FINANCE

Published on
KembaraXtra – Islamic Derivatives: Delay in Delivery in Futures Contracts & Why It Is Considered a Debt


🔹 What is Delay in Delivery?
 
In a futures contract:
  • The seller agrees to deliver goods at a future date
  • No goods are given at the time of agreement
 
👉 This is called deferred delivery


🔹 Why Is It Considered a Debt?
 
In Islamic finance, once a contract is made:
  • The seller now has an obligation to deliver goods in the future
  • This obligation is treated as a debt (dayn)
 
👉 Because:
  • The buyer is owed the goods
  • Even though delivery is just “late”, it becomes a binding liability


🔹 Simple Explanation
 
Think of it like this:
  • If someone promises to give you something later
  • You now have a right over that item
  • They now owe you that item
 
👉 That “owing” = debt


🔹 In Futures Contracts
  • Seller owes → future delivery of goods (debt)
  • Buyer owes → future payment (debt)
 
👉 So both sides owe something →
This becomes debt vs debt (Bai al-Kali bil-Kali)


🔹 Why This Is Problematic in Islam
 
Islam allows:
  • ✅ One side delayed (like in Salam)
 
But does NOT allow:
  • ❌ Both sides delayed
 
Because it leads to:
  • Uncertainty (gharar)
  • Risk of non-fulfillment
  • No real exchange at contract time


🔹 Important Clarification
 
✔ It’s not just “being late” casually
✔ It is a formal obligation created by contract
 
👉 That’s why it is treated as a debt, not just a delay


🔹 Simple Summary
  • Delay in delivery = seller owes goods in the future
  • This obligation = debt (dayn)
  • In futures, both sides owe → debt for debt ❌
  • This is why it is not Shariah-compliant
 

​
Picture
0 Comments

Author

Facts about finance