- Published on
Islamic Capital Market – Sukuk-Summary of Salient Features of Islamic Sukuk
1. Instrument
Original idea: A Sukuk is a certificate of investment in a real asset or project, not a share or a bond.
A Sukuk represents ownership in a specific asset, business activity, or project.
It is not a conventional bond (which represents debt), nor a share (which represents corporate ownership).
Instead, it is an Islamic investment certificate backed by actual assets, giving holders the right to earn returns generated from those assets.
2. Investors
Original idea: Investors are not creditors; they own a proportionate share in the asset.
Expanded explanation:
Sukuk holders are owners, not lenders.
By subscribing to a Sukuk, investors obtain an undivided proportional stake in the underlying asset pool or project.
This ownership entitles them to receive income (rent, profit share) and potentially capital gains.
3. Method of Issuance
Original idea: Based on securitization of non-financial assets into equal-value units.
Expanded explanation:
Sukuk are issued by bundling real, non-debt assets (like property, equipment, or project rights) into investment units.
Each Sukuk certificate represents:
4. Contracts Used to Evidence Ownership
Contracts commonly used include:
a) Ijarah
Sukuk holders own leased assets and receive rental income.
b) Musharakah
Sukuk holders own a share in a partnership venture and receive profit based on the project’s performance.
c) Mudarabah
Sukuk holders provide capital while the issuer provides expertise, with profits shared and losses borne by capital providers (unless negligence occurs).
5. Return
Two types of income depending on structure:
a) Fixed or floating income for Sukuk Ijarah
Rent payments may be predetermined or benchmark-based.
b) Expected profit distribution for equity-based Sukuk
(Mudarabah and Musharakah)
Returns depend entirely on the performance of the project, not a fixed rate.
6. Trading
Sukuk can be traded because they represent ownership rights, not loans.
When traded, what is being sold is the holder’s share in the underlying asset.
7. Tenure
Sukuk are usually medium to long-term instruments, depending on the nature of the project.
8. Issuer
The issuer can be:
The SPV typically holds legal title to the assets on behalf of investors.
9. Rating
Sukuk may receive credit ratings based on the issuer’s creditworthiness and the asset structure.
Ratings depend on:
10. Risk
Sukuk involve several risks, such as:
a) Originator credit risk (for Ijarah Sukuk)
If the originator fails to pay rent on time, income to investors is affected.
b) Market risk
For Ijarah Sukuk, the value of leased assets may change (but hedged by a purchase undertaking).
c) Equity investment risk
For Mudarabah or Musharakah Sukuk, investors must share in business risks.
Although a put option may exist, it still involves project-based uncertainties.
11. Redemption
Sukuk can be redeemed:
Redemption terms are set in the Sukuk agreement.
12. Shariah Compliance Issues
Two main concerns:
a) Generally acceptable structure
As long as Sukuk are backed by assets and not purely monetary claims.
b) Objections regarding fixed-price undertakings
Some scholars oppose clauses such as:
Their concern:
If the buyback price = par value, it resembles a capital guarantee, which is not allowed in equity-based Sukuk.
They prefer market value-based repurchase prices.
1. Instrument
Original idea: A Sukuk is a certificate of investment in a real asset or project, not a share or a bond.
A Sukuk represents ownership in a specific asset, business activity, or project.
It is not a conventional bond (which represents debt), nor a share (which represents corporate ownership).
Instead, it is an Islamic investment certificate backed by actual assets, giving holders the right to earn returns generated from those assets.
2. Investors
Original idea: Investors are not creditors; they own a proportionate share in the asset.
Expanded explanation:
Sukuk holders are owners, not lenders.
By subscribing to a Sukuk, investors obtain an undivided proportional stake in the underlying asset pool or project.
This ownership entitles them to receive income (rent, profit share) and potentially capital gains.
3. Method of Issuance
Original idea: Based on securitization of non-financial assets into equal-value units.
Expanded explanation:
Sukuk are issued by bundling real, non-debt assets (like property, equipment, or project rights) into investment units.
Each Sukuk certificate represents:
- an equal share of asset ownership, and
- entitlement to the income generated.
4. Contracts Used to Evidence Ownership
Contracts commonly used include:
a) Ijarah
Sukuk holders own leased assets and receive rental income.
b) Musharakah
Sukuk holders own a share in a partnership venture and receive profit based on the project’s performance.
c) Mudarabah
Sukuk holders provide capital while the issuer provides expertise, with profits shared and losses borne by capital providers (unless negligence occurs).
5. Return
Two types of income depending on structure:
a) Fixed or floating income for Sukuk Ijarah
Rent payments may be predetermined or benchmark-based.
b) Expected profit distribution for equity-based Sukuk
(Mudarabah and Musharakah)
Returns depend entirely on the performance of the project, not a fixed rate.
6. Trading
Sukuk can be traded because they represent ownership rights, not loans.
When traded, what is being sold is the holder’s share in the underlying asset.
7. Tenure
Sukuk are usually medium to long-term instruments, depending on the nature of the project.
8. Issuer
The issuer can be:
- Agent (wakil)
- Special Purpose Vehicle (SPV)
- Partner (for Musharakah structures)
The SPV typically holds legal title to the assets on behalf of investors.
9. Rating
Sukuk may receive credit ratings based on the issuer’s creditworthiness and the asset structure.
Ratings depend on:
- jurisdiction
- legal structure
- type of assets
- cash flow stability
10. Risk
Sukuk involve several risks, such as:
a) Originator credit risk (for Ijarah Sukuk)
If the originator fails to pay rent on time, income to investors is affected.
b) Market risk
For Ijarah Sukuk, the value of leased assets may change (but hedged by a purchase undertaking).
c) Equity investment risk
For Mudarabah or Musharakah Sukuk, investors must share in business risks.
Although a put option may exist, it still involves project-based uncertainties.
11. Redemption
Sukuk can be redeemed:
- at maturity, or
- earlier if certain events occur (e.g., default triggers, early dissolution)
Redemption terms are set in the Sukuk agreement.
12. Shariah Compliance Issues
Two main concerns:
a) Generally acceptable structure
As long as Sukuk are backed by assets and not purely monetary claims.
b) Objections regarding fixed-price undertakings
Some scholars oppose clauses such as:
- fixed exercise price options in Ijarah
- purchase undertakings in Musharakah and Mudarabah Sukuk
Their concern:
If the buyback price = par value, it resembles a capital guarantee, which is not allowed in equity-based Sukuk.
They prefer market value-based repurchase prices.
0 Comments