- Published on
Malaysian Negotiable Instruments – Cheques ( Dishonour, Liability, Remedies and Legal Consequences)
Case Scenario
Ali owns Ali Trading Sdn. Bhd. and purchases construction materials worth RM250,000 from Mega Builders Sdn. Bhd.
Ali issues a cheque payable to “Mega Builders Sdn. Bhd. or Order.”
Mega Builders deposits the cheque into its bank account.
Two days later, the bank returns the cheque marked:
“Refer to Drawer.”
Mega Builders immediately contacts Ali.
Ali admits that there were insufficient funds in his account.
Mega Builders now wishes to know:
This situation illustrates one of the most common legal disputes involving cheques--dishonour of a cheque.
⸻
Introduction
A cheque is intended to function as a reliable method of payment. However, not every cheque presented to a bank is honoured. A bank may refuse payment for various legal reasons, resulting in what is known as dishonour.
Dishonour is significant because it affects the rights and liabilities of:
Understanding why a cheque is dishonoured and the legal consequences that follow is essential in negotiable instruments law.
⸻
Questions and Answers
Q1. What does “honour” mean?
A cheque is honoured when the drawee bank pays the amount stated on the cheque according to the drawer’s instructions.
Once payment is made:
⸻
Q2. What is dishonour?
Dishonour occurs when the bank refuses to pay a cheque upon presentation.
Instead of making payment, the bank returns the cheque unpaid together with a reason for refusing payment.
⸻
Q3. Why may a cheque be dishonoured?
A cheque may be dishonoured for many reasons, including:
⸻
Legal Mechanism – Dishonour of a Cheque
Step 1 – The Cheque is Issued
Ali purchases goods worth RM100,000.
Ali writes a cheque payable to Mega Builders.
Legal Position
Ali (Drawer) instructs his bank to make payment.
⸻
Step 2 – The Cheque is Deposited
Mega Builders deposits the cheque.
Its bank forwards the cheque to Ali’s bank.
Legal Position
The cheque enters the banking clearing system.
⸻
Step 3 – The Bank Examines the Cheque
Ali’s bank checks:
Legal Position
The bank decides whether payment should be made.
⸻
Step 4A – If Everything is Correct
The bank pays the cheque.
Legal Position
⸻
Step 4B – If There is a Problem
The bank refuses payment.
The cheque is returned unpaid.
Legal Position
The cheque has been dishonoured.
The holder may now exercise legal rights against parties liable on the cheque.
⸻
Common Reasons for Dishonour
Insufficient Funds
The drawer does not have enough money in the account.
This is the most common reason.
⸻
Signature Differs
The signature on the cheque does not match the bank’s specimen signature.
The bank refuses payment to protect the customer’s account.
⸻
Post-Dated Cheque
The cheque bears a future date.
If presented before that date,
the bank normally refuses payment.
⸻
Stale Cheque
A cheque presented long after its date (commonly after six months in banking practice).
The bank may refuse payment because the cheque has become stale.
⸻
Stop Payment Instruction
The drawer instructs the bank not to honour the cheque.
The bank must generally comply unless prevented by law.
⸻
Material Alteration
The cheque has been altered without proper authentication.
Examples:
The bank may refuse payment.
⸻
Closed Account
The drawer’s account has already been closed.
No payment can be made.
⸻
Liability After Dishonour
Q4. Who is primarily liable?
The Drawer remains liable to the holder if the cheque is dishonoured, provided the legal requirements are satisfied.
⸻
Q5. Are endorsers liable?
Yes.
If an endorser has transferred the cheque,
that endorser may become liable to later holders if the cheque is dishonoured.
⸻
Q6. Is the bank automatically liable?
No.
The bank’s liability depends upon whether it wrongfully dishonoured the cheque or wrongfully paid it.
⸻
Wrongful Dishonour
Q7. What is wrongful dishonour?
Wrongful dishonour occurs when the bank refuses payment even though:
⸻
Example
Ali has RM500,000 in his account.
He issues a cheque for RM20,000.
The bank mistakenly refuses payment.
Legal Position
The bank may be liable to Ali for damages because it wrongfully dishonoured the cheque.
⸻
Wrongful Payment
Banks must also exercise care before making payment.
Example
The cheque contains a forged signature.
The bank nevertheless pays.
Legal Position
The bank may bear the loss because it failed to detect the forgery.
⸻
Remedies Available to the Holder
If the cheque is dishonoured,
the holder may:
⸻
Practical Example
A supplier sells RM300,000 worth of steel.
The buyer issues a cheque.
The cheque is dishonoured due to insufficient funds.
The supplier immediately sues for:
The supplier is not limited to relying only upon the cheque because the original contract of sale still exists.
⸻
Critical Analysis
The law governing dishonour balances two competing interests.
On one hand,
banks must protect customers by refusing payment where fraud, forgery or irregularities exist.
On the other hand,
banks must avoid wrongfully dishonouring genuine cheques because doing so may seriously damage the customer’s commercial reputation.
Similarly,
the law protects holders by allowing them to pursue both the negotiable instrument and the underlying contractual obligation.
Consequently,
dishonour does not extinguish the original debt.
Instead,
it provides additional legal remedies.
⸻
Practical Applications
Dishonoured cheques commonly arise in:
Businesses therefore usually verify payment before releasing high-value goods.
⸻
Case Scenario with Solution
Facts
Ali purchases industrial machinery worth RM450,000.
Ali issues an order cheque.
The supplier deposits the cheque.
Ali’s bank returns it marked:
Insufficient Funds
The supplier immediately demands payment.
Ali refuses.
⸻
Legal Issues
⸻
Legal Analysis
The cheque was dishonoured because sufficient funds were unavailable.
Dishonour does not extinguish Ali’s contractual obligation to pay.
Ali remains liable for:
⸻
Solution
The supplier may commence legal proceedings against Ali to recover the outstanding debt despite the dishonoured cheque.
⸻
Common Student Mistakes
Many students incorrectly believe:
❌ A dishonoured cheque cancels the original contract.
Incorrect.
The underlying contractual obligation usually continues to exist.
⸻
Some students also think:
❌ Once a cheque is dishonoured, the debt disappears.
Incorrect.
The creditor may still sue for the original debt.
⸻
Another common mistake:
❌ Every dishonour makes the bank liable.
Incorrect.
The bank is liable only if it wrongfully dishonours or wrongfully pays a cheque.
⸻
Examination Tips
Whenever you encounter a dishonoured cheque problem, answer it in this order:
Step 1
Identify the reason for dishonour.
⸻
Step 2
Determine whether the dishonour was lawful.
⸻
Step 3
Identify who is liable:
⸻
Step 4
Determine the remedies available.
⸻
Step 5
Consider whether the underlying contractual debt still exists.
⸻
Practical Revision Summary
Whenever analysing a cheque, follow this legal sequence:
Following these eight questions will enable you to analyse almost every examination problem relating to cheques under Malaysian negotiable instruments law.
⸻
Conclusion
The legal consequences of a dishonoured cheque extend far beyond the refusal of payment. Dishonour determines the liability of the drawer, endorsers and, in certain cases, the bank itself. It also preserves the holder’s right to recover the underlying debt through legal proceedings. Although electronic banking has reduced the use of paper cheques, the principles governing honour, dishonour, liability and remedies remain fundamental to commercial law and continue to influence modern banking practice. Understanding the complete legal mechanism—from issuance to dishonour and eventual recovery—is essential for mastering Malaysian negotiable instruments law.
Case Scenario
Ali owns Ali Trading Sdn. Bhd. and purchases construction materials worth RM250,000 from Mega Builders Sdn. Bhd.
Ali issues a cheque payable to “Mega Builders Sdn. Bhd. or Order.”
Mega Builders deposits the cheque into its bank account.
Two days later, the bank returns the cheque marked:
“Refer to Drawer.”
Mega Builders immediately contacts Ali.
Ali admits that there were insufficient funds in his account.
Mega Builders now wishes to know:
- Why was the cheque dishonoured?
- Who is legally liable?
- Can Ali be sued?
- What legal remedies are available?
This situation illustrates one of the most common legal disputes involving cheques--dishonour of a cheque.
⸻
Introduction
A cheque is intended to function as a reliable method of payment. However, not every cheque presented to a bank is honoured. A bank may refuse payment for various legal reasons, resulting in what is known as dishonour.
Dishonour is significant because it affects the rights and liabilities of:
- the drawer;
- the payee;
- endorsers;
- holders; and
- banks.
Understanding why a cheque is dishonoured and the legal consequences that follow is essential in negotiable instruments law.
⸻
Questions and Answers
Q1. What does “honour” mean?
A cheque is honoured when the drawee bank pays the amount stated on the cheque according to the drawer’s instructions.
Once payment is made:
- the drawer’s debt is discharged;
- the cheque has served its purpose; and
- the instrument is completed.
⸻
Q2. What is dishonour?
Dishonour occurs when the bank refuses to pay a cheque upon presentation.
Instead of making payment, the bank returns the cheque unpaid together with a reason for refusing payment.
⸻
Q3. Why may a cheque be dishonoured?
A cheque may be dishonoured for many reasons, including:
- insufficient funds;
- signature mismatch;
- post-dated cheque presented too early;
- stale cheque;
- material alteration;
- closed account;
- stop payment instruction;
- irregular endorsement;
- suspected fraud;
- court order preventing payment.
⸻
Legal Mechanism – Dishonour of a Cheque
Step 1 – The Cheque is Issued
Ali purchases goods worth RM100,000.
Ali writes a cheque payable to Mega Builders.
Legal Position
Ali (Drawer) instructs his bank to make payment.
⸻
Step 2 – The Cheque is Deposited
Mega Builders deposits the cheque.
Its bank forwards the cheque to Ali’s bank.
Legal Position
The cheque enters the banking clearing system.
⸻
Step 3 – The Bank Examines the Cheque
Ali’s bank checks:
- the signature;
- available funds;
- date;
- endorsements;
- alterations;
- crossing;
- banking instructions.
Legal Position
The bank decides whether payment should be made.
⸻
Step 4A – If Everything is Correct
The bank pays the cheque.
Legal Position
- Debt discharged.
- Cheque honoured.
- Transaction completed.
⸻
Step 4B – If There is a Problem
The bank refuses payment.
The cheque is returned unpaid.
Legal Position
The cheque has been dishonoured.
The holder may now exercise legal rights against parties liable on the cheque.
⸻
Common Reasons for Dishonour
Insufficient Funds
The drawer does not have enough money in the account.
This is the most common reason.
⸻
Signature Differs
The signature on the cheque does not match the bank’s specimen signature.
The bank refuses payment to protect the customer’s account.
⸻
Post-Dated Cheque
The cheque bears a future date.
If presented before that date,
the bank normally refuses payment.
⸻
Stale Cheque
A cheque presented long after its date (commonly after six months in banking practice).
The bank may refuse payment because the cheque has become stale.
⸻
Stop Payment Instruction
The drawer instructs the bank not to honour the cheque.
The bank must generally comply unless prevented by law.
⸻
Material Alteration
The cheque has been altered without proper authentication.
Examples:
- changing the amount;
- changing the payee;
- changing the date.
The bank may refuse payment.
⸻
Closed Account
The drawer’s account has already been closed.
No payment can be made.
⸻
Liability After Dishonour
Q4. Who is primarily liable?
The Drawer remains liable to the holder if the cheque is dishonoured, provided the legal requirements are satisfied.
⸻
Q5. Are endorsers liable?
Yes.
If an endorser has transferred the cheque,
that endorser may become liable to later holders if the cheque is dishonoured.
⸻
Q6. Is the bank automatically liable?
No.
The bank’s liability depends upon whether it wrongfully dishonoured the cheque or wrongfully paid it.
⸻
Wrongful Dishonour
Q7. What is wrongful dishonour?
Wrongful dishonour occurs when the bank refuses payment even though:
- sufficient funds exist;
- the cheque is valid;
- no legal reason exists for refusing payment.
⸻
Example
Ali has RM500,000 in his account.
He issues a cheque for RM20,000.
The bank mistakenly refuses payment.
Legal Position
The bank may be liable to Ali for damages because it wrongfully dishonoured the cheque.
⸻
Wrongful Payment
Banks must also exercise care before making payment.
Example
The cheque contains a forged signature.
The bank nevertheless pays.
Legal Position
The bank may bear the loss because it failed to detect the forgery.
⸻
Remedies Available to the Holder
If the cheque is dishonoured,
the holder may:
- demand payment;
- sue the drawer;
- sue liable endorsers;
- recover the debt under the underlying contract;
- claim interest where appropriate.
⸻
Practical Example
A supplier sells RM300,000 worth of steel.
The buyer issues a cheque.
The cheque is dishonoured due to insufficient funds.
The supplier immediately sues for:
- the unpaid purchase price;
- interest;
- legal costs.
The supplier is not limited to relying only upon the cheque because the original contract of sale still exists.
⸻
Critical Analysis
The law governing dishonour balances two competing interests.
On one hand,
banks must protect customers by refusing payment where fraud, forgery or irregularities exist.
On the other hand,
banks must avoid wrongfully dishonouring genuine cheques because doing so may seriously damage the customer’s commercial reputation.
Similarly,
the law protects holders by allowing them to pursue both the negotiable instrument and the underlying contractual obligation.
Consequently,
dishonour does not extinguish the original debt.
Instead,
it provides additional legal remedies.
⸻
Practical Applications
Dishonoured cheques commonly arise in:
- supplier disputes;
- property transactions;
- construction contracts;
- rental payments;
- salary payments;
- insurance settlements;
- commercial financing.
Businesses therefore usually verify payment before releasing high-value goods.
⸻
Case Scenario with Solution
Facts
Ali purchases industrial machinery worth RM450,000.
Ali issues an order cheque.
The supplier deposits the cheque.
Ali’s bank returns it marked:
Insufficient Funds
The supplier immediately demands payment.
Ali refuses.
⸻
Legal Issues
- Has the cheque been dishonoured?
- Is Ali still liable?
- What remedies does the supplier have?
⸻
Legal Analysis
The cheque was dishonoured because sufficient funds were unavailable.
Dishonour does not extinguish Ali’s contractual obligation to pay.
Ali remains liable for:
- the amount of the cheque;
- the purchase price under the contract;
- possible legal costs and interest.
⸻
Solution
The supplier may commence legal proceedings against Ali to recover the outstanding debt despite the dishonoured cheque.
⸻
Common Student Mistakes
Many students incorrectly believe:
❌ A dishonoured cheque cancels the original contract.
Incorrect.
The underlying contractual obligation usually continues to exist.
⸻
Some students also think:
❌ Once a cheque is dishonoured, the debt disappears.
Incorrect.
The creditor may still sue for the original debt.
⸻
Another common mistake:
❌ Every dishonour makes the bank liable.
Incorrect.
The bank is liable only if it wrongfully dishonours or wrongfully pays a cheque.
⸻
Examination Tips
Whenever you encounter a dishonoured cheque problem, answer it in this order:
Step 1
Identify the reason for dishonour.
⸻
Step 2
Determine whether the dishonour was lawful.
⸻
Step 3
Identify who is liable:
- Drawer
- Endorser
- Bank
⸻
Step 4
Determine the remedies available.
⸻
Step 5
Consider whether the underlying contractual debt still exists.
⸻
Practical Revision Summary
Whenever analysing a cheque, follow this legal sequence:
- Was there a valid underlying transaction?
- Was the cheque properly issued?
- Was the cheque transferred correctly?
- Was the cheque presented?
- Was it honoured or dishonoured?
- Why was it dishonoured?
- Who is legally liable?
- What remedies are available?
Following these eight questions will enable you to analyse almost every examination problem relating to cheques under Malaysian negotiable instruments law.
⸻
Conclusion
The legal consequences of a dishonoured cheque extend far beyond the refusal of payment. Dishonour determines the liability of the drawer, endorsers and, in certain cases, the bank itself. It also preserves the holder’s right to recover the underlying debt through legal proceedings. Although electronic banking has reduced the use of paper cheques, the principles governing honour, dishonour, liability and remedies remain fundamental to commercial law and continue to influence modern banking practice. Understanding the complete legal mechanism—from issuance to dishonour and eventual recovery—is essential for mastering Malaysian negotiable instruments law.
0 Comments