Malaysian Banking Law – Definition of a Banker According to Dr HL Hart
General Overview
Another important legal definition of a banker was provided by Dr HL Hart. Dr Hart defined a banker or bank as:
“A person or company carrying on the business of receiving moneys, and collecting drafts, for customers subject to the obligation of honouring cheques drawn upon them from time to time by the customers to the extent of the amounts available on their current accounts.”
This definition focuses on the essential operational duties of a banker, particularly the acceptance of money, collection of payment instruments, and the obligation to honour customer cheques.


Essential Elements of Dr Hart’s Definition
1. A Person or Company
According to Dr Hart, a banker may be:

• An individual person, or
• A company or corporation.

This means banking business is not limited only to large incorporated banks.


2. Carrying on the Business of Receiving Money
A banker receives money from customers through:

• Current accounts,
• Deposit accounts,
• Savings accounts,
• Other banking arrangements.

Receiving money from customers is one of the core characteristics of banking business.


3. Collecting Drafts for Customers
Banks collect drafts and payment instruments on behalf of customers.
A draft generally refers to:

• Cheques,
• Bills of exchange,
• Payment orders,
• Other negotiable instruments.

This function assists customers in receiving payments and conducting commercial transactions.


4. Obligation to Honour Cheques
A key feature in Dr Hart’s definition is the banker’s obligation to honour customer cheques.
This means:

• The bank must pay cheques issued by customers,
• Provided sufficient funds are available in the customer’s current account.

This obligation forms an important part of the banker–customer relationship.


5. Current Accounts
Dr Hart’s definition specifically refers to current accounts.
Current accounts allow:

• Continuous deposits,
• Frequent withdrawals,
• Payment transactions,
• Commercial banking activities.

The use of current accounts is treated as an important feature of traditional banking.


Note Form – Dr Hart’s Definition of a Banker
A Banker May Be:

• An individual person.
• A company or corporation.

Essential Banking Functions

• Receiving money from customers.
• Collecting drafts and payment instruments.
• Maintaining current accounts.
• Honouring customer cheques.
• Facilitating commercial transactions.

Important Legal Principle
A banker has a duty to honour customer cheques so long as sufficient funds are available in the account.


Relationship With Other Definitions
Similarities With
United Dominions Trust Ltd v Kirkwood
Dr Hart’s definition is similar to the principles discussed in United Dominions Trust Ltd v Kirkwood because both emphasise:

• Current accounts,
• Payment of cheques,
• Collection of cheques or drafts,
• Banking as a regular business activity.

Similarities With
Halsbury’s Laws of England
Like Halsbury’s Laws of England, Dr Hart’s definition focuses on traditional banking functions involving deposits and cheque operations.


Difference From Broader Modern Approaches
Modern banking law sometimes adopts a broader approach by recognising digital payment systems and electronic transfers as substitutes for traditional cheque systems.
Therefore, modern banking may extend beyond the strict cheque-based model described in older legal definitions.


Application in a Case Scenario
Scenario
SecureBank Sdn Bhd accepts deposits into customer current accounts. Customers may issue cheques, deposit payment drafts, and transfer money through banking facilities. The bank regularly collects cheques for customers and honours cheque payments where sufficient funds exist.
Under Dr Hart’s definition, SecureBank clearly qualifies as a banker because it:

• Receives customer money,
• Maintains current accounts,
• Collects drafts,
• Honours customer cheques.

Critical Analysis
Dr Hart’s definition reflects the traditional understanding of banking during a period when cheques and negotiable instruments played a central role in commerce.
However, modern banking systems increasingly rely on:

• Electronic transfers,
• Internet banking,
• Mobile payments,
• Digital wallets,
• Instant payment systems.

As cheque usage declines, questions arise regarding whether cheque payment and collection should still be regarded as essential characteristics of banking.
Another issue is that many modern financial technology companies perform payment and deposit functions similar to banks without maintaining traditional cheque systems.
Therefore, while Dr Hart’s definition remains legally influential, courts and regulators may need to adopt more flexible interpretations to address modern banking practices.


Unresolved Issues
Decline of Cheques
Many modern banking systems rarely use cheques, raising uncertainty regarding whether cheque-related functions remain essential.


Digital Financial Platforms
FinTech companies may perform banking-like activities without satisfying traditional banking definitions based on cheques and current accounts.


Modernisation of Banking Law
Traditional legal definitions may not fully reflect the realities of digital banking and electronic payment systems.


Conclusion
According to Dr HL Hart, a banker is a person or company engaged in receiving money, collecting drafts, and honouring customer cheques from current accounts. This definition highlights the traditional core functions of banking, especially the operation of current accounts and cheque payment systems. Although modern banking has evolved significantly through digital technology and electronic payments, Dr Hart’s definition continues to provide an important foundation for understanding the legal characteristics of banking business in Malaysian banking law.

​

Malaysian Banking Law – Definition of a Banker According to
Halsbury’s Laws of England
General Overview
Another important legal definition of a banker can be found in Halsbury’s Laws of England. This legal authority defines a banker as:
“An individual, partnership or corporation, whose sole or predominating business is banking, that is, the receipt of money on current or deposit account and the payment of cheques drawn by and the collection of cheques paid in by a customer.”
This definition focuses on the main business activities carried out by a bank. It emphasises that banking must be the principal or dominant business of the institution.


Essential Elements of the Definition
1. Individual, Partnership, or Corporation
A banker may exist in different legal forms, including:

• An individual person,
• A partnership, or
• A corporation or company.

This means banking business is not restricted only to incorporated banks.


2. Sole or Predominating Business
The definition stresses that banking must be:

• The sole business, or
• The main or predominant business

of the institution.
This means banking activities must form the primary function of the organisation rather than merely being incidental to another business.


3. Receipt of Money on Current or Deposit Account
A banker receives money from customers through:

• Current accounts,
• Deposit accounts,
• Savings accounts, or
• Other banking accounts.

Customers place funds with the bank for safekeeping, transactions, or investment purposes.


4. Payment of Cheques Drawn by Customers
Banks honour cheques issued by customers from their accounts.
This function:

• Facilitates trade and commerce,
• Enables payments,
• Reflects the bank’s role in the payment system.

5. Collection of Cheques Paid in by Customers
Banks also collect cheques deposited by customers and credit the proceeds into customer accounts.
Cheque collection services:

• Support commercial transactions,
• Facilitate movement of funds,
• Form part of ordinary banking business.

Note Form – Definition of a Banker
A Banker May Be:

• An individual,
• A partnership,
• A corporation or company.

Main Characteristics of a Banker

• Banking must be the sole or predominant business.
• Receives money through current or deposit accounts.
• Pays cheques drawn by customers.
• Collects cheques deposited by customers.

Important Principle
The institution must genuinely conduct banking as its principal business activity rather than merely performing occasional financial services.


Relationship With
United Dominions Trust Ltd v Kirkwood
The definition in Halsbury’s Laws of England is closely connected with the principles discussed in United Dominions Trust Ltd v Kirkwood.
Both authorities emphasise:

• Current accounts,
• Payment of cheques,
• Collection of cheques,
• Genuine banking business.

However, Kirkwood also recognised that reputation and commercial understanding may help determine whether a person or institution qualifies as a banker.


Application in a Case Scenario
Scenario
ABC Finance Sdn Bhd provides investment advice and insurance services. Occasionally, it accepts customer money for short-term investment purposes, but its main business remains insurance and financial consultancy.
A legal issue arises regarding whether ABC Finance qualifies as a banker. Applying the definition from Halsbury’s Laws of England, the company may not qualify as a banker because:

• Banking is not its predominant business,
• It does not maintain current accounts,
• It does not pay or collect cheques for customers.

Therefore, the company is more likely to be regarded as a financial service provider rather than a bank.


Critical Analysis
The definition provided by Halsbury’s Laws of England reflects traditional banking practices where cheque transactions and current accounts formed the centre of banking operations.
However, modern banking has evolved significantly. Many digital banks and financial technology companies now rely mainly on:

• Electronic payments,
• Mobile banking,
• Instant fund transfers,
• Digital wallets.

As a result, cheque-related services may no longer represent the true reality of modern banking systems.
Another issue is that some financial institutions may perform banking-like activities without technically satisfying all traditional banking characteristics. This creates uncertainty regarding:

• Licensing,
• Regulation,
• Consumer protection,
• Legal classification.

Therefore, courts increasingly adopt a flexible approach by examining the substance of the activities carried out rather than relying solely on traditional banking methods.


Unresolved Issues
Decline of Cheque Usage
Modern banking systems increasingly rely on electronic payments instead of cheques, raising questions about whether cheque services remain essential characteristics of banking.


Digital Banks and FinTech
Digital financial institutions may perform banking functions without maintaining traditional current accounts or cheque facilities.


Regulatory Classification
It may be difficult to determine whether modern financial companies should legally be classified as banks or merely financial service providers.


Conclusion
According to Halsbury’s Laws of England, a banker is an individual, partnership, or corporation whose main business involves receiving deposits, paying cheques, and collecting cheques for customers. This definition reflects the traditional characteristics of banking business. However, modern financial developments continue to challenge these traditional concepts, requiring courts and regulators to adopt more flexible interpretations of banking activities in contemporary financial systems.

​

Malaysian Banking Law – Deposit-Taking Business and Banking Business
General Overview
In United Dominions Trust Ltd v Kirkwood, the Court of Appeal further discussed the characteristics required for a deposit-taking business to be regarded as carrying on banking business.
The court suggested that a business does not necessarily need to engage in lending activities in order to qualify as a banking business. Instead, the court referred to the principles stated in Paget’s Law of Banking, which identified certain minimum banking services that are generally associated with banking business.
According to the court, if a business provides these minimum services openly to the public and the banking activities are genuine rather than merely a disguise for another business, the institution may legally be recognised as a bank or banker.


Minimum Characteristics of Banking Business
According to the principles quoted from Paget’s Law of Banking, a banking business generally involves the following minimum services:


1. Accepting Money on Current Accounts
A banking business normally accepts money from customers through current accounts.
This means:

• Customers may deposit money into accounts,
• The account operates continuously,
• Funds may be deposited and withdrawn regularly.

Current accounts are therefore an important feature of banking business.


2. Paying Cheques Drawn on the Account
Banks usually pay cheques issued by customers from their accounts.
This function:

• Supports commercial transactions,
• Facilitates payments,
• Demonstrates the bank’s role in the financial system.

The ability to honour cheques is considered one of the traditional banking functions.


3. Collecting Cheques for Customers
Banks also collect cheques on behalf of customers and credit the proceeds into customer accounts.
Cheque collection services:

• Assist business transactions,
• Facilitate money transfers,
• Form part of normal banking operations.

Banking Services Must Be Offered to the Public
The court stated that these banking services must generally be offered:

• To all and sundry,
• Without restriction,
• As part of genuine banking activities.

This means the business should openly provide banking services to the public rather than operating privately for limited purposes only.


Banking Business Must Not Be a Mere Facade
The court further explained that the banking activities must be genuine and not merely a facade or disguise for another type of business.
In other words:

• The institution must genuinely conduct banking activities,
• Banking functions must form a substantial part of the business,
• The business should not pretend to be a bank merely to obtain legal advantages or exemptions.

If the banking activities are real and substantial, the institution may legally qualify as a banker.


Lending Is Not Always Essential
An important principle from the case is that lending money may not always be essential for banking business.
The court suggested that:

• A deposit-taking institution may still qualify as a bank,
• Even if it does not actively make loans,
• Provided that it performs the minimum banking services associated with banking business.

This shows that courts focus on the overall nature of the activities carried out rather than requiring every traditional banking function.


Note Form – Minimum Banking Characteristics
Banking Business Generally Includes:

• Accepting money through current accounts.
• Paying cheques drawn by customers.
• Collecting cheques for customers.
• Operating accounts with regular deposits and withdrawals.
• Providing banking services to the public.

Important Principles

• Lending money is not always essential.
• Banking activities must be genuine.
• Banking business must not merely disguise another business.
• Public reputation and commercial understanding may be relevant.

Banking Services Must Be:

• Openly provided to the public.
• Conducted regularly and genuinely.
• Part of the institution’s real business activities.

Application in a Case Scenario
Scenario
A company called PayWorld accepts customer deposits through online current accounts. Customers may transfer money electronically and deposit funds into their accounts. However, the company does not provide loans or financing facilities.
A dispute arises regarding whether PayWorld is legally carrying on banking business. The court may apply the principles from United Dominions Trust Ltd v Kirkwood and Paget’s Law of Banking to determine whether:

• The company accepts deposits,
• Operates current accounts,
• Processes payment instructions,
• Provides services genuinely to the public.

Even though PayWorld does not make loans, it may still be regarded as carrying on banking business if the essential banking functions are present.


Critical Analysis
The case reflects a flexible judicial approach in determining what amounts to banking business. Courts recognise that modern banking practices evolve continuously, and not every bank performs identical functions.
This flexibility is useful because many modern financial institutions, especially digital banks and electronic payment platforms, may not operate in the same manner as traditional banks.
However, the absence of a precise definition also creates legal uncertainty. Some companies may provide banking-like services while attempting to avoid banking regulations by arguing that they do not perform all traditional banking functions.
Another challenge arises with financial technology companies that provide payment and deposit services without being licensed as banks. Regulators must therefore carefully examine whether these institutions should fall within banking regulations.
The role of Bank Negara Malaysia is important in ensuring that institutions carrying on banking-like activities are properly supervised and regulated.


Unresolved Issues
Digital Payment Platforms
Modern electronic payment companies may perform functions similar to banks without formally operating as licensed banks.


Online Deposit Services
Some digital institutions accept customer funds but avoid classification as banks because they do not provide traditional lending services.


Regulatory Challenges
Courts and regulators continue to face difficulties in distinguishing genuine banking business from other financial activities.


Conclusion
The decision in United Dominions Trust Ltd v Kirkwood and the principles stated in Paget’s Law of Banking demonstrate that a deposit-taking business may qualify as carrying on banking business even without actively making loans. The essential features include accepting money through current accounts, paying cheques, and collecting cheques for customers. However, these activities must be genuine and openly provided to the public rather than serving merely as a facade for another business. The case remains highly relevant in modern banking law due to the rapid development of digital finance and financial technology services.

​

Malaysian Banking Law – Characteristics of Banking in
United Dominions Trust Ltd v Kirkwood
General Overview
In England, the Court of Appeal in United Dominions Trust Ltd v Kirkwood discussed the essential characteristics of banking business. The court attempted to identify the features commonly associated with a banker and the business of banking.
The case is important because it explains that although banking may be difficult to define precisely, certain core characteristics are commonly found in banking activities. The court also recognised that reputation within banking and commercial circles may help determine whether a person or institution is regarded as a banker.


Essential Characteristics of Banking
According to the Court of Appeal in United Dominions Trust Ltd v Kirkwood, the usual characteristics of banking include:
1. Conduct of Current Accounts
A banker usually maintains current accounts for customers. Customers may deposit money into these accounts and withdraw funds when needed.
Current accounts generally allow:

• Frequent transactions,
• Deposits and withdrawals,
• Payment instructions, and
• Business and commercial banking activities.

Diplock LJ explained that it is essential for banking business that money is accepted into a running account where customers may continuously deposit and withdraw funds.


2. Payment of Cheques
Another important characteristic of banking is the payment of cheques drawn by customers.
Banks usually:

• Honour customer cheques,
• Process payment instructions, and
• Facilitate commercial transactions through cheque payments.

This function reflects the bank’s role in the payment system and commercial activities.


3. Collection of Cheques
Banks also collect cheques on behalf of customers.
This includes:

• Receiving cheques from customers,
• Processing cheque payments,
• Crediting customer accounts after collection.

Cheque collection services support business and commercial transactions within the financial system.


Reputation as a Banker
The court also recognised that reputation may help determine whether a person or institution is considered a banker.
Diplock LJ stated that where there is insufficient evidence regarding banking characteristics, the court may consider whether the institution is recognised in banking and commercial circles as a banker.
This means that:

• Public reputation,
• Commercial recognition, and
• Industry perception

may assist in identifying banking status.


Difference Between “Usual” and “Essential” Characteristics
Lord Denning MR explained that the usual characteristics of banking are not necessarily the only characteristics of a banker. A list of usual features does not provide a complete legal definition.
He stated that other important qualities include:

• Stability,
• Soundness,
• Honesty,
• Financial reliability, and
• Commercial trustworthiness.

Lord Denning famously observed that a banker is often easier to recognise than to define.
This means the courts may examine the overall nature and reputation of the institution rather than relying solely on strict technical definitions.


Note Form – Characteristics of Banking
Essential Characteristics Mentioned in the Case

• Conducting current accounts.
• Paying customer cheques.
• Collecting cheques for customers.
• Accepting money into running accounts.
• Allowing deposits and withdrawals.

Additional Qualities of a Banker

• Stability.
• Soundness.
• Probity (honesty and integrity).
• Commercial reputation.
• Public confidence.

Important Legal Principle
A strict definition of banking is difficult. Courts may examine:

• The actual activities performed,
• The reputation of the institution,
• Commercial understanding within the industry.

Application in a Case Scenario
Scenario
A company called QuickFinance accepts customer funds through digital accounts and allows customers to make electronic payments. However, it does not maintain traditional current accounts or provide cheque collection services.
A dispute arises regarding whether QuickFinance should legally be regarded as a bank. The court may apply the principles from United Dominions Trust Ltd v Kirkwood to examine:

• Whether the company performs essential banking functions,
• Whether it conducts running accounts,
• Whether it is recognised commercially as a banker.

Even if certain traditional banking characteristics are absent, the company’s reputation and overall business activities may still be relevant.


Critical Analysis
The decision in United Dominions Trust Ltd v Kirkwood highlights the difficulty of defining banking in precise legal terms. Banking evolves continuously, and strict definitions may not suit modern financial systems.
The case also demonstrates the importance of commercial reputation. A company may be recognised as a banker because of how it operates and how it is viewed within the financial industry.
However, modern technology raises new challenges. Digital banks and financial technology companies may not provide traditional cheque services or current accounts, yet they perform banking-like functions through electronic systems.
This creates uncertainty regarding:

• Licensing requirements,
• Consumer protection,
• Regulatory supervision,
• Legal classification of digital financial institutions.

The case therefore remains relevant because it supports a flexible and practical approach in determining whether a business carries on banking activities.


Unresolved Issues
Digital Banking Services
Modern online banks may not use traditional cheque systems, raising questions about whether cheque-related functions remain essential characteristics of banking.


FinTech and E-Wallet Platforms
Digital payment platforms may provide banking-like services without formally operating as banks.


Reputation Versus Legal Status
An institution may appear to function like a bank commercially but may not legally qualify as a bank under statutory regulations.


Conclusion
The case of United Dominions Trust Ltd v Kirkwood identifies important characteristics commonly associated with banking, including the conduct of current accounts, payment of cheques, and collection of cheques for customers. However, the court recognised that these are not the only factors relevant in defining a banker. Reputation, stability, and commercial recognition may also assist in determining whether an institution carries on banking business. The case continues to influence modern banking law, especially in dealing with new financial technologies and evolving banking practices.

​

Malaysian Banking Law – Essential Characteristics of Banking Business
General Overview
The courts have recognised that banking is not limited to traditional activities such as collecting cheques or operating current accounts. Instead, the true nature of banking depends on the essential functions carried out by the institution. One important case explaining this principle is State Savings Bank of Victoria, Commissioners v Permewan, Wright & Co Ltd.
In this case, the High Court of Australia explained that a bank acts as a “financial reservoir.” A bank receives money from customers and uses those funds to support commercial, industrial, and other economic activities through lending and financing.
The court further stated that the essential business of banking involves:

• Receiving money through deposits,
• Holding money repayable according to agreement, and
• Using the collected funds by lending them to others.

Therefore, the core function of banking is the collection and utilisation of money rather than the specific methods used to conduct banking transactions.


Essential Characteristics of Banking
Collection of Money Through Deposits
One of the main characteristics of banking is the acceptance of deposits from customers. Customers place money with the bank either for safekeeping or investment purposes.
These deposits may include:

• Savings accounts,
• Fixed deposit accounts,
• Deposit accounts repayable at call, or
• Other agreed forms of deposits.

The court emphasised that banks are not legally required to maintain current accounts only. Banks may operate using various types of deposit arrangements.


Repayment of Deposits
Banks receive money on the understanding that the funds will be repaid according to the agreement between the bank and customer. Repayment may occur:

• On demand,
• At a fixed date,
• In part, or
• According to agreed conditions.

This repayment obligation forms an important legal aspect of the banker–customer relationship.


Utilisation of Deposits Through Lending
Banks do not merely store money. They also utilise deposited funds by lending money to businesses, individuals, and commercial enterprises.
Examples include:

• Housing loans,
• Business financing,
• Personal loans,
• Trade financing, and
• Investment financing.

The court recognised lending as a fundamental banking activity because it supports economic and commercial growth.


Methods of Banking Are Auxiliary
The court explained that many banking methods are merely auxiliary or incidental to the banking business. These methods may differ depending on business needs and technological developments.
Examples include:

• Current accounts,
• Cheques,
• Deposit accounts,
• Secured loans,
• Discounting bills,
• Letters of credit,
• Telegraphic transfers,
• Internet banking,
• Mobile banking,
• Digital payments.

The court stated that the existence or absence of these services does not necessarily determine whether an institution is legally carrying on banking business.


Meaning of “Financial Reservoir”
The court described a bank as a “financial reservoir” because banks collect money from many customers and redistribute those funds into the economy through lending and financing activities.
This process:

• Supports trade and commerce,
• Encourages industrial development,
• Promotes investments, and
• Contributes to economic growth.

Banks therefore play an essential role in the modern financial system.


Note Form – Essential Characteristics of Banking
Banking Business Includes:

• Receiving deposits from customers.
• Holding money repayable under agreement.
• Lending money to individuals and businesses.
• Supporting economic and commercial activities.
• Acting as a financial intermediary.

Banking Methods May Include:

• Current accounts.
• Savings accounts.
• Fixed deposits.
• Cheques.
• Loans and financing.
• Letters of credit.
• Telegraphic transfers.
• Internet banking.
• Digital and mobile payments.

Important Principle
The method used by the institution is not the most important factor. The real test is whether the institution substantially carries on the business of receiving deposits and utilising those funds through lending activities.


Application in a Case Scenario
Scenario
A company called FinServe accepts deposits from customers through digital accounts and later uses the money to provide financing to small businesses. However, the company does not issue cheques or maintain traditional current accounts.
A legal dispute arises regarding whether FinServe is carrying on banking business. The court may apply the principles from State Savings Bank of Victoria, Commissioners v Permewan, Wright & Co Ltd to determine whether the company’s essential activities amount to banking.
Even though FinServe does not provide traditional banking methods such as cheques, it may still legally qualify as carrying on banking business because it receives deposits and lends money.


Critical Analysis
The case demonstrates that banking law focuses on the substance of banking activities rather than the form or method used. This flexible approach allows courts to adapt banking law to changing financial practices and technological developments.
However, modern financial technology creates new legal challenges. Many digital platforms now perform functions similar to banks without operating as traditional banking institutions. This creates uncertainty regarding licensing, regulation, and customer protection.
Another issue is that financial companies may attempt to avoid strict banking regulations by arguing that they do not provide traditional banking services such as current accounts or cheque facilities. Courts must therefore examine the true nature of the business activities carried out.
The decision also highlights the importance of regulation by Bank Negara Malaysia to ensure that institutions engaging in banking-like activities comply with legal and financial requirements.


Unresolved Issues
Digital Banking and FinTech
Modern digital finance companies may perform deposit-taking and lending activities without clearly falling within traditional banking definitions.


Regulatory Gaps
Some financial institutions may carry on banking-like activities without being subject to the same strict regulations imposed on licensed banks.


Consumer Protection
Customers may not fully understand whether their funds are protected when dealing with digital financial institutions that are not licensed banks.


Conclusion
The case of State Savings Bank of Victoria, Commissioners v Permewan, Wright & Co Ltd establishes that the essential characteristics of banking are the receipt of deposits and the utilisation of those funds through lending and financing activities. The methods used by banks, such as cheques or current accounts, are only auxiliary features. This flexible interpretation allows banking law to adapt to changing financial systems while ensuring that institutions performing true banking functions are properly recognised and regulated.

​

Malaysian Banking Law – Difference Between a Bank and a Financial Service Provider
General Overview
Modern financial systems include both banks and financial service providers. Although both offer financial-related services, they are not legally the same. A bank performs core banking activities such as accepting deposits and granting loans, while a financial service provider usually offers specialised financial services without operating fully as a licensed bank.
Technological development and digital finance have blurred the distinction between these institutions. Therefore, understanding the differences between a bank and a financial service provider is important in Malaysian banking law.


Bank
Definition
A bank is a licensed financial institution that carries on banking business. Its traditional functions include accepting deposits, honouring cheques, and granting loans.


Main Functions

• Accepts deposits from the public.
• Provides loans and financing facilities.
• Operates savings and current accounts.
• Facilitates payments and money transfers.
• Provides trade finance and investment services.

Legal Status
A bank is legally recognised as carrying on banking business and is subject to strict banking laws and financial regulations.


Regulation
Banks in Malaysia are supervised and regulated by Bank Negara Malaysia under laws such as the Financial Services Act 2013.


Examples of Banks
Examples of banks in Malaysia include:

• Malayan Banking Berhad
• CIMB Bank Berhad
• Public Bank Berhad
• RHB Bank Berhad

Financial Service Provider
Definition
A financial service provider is a company that offers financial-related services but may not legally qualify as a bank because it does not perform the full range of banking activities.


Main Functions

• Provides specialised financial services.
• May offer insurance, investments, remittance, or digital payment services.
• Usually does not accept public deposits like traditional banks.
• May provide electronic wallets or online financial platforms.

Legal Status
A financial service provider may carry out financial activities without being legally classified as a bank.


Regulation
These institutions are regulated according to the type of financial service they provide. Some may still fall under the supervision of Bank Negara Malaysia or other regulatory authorities.


Examples of Financial Service Providers
Examples include:

• Boost – digital wallet and e-payment services.
• Touch ’n Go eWallet – mobile and digital payment services.
• AIA Malaysia – insurance and financial protection services.
• Western Union – remittance and money transfer services.
• Rakuten Trade – investment and share trading services.

Key Differences in Note Form
Bank

• Accepts public deposits.
• Provides loans and financing.
• Maintains customer savings and current accounts.
• Forms part of the official banking system.
• Subject to strict banking regulation.
• Provides full banking services.

Financial Service Provider

• Provides selected financial services only.
• Usually does not accept deposits from the public.
• May focus on digital payments, insurance, investments, or remittance.
• May not legally qualify as a bank.
• Regulation depends on the type of service provided.
• Often operates through financial technology platforms.

Application in a Case Scenario
Scenario
A company called PayLink offers mobile payment services, online money transfers, and digital wallets through a smartphone application. Customers can store electronic money and make digital payments using the application. However, PayLink does not accept savings deposits or provide traditional banking accounts.
A legal issue arises regarding whether PayLink should legally be considered a bank. The court may examine whether the company performs core banking activities such as accepting public deposits and lending money. Even though PayLink provides financial services, it may still be classified only as a financial service provider rather than a bank.
This situation shows that not all financial institutions automatically qualify as banks under banking law.


Critical Analysis
The distinction between banks and financial service providers has become increasingly unclear because of technological advancements. Many financial technology companies now provide services similar to banks, including digital payments and financing facilities.
This creates regulatory challenges because some companies may perform banking-like activities without being subject to the same strict legal requirements as licensed banks. As a result, customers may face greater risks when using unregulated or lightly regulated financial platforms.
Another concern is customer confusion. Consumers may assume that all financial institutions provide equal legal protection, even though licensed banks generally offer stronger financial safeguards and regulatory supervision.
The law must therefore balance innovation with consumer protection. Regulators such as Bank Negara Malaysia play an important role in ensuring that financial institutions operate safely and responsibly.


Unresolved Issues
Regulation of FinTech Companies
Many digital financial companies provide banking-like services, but uncertainty remains regarding whether they should legally be treated as banks.


Consumer Protection
Customers may not fully understand the legal differences between banks and financial service providers, especially concerning deposit protection and financial security.


Cryptocurrency and Digital Finance
Cryptocurrency platforms and decentralised finance systems continue to challenge traditional banking concepts and legal regulations.


Conclusion
Banks and financial service providers both contribute to the financial system, but they are legally different institutions. Banks perform core banking activities such as deposit-taking and lending, while financial service providers usually focus on specialised financial services. As technology continues to transform the financial industry, the distinction between these institutions becomes increasingly complex, making legal regulation and interpretation essential in Malaysian banking law.

​

Malaysian Banking Law – Nature and Business of Banking
Banking as Part of Modern Society
Banking plays an important role in modern trade, commerce, and economic activities. It is an essential part of society because businesses, governments, and individuals depend on banking services for financial transactions, savings, investments, and credit facilities. Without banks, commercial activities and economic growth would be difficult to sustain.
Courts have recognised the importance of banking in supporting economic and social development. Because banking activities are closely connected to trade and commerce, the law treats banking as a significant commercial activity that affects the entire financial system.


Judicial Definitions of Banking Business
Commonwealth of Australia v Bank of New South Wales
In Commonwealth of Australia v Bank of New South Wales, the court stated that the business of banking includes:

• The creation and transfer of credit,
• The granting of loans,
• The purchase and disposal of investments, and
• Other related financial activities.

This definition shows that banking is not limited to accepting deposits. Banks also create financial credit, provide financing facilities, and engage in investment-related activities. Therefore, banking involves a broad range of commercial and financial services.


Commercial Banking Co of Sydney Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation
In Commercial Banking Co of Sydney Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation, the High Court held that the principal business of a bank is the lending of money.
This case highlights the importance of loans and credit facilities in banking operations. Lending money allows banks to support businesses, investments, housing, and consumer spending, which are important for economic development.


Re Securitibank (in liquidation)
In the New Zealand case of Re Securitibank (in liquidation), certain companies described themselves as merchant bankers and were involved in short-term money market activities, bills markets, and various financial services. However, the court decided that these companies were not “carrying on the business of banking” for the purpose of exemption under the Moneylenders Act 1908.
This case demonstrates that not every financial activity automatically amounts to banking business. Even if a company provides financial services or uses the word “banker,” the court may still decide that the company is not legally operating as a bank.


Characteristics of Banking Business
Creation and Transfer of Credit
Banks create credit by lending money to customers. When banks approve loans or financing facilities, they increase the flow of money within the economy. Banks also transfer credit through payment systems, electronic banking, and financial transactions.


Lending of Money
One of the main functions of banks is lending money to individuals and businesses. Loans may include personal loans, housing loans, business financing, and credit card facilities. Lending activities generate profit for banks through interest or financing charges.


Investment Activities
Banks also engage in investment-related activities, including the buying and selling of securities, shares, bonds, and financial instruments. Modern banks may provide investment advice and wealth management services to customers.


Other Related Financial Activities
Modern banks perform many additional activities such as internet banking, mobile payments, foreign exchange transactions, insurance services, and trade financing. These activities show that banking is broader than traditional deposit-taking functions.


Application in a Case Scenario
Scenario
Daniel establishes a financial company that provides short-term financing, investment advice, and foreign exchange services. The company also advertises itself as a “merchant bank.” However, it does not accept public deposits like traditional banks.
A legal dispute arises regarding whether Daniel’s company should legally be classified as a bank. The court may examine the principles established in Re Securitibank (in liquidation) to determine whether the company is truly carrying on banking business or merely engaging in financial activities.
This scenario shows that the legal definition of banking depends on the actual nature of the activities carried out rather than the title used by the company.


Critical Analysis
The cases show that banking is a broad and evolving concept. Modern banks perform many functions beyond accepting deposits and granting loans. Technological advancements and financial innovations continue to expand the meaning of banking business.
However, the absence of a precise definition may create uncertainty. Some financial institutions perform banking-like activities without being fully regulated as banks. This may expose customers to financial risks if such institutions are not properly supervised.
Another issue is the growth of financial technology companies and digital finance platforms. Many of these companies provide services similar to banks, such as electronic payments and lending facilities, but they may not fall clearly within traditional banking definitions.
The courts therefore play an important role in determining whether certain financial activities amount to banking business. At the same time, regulators such as Bank Negara Malaysia must ensure that financial institutions operate safely and comply with banking laws.


Unresolved Issues
One unresolved issue concerns the distinction between banks and financial service providers. Modern financial institutions often provide similar services, making it difficult to determine whether they should legally be treated as banks.
Another issue relates to digital banking and financial technology. Online platforms, digital wallets, and cryptocurrency businesses continue to challenge traditional banking concepts and legal regulations.
There is also concern regarding regulatory gaps. Some companies may perform banking-related activities without being subject to the same strict regulations imposed on licensed banks, potentially creating risks for consumers and the financial system.


Conclusion
Banking is an essential part of modern trade, commerce, and economic development. Courts have recognised that banking includes the creation of credit, lending of money, investment activities, and other related financial services. Cases such as Commonwealth of Australia v Bank of New South Wales, Commercial Banking Co of Sydney Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation, and Re Securitibank (in liquidation) demonstrate that the definition of banking depends on the actual nature of the activities carried out. As financial services continue to evolve, banking law must also adapt to modern economic and technological developments.

​

Malaysian Banking Law – Definition of a Bank at Common Law
General Explanation
At common law, there is no complete or fixed definition of the word “bank.” Courts have recognised that banking activities change over time and differ from one country to another. Because banking develops together with economic and social changes, it is difficult to create one universal definition that covers every banking activity.
In the case of Bank of Chettinad Ltd of Colombo v IT Commissioners of Colombo, the Privy Council explained that the meanings of the words “bank” and “banking” may vary depending on the historical period, the country involved, and the level of economic and social development in that society. This means that what is considered banking in one country or era may not necessarily be regarded the same way elsewhere.
Similarly, in Bank of New South Wales v Commonwealth, Dixon J stated that banking should be given a broad meaning because it forms part of the commercial, economic, and social structure of society. He further explained that it is impossible to provide a complete and inclusive definition of banking because banking practices constantly evolve and differ across countries.


Why There Is No Exhaustive Definition of a Bank
Banking Changes Over Time
Banking activities have developed significantly throughout history. In the past, banks mainly accepted deposits, honoured cheques, and provided loans. Today, banks also provide internet banking, digital payments, investment services, insurance products, and international financial transactions. Because banking services continue to expand, a strict definition may become outdated quickly.


Banking Differs Between Countries
Different countries have different financial systems, laws, and economic conditions. As a result, the meaning of banking may not be identical everywhere. For example, Islamic banking in Malaysia operates according to Shariah principles, while conventional banking systems in other countries may follow different financial practices.


Banking Is Connected to Society and Economy
Banking is closely linked to trade, business, investment, and economic growth. Since economic systems change over time, banking institutions must also adapt to new technologies and financial practices. Therefore, courts prefer to interpret the meaning of banking broadly rather than restrictively.


Application in a Case Scenario
Scenario
Jason establishes a digital financial platform that allows customers to store money electronically, transfer funds internationally, and make online payments through mobile applications. Although the company does not operate like a traditional bank branch, it performs many banking-related services.
A legal issue arises regarding whether Jason’s company should legally be treated as a bank under financial regulations. The court may apply the principles from Bank of Chettinad Ltd of Colombo v IT Commissioners of Colombo and Bank of New South Wales v Commonwealth to determine whether the activities carried out by the company fall within the broad meaning of banking.
This scenario demonstrates why courts avoid giving a narrow definition of banking. Modern financial services continue to evolve, and legal interpretations must remain flexible.


Critical Analysis
The absence of a fixed definition of “bank” provides flexibility and allows the law to adapt to technological and financial developments. Courts can interpret banking broadly to include new financial services such as digital banking, mobile payments, and financial technology platforms.
However, this flexibility may also create legal uncertainty. Businesses may be unsure whether their activities fall within banking regulations. Consumers may also face confusion regarding which institutions are legally recognised and protected as banks.
Another concern is regulatory supervision. As financial technology companies increasingly provide banking-like services, governments and regulators must decide whether these companies should be subject to the same laws and responsibilities as traditional banks.
The broad interpretation of banking also increases the importance of financial regulation. In Malaysia, Bank Negara Malaysia plays a key role in determining which institutions may lawfully conduct banking business and provide financial services.


Unresolved Issues
One unresolved issue is whether modern financial technology companies should legally be classified as banks. Many digital platforms provide services similar to banks but may not fall clearly within traditional legal definitions.
Another unresolved issue concerns cryptocurrency and digital assets. Courts and regulators continue to debate whether activities involving digital currencies should be treated as banking activities under existing laws.
There is also uncertainty regarding future banking technologies. Artificial intelligence, virtual banking platforms, and decentralised finance systems continue to challenge traditional banking concepts and legal frameworks.


Conclusion
At common law, there is no exhaustive or universal definition of the word “bank.” Courts recognise that banking evolves according to historical, economic, and social developments. Cases such as Bank of Chettinad Ltd of Colombo v IT Commissioners of Colombo and Bank of New South Wales v Commonwealth show that banking should be interpreted broadly and flexibly. This approach allows the law to adapt to modern financial developments while ensuring that banking continues to serve the needs of society and the economy.

​

​Malaysian Banking Law – The Legal Relationship Between Banker and Customer

Introduction
Banking is an important service industry that provides financial services to individuals and businesses. A bank’s main concern is to maintain a strong and positive relationship with its customers. To achieve this, banks try to satisfy the many different needs of customers by providing efficient and reliable services. When a bank cannot fulfil a customer’s request, it should handle the matter professionally and carefully in order to preserve trust and confidence.

Before studying banking law, it is necessary to understand the legal relationship between a banker and a customer. This relationship forms the foundation of banking transactions and determines the legal rights, duties, and obligations of both parties. Banking law explains the responsibilities owed by banks to customers and the obligations customers owe to banks.
To understand this relationship clearly, the legal meaning of the words “bank” and “customer” must first be examined. Courts and legal authorities have interpreted these terms through various cases and legal materials, helping to explain how the banker–customer relationship operates in practice.

Definition of a Banker
General Meaning of a Banker
Traditionally, banks mainly accepted deposits, honoured cheques, and granted loans. However, the role of banks has expanded significantly in modern times. Today, banks provide a wide variety of financial and investment services. Because of this development, it is now difficult to define the term “banker” narrowly. Modern bankers are more commonly regarded as financial service providers because they offer numerous banking and financial facilities beyond traditional banking activities.

The definition of a banker is important for two reasons. First, the relationship between a bank and its customer contains special legal characteristics that distinguish it from ordinary commercial relationships. Secondly, many laws and statutes specifically refer to banks, bankers, and banking businesses. Therefore, identifying who qualifies as a banker is important in determining legal rights, liabilities, and regulatory obligations.

Modern Banking Services
Credit Cards and Charge Cards
Modern banks provide credit card and charge card facilities to customers. A credit card allows customers to purchase goods and services using money borrowed from the bank, which is repaid later, often with interest if payment is delayed. A charge card is similar, except the outstanding balance usually must be paid in full within a fixed period. These facilities encourage convenient and cashless transactions.

Foreign Exchange and Money Market Transactions
Banks also provide foreign exchange services involving the buying and selling of currencies. These services are important for international trade, overseas travel, and cross-border investments. In addition, banks participate in money market transactions involving short-term financial instruments that help businesses and financial institutions manage liquidity and financing needs.

Telegraphic and Electronic Transfers
Telegraphic and electronic transfer services allow customers to transfer funds quickly between accounts locally and internationally. These services improve banking efficiency and reduce reliance on physical cash transactions. Electronic transfers are commonly used for salaries, business payments, and remittances.

Internet Banking
Internet banking enables customers to access banking services through online platforms. Customers may check balances, transfer money, pay bills, and manage accounts without visiting a bank branch physically. This service has become increasingly important due to advancements in technology and customer demand for convenience.

Mobile and Digital Payments
Banks now provide mobile banking and digital payment services through smartphones and electronic applications. Customers may conduct banking activities, make purchases, and transfer funds using mobile applications and digital wallets. These services contribute to the growth of a cashless society and improve financial accessibility.

Bills and Trade Finance Facilities
Banks assist businesses by providing trade finance facilities such as letters of credit, guarantees, and bill financing. These facilities support domestic and international trade by reducing payment risks and facilitating commercial transactions between buyers and sellers.

Share Financing and Investment Services
Modern banks also offer investment and wealth management services. Share financing allows customers to borrow funds for investment in shares and securities. Banks may additionally provide investment advice, unit trust services, portfolio management, and other financial planning services to help customers increase their wealth.

Auto-Financing
Banks provide vehicle financing facilities that enable customers to purchase vehicles through instalment payments. Under auto-financing arrangements, the customer repays the financing amount together with interest or profit charges over an agreed period.

Insurance Services
Many banks now cooperate with insurance companies to offer insurance products to customers. This practice is commonly known as bancassurance. Customers may obtain life insurance, medical insurance, and other protection plans through banking institutions.

Custodian and Trust Businesses
Banks may also provide custodian and trust services. Custodian services involve safeguarding valuable documents, securities, or assets on behalf of customers. Trust services involve managing property or assets for the benefit of another party according to legal obligations and trust arrangements.

Application in a Case Scenario
Scenario
Farah opens a savings account with RHB Bank Berhad and later applies for a credit card and auto-financing facility. She also uses internet banking and mobile applications to pay bills and transfer money to family members overseas.
This situation demonstrates that modern banking services extend beyond merely accepting deposits and granting loans. The relationship between Farah and the bank involves various legal duties concerning financing, electronic banking, confidentiality, and consumer protection. The bank is required to manage her funds responsibly, protect her personal information, and ensure secure transactions.

Critical Analysis
The expansion of banking services has transformed banks into comprehensive financial institutions. While this development increases convenience and efficiency for customers, it also creates legal and regulatory challenges.
One major concern is cybersecurity. Internet banking and digital payment systems expose customers to online fraud, hacking, phishing scams, and identity theft. Banks therefore have a responsibility to strengthen security systems and protect customer information from unauthorised access.

Another concern is the imbalance of bargaining power between banks and customers. Banking contracts are often lengthy and complicated, and customers may accept terms without fully understanding their legal consequences. This raises questions regarding fairness, transparency, and consumer protection.

The increasing complexity of financial products also means that customers may face risks they do not fully understand, especially in investment and financing services. Therefore, stricter regulation and greater financial literacy are necessary to ensure responsible banking practices.
In Malaysia, Bank Negara Malaysia plays an important role in regulating financial institutions and ensuring financial stability and consumer confidence.

Unresolved Issues
Despite developments in banking law and technology, several unresolved issues remain in the banker–customer relationship.

One unresolved issue concerns liability for unauthorised online transactions. Customers who become victims of phishing or cyber fraud often dispute whether the loss should be borne by the customer or the bank. Determining responsibility may be difficult because both parties may have contributed to the security failure.

Another issue relates to customer privacy and data protection. Modern banks collect and store large amounts of personal and financial information, increasing the risk of data breaches and misuse of customer information.

There are also ongoing concerns regarding unfair terms in banking contracts. Customers may not fully understand complicated legal clauses contained in financing agreements, credit card contracts, or investment documents.

Furthermore, technological developments such as cryptocurrency, artificial intelligence, and digital banking platforms continue to challenge existing banking laws and regulatory frameworks. Legislators and courts may struggle to keep pace with these rapid changes.

Further Points to Consider
Definition of a Customer
A person generally becomes a customer once the bank agrees to provide banking services, such as opening an account or granting financing facilities.

Duty of Care
Banks owe customers a duty to exercise reasonable care and skill when handling customer transactions and financial matters.

Confidentiality Obligations
Banks are expected to keep customer information confidential unless disclosure is required by law or permitted by the customer.

Statutory Regulation
In Malaysia, banking activities are regulated by legislation such as the Financial Services Act 2013 and supervised by Bank Negara Malaysia.

Consumer Protection
Modern banking law increasingly emphasises consumer protection against fraud, unfair banking practices, and misuse of customer data.

Islamic Banking Principles
Malaysia’s dual banking system includes Islamic banking, which operates according to Shariah principles. Islamic banking may involve different legal concepts and obligations compared to conventional banking.

Conclusion
The banker–customer relationship forms the foundation of banking law. Modern banks no longer perform only traditional functions such as accepting deposits and granting loans. Instead, they now provide a wide range of financial, investment, and digital services. As banking services continue to evolve, the legal relationship between banks and customers becomes increasingly important and complex. Understanding the role of modern bankers, the services they provide, and the legal duties involved is essential for understanding Malayan banking law.

KembaraXtra – Legal Terms – Pay Statement
A pay statement is a written statement provided by an employer showing details of an employee’s wages or salary.
It is commonly referred to as a payslip.
The statement normally includes gross pay, deductions, and net pay received by the employee.
Deductions may include income tax, National Insurance contributions, pension payments, or other authorized amounts.
Employees have statutory rights to receive accurate itemized pay statements from their employers.

​