- Published on
Malaysian Banking Law – Updated Notes on Banker, Customer and Banker–Customer Relationship
Bekalan Sains P & C Sdn Bhd v Bank Bumiputra Malaysia Bhd
[2011] 5 MLJ 1, Court of Appeal
Facts
Bekalan Sains P & C Sdn Bhd was involved in the cattle business. Since 1993, it had obtained several banking facilities from Bank Bumiputra Malaysia Bhd, including:
After negotiations, the bank agreed on 26 February 1996 to restructure the total facilities amounting to RM8.8 million.
However, on 26 April 1996, the bank informed the company that its head office required a 1:1 condition. This meant that for every RM100 letter of credit requested, the company had to deposit RM100 with the bank. The company was also required to pay RM15,000 monthly towards interest.
The company argued that the bank had breached the restructuring agreement by imposing the new 1:1 condition unilaterally.
The bank argued that the company had failed to comply with the conditions precedent and had not paid the RM15,000 monthly interest. Therefore, the bank was entitled to suspend further credit facilities.
Held
The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal.
The court held that:
Principle From Bekalan Sains
The case confirms that the banker-customer relationship creates reciprocal rights and duties.
A bank owes duties to its customer, but a customer must also comply with banking obligations, especially:
Definition of Customer
A customer is a person who has entered into a banking relationship with a bank.
A person may become a customer by:
The court also stated that all depositors are customers, but not all customers are depositors. This is because the word “depositor” is narrower than “customer”.
Authorities on Customer Status
Great Western Railway Co v London and County Banking Co Ltd
The existence of an account is an important factor in determining whether a person is a customer.
Commissioners of Taxation v English, Scottish and Australian Bank Ltd
Duration is not essential. A person may become a customer immediately once the banking relationship begins.
Ladbroke & Co v Todd
The banker-customer relationship may begin once the first cheque is accepted for collection.
Robinson v Midland Bank Ltd
The chief criterion of customer status is the existence of an account through which banking transactions are passed.
Woods v Martins Bank Ltd
A person may become a customer where negotiations and contractual dealings directly lead to a banking agreement.
Importers Co Ltd v Westminster Bank Ltd
A bank may also become the customer of another bank where banking services, such as cheque collection, are performed between them.
Definition of Banker / Bank
Under section 2(1) of the former Banking and Financial Institutions Act 1989, a bank was defined as a person carrying on banking business.
Banking business included:
However, the Act does not fully define “business of banking”.
United Dominions Trust Ltd v Kirkwood
The main characteristics of banking business are:
Modern Meaning of Banking
The Court of Appeal in Bekalan Sains recognised that modern banking has moved beyond traditional banking activities.
Modern banking may include:
Nature of the Banker-Customer Relationship
The banker-customer relationship is contractual.
For deposit accounts, the parties must agree to terms that bind them.
The essence of the contract is:
Foley v Hill
The House of Lords held that when money is paid into a bank, the bank becomes debtor to the customer.
The bank may use the money as its own, but must repay the equivalent amount to the customer.
Thus:
Joachimson v Swiss Bank Corporation
This case gives the classic explanation of the banker-customer contract.
The bank undertakes to:
Rights of the Banker
A banker may have rights including:
Rights of the Customer
A customer may have rights including:
Duties of the Banker
A bank owes duties to the customer, including:
Duty of Care in Customer Instructions
In Redmond v Allied Irish Banks Plc, the court stated that a bank must take reasonable care and skill in interpreting and acting on customer instructions.
This means the customer’s mandate is very important.
A bank must not blindly act in a way that ignores the customer’s instructions or agreed contractual terms.
Equity and Fiduciary Issues
The banker-customer relationship is generally commercial and contractual, not fiduciary.
In Bank of Scotland v A Ltd, the court explained that where an account is in credit, the bank is debtor, not trustee.
However, in exceptional cases, equity may impose liability where a bank dishonestly assists in breach of trust or knowingly receives trust property.
Therefore:
Bank Pertanian Malaysia v Mohd Gazzali Mohd Ismail
[1997] 3 CLJ Supp 299
This case confirms the importance of express contractual terms in banker-customer relationships.
Where a loan agreement states that repayment is “on demand”, demand becomes necessary before the bank may sue.
The court held that:
Practical Application
If a customer obtains banking facilities and later fails to pay agreed interest, the bank is not required to continue releasing further credit.
For example, if a restructuring agreement requires monthly interest payments and the borrower fails to pay, the bank may suspend further drawdowns.
This is exactly the principle applied in Bekalan Sains P & C Sdn Bhd v Bank Bumiputra Malaysia Bhd.
Critical Analysis
The banker-customer relationship is no longer limited to simple deposit accounts and cheque payments.
Modern banking involves complex facilities such as trade finance, electronic transfers, internet banking and investment services.
However, the legal foundation remains contractual.
The courts try to balance:
Solution to the Case Scenario
Applying Bekalan Sains, Agro Livestock is unlikely to succeed if it failed to pay the agreed monthly interest and failed to fulfil the conditions precedent under the restructuring agreement.
The bank would likely be entitled to:
Conclusion
The banker-customer relationship in Malaysian banking law is contractual in nature.
A banker is generally an institution carrying on banking business, including accepting deposits, maintaining current accounts, paying and collecting cheques, and providing finance.
A customer is a person who has entered into a recognised banking relationship with a bank, whether through an account, deposit, credit facility or banking agreement.
The key cases show that:
Bekalan Sains P & C Sdn Bhd v Bank Bumiputra Malaysia Bhd
[2011] 5 MLJ 1, Court of Appeal
Facts
Bekalan Sains P & C Sdn Bhd was involved in the cattle business. Since 1993, it had obtained several banking facilities from Bank Bumiputra Malaysia Bhd, including:
- overdraft facilities;
- letters of credit;
- trust receipts;
- banker’s guarantees.
After negotiations, the bank agreed on 26 February 1996 to restructure the total facilities amounting to RM8.8 million.
However, on 26 April 1996, the bank informed the company that its head office required a 1:1 condition. This meant that for every RM100 letter of credit requested, the company had to deposit RM100 with the bank. The company was also required to pay RM15,000 monthly towards interest.
The company argued that the bank had breached the restructuring agreement by imposing the new 1:1 condition unilaterally.
The bank argued that the company had failed to comply with the conditions precedent and had not paid the RM15,000 monthly interest. Therefore, the bank was entitled to suspend further credit facilities.
Held
The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal.
The court held that:
- the dispute involved a banker-customer relationship;
- the borrower had failed to pay interest;
- the borrower had not fulfilled the restructuring conditions;
- it is settled law that a bank may withhold further drawdowns where the borrower breaches its obligation to pay interest.
Principle From Bekalan Sains
The case confirms that the banker-customer relationship creates reciprocal rights and duties.
A bank owes duties to its customer, but a customer must also comply with banking obligations, especially:
- repayment of loan facilities;
- payment of interest;
- fulfilment of conditions precedent;
- compliance with restructuring agreements.
- suspend further drawdowns;
- recall facilities;
- impose protective conditions;
- enforce its contractual rights.
Definition of Customer
A customer is a person who has entered into a banking relationship with a bank.
A person may become a customer by:
- opening an account;
- maintaining an existing account;
- depositing money;
- obtaining an overdraft;
- obtaining letters of credit or trust receipts;
- obtaining banker’s guarantees;
- entering into negotiations that directly lead to a banking agreement.
The court also stated that all depositors are customers, but not all customers are depositors. This is because the word “depositor” is narrower than “customer”.
Authorities on Customer Status
Great Western Railway Co v London and County Banking Co Ltd
The existence of an account is an important factor in determining whether a person is a customer.
Commissioners of Taxation v English, Scottish and Australian Bank Ltd
Duration is not essential. A person may become a customer immediately once the banking relationship begins.
Ladbroke & Co v Todd
The banker-customer relationship may begin once the first cheque is accepted for collection.
Robinson v Midland Bank Ltd
The chief criterion of customer status is the existence of an account through which banking transactions are passed.
Woods v Martins Bank Ltd
A person may become a customer where negotiations and contractual dealings directly lead to a banking agreement.
Importers Co Ltd v Westminster Bank Ltd
A bank may also become the customer of another bank where banking services, such as cheque collection, are performed between them.
Definition of Banker / Bank
Under section 2(1) of the former Banking and Financial Institutions Act 1989, a bank was defined as a person carrying on banking business.
Banking business included:
- receiving deposits on current, savings, deposit or similar accounts;
- paying or collecting cheques drawn by or paid in by customers;
- providing finance.
However, the Act does not fully define “business of banking”.
United Dominions Trust Ltd v Kirkwood
The main characteristics of banking business are:
- conducting current accounts;
- paying cheques drawn on the bank;
- collecting cheques for customers.
Modern Meaning of Banking
The Court of Appeal in Bekalan Sains recognised that modern banking has moved beyond traditional banking activities.
Modern banking may include:
- credit cards;
- charge cards;
- foreign exchange dealings;
- telegraphic transfers;
- electronic transfers;
- internet banking transactions;
- trade finance;
- share financing;
- money market transactions;
- investment services.
Nature of the Banker-Customer Relationship
The banker-customer relationship is contractual.
For deposit accounts, the parties must agree to terms that bind them.
The essence of the contract is:
- the bank may use the customer’s money for its own purposes;
- the bank undertakes to repay an equivalent amount;
- repayment may be on demand or at a fixed time;
- interest may or may not be payable depending on the agreement.
Foley v Hill
The House of Lords held that when money is paid into a bank, the bank becomes debtor to the customer.
The bank may use the money as its own, but must repay the equivalent amount to the customer.
Thus:
- the bank is not normally a trustee;
- the customer is a creditor;
- the bank is a debtor.
Joachimson v Swiss Bank Corporation
This case gives the classic explanation of the banker-customer contract.
The bank undertakes to:
- receive money;
- collect bills;
- repay the customer upon demand;
- honour valid written payment instructions;
- give reasonable notice before ending the relationship.
- exercise reasonable care when issuing instructions;
- avoid misleading the bank;
- avoid facilitating fraud or forgery.
Rights of the Banker
A banker may have rights including:
- right to service charges;
- right to commission;
- right to interest;
- right of set-off;
- right to suspend facilities after default;
- right to recall facilities where contractual terms permit.
Rights of the Customer
A customer may have rights including:
- right to draw cheques;
- right to repayment of funds;
- right to interest where agreed;
- right to have valid instructions carried out;
- right to confidentiality;
- right to reasonable care and skill from the bank.
Duties of the Banker
A bank owes duties to the customer, including:
- duty of confidentiality;
- duty to exercise reasonable care and skill;
- duty to follow customer instructions;
- duty to honour valid mandates;
- duty to inform customers of substantial changes to facility terms.
Duty of Care in Customer Instructions
In Redmond v Allied Irish Banks Plc, the court stated that a bank must take reasonable care and skill in interpreting and acting on customer instructions.
This means the customer’s mandate is very important.
A bank must not blindly act in a way that ignores the customer’s instructions or agreed contractual terms.
Equity and Fiduciary Issues
The banker-customer relationship is generally commercial and contractual, not fiduciary.
In Bank of Scotland v A Ltd, the court explained that where an account is in credit, the bank is debtor, not trustee.
However, in exceptional cases, equity may impose liability where a bank dishonestly assists in breach of trust or knowingly receives trust property.
Therefore:
- ordinary banking relationship = debtor and creditor;
- exceptional fraud or trust cases = possible equitable liability.
Bank Pertanian Malaysia v Mohd Gazzali Mohd Ismail
[1997] 3 CLJ Supp 299
This case confirms the importance of express contractual terms in banker-customer relationships.
Where a loan agreement states that repayment is “on demand”, demand becomes necessary before the bank may sue.
The court held that:
- the express term must be enforced;
- time does not run until demand is made and repayment refused;
- the bank was entitled to an order for sale.
Practical Application
If a customer obtains banking facilities and later fails to pay agreed interest, the bank is not required to continue releasing further credit.
For example, if a restructuring agreement requires monthly interest payments and the borrower fails to pay, the bank may suspend further drawdowns.
This is exactly the principle applied in Bekalan Sains P & C Sdn Bhd v Bank Bumiputra Malaysia Bhd.
Critical Analysis
The banker-customer relationship is no longer limited to simple deposit accounts and cheque payments.
Modern banking involves complex facilities such as trade finance, electronic transfers, internet banking and investment services.
However, the legal foundation remains contractual.
The courts try to balance:
- customer protection;
- bank autonomy;
- commercial certainty;
- financial stability;
- contractual fairness.
Solution to the Case Scenario
Applying Bekalan Sains, Agro Livestock is unlikely to succeed if it failed to pay the agreed monthly interest and failed to fulfil the conditions precedent under the restructuring agreement.
The bank would likely be entitled to:
- withhold further drawdowns;
- impose protective conditions;
- suspend further facilities;
- rely on the borrower’s breach.
Conclusion
The banker-customer relationship in Malaysian banking law is contractual in nature.
A banker is generally an institution carrying on banking business, including accepting deposits, maintaining current accounts, paying and collecting cheques, and providing finance.
A customer is a person who has entered into a recognised banking relationship with a bank, whether through an account, deposit, credit facility or banking agreement.
The key cases show that:
- Foley v Hill establishes the debtor-creditor relationship;
- Joachimson explains the contractual duties of banker and customer;
- United Dominions Trust v Kirkwood identifies the classic features of banking;
- Bank Pertanian Malaysia confirms that express terms such as “on demand” clauses must be enforced;
- Bekalan Sains confirms that banks may withhold facilities where borrowers breach repayment obligations.
0 Comments