FINANCE

Published on
KembaraXtra – Islamic Derivatives: What Happens If There Is No Margin in Futures Contracts (Case Example)


🔹 Key Idea
 
👉 Margin exists to protect both parties
👉 Without margin → the system becomes very risky and unstable


🔹 Case Scenario (Without Margin) 🌴
 
📌 Agreement
  • Buyer agrees to buy 1 ton palm oil at RM4,000
  • Seller agrees to sell at RM4,000
  • ❌ No margin is deposited


📅 After 1 Month (Market Price Changes)
 
🔸 Case 1: Price Rises to RM4,800
👉 Buyer:
  • Gains RM800 ✅
 
👉 Seller:
  • Loses RM800 ❌


🚨 Problem (No Margin)
  • Seller now has to pay RM800
  • But what if the seller:
    • Has no money?
    • Refuses to pay?
 
👉 Buyer may not receive profit


📅 Case 2: Price Falls to RM3,200
 
👉 Buyer:
  • Loses RM800 ❌
 
👉 Seller:
  • Gains RM800 ✅


🚨 Problem Again
  • Buyer must pay RM800
  • If buyer cannot pay →
 
👉 Seller may not receive profit


🔹 What Goes Wrong Without Margin
 
❌ 1. High Risk of Default
  • Parties may fail to pay losses


❌ 2. No Guarantee of Profit
  • Winning party might not get paid


❌ 3. Large Loss Accumulation
  • Losses build up until the end
  • Can become too big to handle


❌ 4. Market Becomes Unstable
  • Lack of trust
  • Fewer participants
  • Possible market collapse


🔹 Why Margin Solves This
 
✔ Money is already deposited
✔ Losses are paid daily
✔ Default risk is minimized
✔ Market stays stable


🔹 Simple Analogy
  • Without margin → like lending money with no guarantee
  • With margin → like holding a security deposit


🔹 Simple Summary
  • No margin = ❌ high risk, no protection
  • Traders may not pay losses
  • Profits are not guaranteed
  • 👉 Margin is essential for safety and trust
 

​
Picture
0 Comments

Author

Facts about finance