LAW

Published on
Malaysian Banking Law – Wash Trade
Definition
A wash trade is a form of market manipulation where a person directly or indirectly buys and sells the same financial instrument without any genuine commercial purpose or genuine change in beneficial ownership.
The transaction creates a false or misleading appearance of active trading, market demand, liquidity, or trading volume, even though no real economic transaction has occurred.
A wash trade is prohibited because it deceives other market participants into believing that there is genuine market activity when, in reality, the transaction is artificial.


Why Is It Called a Wash Trade?
The term “wash trade” is used because the transaction effectively cancels itself out or “washes out.”
Although there may appear to be a purchase and sale, the person ultimately remains in substantially the same position before and after the transaction.
There is:
  • No genuine transfer of beneficial ownership;
  • No legitimate investment objective;
  • No genuine commercial purpose; and
  • Little or no real economic risk.
The sole purpose is often to create an illusion of market activity.


Simple Example
Scenario
Mr A owns RM10 million worth of government securities.
He instructs Broker X to sell the securities from Account A while simultaneously arranging for the same securities to be purchased through Account B, which is also under his control.
After the transaction:
  • Mr A still effectively owns the same securities;
  • No genuine investment decision has been made;
  • No real economic exposure has changed.
However, the market records a RM10 million transaction.
Other market participants may wrongly assume:
  • There is significant market demand;
  • Trading activity is increasing;
  • The securities are becoming more attractive.
This is a wash trade.


Banking Example
Case Scenario
A treasury dealer at XYZ Bank Berhad wishes to create the appearance of strong market interest in a government bond.
The dealer secretly arranges for:
  • XYZ Bank to sell the bond; and
  • A related institution to purchase the same bond,
with an understanding that the securities will eventually be returned or repurchased.
The transaction has no genuine commercial purpose.
Its objective is to:
  • Increase reported trading volume;
  • Create artificial demand;
  • Influence market perception; and
  • Encourage other investors to enter the market.
The transaction constitutes a wash trade and may amount to market manipulation under section 141 of the Financial Services Act 2013 and section 153 of the Islamic Financial Services Act 2013.


Why Are Wash Trades Harmful?
Wash trades distort the proper operation of financial markets because they create false signals regarding:
Trading Volume
Investors may believe that significant trading activity exists when it does not.
Market Demand
The market may appear to have strong buying interest even though the transactions are artificial.
Liquidity
Participants may wrongly assume that there is sufficient liquidity in the market.
Market Price
Artificial transactions may influence prices and affect investment decisions.
Consequently, investors, banks, and institutions may make decisions based on misleading information.


Relationship with Market Manipulation
Wash trades are recognised as a form of market manipulation because they interfere with normal market forces.
Instead of allowing prices to be determined by genuine buyers and sellers, wash trades artificially affect:
  • Supply;
  • Demand;
  • Trading volume;
  • Market sentiment; and
  • Price formation.
For this reason, wash trades are specifically identified in the Code of Conduct for Malaysia Wholesale Financial Markets as an example of prohibited conduct.


Comparison Between a Genuine Trade and a Wash Trade
Genuine Trade
  • Involves an independent buyer and seller.
  • Genuine transfer of ownership occurs.
  • Legitimate commercial or investment purpose exists.
  • Real market risk is assumed.
  • Reflects actual market supply and demand.
  • Produces genuine trading activity.
  • Assists accurate price discovery.
  • Lawful market conduct.
Wash Trade
  • Same person or colluding parties effectively act as both buyer and seller.
  • No genuine change in beneficial ownership.
  • No legitimate commercial or investment purpose.
  • Little or no real market risk assumed.
  • Creates artificial supply and demand conditions.
  • Produces false trading activity.
  • Distorts price discovery.
  • May constitute unlawful market manipulation.


Critical Analysis
Wash trades may appear legitimate because a purchase and sale technically occur. However, regulators and courts focus on the substance of the transaction rather than its form.
The critical question is whether the transaction has a genuine commercial purpose and whether beneficial ownership genuinely changes.
Modern financial markets make wash trades increasingly sophisticated. Traders may use multiple accounts, related companies, offshore entities, or coordinated trading arrangements to disguise the true nature of transactions.
Consequently, regulators such as Bank Negara Malaysia employ sophisticated surveillance systems to detect unusual trading patterns and identify potentially manipulative conduct.
The prohibition against wash trades is therefore essential to preserve:
  • Market integrity;
  • Investor confidence;
  • Fair competition;
  • Accurate price discovery; and
  • Financial stability.
Without such prohibitions, market prices and trading volumes could become unreliable indicators of genuine economic activity.


Conclusion
A wash trade is a transaction in which a person directly or indirectly buys and sells the same financial instrument without any genuine commercial purpose or meaningful change in beneficial ownership.
Its purpose is generally to:
  • Create artificial trading volume;
  • Generate a false appearance of market activity;
  • Mislead investors and market participants;
  • Influence market prices; or
  • Manipulate supply and demand.
Because wash trades create a false or misleading appearance of active dealing, they constitute a form of market manipulation and may expose the offender to criminal, civil, and administrative sanctions under the Financial Services Act 2013 and the Islamic Financial Services Act 2013. In Malaysia’s wholesale financial markets, genuine trading activity must always be distinguished from artificial transactions designed to mislead the market.

​
Picture
0 Comments