FINANCE

Published on
KembaraXtra – Islamic Derivatives: Risk & Shariah Comparison Between Futures and Options (Margin vs Premium)


🔹 1. Risk Structure
 
🔸 Futures Contracts
  • Both buyer (long) and seller (short):
    • Have obligation
    • Face unlimited risk
 
👉 That’s why:
  • Both must deposit margin
 
✔ Risk is shared on both sides


🔸 Option Contracts
  • Buyer:
    • Has right only (not obligation)
    • Risk is limited to premium
  • Seller (writer):
    • Has full obligation
    • Risk can be very high or unlimited
 
👉 That’s why:
  • Only seller needs margin
 
✔ Risk is uneven (one-sided)


🔹 2. Margin vs Premium (Risk Meaning)
  • Margin (Futures):
    • Security to ensure both parties can pay losses
    • Supports a binding contract
  • Premium (Options):
    • Price paid for a right only
    • Buyer risks little, seller risks more


🔹 3. Shariah Perspective
 
🔸 Futures Contracts
 
Issues:
  • ❌ Both payment & delivery deferred (debt vs debt)
  • ❌ Speculation (maisir)
  • ❌ Uncertainty (gharar)
 
👉 Generally not permissible


🔸 Option Contracts
 
Issues:
  • ❌ Premium paid for intangible right
  • ❌ High uncertainty (gharar)
  • ❌ Speculative nature (maisir)
  • ❌ No real ownership
 
👉 Also generally not permissible


🔹 4. Key Difference in Shariah Concern
  • Futures:
    • Problem = structure of contract (debt vs debt)
  • Options:
    • Problem = nature of right + premium + speculation


🔹 5. Simple Comparison (Easy Notes)
  • Futures:
    • Both sides obligated
    • Both deposit margin
    • Debt vs debt ❌
  • Options:
    • Buyer has right only
    • Seller bears more risk
    • Premium + speculation ❌


🔹 6. Final Simple Summary
  • Margin = protects mutual obligation (futures)
  • Premium = pays for one-sided right (options)
  • Both structures involve elements that are problematic in Shariah
 

​
Picture
0 Comments

Author

Facts about finance