- Published on
Islamic Derivatives – Final Buyer & Delivery in Futures
A. Your Understanding (Correct)
B. What Happens at Expiry
If Physical Delivery Contract
If Cash-Settled Contract
C. Important Clarification
D. Why Most Traders Don’t End Up Delivering
E. Real Market Behavior
F. Shari’ah Insight
Final Takeaway
If you want, I can give a step-by-step chain example (A → B → C → D) showing how the obligation moves 👍
Answer
✔️ Yes — in general, the last holder must fulfill the contract at expiry
❗ But only if the contract is physically settled
Islamic Derivatives – Final Buyer & Delivery in Futures
A. Your Understanding (Correct)
B. What Happens at Expiry
If Physical Delivery Contract
If Cash-Settled Contract
C. Important Clarification
D. Why Most Traders Don’t End Up Delivering
E. Real Market Behavior
F. Shari’ah Insight
Final Takeaway
If you want, I can give a step-by-step chain example (A → B → C → D) showing how the obligation moves 👍
A. Your Understanding (Correct)
- A futures contract can be:
- Bought and sold many times
- At expiry:
- The final buyer (long position)
- The final seller (short position)
- ✔️ Legally obligated to complete the contract
B. What Happens at Expiry
If Physical Delivery Contract
- Final buyer:
- ✔️ Must receive the commodity
- Final seller:
- ✔️ Must deliver the commodity
If Cash-Settled Contract
- ❌ No physical delivery
- ✔️ Only price difference is paid in cash
C. Important Clarification
- Not all futures require delivery:
- Some are designed as cash-settled from the start
D. Why Most Traders Don’t End Up Delivering
- Most traders:
- Exit before expiry
- So:
- They transfer obligation to someone else
E. Real Market Behavior
- ✔️ Theoretically:
- Delivery should happen
- ❗ Practically:
- Very few contracts reach delivery stage
- Most are:
- Closed early
- Or cash-settled
F. Shari’ah Insight
- Even though delivery is possible:
- Frequent non-delivery usage leads to:
- Gharar
- Maisir
- Frequent non-delivery usage leads to:
- Because:
- Trading becomes price speculation rather than real exchange
Final Takeaway
- ✔️ Yes — the final buyer must receive the commodity
- ❗ But only:
- If contract is physically settled
- 👉 In reality:
- Most contracts never reach that stage
If you want, I can give a step-by-step chain example (A → B → C → D) showing how the obligation moves 👍
Answer
✔️ Yes — in general, the last holder must fulfill the contract at expiry
❗ But only if the contract is physically settled
Islamic Derivatives – Final Buyer & Delivery in Futures
A. Your Understanding (Correct)
- A futures contract can be:
- Bought and sold many times
- At expiry:
- The final buyer (long position)
- The final seller (short position)
- ✔️ Legally obligated to complete the contract
B. What Happens at Expiry
If Physical Delivery Contract
- Final buyer:
- ✔️ Must receive the commodity
- Final seller:
- ✔️ Must deliver the commodity
If Cash-Settled Contract
- ❌ No physical delivery
- ✔️ Only price difference is paid in cash
C. Important Clarification
- Not all futures require delivery:
- Some are designed as cash-settled from the start
D. Why Most Traders Don’t End Up Delivering
- Most traders:
- Exit before expiry
- So:
- They transfer obligation to someone else
E. Real Market Behavior
- ✔️ Theoretically:
- Delivery should happen
- ❗ Practically:
- Very few contracts reach delivery stage
- Most are:
- Closed early
- Or cash-settled
F. Shari’ah Insight
- Even though delivery is possible:
- Frequent non-delivery usage leads to:
- Gharar
- Maisir
- Frequent non-delivery usage leads to:
- Because:
- Trading becomes price speculation rather than real exchange
Final Takeaway
- ✔️ Yes — the final buyer must receive the commodity
- ❗ But only:
- If contract is physically settled
- 👉 In reality:
- Most contracts never reach that stage
If you want, I can give a step-by-step chain example (A → B → C → D) showing how the obligation moves 👍
0 Comments