THE ULTIMATE

Kembara XTRA 

Published on
Islamic Contract – Bay’ al-Istisnā‘: Rebate Clause in Istisnā‘ Contracts
Q1: What is a rebate in an istisnā‘ contract?
Answer
A rebate refers to:
a reduction or waiver of part of the payment obligation granted by the seller or manufacturer to the purchaser.
In istisnā‘ financing, rebates commonly arise when:
  • the purchaser makes early payment (prepayment);
  • settlement occurs earlier than agreed.
The rebate functions similarly to:
ibrā’ (waiver or remission)
in Islamic finance.


Q2: What is the AAOIFI position regarding rebate clauses?
Answer
According to AAOIFI Shariah Standard (Para 4/1/3):
  • granting a rebate for prepayment is permissible;
  • however, the rebate:
must not be stipulated at the time the contract is concluded.
This means:
  • the seller may voluntarily grant a rebate later;
  • but the contract should not initially guarantee the rebate.


Why Does AAOIFI Restrict Pre-Agreed Rebate Clauses?
Explanation
AAOIFI is concerned that:
  • pre-agreed rebates linked to early payment
    may resemble:
interest recalculation in conventional loans.
If rebate becomes contractually guaranteed:
  • the transaction may appear similar to:
    • reducing interest because debt is settled earlier.
Therefore:
  • AAOIFI prefers rebates to remain:
    • voluntary;
    • discretionary;
    • not contractually binding.


Q3: What is the BNM position regarding rebate clauses?
Answer
According to the BNM Policy Document on Istisnā‘ (Para 25.3):
  • a rebate clause must be incorporated into the istisnā‘ contract
    if:
required by the relevant authority or regulator.
This approach:
  • promotes transparency;
  • protects customers;
  • standardises industry practice.
Under BNM:
  • rebate formulas may be predetermined and disclosed clearly.


Comparison Notes: AAOIFI vs BNM on Rebate Clauses
AAOIFI Position
  • Rebate for prepayment permissible.
  • Must not be stipulated during contract formation.
  • Rebate remains voluntary.
BNM Position
  • Rebate clause may be mandatory if required by regulator.
  • Rebate mechanism may be stated in contract.
  • Promotes transparency and customer protection.


Case Study 1: AAOIFI Approach — Voluntary Rebate
A developer enters into an istisnā‘ contract to construct a warehouse.
Contract Details
  • Contract price = RM5,000,000
  • Payment period = 5 years
The contract does NOT mention any rebate clause.
After 3 years:
  • purchaser settles remaining balance early.
The developer voluntarily grants:
  • RM200,000 rebate.


Final Settlement Calculation
5{,}000{,}000 - 200{,}000 = 4{,}800{,}000
5{,}000{,}000 - 200{,}000 = 4{,}800{,}000
Analysis
  • Rebate was not pre-promised.
  • Granted voluntarily after prepayment.
Result
✅ Permissible under AAOIFI.


Case Study 2: BNM Approach — Rebate Clause Included in Contract
An Islamic bank finances construction of apartment units under istisnā‘.
Contract Details
  • Contract price = RM20,000,000
  • Financing tenure = 10 years
The contract expressly states:
“Purchaser shall be entitled to rebate upon early settlement according to the bank’s rebate formula.”
After 6 years:
  • purchaser settles financing early.
The bank grants:
  • RM1,500,000 rebate.


Final Settlement Calculation
20,000,000 - 1,500,000 = 18,500,000
Analysis
  • Rebate clause was contractually stated.
  • Rebate mechanism transparent and predetermined.
Result
✅ Permissible under BNM framework.


Q4: Why is rebate important in istisnā‘ financing?
Answer
Rebate mechanisms:
  • encourage early settlement;
  • promote fairness;
  • prevent unjust enrichment;
  • align financing obligations with actual commercial exposure.
They are especially important in:
  • long-term construction financing;
  • project financing;
  • Islamic banking facilities.


Important Principle
In Islamic finance:
  • rebate should not become a disguised form of interest recalculation.
Therefore:
  • AAOIFI prefers voluntary rebate;
  • BNM permits contractual rebate for regulatory transparency.
Both approaches aim to:
  • preserve fairness;
  • maintain Shariah compliance;
  • avoid ribā-like structures.

Picture
Published on
​Islamic Contract – Bay’ al-Istisnā‘: Application of Istisnā‘ in Islamic Finance
Q1: How is istisnā‘ applied in contemporary Islamic finance?
Answer
In contemporary Islamic finance, istisnā‘ is widely used in:
  • Islamic banking;
  • project financing;
  • industrial manufacturing; and
  • ṣukūk structuring.
Istisnā‘ is especially suitable for:
assets that need to be manufactured, constructed, or developed according to specific requirements.
This is because the contract allows:
  • future construction/manufacturing;
  • flexible payment arrangements; and
  • delivery at a future date.


Q2: What types of projects commonly use istisnā‘ financing?
Answer
Istisnā‘ is commonly used in financing:
  • housing construction;
  • infrastructure development;
  • industrial manufacturing;
  • advanced technology industries.
Examples include manufacturing or construction of:
  • aircraft;
  • automobiles;
  • ships;
  • factory equipment;
  • buildings;
  • roads;
  • bridges.


Q3: Why is istisnā‘ suitable for construction and manufacturing industries?
Answer
Istisnā‘ is suitable because:
  • the asset does not need to exist at contract formation;
  • assets can be custom-built according to specifications;
  • payment can be:
    • progressive;
    • deferred;
    • or upfront.
This flexibility makes istisnā‘ highly practical for:
  • long-term projects;
  • engineering industries;
  • infrastructure financing.


Case Study 1: Housing Construction Financing
An Islamic bank finances the construction of residential houses through istisnā‘.
Contract Details
  • Construction of 50 houses
  • Total project value = RM25,000,000
  • Construction period = 3 years


Structure
First Istisnā‘ Contract
Between:
  • home developer;
  • Islamic bank.
The bank agrees to deliver completed houses.


Second Istisnā‘ Contract (Parallel Istisnā‘)
Between:
  • Islamic bank;
  • construction company.
The contractor constructs the houses.
Construction Cost
RM22,000,000


Bank’s Profit Calculation
25{,}000{,}000 - 22{,}000{,}000 = 3{,}000{,}000
25{,}000{,}000 - 22{,}000{,}000 = 3{,}000{,}000
Analysis
  • Houses are constructed according to specifications.
  • Parallel istisnā‘ structure used.
  • Common application in Islamic banking.


Case Study 2: Aircraft Manufacturing Financing
An airline company requires customised aircraft.
Contract Details
  • Aircraft manufacturing price = RM500,000,000
  • Delivery period = 5 years
The Islamic financial institution enters into:
  • istisnā‘ arrangement with airline;
  • parallel istisnā‘ with aircraft manufacturer.
Analysis
Istisnā‘ is suitable because:
  • aircraft require future manufacturing;
  • detailed specifications necessary;
  • project involves long-term production.


Q4: How is istisnā‘ applied in ṣukūk structures?
Answer
Istisnā‘ is widely used in:
ṣukūk (Islamic bonds) for infrastructure and development projects.
In ṣukūk istisnā‘:
  • investors finance construction/manufacturing projects;
  • returns are generated from project completion and operation.


Case Study 3: Infrastructure Ṣukūk Using Istisnā‘
A government issues ṣukūk to finance construction of a highway.
Project Value
RM2 billion
Structure
  • Investors subscribe to ṣukūk.
  • Funds used to construct highway through istisnā‘.
  • Upon completion:
    • highway may be leased using ijārah structure.
Analysis
Istisnā‘ finances:
  • construction stage.
Ijārah finances:
  • operational/use stage after completion.


Q5: What is an example of green ṣukūk using istisnā‘?
Answer
The world’s first green ṣukūk issued in Malaysia by:
Tadau Energy Sdn Bhd
was structured using:
  • istisnā‘; combined with
  • ijārah.
The ṣukūk financed:
  • environmentally sustainable solar energy projects.


How the Structure Worked
Istisnā‘ Stage
  • solar facilities were constructed.
Ijārah Stage
  • completed facilities were leased to generate returns.
This demonstrates how:
  • istisnā‘ finances creation/construction;
  • ijārah monetises operational use.


Case Study 4: Green Energy Project
A renewable energy company constructs solar power facilities.
Project Cost
RM250,000,000
Structure
  1. Investors fund project via ṣukūk.
  2. Solar facilities constructed through istisnā‘.
  3. Completed facilities leased under ijārah.
Analysis
  • Istisnā‘ used during construction.
  • Ijārah used after completion to generate rental returns.
This structure supports:
  • sustainable financing;
  • socially responsible investment.


Important Difference Between Istisnā‘ and Ijārah in Finance
Istisnā‘
Used for:
  • construction;
  • manufacturing;
  • creation of assets.
Example
Building:
  • houses;
  • aircraft;
  • infrastructure.


Ijārah
Used after asset completion for:
  • leasing;
  • operational usage;
  • generating rental income.
Example
Leasing:
  • completed buildings;
  • machinery;
  • solar facilities.


Important Principle
Istisnā‘ plays a major role in Islamic finance because it enables:
  • Shariah-compliant project financing;
  • infrastructure development;
  • industrial manufacturing;
  • sustainable investment projects;
while ensuring:
  • genuine asset creation;
  • ownership transfer; and
  • real economic activity.

Picture
Published on
Islamic Contract – Bay’ al-Istisnā‘: When Does the Customer Make Payment?
Q1: When does the customer pay in an istisnā‘ contract?
Answer
In an istisnā‘ contract, payment is very flexible.
The customer may pay:
  1. fully in advance;
  2. progressively during construction;
  3. upon completion and delivery; or
  4. on a deferred instalment basis.
Unlike salam contracts:
  • full upfront payment is NOT required in istisnā‘.
This flexibility is one of the reasons why istisnā‘ is widely used in:
  • construction financing;
  • infrastructure projects;
  • Islamic banking.


Q2: What are the common payment methods in istisnā‘?
1. Upfront Payment
The purchaser pays the entire price at the beginning of the contract.


Example
A customer orders customised furniture.
Contract Price
RM100,000
Payment
  • RM100,000 paid immediately upon signing.
Delivery
Furniture delivered after 6 months.


2. Progressive Payment (Most Common)
The purchaser pays according to stages of completion.
This is commonly used in:
  • housing construction;
  • infrastructure projects;
  • manufacturing industries.


Example
Construction of a house.
Contract Price
RM500,000
Payment Structure
  • RM100,000 upon signing;
  • RM200,000 when structure completed;
  • RM200,000 upon final delivery.
Analysis
Payments follow construction progress.


3. Payment Upon Completion
The purchaser only pays after the asset is completed and delivered.


Example
A factory orders machinery.
Contract Price
RM2,000,000
Payment
Full payment made:
  • after machinery delivered.


4. Deferred Instalment Payment
The purchaser pays over time after delivery.
This structure is commonly used in:
  • Islamic banking financing.


Example
An Islamic bank constructs a house through istisnā‘.
Construction Cost
RM400,000
The bank delivers completed house to customer.
The customer pays:
  • RM2,500 monthly instalments for 20 years.
Analysis
  • House constructed first.
  • Customer repays gradually after delivery.


Q3: In parallel istisnā‘, who pays whom and when?
Answer
Parallel istisnā‘ involves:
  • two separate contracts.
Thus:
  • payment flows separately.


Example of Parallel Istisnā‘ Payment Flow
First Contract
Customer ↔ Islamic Bank
The customer agrees to buy:
  • factory building.
Selling Price
RM15,000,000
Customer Payment
  • progressive instalments over 10 years.


Second Contract
Islamic Bank ↔ Contractor
The bank appoints contractor to build factory.
Construction Cost
RM12,000,000
Bank Payment to Contractor
  • according to construction milestones.


Important Point
The two payment obligations are:
  • separate;
  • independent.
The customer:
  • pays bank.
The bank:
  • separately pays contractor.


Q4: Can payment timing be revised later?
Answer
Yes, payment schedules may be revised by mutual agreement.
However:
  • price cannot be increased merely because payment is delayed.
Otherwise:
  • it may resemble ribā.


Simplified Summary
Istisnā‘ Payment Flexibility
Permissible Payment Timing
✅ Upfront
✅ Progressive
✅ Upon completion
✅ Deferred instalments


Most Common Practice in Islamic Finance
Construction Projects
➡️ Progressive payment
Islamic Home Financing
➡️ Deferred instalments after delivery
Manufacturing Projects
➡️ Milestone-based payments


Important Principle
Istisnā‘ is designed to facilitate:
  • long-term construction;
  • manufacturing;
  • infrastructure financing.
Therefore:
Shariah allows flexible payment arrangements to suit commercial needs.

​
Picture
Published on
​Islamic Contract – Bay’ al-Salam: Definition and Nature of Forward Sale
Q1: What is Bay’ al-Salam?
Answer
Literally, the word salam means:
“giving in advance.”
Technically, Bay’ al-Salam (hereinafter, salam) refers to:
a sale contract in which the purchaser pays the full purchase price in advance for specific commodities to be delivered in the future.
Thus, salam is:
  • a forward sale contract;
  • where payment is immediate;
  • while delivery of goods is deferred.


Q2: What are the main characteristics of a salam contract?
Answer
The main characteristics of salam are:
1. Full Advance Payment
The purchase price must be:
  • fully paid at the contract session.
2. Future Delivery
The commodities are delivered:
  • at a future agreed date.
3. Specific Commodities
The goods must be:
  • clearly specified;
  • measurable;
  • standardised.
4. Commodity-Based Contract
Salam usually applies to:
  • fungible goods;
  • commodities;
  • agricultural products.


Q3: Why is salam permitted although the goods do not yet exist?
Answer
Normally, Islamic law prohibits:
selling something that does not yet exist or is not possessed.
However, salam is permitted as:
an exception based on necessity (ḥājah) and public interest.
Historically:
  • farmers and traders needed advance financing before harvest or production.
Salam allows:
  • producers to obtain immediate capital;
  • purchasers to secure future supply of goods.


Q4: What types of commodities are commonly used in salam?
Answer
Salam commonly involves:
  • wheat;
  • rice;
  • dates;
  • palm oil;
  • sugar;
  • agricultural produce;
  • standardised commodities.
The goods must be:
  • precisely describable;
  • measurable by quantity, weight, or volume.


Case Study 1: Agricultural Salam Contract
A farmer requires financing before harvesting rice crops.
A buyer enters into salam contract with the farmer.
Contract Details
  • Commodity: 10,000 kg of rice
  • Salam price: RM50,000
  • Delivery date: 1 December 2027
The buyer:
  • pays RM50,000 immediately.
The farmer:
  • delivers the rice at the agreed future date.


Analysis
  • Full payment made upfront.
  • Commodity delivered later.
  • Commodity clearly specified.
Result
✅ Valid salam contract.


Case Study 2: Palm Oil Salam Financing
An Islamic bank finances a palm oil producer through salam.
Contract Details
  • Commodity: 100 metric tonnes of crude palm oil
  • Purchase price: RM400,000
  • Delivery period: 6 months
The bank:
  • pays RM400,000 immediately.
The producer:
  • supplies palm oil after 6 months.


Analysis
The producer benefits because:
  • immediate financing obtained.
The bank benefits because:
  • future commodity supply secured.
Result
✅ Permissible salam arrangement.


Q5: What is the main difference between salam and istisnā‘?
Answer
Although both involve:
  • future delivery of goods,
they differ significantly.


Difference Between Salam and Istisnā‘
Salam
Payment
Full price paid upfront.
Subject Matter
Usually commodities or fungible goods.
Delivery
Deferred.
Example
Rice, wheat, palm oil.


Istisnā‘
Payment
Flexible:
  • upfront;
  • progressive;
  • deferred.
Subject Matter
Manufactured or constructed assets.
Delivery
Deferred.
Example
Buildings, ships, aircraft.


Example Comparing Salam and Istisnā‘
Salam Example
A buyer pays:
  • RM100,000 now
    for:
  • 50 tonnes of wheat
    to be delivered after harvest.


Istisnā‘ Example
A company commissions:
  • construction of factory machinery
    worth:
  • RM5,000,000,
    with payment made progressively during manufacturing.


Important Principle
Salam is permitted because:
  • it facilitates financing for producers and farmers;
  • it fulfils commercial needs;
  • it promotes economic activity.
However:
  • strict conditions apply to minimise uncertainty (gharar) and disputes.

Picture
Published on
Islamic Contract-Classification of Sharīʿah Contracts and Principles


Exchange Contracts
Bayʿ al-Murābaḥah
Definition
A sale contract where the seller discloses the original cost of an asset and sells it to the buyer with an agreed profit margin.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Customer identifies asset needed.
  2. Bank/seller purchases the asset.
  3. Seller discloses cost and profit margin.
  4. Asset is sold to customer at deferred or lump-sum payment.
Example
Islamic home and vehicle financing.


Bayʿ al-Salam
Definition
A contract where payment is made in advance for goods delivered at a future date.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Buyer pays full amount upfront.
  2. Seller agrees to deliver goods later.
  3. Quantity, quality, and delivery date must be specified.
Example
Agricultural financing.


Bayʿ al-ʿĪnah
Definition
A transaction where an asset is sold on deferred payment and repurchased immediately for cash at a lower price.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Seller sells asset on credit.
  2. Buyer resells asset for immediate cash.
  3. Buyer obtains liquidity.
Example
Personal financing facility.


Bayʿ al-Dayn
Definition
A contract involving the sale or transfer of debt receivables.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Creditor owns debt.
  2. Debt is transferred or sold to another party.
  3. New owner collects debt from debtor.
Example
Islamic capital market instruments.


Ijārah
Definition
A leasing contract where the right to use an asset is transferred for rental payment.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Lessor purchases asset.
  2. Asset is leased to customer.
  3. Customer pays rental periodically.
  4. Ownership may transfer later under separate agreement.
Example
Vehicle and equipment leasing.


Bayʿ al-Istiṣnāʿ
Definition
A contract for manufacturing or constructing an asset according to agreed specifications.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Buyer places order.
  2. Manufacturer produces asset.
  3. Payment may be staged or deferred.
  4. Completed asset delivered later.
Example
Construction and infrastructure projects.


Bayʿ al-Istijrār
Definition
A contract involving continuous supply of goods with periodic settlement.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Buyer continuously receives goods.
  2. Quantity accumulates over time.
  3. Payment settled periodically.
Example
Retail and utility supplies.


Tawarruq
Definition
A financing arrangement using commodity trading to obtain cash liquidity.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Bank purchases commodity.
  2. Bank sells commodity to customer on deferred payment.
  3. Customer sells commodity to third party for cash.
  4. Customer obtains liquidity.
Example
Personal financing.


Bayʿ al-Ṣarf
Definition
A contract involving exchange of currencies or monetary values.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Two currencies are exchanged.
  2. Exchange rate agreed upon.
  3. Immediate possession/delivery is required.
Example
Foreign currency exchange.


Musāwamah
Definition
A sale contract where the seller is not required to disclose the original cost price.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Seller offers asset for sale.
  2. Buyer and seller negotiate price freely.
  3. Agreed price is finalized.
  4. Ownership transfers upon completion.
Example
Ordinary market trading.


Tawliyah
Definition
A sale contract where the seller transfers an asset at the exact original purchase cost without profit.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Seller discloses original cost.
  2. Asset sold at same purchase price.
  3. Ownership transferred to buyer.
Example
Friendly or trust-based sale.


Partnership Contracts
Mushārakah
Definition
A partnership where all partners contribute capital and share profit and loss.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Partners contribute capital.
  2. Business activities conducted jointly.
  3. Profit shared according to agreement.
  4. Loss shared according to capital contribution.
Example
Joint venture financing.


Muḍārabah
Definition
A partnership where one party provides capital and another provides expertise.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Investor provides capital.
  2. Entrepreneur manages business.
  3. Profit shared according to agreed ratio.
  4. Financial loss borne by investor unless negligence occurs.
Example
Investment funds.


Agency Contract
Wakālah
Definition
A contract where one party appoints another party as an agent to perform tasks on their behalf.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Principal appoints agent.
  2. Agent acts within authorized scope.
  3. Agent may receive fee.
  4. Transactions carried out for principal.
Example
Investment agency services.


Charity Contracts
Qard
Definition
An interest-free loan provided for welfare or assistance purposes.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Lender provides money.
  2. Borrower uses funds temporarily.
  3. Borrower repays exact amount borrowed.
Example
Emergency financial assistance.


Wadīʿah
Definition
A contract where assets or money are entrusted to another party for safekeeping.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Depositor places money/assets with custodian.
  2. Custodian safeguards asset.
  3. Asset returned upon request.
Example
Islamic savings accounts.


Hibah
Definition
A voluntary transfer of ownership without consideration.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Donor offers gift.
  2. Recipient accepts gift.
  3. Ownership transfers immediately.
Example
Bank discretionary gifts to customers.


Security Contracts
Kafālah
Definition
A contract where a guarantor guarantees another party’s obligation.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Guarantor assumes responsibility.
  2. Debtor fulfills obligation.
  3. Guarantor compensates if debtor defaults.
Example
Bank guarantee.


Rahn
Definition
A contract where an asset is pledged as collateral for debt.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Borrower pledges asset.
  2. Creditor holds collateral.
  3. Asset may be sold if borrower defaults.
Example
Islamic pawn broking.


Supporting Contracts and Principles
Waʿd
Definition
A promise made by one party to undertake an action in the future.
Mechanism of Action
  1. One party makes promise.
  2. Promise supports financial transaction.
  3. Promise may become binding.
Example
Islamic hedging arrangement.


Ḥiwālah
Definition
A contract involving transfer of debt responsibility from one party to another.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Original debtor transfers obligation.
  2. New debtor accepts liability.
  3. Creditor claims from new debtor.
Example
Remittance services.


Muqāṣṣah
Definition
A settlement mechanism through offsetting mutual debts.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Two parties owe each other.
  2. Debts are offset.
  3. Only remaining balance is payable.
Example
Interbank settlements.


Ibrāʾ
Definition
A voluntary waiver or reduction of debt by the creditor.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Creditor forgives part/all of debt.
  2. Debtor’s obligation is reduced.
  3. Liability ends partially or fully.
Example
Early settlement rebate in financing.

​
Picture
Published on
​Islamic Contract – Bay’ al-Murābahah: Emphasis on Murābahah to the Purchase Orderer (MPO)
Q1: What is Murābahah to the Purchase Orderer (MPO)?
Answer:
Murābahah to the Purchase Orderer (MPO) is a special form of murābahah in which a customer requests a seller or Islamic bank to purchase a specific asset on their behalf. The customer also promises to buy the asset from the seller at a disclosed markup price, usually through deferred payment or instalments.
Unlike ordinary murābahah, the transaction in MPO begins with the customer’s request. The seller or Islamic bank only purchases the asset after receiving the customer’s order and promise to purchase.
MPO is widely used in Islamic banking as a financing mechanism for:
  • vehicles;
  • houses;
  • machinery;
  • business equipment; and
  • other commercial assets.
The Islamic bank must first obtain ownership and possession of the asset before selling it to the customer. This is important to ensure that the transaction is a genuine sale and not merely a loan with interest.


Q2: How does MPO operate in practice?
Answer:
The operation of MPO generally involves the following steps:
  1. The customer identifies an asset that he wishes to purchase.
  2. The customer requests the Islamic bank to purchase the asset.
  3. The customer signs a promise to purchase the asset from the bank.
  4. The bank purchases and takes ownership of the asset from the supplier.
  5. The bank sells the asset to the customer at a disclosed cost plus profit margin.
  6. The customer pays the selling price through deferred instalments.


Q3: How is MPO different from ordinary murābahah?
Answer:
The major difference lies in the existence of a prior request and financing purpose.
In ordinary murābahah, the seller independently purchases goods for resale without any prior arrangement with a customer. In MPO, however, the purchase is initiated by the customer’s request, and the seller or Islamic bank purchases the asset specifically for that customer.
MPO is therefore more structured and financing-oriented, while ordinary murābahah is mainly trade-oriented.


Case Study Comparison
Case Study 1: Ordinary Murābahah
Ahmad owns an electronics shop. He purchases ten laptops from a supplier for RM3,000 each without any prior customer order. Later, a customer named Hakim visits the shop and agrees to buy one laptop for RM3,500 after Ahmad discloses the original cost and the RM500 profit margin.
Analysis
  • Ahmad purchased the laptops independently.
  • No customer requested the purchase beforehand.
  • The transaction is a normal trading activity.
  • The profit is earned through resale after ownership is obtained.
This is an example of ordinary murābahah.


Case Study 2: Murābahah to the Purchase Orderer (MPO)
Aisyah wishes to buy industrial sewing machines worth RM100,000 for her clothing business but lacks sufficient funds. She approaches an Islamic bank and requests the bank to purchase the machines on her behalf.
The bank agrees after Aisyah signs a promise to purchase the machines once the bank acquires them. The bank then purchases the machines from the supplier and takes ownership. Afterwards, the bank sells the machines to Aisyah for RM120,000 payable over five years in monthly instalments.
The bank clearly discloses:
  • the original purchase cost of RM100,000; and
  • the profit margin of RM20,000.
Analysis
  • The transaction started with the customer’s request.
  • The bank purchased the asset specifically for Aisyah.
  • The customer promised to purchase the asset.
  • The transaction serves as an Islamic financing arrangement.
  • Ownership was first transferred to the bank before resale to the customer.
This is an example of Murābahah to the Purchase Orderer (MPO).


Notes: Key Differences Between Ordinary Murābahah and MPO
Ordinary Murābahah
  • Seller purchases goods before finding a buyer.
  • No prior promise or order from customers.
  • Common in normal retail and trading businesses.
  • Seller bears the commercial risk of not finding buyers.
  • Transaction focuses mainly on trade and resale.
Murābahah to the Purchase Orderer (MPO)
  • Customer requests the seller or Islamic bank to purchase a specific asset.
  • Customer usually provides a purchase undertaking or promise.
  • Commonly used by Islamic banks for financing purposes.
  • Asset is purchased specifically for the customer.
  • Seller or bank must own the asset before reselling it.
  • Transaction functions as a Shariah-compliant financing mechanism instead of an interest-based loan.







Picture
Published on
​Islamic Contract – Bay’ al-Murābahah: Disclosure of Cost Price, Profit Margin, and Sale Price
Q1: What must be disclosed in a murābahah contract?
Answer:
In a murābahah contract, the seller must disclose:
  • the original cost price of the asset; and
  • the profit margin added to the cost.
Once both the cost price and profit margin are disclosed, the final sale price becomes known automatically.
For example:
  • Cost price = RM10,000
  • Profit margin = RM2,000
  • Final sale price = RM12,000
Thus, murābahah is commonly described as:
“A sale based on disclosed cost and disclosed profit.”


Q2: Does murābahah require disclosure of the sale price as well?
Answer:
Yes. Although the essential requirement is the disclosure of the cost price and profit margin, the final sale price must also be clearly known and agreed upon by both parties before the contract is concluded.
The sale price is calculated as:
Cost Price + Profit Margin = Sale Price
Therefore, murābahah involves transparency in all pricing elements to avoid uncertainty (gharar) and ensure fairness between the contracting parties.


Q3: How is murābahah different from musāwamah in terms of price disclosure?
Answer:
The main difference lies in the disclosure requirement.
Murābahah
  • Seller discloses:
    • original cost price; and
    • profit margin.
  • Buyer knows how the final sale price is calculated.
Musāwamah
  • Seller only states the final selling price.
  • Original cost price and profit margin are not disclosed.
  • Price is determined through negotiation between the parties.


Case Scenario
An Islamic bank purchases office equipment for RM20,000 at the request of a customer. The bank informs the customer that:
  • the original purchase cost is RM20,000; and
  • the bank’s profit margin is RM5,000.
The bank then sells the equipment to the customer for RM25,000 payable over three years.
This transaction is valid murābahah because:
  • the cost price was disclosed;
  • the profit margin was disclosed; and
  • the final sale price was clearly agreed upon before the contract was concluded.

Picture
Published on
​Islamic Contract – Bay’ al-Murābahah: Basic Rules and Conditions of Murābahah
Q1: What are the basic rules and conditions of a murābahah contract?
Answer:
Since murābahah is a type of sale contract, all general conditions of a valid sale contract in Islamic law also apply to murābahah. In addition, there are specific conditions that must be fulfilled for a murābahah contract to be valid.
The basic rules and conditions are as follows:


Q2: Why must the cost price be disclosed in murābahah?
Answer:
The cost price must be disclosed because murābahah is a trust-based (fiduciary) sale contract. The buyer must know the actual cost incurred by the seller for the contract to be valid.
According to the majority of Shariah scholars:
  • failure to disclose the cost price renders the murābahah contract null and void.
According to the Hanafi School:
  • the contract becomes fāsid (defective) but rectifiable;
  • once the defect is corrected through proper disclosure, the contract becomes valid.
If the exact cost is unknown, the commodity cannot be sold through murābahah. Instead, it may be sold using another sale contract such as musāwamah, where disclosure of cost is not required.
Case Scenario
A trader purchases ten different electronic items in one bulk transaction for RM20,000 but does not know the individual cost of each item. Since the exact cost of each item is unknown, the trader cannot sell the items individually on a murābahah basis. However, the trader may still sell them through musāwamah by negotiating the selling price without disclosing the original cost.


Q3: Why must the profit margin be disclosed?
Answer:
The markup or profit margin must also be disclosed because it forms part of the selling price in a murābahah contract. The buyer must clearly know:
  • how much represents the original cost; and
  • how much represents the seller’s profit.
The profit margin must be mutually agreed upon by both contracting parties at the time the contract is concluded.
Case Scenario
An Islamic bank purchases machinery for RM50,000 and informs the customer that:
  • the cost price is RM50,000; and
  • the bank’s profit margin is RM8,000.
The machinery is then sold for RM58,000 through deferred instalments. The contract is valid because both the cost price and profit margin were clearly disclosed and agreed upon.


Q4: What kind of asset can be sold through murābahah?
Answer:
The subject matter of murābahah must be recognised as valuable property (māl) under Shariah. Therefore, prohibited or impure items cannot be the subject matter of a murābahah contract.
Examples of prohibited items include:
  • pork;
  • wine;
  • blood; and
  • other unlawful substances.
These items are not recognised as lawful property in Islam and therefore cannot be traded through murābahah.
Case Scenario
A businessman seeks financing from an Islamic bank to purchase alcoholic beverages for resale. The Islamic bank cannot enter into a murābahah contract for this transaction because alcohol is prohibited and is not recognised as lawful property under Shariah.


Q5: Why must murābahah avoid ribā?
Answer:
A murābahah contract must not involve any element of ribā (usury or interest). If the subject matter is a ribawī item (an item subject to the rules of ribā in sales), the transaction must comply with Shariah requirements to prevent ribā from occurring.
If ribawī items of the same type are exchanged with an increment, the increment is considered ribā rather than legitimate profit.
Therefore:
  • ribawī items of the same genus and quantity cannot be traded through murābahah if an increment exists;
  • they also cannot be traded through wadī‘ah if a discount or increment leads to ribā;
  • however, they may be exchanged through tawliyah if no increment occurs.
Case Scenario
A person exchanges 100 grams of gold for 120 grams of gold through a murābahah arrangement and claims that the extra 20 grams represent profit. This transaction is invalid because the increment in the exchange of the same ribawī item constitutes ribā rather than lawful profit.
However, if 100 grams of gold are exchanged for exactly 100 grams of gold without any increment, the transaction may be permissible through tawliyah because no ribā exists.


Notes: Important Conditions for a Valid Murābahah Contract
Disclosure Requirement
  • Cost price must be disclosed.
  • Profit margin must be disclosed.
  • Final sale price must be clearly agreed upon.
Subject Matter Requirement
  • Asset must be lawful and recognised by Shariah.
  • Prohibited items cannot be sold through murābahah.
Ribā Requirement
  • Transaction must not involve ribā.
  • Ribawī items must comply with Islamic rules of exchange.
Certainty Requirement
  • The seller must know the exact cost of the asset.
  • Uncertainty regarding cost may invalidate the murābahah contract.

Picture
Published on
​Islamic Contract – Bay’ al-Murābahah: Murābahah Involving Ribawī Items Such as Gold


Q1: Is it permissible to sell ribawī items such as gold through murābahah?


Answer:
Yes, it is permissible to sell ribawī items such as gold through murābahah, provided that the rules of ribā in Islamic law are strictly observed.


Gold is classified as a ribawī item. Therefore, transactions involving gold must comply with the Shariah rules governing the exchange of ribawī items.


⸻


Q2: Is the exchange of gold for money permissible in murābahah?


Answer:
Yes. The exchange of gold for money is generally permissible because they are of different categories:


  • gold is a ribawī commodity; and
  • money functions as currency.


However, the transaction must fulfil the Shariah requirement of:


  • immediate exchange (taqabud or possession); and
  • absence of ribā and excessive uncertainty.


If the murābahah transaction involves deferred payment, scholars have discussed the issue extensively because gold and currency are both ribawī items associated with monetary value.


⸻


Q3: Why is deferred payment involving gold controversial?


Answer:
The controversy arises because classical Islamic law treats gold and silver as currency. Under the rules of bay‘ al-sarf (currency exchange):


  • the exchange of gold and money must generally occur on a spot basis; and
  • deferment by one or both parties may lead to ribā al-nasī’ah (ribā due to delay).


For this reason, many classical scholars prohibit deferred sales of gold for money.


However, some contemporary scholars and Shariah standards permit deferred murābahah involving gold if:


  • the gold is treated as a commodity rather than currency;
  • ownership and possession are properly transferred; and
  • the transaction avoids speculative or interest-based elements.


This approach is commonly adopted in certain Islamic banking and commodity murābahah practices today.


⸻


Case Scenario 1: Permissible Spot Transaction


A jewellery shop sells a gold bracelet worth RM8,000 to a customer. The customer pays the full amount immediately, and the gold bracelet is handed over on the spot.


Analysis


  • Gold is exchanged for money immediately.
  • Both payment and delivery occur at the same session.
  • No ribā arises.


This transaction is generally permissible under Shariah.


⸻


Case Scenario 2: Problematic Deferred Transaction


A seller agrees to sell 100 grams of gold to a buyer today, but the buyer will only pay six months later.


Analysis


  • Gold and money are exchanged on a deferred basis.
  • Delay in payment may lead to ribā al-nasī’ah.
  • Many classical scholars consider this impermissible.


⸻


Case Scenario 3: Contemporary Murābahah Practice


An Islamic bank purchases gold bullion as a commodity investment and subsequently sells it to a customer through a structured murābahah arrangement. The bank first acquires ownership and possession of the gold before reselling it at a disclosed markup.


Analysis


  • The transaction is structured as a commodity sale.
  • Ownership transfer is essential.
  • The permissibility depends on compliance with contemporary Shariah standards and regulatory guidelines.


⸻


Notes: Important Rules on Gold in Murābahah


Permissible Situations


  • Gold may be sold for money on a spot basis.
  • Ownership and possession must be genuine.
  • Cost price and profit must be disclosed in murābahah.


Impermissible Situations


  • Exchange of gold for gold with unequal quantities.
  • Deferred exchange that leads to ribā.
  • Transactions involving speculation or fictitious ownership.


Key Principle


The main objective is to ensure that the transaction remains a genuine sale and does not become a disguised form of interest-based financing.
Picture
Published on
Islamic Contract – Bay’ al-Murābahah: Pricing in Murābahah Transactions
Q1: Does Islamic law allow different prices for cash sales and deferred payment sales in murābahah?
Answer:
Yes. Islamic law recognises the legitimacy of having a higher price in a deferred payment sale compared to a cash sale in murābahah transactions.
A famous legal maxim states:
“Time is a portion of the price.”
This means that the deferred payment period may justify a higher selling price because the seller waits longer to receive payment.
For this reason, Muslim jurists generally permit:
  • a lower price for spot cash payment; and
  • a higher price for deferred instalment payment.
However, the price must be:
  • fixed;
  • clearly known; and
  • mutually agreed upon at the time the contract is concluded.


Q2: Why is a higher deferred payment price permissible?
Answer:
According to al-Kāsānī of the Hanafi School, deferred payment warrants additional consideration (‘iwad) in the form of a price markup because time has value in commercial transactions.
The majority of Muslim jurists agree that:
  • deferment increases commercial risk and opportunity cost; and
  • therefore justifies a higher selling price.
The higher price may reflect:
  • inflation risk;
  • uncertainty;
  • delayed access to money;
  • lost investment opportunities; or
  • other market considerations.
Importantly, this concept of time preference is not automatically equivalent to ribā (interest), because:
  • the price is fixed once at the contract stage; and
  • no additional increase occurs due to late payment after the contract is concluded.


Q3: What did classical Muslim jurists say about time preference?
Answer:
Classical jurists from various schools of Islamic law recognised that deferment affects pricing.
Maliki School – al-Dasūqī
Al-Dasūqī stated that the seller in murābahah must disclose the deferred payment period because:
“the deferred period comprises a portion of the price.”
Hanafi School – al-Kāsānī
Al-Kāsānī explained that:
“the price increases according to the deferred period.”
This means that a longer payment period may justify a higher sale price.
Shafi‘i School – al-Sharbīnī
Al-Sharbīnī stated that specifying the deferred payment period is necessary because:
“the deferral is equivalent to a portion of the sale price.”
Hanbali School – Ibn Taymiyyah
Ibn Taymiyyah similarly stated:
“the deferred period takes a portion of the sale price.”
These juristic opinions demonstrate that classical Islamic jurisprudence recognises the commercial value of time in exchange transactions.


Q4: Is there a limit on profit in murābahah?
Answer:
Muslim jurists differ regarding the maximum permissible profit margin in murābahah.
Majority View
The majority of scholars hold that:
  • Shariah does not fix a maximum profit limit;
  • profit should be determined by market forces such as demand and supply; and
  • contracting parties are free to negotiate a mutually acceptable price.
Maliki View
The Maliki School restricts profit margins exceeding one-third of the original cost.
According to this view:
  • excessive profit (ghabn fāhish) is prohibited;
  • profit beyond one-third may be considered exploitative.
This opinion is based on the hadith in which the Prophet Muhammad (SAW) stated:
“A third is a lot.”
(al-Bukhāri, hadith no. 2742)


Q5: What is the position of the Shariah Advisory Council (SAC) Malaysia regarding pricing?
Answer:
The Shariah Advisory Council (SAC) of the Securities Commission Malaysia resolved in its 224th meeting held on 26 September 2019 that, in relation to sukūk issuance:
  • the purchase price of an identified asset must not exceed 1.51 times the asset’s fair value; or
  • any other appropriate value determined for the asset.
This guideline aims to avoid excessive pricing and ensure fairness in Islamic financial transactions.


Case Study 1: Permissible Deferred Pricing in Murābahah
An Islamic bank purchases a vehicle for RM80,000. The bank offers the customer two payment options:
  • Cash payment price: RM85,000
  • Deferred payment price over five years: RM100,000
The customer agrees to purchase the vehicle for RM100,000 through monthly instalments.
Analysis
  • The higher deferred price is permissible because:
    • the price was fixed at the contract stage;
    • both parties agreed to the deferred arrangement;
    • no additional increase will occur after the contract.
This is considered a valid murābahah transaction and not ribā.


Case Study 2: Impermissible Increase After Delay
A customer purchases equipment through murābahah for RM50,000 payable over three years. After missing several instalments, the seller increases the outstanding amount to RM60,000 solely because of the delay.
Analysis
  • The additional increase due to delay resembles ribā.
  • In murābahah, the price must remain fixed once agreed.
  • Charging extra money merely because payment is late is generally prohibited.


Notes: Key Principles of Pricing in Murābahah
Permissible
  • Higher price for deferred payment.
  • Profit margin agreed upon at contract stage.
  • Price fixed and certain.
  • Deferred period clearly specified.
Impermissible
  • Additional increase after contract due to delay.
  • Uncertain or floating selling price.
  • Excessive exploitation or injustice.
Important Principle
In murābahah, time may influence the original sale price, but time alone cannot justify additional charges after the debt has already been established.

​
Picture

Author

A writer who is passionate about knowledge 

Author

Write something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview.