FINANCE

Published on
Islamic Derivatives – Issues with Futures Contracts  
  • General view:
    • Muslim scholars have differing opinions
    • Many argue futures contracts do not fully comply with Shari’ah principles


1. Absence of Countervalues at Contract Stage
  • No immediate payment and no delivery of goods/services
  • Transaction exists only on paper (speculative intent)
  • Shari’ah requirement:
    • At least one countervalue must be present for validity
  • Comparison with Salam:
    • Buyer pays in advance
    • Seller delivers later
  • Issue:
    • Futures defer both payment and delivery, which is not permitted


2. Short Selling (Selling Without Ownership)
  • Seller sells commodities not owned or possessed
  • Violates principle:
    • Sale must involve transfer of ownership
  • Ownership cannot transfer if seller does not own the asset


3. Lack of Actual Possession Before Resale
  • Many futures trades occur without physical delivery
  • Shari’ah requires:
    • Ownership and possession before resale
  • This condition is often not fulfilled


4. Sale of Debt for Debt (Prohibited)
  • Both payment and delivery are deferred
  • Results in:
    • Bai al-kali bil-kali
  • This type of transaction is prohibited in Shari’ah


5. Speculation, Gambling, and Uncertainty
  • High level of speculation in futures markets
  • Linked to:
    • Maisir (gambling)
    • Gharar (uncertainty)
  • Both are strictly prohibited
  • Can lead to:
    • Price volatility in real markets


Overall Conclusion
  • Key concerns:
    • Lack of ownership
    • Deferred countervalues
    • Speculative nature
  • These issues make conventional futures contracts problematic under Islamic law

Picture
0 Comments

Author

Facts about finance