractual claims, including substantial wrongful dismissal disputes.

159. Employment Tribunal

Employment tribunals have limited jurisdiction over certain breach of contract claims arising from employment termination.

160. Employment Tribunals Extension of Jurisdiction Order 1994

The Employment Tribunals Extension of Jurisdiction (England and Wales) Order 1994 confers specified contractual jurisdiction upon employment tribunals.

161. Tribunal Contractual Jurisdiction

The employment tribunal may determine qualifying breach of contract claims arising or outstanding on termination, subject to statutory restrictions.

162. £25,000 Limit

The employment tribunal’s award for qualifying breach of contract claims under the relevant jurisdiction is generally subject to a £25,000 limit.

This is distinct from the statutory unfair dismissal compensation regime.

163. Importance of the Limit

A claimant with a substantial contractual claim may need to consider proceedings in the civil courts.

164. Tribunal Time Limits

A qualifying employment tribunal breach of contract claim is generally subject to a short limitation period, commonly three months from termination, subject to applicable rules and extensions.

165. Early Conciliation

Acas early conciliation requirements may apply before commencing an employment tribunal claim.

166. Acas

Acas is the Advisory, Conciliation and Arbitration Service.

It provides services concerning employment disputes and workplace relations.

167. Acas Early Conciliation

Early conciliation provides an opportunity to resolve qualifying employment disputes before tribunal proceedings.

168. Effect on Time Limits

Acas early conciliation may affect the calculation of tribunal limitation periods.

The statutory rules must be applied carefully.

169. Civil Court Limitation

Ordinary breach of contract claims in England and Wales are generally subject to the six-year limitation period under the Limitation Act 1980, subject to applicable exceptions.

170. Limitation Act 1980 Section 5

Section 5 provides a six-year limitation period for actions founded on simple contract.

171. Tribunal Versus Civil Court

The choice of forum may depend upon:

  • Claim value.
  • Limitation period.
  • Jurisdictional restrictions.
  • Procedural considerations.
  • Available remedies.
  • Litigation costs.

172. Costs in Employment Tribunals

Employment tribunals generally operate under a different costs regime from ordinary civil litigation.

Costs orders may be made in specified circumstances.

173. Costs in Civil Courts

Civil court proceedings are subject to the applicable CPR costs rules.

The financial risks may differ from tribunal litigation.

174. Wrongful Dismissal and Unfair Dismissal Claims Together

An employee may pursue both claims where the legal requirements are satisfied.

175. Avoiding Double Recovery

An employee cannot ordinarily recover compensation twice for the same loss.

176. Unfair Dismissal

Unfair dismissal is a statutory claim concerned with whether dismissal complies with the applicable statutory requirements.

177. Employment Rights Act 1996 Section 94

Section 94 establishes the statutory right not to be unfairly dismissed, subject to the applicable provisions.

178. Potentially Fair Reasons

The statutory unfair dismissal framework recognises potentially fair reasons including:

  • Capability or qualifications.
  • Conduct.
  • Redundancy.
  • Contravention of a statutory duty or restriction.
  • Some other substantial reason.

179. Section 98

Section 98 of the Employment Rights Act 1996 governs important aspects of the reasons for dismissal and the statutory fairness assessment.

180. Reasonableness of Dismissal

Unfair dismissal law may require examination of whether the employer acted reasonably in treating the relevant reason as sufficient for dismissal.

181. British Home Stores v Burchell

In British Home Stores Ltd v Burchell 1978 IRLR 379, the Employment Appeal Tribunal addressed principles concerning misconduct dismissals.

182. Burchell Test

The Burchell approach is associated with the employer’s belief in misconduct, the grounds for that belief, and the investigation undertaken.

183. Difference from Wrongful Dismissal

For wrongful dismissal, the issue may be whether the employee actually committed conduct justifying summary dismissal.

For unfair dismissal, the inquiry concerns statutory fairness, including the employer’s reasonable decision-making.

184. Example: Fair but Wrongful

An employer has a legitimate redundancy reason but fails to provide the contractual notice.

The dismissal may be fair under the statutory regime yet wrongful in contract.

185. Example: Unfair but Not Wrongful

An employer gives full contractual notice but dismisses an employee without satisfying statutory fairness requirements.

The dismissal may be unfair but not wrongful.

186. Example: Both Wrongful and Unfair

An employer dismisses an employee immediately for a minor mistake, without notice or a fair procedure.

Both claims may arise if their respective requirements are satisfied.

187. Qualifying Service

Statutory unfair dismissal rights may depend upon qualifying service, subject to exceptions and legislative changes.

Wrongful dismissal generally does not require the same qualifying service.

188. Importance of Qualifying Service

An employee may have a wrongful dismissal claim even where the employee does not qualify for an ordinary statutory unfair dismissal claim.

189. Automatically Unfair Dismissal

Certain dismissals are treated as automatically unfair under statutory provisions.

The relevant requirements depend upon the protected reason.

190. Whistleblowing

Dismissal because of protected whistleblowing may give rise to statutory claims.

191. Employment Rights Act 1996 Section 103A

Section 103A concerns dismissal for making a protected disclosure.

192. Discrimination

A dismissal may also involve unlawful discrimination under the Equality Act 2010.

193. Equality Act 2010

The Equality Act 2010 prohibits specified forms of discrimination in employment.

194. Discriminatory Dismissal

A dismissal because of a protected characteristic may give rise to a discrimination claim where the statutory requirements are satisfied.

195. Discrimination Compensation

Compensation for unlawful discrimination may include heads of loss not ordinarily recoverable in a basic wrongful dismissal claim, including injury to feelings.

196. Injury to Feelings

Injury-to-feelings awards are available in qualifying discrimination claims.

They should not be confused with ordinary contractual damages for wrongful dismissal.

197. Redundancy

Redundancy concerns circumstances recognised by employment legislation involving diminished or ceased requirements for employees to perform particular work.

198. Redundancy and Notice

Even where redundancy is genuine, the employer must ordinarily comply with applicable notice obligations.

199. Statutory Redundancy Payment

A qualifying employee may be entitled to a statutory redundancy payment.

This is distinct from wrongful dismissal damages.

200. Redundancy Consultation

An employer may have individual or collective consultation obligations in qualifying redundancy circumstances.

Breach of such obligations may create separate legal consequences.

201. Settlement Agreements

A settlement agreement may resolve wrongful dismissal and other employment claims.

202. Valid Settlement Agreement

A statutory settlement agreement must satisfy the applicable legal requirements to waive specified statutory employment claims.

203. Contractual Settlement

The parties may settle contractual disputes through an enforceable agreement.

204. Acas COT3 Agreement

A COT3 agreement is a settlement recorded through Acas conciliation.

It may resolve qualifying employment disputes.

205. Release of Claims

A settlement may include provisions releasing specified claims.

Its legal effect depends upon the wording and applicable law.

206. Confidentiality Clauses

Settlement agreements may contain confidentiality obligations.

Their validity and enforceability are subject to legal restrictions.

207. Restrictive Covenants

Employment contracts may contain post-termination restrictions.

These may concern competition, solicitation, or confidential information.

208. Wrongful Dismissal and Restrictive Covenants

An employer’s repudiatory breach may affect its ability to enforce certain contractual post-termination restrictions.

209. General Billposting v Atkinson

In General Billposting Co Ltd v Atkinson 1909 AC 118, the House of Lords considered the effect of wrongful dismissal on restrictive contractual obligations.

210. Importance of General Billposting

The case is important in understanding how an employer’s repudiatory breach may affect post-termination restraints.

211. Restrictive Covenant Enforceability

Post-termination restrictions are generally enforceable only where they protect legitimate interests and satisfy the applicable reasonableness requirements.

212. Confidentiality Obligations

Certain confidentiality obligations may continue after employment ends.

Their enforceability depends upon the applicable contractual and legal principles.

213. Trade Secrets

Trade secrets may receive legal protection independently of some ordinary contractual restrictions.

214. Wrongful Dismissal and References

An employer’s provision of an employment reference may create separate legal issues.

215. Spring v Guardian Assurance

In Spring v Guardian Assurance plc 1994 UKHL 7, the House of Lords considered duties concerning employment references.

216. Importance of Spring

The decision illustrates that employers may owe duties when providing references.

Such claims are distinct from the basic wrongful dismissal cause of action.

217. Post-Termination Obligations

Employment contracts may impose obligations continuing after termination.

Their validity depends upon contractual and legal principles.

218. Repudiation and Acceptance

An employer’s repudiatory breach may give the employee the right to accept the breach and treat the contract as terminated.

219. Contractual Election

The innocent party’s response to repudiation may affect the legal status of the contract.

220. Affirmation of Contract

Affirmation occurs where the innocent party elects to continue the contract despite the repudiatory breach.

221. Importance of Election

The distinction between accepting repudiation and affirming the contract may affect remedies and ongoing obligations.

222. Employment Contract as Personal Service Contract

Employment contracts involve personal service obligations.

This affects both termination principles and equitable remedies.

223. Employer’s Right to Terminate

An employer may possess a contractual right to terminate employment by giving proper notice.

The exercise of that right may still be subject to statutory restrictions.

224. Contractual Freedom

Contract law generally recognises parties’ freedom to agree employment terms, subject to mandatory statutory protections and other legal limits.

225. Statutory Minimum Rights

Statutory rights may override contractual provisions that purport to provide less protection than the law requires.

226. Unlawful Contractual Waiver

A contractual clause cannot automatically exclude statutory employment protections.

The applicable legislation determines when rights may be waived or settled.

227. Wrongful Dismissal and Employer Insolvency

Employer insolvency may affect recovery of unpaid wages, notice-related sums, and other employment debts.

228. Insolvency Act 1986

The Insolvency Act 1986 governs important aspects of corporate insolvency.

229. National Insurance Fund

In qualifying circumstances, employees may claim certain statutory payments from the National Insurance Fund when an employer is insolvent.

230. Statutory Notice Pay

Qualifying employees may be entitled to statutory notice-related payments through the applicable insolvency arrangements.

231. Limits on Insolvency Payments

Payments from statutory schemes are subject to eligibility requirements and prescribed limits.

232. Priority of Employment Debts

Certain employment debts may receive preferential treatment in insolvency.

Other claims may rank as unsecured debts.

233. Importance of Insolvency

A successful wrongful dismissal claim does not guarantee full recovery where the employer lacks sufficient assets.

234. Practical Example: No Notice

An employee has a contractual entitlement to eight weeks’ notice.

The employer dismisses the employee immediately without lawful justification.

The employee may claim damages for the lost contractual notice entitlement.

235. Practical Example: Gross Misconduct Allegation

An employer dismisses an employee without notice for alleged theft.

The allegation is not established and no other sufficient justification exists.

The dismissal may be wrongful.

236. Practical Example: Genuine Gross Misconduct

An employee commits serious dishonesty amounting to a repudiatory breach.

The employer may be entitled to dismiss summarily without notice.

237. Practical Example: Fixed-Term Contract

An employee has eighteen months remaining under a fixed-term contract with no applicable early termination right.

The employer terminates immediately.

The employee may have a substantial contractual claim, subject to mitigation and the applicable measure of damages.

238. Practical Example: Contractual Procedure

An employer is contractually required to follow a specified disciplinary procedure.

The employer dismisses the employee without complying.

The breach may support a contractual claim, although damages depend upon the applicable legal principles.

239. Practical Example: PILON

An employment contract permits immediate termination upon payment of three months’ salary in lieu of notice.

The employer properly exercises the clause.

The termination may be contractually lawful.

240. Practical Example: No PILON Clause

An employer terminates immediately without a contractual PILON right but pays the employee an amount equal to notice salary.

The termination may technically breach the contract, although the payment may eliminate or reduce the recoverable financial loss.

241. Practical Example: Garden Leave

An employer gives the required contractual notice and places the employee on garden leave under a valid clause.

The employment continues until the notice period expires.

242. Practical Example: Constructive Dismissal

An employer seriously and unjustifiably reduces an employee’s contractual salary.

The employee resigns in response to the repudiatory breach.

A contractual claim may arise.

243. Practical Example: New Employment

An employee wrongfully dismissed with three months’ notice entitlement obtains equivalent employment after one month.

The employee’s earnings from the new employment may reduce recoverable damages.

244. Practical Example: Unfair but Contractually Lawful

An employer dismisses an eligible employee on full contractual notice but without a fair reason.

The employee may have an unfair dismissal claim without a wrongful dismissal claim.

245. Practical Example: Fair but Contractually Wrongful

An employer lawfully selects an employee for redundancy but fails to give the required notice.

The employee may have a wrongful dismissal claim.

246. Practical Example: Senior Executive

A senior executive has a twelve-month contractual notice entitlement.

The employer terminates immediately without lawful justification.

The contractual claim may be substantial, subject to mitigation and other legal limitations.

247. Practical Example: Probation

An employee’s contract provides one week’s notice during probation.

The employer dismisses without notice and without sufficient justification.

The employee may have a claim for the applicable notice entitlement.

248. Practical Example: Discrimination

An employee is dismissed in breach of contract because of a protected characteristic.

The employee may have both contractual and statutory discrimination claims.

249. Practical Example: Employer Insolvency

An insolvent company dismisses employees without notice.

The employees may have contractual claims and may qualify for statutory insolvency payments.

250. Common Misunderstanding: Wrongful Dismissal Means Unfair Dismissal

The two claims are legally distinct.

Wrongful dismissal concerns contract; unfair dismissal concerns statutory fairness.

251. Common Misunderstanding: Every Harsh Dismissal Is Wrongful

A harsh dismissal is not necessarily wrongful if the employer complies with contractual termination obligations.

252. Common Misunderstanding: Wrongful Dismissal Requires Two Years’ Service

Wrongful dismissal generally does not depend upon the ordinary qualifying service requirements applicable to statutory unfair dismissal claims.

253. Common Misunderstanding: Gross Misconduct Always Justifies Summary Dismissal

The conduct must be sufficiently serious under the applicable legal principles.

An employer’s label is not conclusive.

254. Common Misunderstanding: An Employer’s Belief Is Always Sufficient

A reasonable belief may be relevant to unfair dismissal.

Wrongful dismissal may require consideration of whether sufficient misconduct actually occurred.

255. Common Misunderstanding: All Disciplinary Policies Are Contractual

A disciplinary policy is not necessarily incorporated into the employment contract.

256. Common Misunderstanding: Every Procedural Breach Produces Large Damages

Damages depend upon the legally recoverable loss and applicable restrictions.

257. Common Misunderstanding: Wrongful Dismissal Always Produces Compensation for Distress

Ordinary wrongful dismissal damages generally do not include compensation for injured feelings.

258. Common Misunderstanding: Damages Continue Until Retirement

Wrongful dismissal damages are generally assessed according to contractual termination rights and applicable principles of loss.

259. Common Misunderstanding: An Employee Need Not Mitigate

Employees claiming contractual damages must take reasonable steps to mitigate loss.

260. Common Misunderstanding: PILON Always Makes Dismissal Lawful

A payment in lieu of notice does not necessarily make termination contractually lawful where the employer lacks an effective contractual right to terminate in that manner.

261. Common Misunderstanding: Wrongful Dismissal Claims Can Only Be Brought in Tribunals

Qualifying claims may be brought in employment tribunals or civil courts, subject to jurisdictional requirements.

262. Common Misunderstanding: Tribunal Claims Have No Monetary Limit

Employment tribunal breach of contract jurisdiction is subject to a statutory monetary limit.

263. Common Misunderstanding: An Employer Can Ignore Statutory Notice

Statutory minimum notice rights generally apply notwithstanding a shorter contractual provision.

264. Common Misunderstanding: Every Resignation Is Voluntary

A resignation may constitute constructive dismissal where it results from an employer’s repudiatory breach.

265. Common Misunderstanding: Wrongful Dismissal Automatically Invalidates Termination

Wrongful dismissal ordinarily gives rise to contractual remedies.

It does not necessarily mean that the employment relationship continues indefinitely.

266. Relationship with Breach of Contract

Wrongful dismissal is a specific form of breach of employment contract.

267. Relationship with Unfair Dismissal

Wrongful dismissal and unfair dismissal may arise from the same termination but involve different legal tests.

268. Relationship with Constructive Dismissal

Constructive dismissal is based upon an employer’s repudiatory breach accepted by the employee through resignation.

269. Relationship with Redundancy

A redundancy dismissal may be wrongful if the employer fails to comply with contractual termination obligations.

270. Relationship with Discrimination

A dismissal may breach both contractual obligations and statutory discrimination protections.

271. Relationship with Notice

Notice obligations are central to many wrongful dismissal claims.

272. Relationship with Gross Misconduct

Sufficiently serious misconduct may justify termination without notice.

273. Relationship with Damages

Damages are the principal remedy for wrongful dismissal.

274. Relationship with Mitigation

Mitigation may reduce the amount recoverable.

275. Relationship with Restrictive Covenants

An employer’s repudiatory breach may affect the enforceability of certain post-termination contractual restrictions.

276. Relationship with Insolvency

Employer insolvency may affect recovery of contractual termination payments.

277. Comparative Perspective: Malaysia

Malaysian employment law also recognises disputes concerning dismissal in breach of contractual obligations.

However, Malaysian statutory employment protections and industrial relations procedures differ from those in England and Wales.

278. Employment Act 1955

The Employment Act 1955 contains important statutory provisions concerning employment conditions and termination in Peninsular Malaysia and the Federal Territory of Labuan, subject to its scope and applicable amendments.

279. Malaysian Notice Requirements

Section 12 of the Employment Act 1955 governs notice of termination for employment contracts within its scope.

The statutory requirements depend upon the circumstances and contractual provisions.

280. Malaysian Statutory Notice Periods

Where the contract does not specify the required notice period, section 12 provides statutory notice periods generally based upon length of service:

  • Four weeks for service of less than two years.
  • Six weeks for service of two years or more but less than five years.
  • Eight weeks for service of five years or more.

The statutory wording and applicable circumstances must be considered.

281. Malaysian Payment in Lieu of Notice

Section 13 of the Employment Act 1955 addresses termination without notice by payment of an indemnity in lieu of notice, subject to its terms.

282. Malaysian Summary Dismissal

Section 14 of the Employment Act 1955 addresses disciplinary action for misconduct, including dismissal in qualifying circumstances.

283. Industrial Relations Act 1967

The Industrial Relations Act 1967 provides an important statutory framework concerning dismissal without just cause or excuse.

284. Section 20 of the Industrial Relations Act

Section 20 provides a mechanism through which an employee may make representations concerning dismissal without just cause or excuse.

285. Dismissal Without Just Cause or Excuse

This Malaysian industrial relations concept must be distinguished from a purely contractual wrongful dismissal claim.

286. Malaysian Industrial Court

The Industrial Court determines qualifying industrial relations disputes under the applicable statutory framework.

287. Malaysian Remedies

Remedies in dismissal disputes may include reinstatement or monetary relief, depending upon the cause of action, forum, and governing law.

288. Comparative Importance

English wrongful dismissal law is principally contractual.

Malaysian dismissal law also requires careful consideration of statutory employment and industrial relations protections.

289. Importance for Employees

Employees should consider:

  • The employment contract.
  • The contractual notice period.
  • Statutory minimum notice.
  • The reason for dismissal.
  • Whether summary dismissal was justified.
  • Whether a disciplinary procedure was contractual.
  • Lost salary and benefits.
  • Mitigation.
  • Limitation periods.
  • The appropriate forum.

290. Importance for Employers

Employers should consider:

  • Whether the contract permits termination.
  • Whether proper notice has been given.
  • Whether a valid PILON clause exists.
  • Whether alleged misconduct justifies summary dismissal.
  • Whether contractual procedures must be followed.
  • Whether statutory unfair dismissal rights apply.
  • Whether discrimination or whistleblowing issues arise.
  • The financial consequences of breach.

291. Importance for Human Resources Professionals

Human resources professionals should distinguish contractual termination requirements from statutory fairness obligations.

Compliance with one does not necessarily establish compliance with the other.

292. Importance for Legal Practitioners

Legal practitioners must analyse the contractual basis of termination, the relevant statutory protections, the available forum, limitation periods, and the appropriate measure of damages.

293. Practical Legal Checklist

When analysing a wrongful dismissal claim:

  • Identify the jurisdiction.
  • Confirm the existence of an employment contract.
  • Examine express termination provisions.
  • Identify applicable implied terms.
  • Determine the statutory minimum notice.
  • Establish how employment ended.
  • Identify the effective date of termination.
  • Determine whether notice was given.
  • Examine any PILON clause.
  • Consider whether summary dismissal was justified.
  • Identify any contractual disciplinary procedure.
  • Consider whether the employer committed a repudiatory breach.
  • Calculate lost salary and contractual benefits.
  • Examine mitigation and replacement earnings.
  • Consider remoteness and other limitations on damages.
  • Identify any separate unfair dismissal or discrimination claim.
  • Check limitation periods and Acas requirements.
  • Determine whether the employment tribunal or civil court is appropriate.
  • Consider the monetary jurisdictional limit.
  • Avoid double recovery.

294. Legal Importance

Wrongful dismissal is the termination of employment in breach of an enforceable contractual obligation.

It is principally a breach of contract claim, commonly arising where an employer fails to provide the required notice or dismisses an employee summarily without sufficient justification.

In England and Wales, the relevant legal framework includes common law contract principles, the employment contract, and the Employment Rights Act 1996, particularly section 86 concerning statutory minimum notice.

Wrongful dismissal is distinct from unfair dismissal, which concerns statutory fairness under the Employment Rights Act 1996.

The principal remedy is damages representing the employee’s legally recoverable contractual loss, commonly salary and benefits for the period of notice that should have been provided.

Damages are subject to mitigation, remoteness, and the applicable limits on contractual recovery.

The decisions in Addis v Gramophone, Johnson v Unisys, Eastwood v Magnox Electric, and Edwards v Chesterfield Royal Hospital are particularly important in understanding the limits of dismissal-related contractual damages.

Wrongful dismissal claims may be brought in the civil courts or, where the statutory requirements are satisfied, in employment tribunals exercising their limited breach of contract jurisdiction.

Ultimately, the legal importance of wrongful dismissal lies in its function as a contractual remedy protecting employees against termination that breaches legally enforceable employment obligations, while distinguishing contractual rights from the separate statutory protections governing the fairness of dismissal.


Image description
0 Comments