- Published on
Islamic Contract – Bay’ al-Salam: Basic Rules and Conditions of Salam
1. Offer and Acceptance in Salam Contract
Explanation
A salam contract may be concluded using:
What is important in Islamic contracts is:
Key Elements Reflected in the Contract Wording
The wording must indicate:
Example 1: Using the Word “Salam”
A trader says:
“I enter into a salam contract to purchase 5,000 kg of rice for RM40,000 to be delivered after 6 months.”
The farmer accepts.
Analysis
✅ Valid salam contract.
Example 2: Using the Word “Salaf”
A buyer says:
“I make a salaf agreement with you for delivery of 100 tonnes of wheat after harvest in exchange for RM300,000 paid today.”
Analysis
✅ Valid salam contract.
Example 3: Using Ordinary Sale Wording
An Islamic bank says:
“We purchase 200 tonnes of crude palm oil from you for RM800,000 paid immediately, with delivery after 8 months.”
Analysis
Although the word “salam” is not used:
✅ Valid salam contract.
Example 4: Invalid Unclear Arrangement
A buyer says:
“I may pay you later if I agree, and you can supply goods whenever available.”
Analysis
The statement lacks:
❌ Invalid salam contract.
Important Principle
In Islamic commercial law:
contracts are judged by their substance and meaning,
not merely by labels or terminology.
Thus:
Summary Notes
Salam Contract May Use:
✅ Salam
✅ Salaf
✅ Sale
✅ Any wording clearly indicating deferred commodity delivery for upfront payment.
Essential Meaning That Must Exist
The contract must clearly show:
1. Offer and Acceptance in Salam Contract
Explanation
A salam contract may be concluded using:
- the word salam;
- the word salaf;
- the word sale; or
- any wording that clearly indicates:
What is important in Islamic contracts is:
- the meaning and intention of the contracting parties,
not merely: - the exact terminology used.
- advance payment; and
- deferred delivery of specified goods
Key Elements Reflected in the Contract Wording
The wording must indicate:
- immediate payment of the price;
- future delivery of goods;
- clearly specified commodities.
Example 1: Using the Word “Salam”
A trader says:
“I enter into a salam contract to purchase 5,000 kg of rice for RM40,000 to be delivered after 6 months.”
The farmer accepts.
Analysis
- The word salam is expressly used.
- Future delivery and upfront payment clearly stated.
✅ Valid salam contract.
Example 2: Using the Word “Salaf”
A buyer says:
“I make a salaf agreement with you for delivery of 100 tonnes of wheat after harvest in exchange for RM300,000 paid today.”
Analysis
- The term salaf historically refers to salam.
- Immediate payment and deferred delivery specified.
✅ Valid salam contract.
Example 3: Using Ordinary Sale Wording
An Islamic bank says:
“We purchase 200 tonnes of crude palm oil from you for RM800,000 paid immediately, with delivery after 8 months.”
Analysis
Although the word “salam” is not used:
- the contract clearly indicates:
- immediate payment;
- deferred commodity delivery.
✅ Valid salam contract.
Example 4: Invalid Unclear Arrangement
A buyer says:
“I may pay you later if I agree, and you can supply goods whenever available.”
Analysis
The statement lacks:
- certainty of payment;
- certainty of delivery;
- precise contractual obligation.
- uncertainty (gharar);
- ambiguity.
❌ Invalid salam contract.
Important Principle
In Islamic commercial law:
contracts are judged by their substance and meaning,
not merely by labels or terminology.
Thus:
- any wording clearly establishing:
- advance payment;
- future delivery;
- specified commodities
Summary Notes
Salam Contract May Use:
✅ Salam
✅ Salaf
✅ Sale
✅ Any wording clearly indicating deferred commodity delivery for upfront payment.
Essential Meaning That Must Exist
The contract must clearly show:
- full advance payment;
- future delivery;
- specified commodity;
- agreed delivery date.
- Published on
Islamic Contract – Bay’ al-Istisnā‘: Definition and Nature of Manufacturing Sale
Q1: What is Bay’ al-Istisnā‘?
Answer:
The word istisnā‘ is derived from the Arabic verb istaṣna‘a, which means:
“to request the manufacture of an asset.”
Technically, Bay’ al-Istisnā‘ (hereinafter, istisnā‘) refers to:
a contractual agreement with a manufacturer to produce or construct an asset with specified descriptions at a pre-determined price to be delivered on an agreed future date.
In an istisnā‘ contract:
Q2: What are the main characteristics of an istisnā‘ contract?
Answer:
The main characteristics of istisnā‘ are as follows:
Manufacturing or Construction Basis
The contract involves:
The asset must be clearly specified, including:
The manufactured asset is delivered at a future agreed date.
Pre-Determined Price
The contract price must be agreed upon at the beginning of the contract.
Flexibility of Payment
Payment may be:
Q3: What types of assets are commonly subject to istisnā‘?
Answer:
Istisnā‘ is commonly used for assets requiring manufacturing or construction, such as:
Case Study 1: Construction of a House
Ahmad enters into an istisnā‘ contract with a construction company to build a house.
Contract Details
Case Study 2: Manufacturing of Industrial Machinery
A factory owner orders specialised machinery from a manufacturer through istisnā‘ financing.
Contract Details
Notes: Important Features of Istisnā‘
Nature of Contract
Q1: What is Bay’ al-Istisnā‘?
Answer:
The word istisnā‘ is derived from the Arabic verb istaṣna‘a, which means:
“to request the manufacture of an asset.”
Technically, Bay’ al-Istisnā‘ (hereinafter, istisnā‘) refers to:
a contractual agreement with a manufacturer to produce or construct an asset with specified descriptions at a pre-determined price to be delivered on an agreed future date.
In an istisnā‘ contract:
- one party requests the manufacture or construction of an asset;
- the manufacturer agrees to produce it according to agreed specifications; and
- delivery takes place in the future.
Q2: What are the main characteristics of an istisnā‘ contract?
Answer:
The main characteristics of istisnā‘ are as follows:
Manufacturing or Construction Basis
The contract involves:
- manufacturing;
- construction; or
- production of an asset.
The asset must be clearly specified, including:
- quantity;
- quality;
- design;
- measurements; and
- other relevant specifications.
The manufactured asset is delivered at a future agreed date.
Pre-Determined Price
The contract price must be agreed upon at the beginning of the contract.
Flexibility of Payment
Payment may be:
- made upfront;
- deferred; or
- paid progressively according to stages of completion.
Q3: What types of assets are commonly subject to istisnā‘?
Answer:
Istisnā‘ is commonly used for assets requiring manufacturing or construction, such as:
- houses;
- buildings;
- ships;
- aircraft;
- roads;
- machinery;
- furniture; and
- customised products.
- Islamic project financing;
- infrastructure development; and
- construction financing.
Case Study 1: Construction of a House
Ahmad enters into an istisnā‘ contract with a construction company to build a house.
Contract Details
- Type of asset: Double-storey house
- Contract price: RM500,000
- Construction period: 18 months
- Payment structure:
- RM100,000 upfront;
- RM200,000 during construction;
- RM200,000 upon completion.
- size;
- number of rooms;
- building materials; and
- design layout.
- The house does not yet exist at the time of contract.
- The manufacturer (contractor) agrees to construct it.
- Delivery will occur in the future.
- Price and specifications are predetermined.
Case Study 2: Manufacturing of Industrial Machinery
A factory owner orders specialised machinery from a manufacturer through istisnā‘ financing.
Contract Details
- Machinery price: RM1,200,000
- Manufacturing period: 12 months
- Payment arrangement:
- 30% upon signing;
- 40% during production;
- 30% upon delivery.
- machine capacity;
- technical features;
- materials used; and
- performance requirements.
- The machinery will be manufactured according to specifications.
- Delivery occurs in the future.
- Payment is structured progressively.
- The contract satisfies the requirements of istisnā‘.
Notes: Important Features of Istisnā‘
Nature of Contract
- Manufacturing or construction contract.
- Asset may not yet exist at contract formation.
- Clear specifications.
- Agreed price.
- Agreed delivery timeline.
- Upfront payment allowed.
- Deferred payment allowed.
- Progressive payment allowed.
- Construction projects.
- Infrastructure financing.
- Manufacturing industries.
- Islamic project financing.
- Published on
Islamic Contract – Bay’ al-Murābahah: Late Payment Charges in Murābahah Transactions
Q1: What are late payment charges in murābahah financing?
Answer:
Late payment charges refer to charges imposed on customers who fail to make payment within the agreed payment period in a murābahah contract.
In Islamic finance, late payment charges are carefully regulated to ensure that they:
Q2: What is the AAOIFI position regarding late payment charges?
Answer:
According to AAOIFI Shariah Standard No. 8 (Para 5/6):
Q3: What is the BNM position regarding late payment charges?
Answer:
According to the Bank Negara Malaysia (BNM) Policy Document on Murābahah (Para 19.1):
Meaning of Gharamah
Comparison Notes: AAOIFI vs BNM on Late Payment Charges
AAOIFI Position
Case Study 1: AAOIFI Approach on Late Payment
An Islamic bank provides murābahah financing for equipment.
Figures
“In the event of late payment, the customer undertakes to contribute 1% of overdue instalments for charitable purposes.”
Calculation
Case Study 2: BNM Approach on Late Payment
An Islamic bank grants home financing through murābahah.
Figures
Ta‘wīd (Compensation)
RM12,000 \times 1\% \times \frac{4}{12}
12000 \times 1% \times \frac{4}{12} = 40
Ta‘wīd payable = RM40
Additional gharamah may also be imposed according to regulatory guidelines.
Analysis
Notes: Important Principles Regarding Late Payment Charges
AAOIFI Emphasis
Late payment charges in Islamic finance must:
Q1: What are late payment charges in murābahah financing?
Answer:
Late payment charges refer to charges imposed on customers who fail to make payment within the agreed payment period in a murābahah contract.
In Islamic finance, late payment charges are carefully regulated to ensure that they:
- do not amount to ribā (interest); and
- are imposed only for legitimate Shariah purposes such as compensation or deterrence against intentional delay.
Q2: What is the AAOIFI position regarding late payment charges?
Answer:
According to AAOIFI Shariah Standard No. 8 (Para 5/6):
- the murābahah contract may include an undertaking by the customer to pay an amount of money or percentage of the debt upon late payment;
- however, the amount collected must be donated to charitable causes.
- the Islamic bank cannot treat the penalty amount as profit or income;
- the purpose is mainly to discourage deliberate default by customers.
- benefiting financially from late payment resembles ribā;
- therefore, any collected penalty should not enrich the bank.
Q3: What is the BNM position regarding late payment charges?
Answer:
According to the Bank Negara Malaysia (BNM) Policy Document on Murābahah (Para 19.1):
- the murābahah contract may include a clause imposing late payment charges;
- these charges may consist of:
- gharamah (penalty); and
- ta‘wīd (compensation).
Meaning of Gharamah
- Penalty imposed to deter late payment.
- Usually channelled for charitable purposes and not recognised as bank profit.
- Compensation for actual loss suffered by the bank due to delayed payment.
- May be recognised as income to the extent of actual losses incurred.
- Shariah compliance;
- operational practicality; and
- financial discipline in Islamic banking.
Comparison Notes: AAOIFI vs BNM on Late Payment Charges
AAOIFI Position
- Late payment undertaking allowed.
- Amount collected must be donated to charity.
- Bank cannot profit from customer’s delay.
- Stronger precaution against ribā.
- Late payment charges expressly allowed.
- Includes:
- gharamah (penalty); and
- ta‘wīd (compensation).
- Charges subject to regulatory limits.
- Bank may recover actual losses through ta‘wīd.
Case Study 1: AAOIFI Approach on Late Payment
An Islamic bank provides murābahah financing for equipment.
Figures
- Murābahah selling price: RM120,000
- Monthly instalment: RM2,000
- Customer delays payment for 3 months.
“In the event of late payment, the customer undertakes to contribute 1% of overdue instalments for charitable purposes.”
Calculation
- Overdue amount = RM6,000
- 1% late payment amount = RM60
- cannot be recognised as bank profit;
- must be channelled to charity.
- Purpose is deterrence, not profit-making.
- This arrangement complies with AAOIFI standards.
Case Study 2: BNM Approach on Late Payment
An Islamic bank grants home financing through murābahah.
Figures
- Murābahah selling price: RM500,000
- Monthly instalment: RM3,000
- Customer delays payment for 4 months.
- Total overdue amount = RM12,000
- ta‘wīd rate = 1% per annum;
- gharamah imposed according to BNM guidelines.
Ta‘wīd (Compensation)
RM12,000 \times 1\% \times \frac{4}{12}
12000 \times 1% \times \frac{4}{12} = 40
Ta‘wīd payable = RM40
Additional gharamah may also be imposed according to regulatory guidelines.
Analysis
- Ta‘wīd compensates the bank for actual losses caused by delayed payment.
- Gharamah functions as a deterrent penalty.
- The arrangement complies with BNM requirements.
Notes: Important Principles Regarding Late Payment Charges
AAOIFI Emphasis
- Penalties allowed only as deterrence.
- Amount collected must go to charity.
- Bank cannot profit from delay.
- Allows both:
- ta‘wīd (compensation); and
- gharamah (penalty).
- Charges regulated by authorities.
- Bank may recover actual losses.
Late payment charges in Islamic finance must:
- avoid ribā;
- prevent injustice;
- encourage payment discipline; and
- remain within Shariah-approved limits.
- Published on
Islamic Contract – Bay’ al-Murābahah: Ibrā’ (Rebate) in Murābahah Transactions
Q1: What is Ibrā’ in Islamic finance?
Answer:
Ibrā’ refers to a rebate, waiver, or remission granted by the seller or Islamic bank to the purchaser by reducing part of the outstanding payment obligation.
In murābahah financing, ibra’ commonly occurs when:
Q2: Why is Ibrā’ important in murābahah financing?
Answer:
Ibrā’ is important because murābahah financing usually involves deferred payment over a long period.
When customers:
Q3: What is the AAOIFI position regarding Ibrā’?
Answer:
According to AAOIFI Shariah Standard No. 8 (Para 5/9):
Q4: What is the BNM position regarding Ibrā’?
Answer:
According to the Bank Negara Malaysia (BNM) Policy Document on Murābahah (Para 18.2):
Comparison Notes: AAOIFI vs BNM on Ibrā’
AAOIFI Position
Case Study 1: AAOIFI Approach on Ibrā’
An Islamic bank finances machinery through murābahah.
Figures
The bank voluntarily grants:
Case Study 2: BNM Approach on Ibrā’
An Islamic bank provides home financing through murābahah.
Figures
“The customer shall be entitled to ibra’ for early settlement based on the bank’s rebate formula.”
After 10 years:
Notes: Important Principles Regarding Ibrā’
AAOIFI Emphasis
Ibrā’ represents:
Q1: What is Ibrā’ in Islamic finance?
Answer:
Ibrā’ refers to a rebate, waiver, or remission granted by the seller or Islamic bank to the purchaser by reducing part of the outstanding payment obligation.
In murābahah financing, ibra’ commonly occurs when:
- the customer settles the financing earlier than scheduled; or
- the bank voluntarily grants a discount on the outstanding balance.
Q2: Why is Ibrā’ important in murābahah financing?
Answer:
Ibrā’ is important because murābahah financing usually involves deferred payment over a long period.
When customers:
- make early settlement; or
- complete payment before maturity,
- unearned profit; or
- part of the remaining sale price.
- the bank receives payment earlier than expected; and
- the bank no longer bears financing risk for the remaining period.
Q3: What is the AAOIFI position regarding Ibrā’?
Answer:
According to AAOIFI Shariah Standard No. 8 (Para 5/9):
- ibra’ cannot be stipulated as part of the murābahah contract.
- the bank cannot contractually promise a rebate in advance;
- ibra’ must remain a voluntary act by the seller.
- making ibra’ contractually binding may resemble interest recalculation in conventional loans.
- the rebate should be discretionary and not pre-agreed within the contract itself.
Q4: What is the BNM position regarding Ibrā’?
Answer:
According to the Bank Negara Malaysia (BNM) Policy Document on Murābahah (Para 18.2):
- ibra’ must be included as part of the contract if required by the regulator.
- Islamic financial institutions are generally required to specify ibra’ clauses in financing agreements.
- promote transparency;
- protect customers;
- standardise early settlement calculations; and
- ensure fairness in Islamic financing practices.
Comparison Notes: AAOIFI vs BNM on Ibrā’
AAOIFI Position
- Ibrā’ cannot be part of the murābahah contract.
- Rebate must remain voluntary.
- Concerned that contractual rebate resembles interest adjustment.
- Emphasises discretionary benevolence.
- Ibrā’ clause must be included if required by regulation.
- Rebate calculation becomes transparent and predictable.
- Protects customers in early settlement situations.
- Widely applied in Malaysian Islamic banking practice.
Case Study 1: AAOIFI Approach on Ibrā’
An Islamic bank finances machinery through murābahah.
Figures
- Cost price: RM100,000
- Profit margin: RM20,000
- Murābahah selling price: RM120,000
- Payment period: 5 years
The bank voluntarily grants:
- RM8,000 rebate (ibrā’) on the remaining balance.
- The rebate was not pre-promised in the contract.
- The bank granted it voluntarily.
- This complies with AAOIFI standards.
Case Study 2: BNM Approach on Ibrā’
An Islamic bank provides home financing through murābahah.
Figures
- House purchase cost: RM300,000
- Profit margin: RM90,000
- Murābahah selling price: RM390,000
- Financing tenure: 20 years
“The customer shall be entitled to ibra’ for early settlement based on the bank’s rebate formula.”
After 10 years:
- outstanding balance = RM220,000
- bank grants RM25,000 ibra’
- customer pays final settlement amount = RM195,000
- Ibrā’ was expressly included in the contract.
- Rebate calculation was transparent and predetermined.
- This complies with BNM regulatory requirements.
Notes: Important Principles Regarding Ibrā’
AAOIFI Emphasis
- Ibrā’ should remain voluntary.
- Cannot be contractually stipulated.
- Avoids resemblance to conventional interest adjustments.
- Ibrā’ clause included for transparency.
- Regulatory protection for customers.
- Standardised industry practice.
Ibrā’ represents:
- fairness;
- benevolence; and
- equitable treatment in deferred payment transactions.
- Published on
Islamic Contract – Bay’ al-Murābahah: Meaning of “Absorbing the Takaful Cost”
Q1: What does “absorbing the takaful cost” mean in murābahah?
Answer:
“Absorbing the takaful cost” means bearing or paying the takaful contribution associated with the asset.
In the context of murābahah:
“the purchaser may absorb the takaful cost before entering into the murābahah contract,”
it means:
Example 1: Seller Absorbs the Takaful Cost (AAOIFI Approach)
An Islamic bank purchases machinery for murābahah financing.
Figures
Here:
RM200,000 + RM5,000 = RM205,000 acquisition cost
The customer then pays:
RM225,000 = RM205,000 cost + RM20,000 profit
Key Point
The takaful cost becomes part of the murābahah selling price because the bank paid it first.
Example 2: Purchaser Absorbs the Takaful Cost (BNM Approach)
A customer applies for Islamic vehicle financing.
Figures
Before the murābahah contract:
The purchaser “absorbs” the takaful cost because:
Simple Difference Between the Two Approaches
Seller Absorbs Takaful Cost
Q1: What does “absorbing the takaful cost” mean in murābahah?
Answer:
“Absorbing the takaful cost” means bearing or paying the takaful contribution associated with the asset.
In the context of murābahah:
- the takaful cost may either be borne by the seller (Islamic bank); or
- paid directly by the purchaser (customer), depending on the contractual arrangement.
“the purchaser may absorb the takaful cost before entering into the murābahah contract,”
it means:
- the customer agrees to pay the takaful contribution separately before the murābahah sale contract is executed.
Example 1: Seller Absorbs the Takaful Cost (AAOIFI Approach)
An Islamic bank purchases machinery for murābahah financing.
Figures
- Cost of machinery: RM200,000
- Takaful contribution paid by bank: RM5,000
- Total acquisition cost: RM205,000
- Profit margin: RM20,000
- Murābahah selling price: RM225,000
Here:
- the bank initially bears (“absorbs”) the takaful cost of RM5,000;
- the bank includes it as part of the acquisition cost.
RM200,000 + RM5,000 = RM205,000 acquisition cost
The customer then pays:
RM225,000 = RM205,000 cost + RM20,000 profit
Key Point
The takaful cost becomes part of the murābahah selling price because the bank paid it first.
Example 2: Purchaser Absorbs the Takaful Cost (BNM Approach)
A customer applies for Islamic vehicle financing.
Figures
- Vehicle price: RM100,000
- Takaful contribution: RM3,000
- Bank’s profit margin: RM15,000
- Murābahah selling price: RM115,000
Before the murābahah contract:
- the customer separately agrees to pay the RM3,000 takaful contribution directly.
- the bank’s acquisition cost remains RM100,000;
- the murābahah selling price becomes RM115,000 only.
- RM3,000 takaful contribution; and
- RM115,000 murābahah price.
- Murābahah price = RM115,000
- Separate takaful payment = RM3,000
- Total overall payment = RM118,000
The purchaser “absorbs” the takaful cost because:
- the customer personally bears and pays the takaful expense instead of the bank including it in the murābahah cost.
Simple Difference Between the Two Approaches
Seller Absorbs Takaful Cost
- Bank pays takaful first.
- Takaful included in murābahah cost.
- Customer indirectly pays through instalments.
- Customer pays takaful separately.
- Takaful excluded from murābahah cost.
- Murābahah selling price becomes lower.
- Published on
Islamic Contract – Bay’ al-Murābahah: Takaful Coverage for Asset Under Seller’s Possession
Q1: What is the purpose of takaful coverage in a murābahah transaction?
Answer:
In a murābahah transaction, the seller or Islamic bank may obtain takaful coverage for the asset while it remains under the seller’s ownership and possession before being sold to the purchaser.
The purpose of takaful is to:
This reflects the Shariah principle:
“Risk accompanies ownership.”
Since the seller owns the asset before resale, the seller bears the associated risks during that ownership period.
Q2: What is the AAOIFI position regarding takaful cost?
Answer:
According to AAOIFI Shariah Standard No. 8 (Paras 3/2/6–3/2/7):
This means the seller initially bears the takaful responsibility because the seller still owns the asset before transferring ownership to the purchaser.
⸻
Q3: What is the BNM position regarding takaful cost?
Answer:
According to the Bank Negara Malaysia (BNM) Policy Document on Murābahah (Para 17.5):
This allows:
However, the arrangement must be:
Comparison Notes: AAOIFI vs BNM on Takaful Cost
AAOIFI Position
BNM Position
Case Study 1: AAOIFI Approach with Figures
An Islamic bank purchases industrial machinery for a customer under a murābahah arrangement.
Transaction Details
The bank obtains takaful coverage while the machinery remains under its ownership before reselling it to the customer.
Analysis
Case Study 2: BNM Approach with Figures
A customer applies for murābahah vehicle financing from an Islamic bank.
Transaction Details
Before the murābahah contract is concluded, the customer separately agrees to pay the RM3,000 takaful contribution.
Analysis
Notes: Important Principles Regarding Takaful in Murābahah
AAOIFI Emphasis
BNM Emphasis
Common Shariah Principle
The party bearing ownership risk should generally bear the corresponding liabilities and responsibilities associated with the asset until ownership is transferred.
Q1: What is the purpose of takaful coverage in a murābahah transaction?
Answer:
In a murābahah transaction, the seller or Islamic bank may obtain takaful coverage for the asset while it remains under the seller’s ownership and possession before being sold to the purchaser.
The purpose of takaful is to:
- protect the asset against damage or loss;
- manage ownership risks borne by the seller; and
- ensure proper risk management in accordance with Shariah principles.
This reflects the Shariah principle:
“Risk accompanies ownership.”
Since the seller owns the asset before resale, the seller bears the associated risks during that ownership period.
Q2: What is the AAOIFI position regarding takaful cost?
Answer:
According to AAOIFI Shariah Standard No. 8 (Paras 3/2/6–3/2/7):
- the seller is obligated to bear the takaful cost while the asset remains under the seller’s possession; and
- the seller may include the takaful expense as part of the acquisition cost of the asset.
This means the seller initially bears the takaful responsibility because the seller still owns the asset before transferring ownership to the purchaser.
⸻
Q3: What is the BNM position regarding takaful cost?
Answer:
According to the Bank Negara Malaysia (BNM) Policy Document on Murābahah (Para 17.5):
- the purchaser may absorb the takaful cost before entering into the murābahah contract.
This allows:
- greater operational flexibility; and
- cost-sharing arrangements agreed upon between the parties before the sale contract is concluded.
However, the arrangement must be:
- clearly agreed upon; and
- properly documented.
Comparison Notes: AAOIFI vs BNM on Takaful Cost
AAOIFI Position
- Seller bears takaful cost during ownership period.
- Takaful cost may be included in acquisition cost.
- Emphasises ownership-risk principle.
- Seller remains responsible until ownership transfer.
BNM Position
- Purchaser may absorb takaful cost before murābahah contract.
- Allows more operational flexibility.
- Requires proper contractual documentation.
- Commonly applied in Islamic banking practice.
Case Study 1: AAOIFI Approach with Figures
An Islamic bank purchases industrial machinery for a customer under a murābahah arrangement.
Transaction Details
- Purchase price of machinery: RM200,000
- Takaful contribution paid by the bank: RM5,000
- Total acquisition cost borne by the bank: RM205,000
- Bank’s profit margin: RM25,000
- Final murābahah selling price: RM230,000
The bank obtains takaful coverage while the machinery remains under its ownership before reselling it to the customer.
Analysis
- The bank bore the takaful cost because it owned the machinery.
- The takaful contribution was included as part of the acquisition cost.
- The customer was informed that:
- original cost = RM205,000; and
- profit = RM25,000.
- This arrangement complies with AAOIFI standards.
Case Study 2: BNM Approach with Figures
A customer applies for murābahah vehicle financing from an Islamic bank.
Transaction Details
- Purchase price of vehicle: RM100,000
- Takaful contribution: RM3,000
- Customer agrees to bear takaful contribution before murābahah execution.
- Bank’s disclosed acquisition cost: RM100,000
- Bank’s profit margin: RM15,000
- Final murābahah selling price: RM115,000
Before the murābahah contract is concluded, the customer separately agrees to pay the RM3,000 takaful contribution.
Analysis
- The purchaser absorbed the takaful cost before the sale contract.
- The bank’s murābahah cost excluded the takaful amount.
- Proper documentation separated:
- takaful arrangement; and
- murābahah contract.
- This arrangement is permissible under BNM guidelines.
Notes: Important Principles Regarding Takaful in Murābahah
AAOIFI Emphasis
- Ownership risk remains with seller before sale.
- Seller responsible for takaful during ownership period.
- Takaful expense may be included in cost price.
BNM Emphasis
- Purchaser may absorb takaful cost earlier.
- Greater flexibility in banking operations.
- Proper agreement and documentation required.
Common Shariah Principle
The party bearing ownership risk should generally bear the corresponding liabilities and responsibilities associated with the asset until ownership is transferred.
- Published on
Islamic Contract – Bay’ al-Murābahah: Supplier Requirement in Murābahah Transactions
Q1: What is the role of the supplier in a murābahah transaction?
Answer:
In a murābahah transaction, the supplier is the party from whom the Islamic bank or seller purchases the asset before reselling it to the customer at a disclosed markup price.
The supplier plays an important role because:
Q2: What is the AAOIFI position regarding the supplier in murābahah?
Answer:
According to AAOIFI Shariah Standard No. 8 (Para 2/2/3):
Bay‘ al-‘īnah refers to a sale and buy-back arrangement that may be used as a legal stratagem to obtain cash financing resembling an interest-based loan.
AAOIFI adopts this requirement to ensure:
Q3: What is the BNM position regarding the supplier?
Answer:
The Bank Negara Malaysia (BNM) Policy Document on Murābahah does not specifically require the supplier to be a third party.
However, according to Paragraph 23:
Comparison Notes: AAOIFI vs BNM on Supplier Requirement
AAOIFI Position
Case Study 1: Permissible Third-Party Supplier Arrangement
A customer requests an Islamic bank to finance the purchase of factory equipment.
The bank:
Case Study 2: Potential Bay‘ al-‘Īnah Concern
A customer sells his own asset to an Islamic bank and immediately repurchases the same asset through murābahah at a higher deferred price.
Analysis
Notes: Important Principles Regarding Suppliers in Murābahah
AAOIFI Emphasis
Murābahah must involve:
Q1: What is the role of the supplier in a murābahah transaction?
Answer:
In a murābahah transaction, the supplier is the party from whom the Islamic bank or seller purchases the asset before reselling it to the customer at a disclosed markup price.
The supplier plays an important role because:
- the murābahah transaction must involve a genuine purchase and ownership transfer; and
- the Islamic bank must own the asset before reselling it to the customer.
Q2: What is the AAOIFI position regarding the supplier in murābahah?
Answer:
According to AAOIFI Shariah Standard No. 8 (Para 2/2/3):
- the supplier should be a third party; and
- the arrangement should not lead to bay‘ al-‘īnah.
Bay‘ al-‘īnah refers to a sale and buy-back arrangement that may be used as a legal stratagem to obtain cash financing resembling an interest-based loan.
AAOIFI adopts this requirement to ensure:
- the transaction represents a genuine trade;
- there is actual transfer of ownership and risk; and
- the murābahah structure is not used to disguise ribā-based financing.
Q3: What is the BNM position regarding the supplier?
Answer:
The Bank Negara Malaysia (BNM) Policy Document on Murābahah does not specifically require the supplier to be a third party.
However, according to Paragraph 23:
- ownership transfer must be genuine; and
- it must be supported by proper and sufficient documentation.
- evidencing genuine ownership transfer;
- ensuring actual sale transactions occur; and
- preventing fictitious or paper-based transactions.
Comparison Notes: AAOIFI vs BNM on Supplier Requirement
AAOIFI Position
- Supplier should be an independent third party.
- Arrangement must not result in bay‘ al-‘īnah.
- Adopts stricter safeguards against legal stratagems.
- Emphasises genuine commercial transactions.
- Does not expressly require a third-party supplier.
- Focuses on genuine ownership transfer.
- Requires sufficient documentation to evidence the transaction.
- Emphasises operational substance and documentary compliance.
Case Study 1: Permissible Third-Party Supplier Arrangement
A customer requests an Islamic bank to finance the purchase of factory equipment.
The bank:
- purchases the equipment from an independent supplier;
- obtains ownership and supporting documents; and
- resells the equipment to the customer through murābahah.
- Supplier is a genuine third party.
- Ownership transfer occurs properly.
- The transaction satisfies AAOIFI and BNM requirements.
Case Study 2: Potential Bay‘ al-‘Īnah Concern
A customer sells his own asset to an Islamic bank and immediately repurchases the same asset through murābahah at a higher deferred price.
Analysis
- The arrangement may resemble bay‘ al-‘īnah.
- AAOIFI generally discourages such structures.
- Concern exists that the transaction merely disguises cash financing with profit increments similar to ribā.
- the focus would be on whether genuine ownership transfer and documentation exist;
- however, Shariah governance mechanisms would still examine whether the arrangement is substantively compliant.
Notes: Important Principles Regarding Suppliers in Murābahah
AAOIFI Emphasis
- Third-party supplier preferred.
- Avoidance of bay‘ al-‘īnah.
- Stronger anti-ribā safeguards.
- Genuine ownership transfer.
- Proper legal documentation.
- Evidence of actual commercial transaction.
Murābahah must involve:
- real asset ownership;
- genuine transfer of risk; and
- actual sale transactions rather than disguised lending arrangements.
- Published on
Islamic Contract – Bay’ al-Istisnā‘: Basic Rules and Conditions of Istisnā‘
1. The Object of Istisnā‘ Must Be Specifically Described
Explanation
Since istisnā‘ involves the sale of an asset that does not yet exist (bay‘ al-ma‘dūm), the subject matter must be clearly specified to avoid uncertainty (gharar).
The following specifications must be clearly determined:
Example
A customer orders a customised sofa set through istisnā‘.
Agreed Specifications
Purchaser’s Rights
The purchaser may:
2. The Object Must Be Manufacturable
Explanation
The subject matter of istisnā‘ must be something:
Similarly, items not commonly manufactured through istisnā‘ arrangements may not qualify.
Example
Valid Istisnā‘
A company commissions the construction of:
Invalid Istisnā‘
A person attempts to use istisnā‘ to purchase:
3. Materials Must Be Supplied by the Manufacturer
Explanation
In an istisnā‘ contract:
Example
Valid Istisnā‘
A contractor agrees to build a house and personally supplies:
Ijārah Situation
A homeowner personally purchases all building materials and only hires the contractor for labour and construction work.
This arrangement resembles ijārah because the contractor mainly provides services rather than manufacturing.
4. Time of Delivery Must Be Specified
Explanation
The delivery date must be clearly determined to avoid uncertainty and future disputes.
If the seller fails to deliver on time, the purchaser may:
Example
A company orders customised buses under istisnā‘.
Contract Terms
Purchaser’s Options
The purchaser may:
5. Place of Delivery Must Be Determined
Explanation
The delivery location should be specified, especially where:
Example
A manufacturer constructs industrial generators.
Contract Terms
6. Price Must Be Determined
Explanation
The price in istisnā‘:
Example
A construction company agrees to build a factory.
Contract Details
The price increase is permissible because:
The seller cannot increase the price solely because:
7. Possession and Ownership Transfer
Explanation
Ownership transfers to the purchaser only after:
However:
Example
An Islamic bank commissions construction of a ship under istisnā‘.
Contract Details
1. The Object of Istisnā‘ Must Be Specifically Described
Explanation
Since istisnā‘ involves the sale of an asset that does not yet exist (bay‘ al-ma‘dūm), the subject matter must be clearly specified to avoid uncertainty (gharar).
The following specifications must be clearly determined:
- type;
- kind;
- quality;
- quantity;
- measurements;
- design; and
- essential characteristics.
- reject the asset and terminate the contract;
- accept the asset at the agreed price; or
- accept the asset subject to revised terms such as:
- reduced price; or
- extended completion period.
Example
A customer orders a customised sofa set through istisnā‘.
Agreed Specifications
- Material: Genuine leather
- Colour: Black
- Length: 3 metres
- Quantity: 2 sofa units
- Price: RM25,000
Purchaser’s Rights
The purchaser may:
- reject delivery entirely;
- accept the sofas at RM25,000;
- negotiate a lower revised price.
2. The Object Must Be Manufacturable
Explanation
The subject matter of istisnā‘ must be something:
- commonly manufactured or constructed; and
- customarily contracted through istisnā‘.
- houses;
- vehicles;
- aircraft;
- furniture; and
- machinery.
Similarly, items not commonly manufactured through istisnā‘ arrangements may not qualify.
Example
Valid Istisnā‘
A company commissions the construction of:
- a warehouse;
- delivery trucks; or
- industrial machinery.
Invalid Istisnā‘
A person attempts to use istisnā‘ to purchase:
- an already completed apartment.
3. Materials Must Be Supplied by the Manufacturer
Explanation
In an istisnā‘ contract:
- the manufacturer (ṣāni‘) should supply the construction or manufacturing materials.
- the contract changes in nature and may become an ijārah (service) contract instead of istisnā‘.
Example
Valid Istisnā‘
A contractor agrees to build a house and personally supplies:
- cement;
- steel;
- bricks; and
- construction materials.
Ijārah Situation
A homeowner personally purchases all building materials and only hires the contractor for labour and construction work.
This arrangement resembles ijārah because the contractor mainly provides services rather than manufacturing.
4. Time of Delivery Must Be Specified
Explanation
The delivery date must be clearly determined to avoid uncertainty and future disputes.
If the seller fails to deliver on time, the purchaser may:
- accept the asset on an “as-is” basis; or
- terminate the contract.
Example
A company orders customised buses under istisnā‘.
Contract Terms
- Delivery date: 1 December 2027
- Contract price: RM2,000,000
Purchaser’s Options
The purchaser may:
- continue and accept late delivery; or
- terminate the contract due to non-compliance.
5. Place of Delivery Must Be Determined
Explanation
The delivery location should be specified, especially where:
- transportation;
- shipping; or
- loading arrangements are involved.
- delivery obligations; and
- transfer of possession.
Example
A manufacturer constructs industrial generators.
Contract Terms
- Delivery place: Port Klang, Selangor
- Delivery date: 15 March 2028
- transportation responsibilities;
- delivery completion point; and
- transfer of risk.
6. Price Must Be Determined
Explanation
The price in istisnā‘:
- must be known and agreed during the contract session.
- cash;
- deferred payment;
- progressive payment;
- usufruct; or
- other valuable consideration.
- bullet payment;
- instalments; or
- progressive payments linked to project completion stages.
- specifications; and
- price accordingly.
- the price cannot be increased merely because of an extension in payment period.
Example
A construction company agrees to build a factory.
Contract Details
- Contract price: RM10,000,000
- Payment arrangement:
- RM2,000,000 upfront
- RM4,000,000 during construction
- RM4,000,000 upon completion
- the purchaser requests additional warehouse space;
- parties revise the contract price to RM11,500,000.
The price increase is permissible because:
- specifications changed.
The seller cannot increase the price solely because:
- the purchaser requested longer payment time.
7. Possession and Ownership Transfer
Explanation
Ownership transfers to the purchaser only after:
- the purchaser takes possession of the istisnā‘ asset; and
- the asset complies with agreed specifications.
- actual possession (qabd haqīqī); or
- constructive possession (qabd hukmī).
- ownership remains with the seller;
- ownership risks are borne by the seller.
However:
- the purchaser may enter into another separate istisnā‘ contract (parallel istisnā‘) involving a similar asset.
Example
An Islamic bank commissions construction of a ship under istisnā‘.
Contract Details
- Ship construction price: RM50,000,000
- Delivery period: 3 years
- the ship remains under the ownership and risk of the manufacturer.
- the bank takes constructive possession through delivery documents and registration transfer.
- ownership transfers to the bank.
- a similar ship through a separate parallel istisnā‘ arrangement.
- Published on
Islamic Contract – Bay’ al-Istisnā‘: Legality of Istisnā‘
Q1: What is the legal basis for the permissibility of istisnā‘?
Answer:
According to Muslim jurists, the legality of the istisnā‘ contract is established through various Islamic legal sources, including:
Q2: What evidence from the Sunnah supports the legality of istisnā‘?
Answer:
The legality of istisnā‘ is supported by a narration reported by Nāfi‘:
“Abdullāh ibn ‘Umar reported that Prophet Muhammad (SAW) requested that a ring be manufactured for him.”
(Ahmad, 2001, hadith no. 12360)
This hadith demonstrates that:
Q3: How does ijmā‘ support the legality of istisnā‘?
Answer:
According to Hanafi jurists, istisnā‘ is also legitimised through:
ijmā‘ (consensus of Muslim jurists).
They argue that:
Q4: What is the role of qiyās and istihsān in legitimising istisnā‘?
Answer:
Qiyās (Analogy)
Jurists use analogy to compare istisnā‘ with other recognised sale contracts involving future delivery and specified assets.
Istihsān (Juristic Preference)
Hanafi jurists particularly rely on istihsān because:
Case Study 1: Manufacturing of Custom Furniture
A hotel owner contracts a furniture manufacturer to produce 200 customised chairs.
Contract Details
Case Study 2: Construction of a Commercial Building
A company appoints a contractor to construct a warehouse under an istisnā‘ arrangement.
Contract Details
Notes: Legal Basis of Istisnā‘
Sunnah
Istisnā‘ is permitted because it facilitates:
Q1: What is the legal basis for the permissibility of istisnā‘?
Answer:
According to Muslim jurists, the legality of the istisnā‘ contract is established through various Islamic legal sources, including:
- the Sunnah;
- ijmā‘ (consensus);
- qiyās (analogy); and
- istihsān (juristic preference).
Q2: What evidence from the Sunnah supports the legality of istisnā‘?
Answer:
The legality of istisnā‘ is supported by a narration reported by Nāfi‘:
“Abdullāh ibn ‘Umar reported that Prophet Muhammad (SAW) requested that a ring be manufactured for him.”
(Ahmad, 2001, hadith no. 12360)
This hadith demonstrates that:
- the Prophet (SAW) requested the manufacture of an item according to specifications; and
- the manufactured item was to be produced in the future.
Q3: How does ijmā‘ support the legality of istisnā‘?
Answer:
According to Hanafi jurists, istisnā‘ is also legitimised through:
ijmā‘ (consensus of Muslim jurists).
They argue that:
- people have continuously practised istisnā‘ transactions throughout different periods of Islamic history;
- scholars did not object to this widespread commercial practice.
Q4: What is the role of qiyās and istihsān in legitimising istisnā‘?
Answer:
Qiyās (Analogy)
Jurists use analogy to compare istisnā‘ with other recognised sale contracts involving future delivery and specified assets.
Istihsān (Juristic Preference)
Hanafi jurists particularly rely on istihsān because:
- strict analogy may initially disallow selling something not yet in existence;
- however, commercial necessity and public interest justify allowing istisnā‘.
- manufacturing;
- construction; and
- economic activities essential for society.
Case Study 1: Manufacturing of Custom Furniture
A hotel owner contracts a furniture manufacturer to produce 200 customised chairs.
Contract Details
- Total contract price: RM80,000
- Manufacturing period: 4 months
- Specifications:
- wood type;
- dimensions;
- colour;
- design.
- The chairs do not yet exist at the time of contract.
- The manufacturer agrees to produce them according to specifications.
- The transaction reflects the essence of istisnā‘.
- Its permissibility is supported by the Sunnah and customary commercial practice.
Case Study 2: Construction of a Commercial Building
A company appoints a contractor to construct a warehouse under an istisnā‘ arrangement.
Contract Details
- Construction price: RM2,500,000
- Completion period: 24 months
- Payment schedule:
- RM500,000 upfront;
- RM1,000,000 during construction;
- RM1,000,000 upon completion.
- The building will be constructed in the future.
- Specifications and delivery timeline are predetermined.
- Payment arrangement is flexible.
- The contract reflects established customary practice accepted by Muslim jurists.
- Sunnah;
- ijmā‘;
- qiyās; and
- istihsān.
Notes: Legal Basis of Istisnā‘
Sunnah
- Prophet Muhammad (SAW) requested manufactured items.
- Hadith supports permissibility of manufacturing contracts.
- Continuous practice of istisnā‘ accepted by Muslim jurists.
- No significant objection from scholars historically.
- Analogy with other valid commercial contracts.
- Juristic preference based on commercial necessity and public interest.
Istisnā‘ is permitted because it facilitates:
- trade;
- manufacturing;
- infrastructure development; and
- societal economic needs within Shariah principles.
- Published on
Islamic Contract — Sale Contracts
The most important group of contracts in Islamic commercial law is the sale contract. Throughout history, sales have played a crucial role in economic activities and commercial transactions. In Islam, sale contracts are strongly emphasized as lawful and legitimate means of conducting business and generating profit.
The Qur’an specifically recognizes sale (Bayʿ) as permissible and distinguishes it from Riba (interest or usury). Allah says in the Qur’an, Chapter 2, Verse 275:
“Allah has permitted trade and prohibited Riba.”
This verse establishes that trade and sale contracts are lawful alternatives to interest-based transactions.
The term Bayʿ in Islamic law includes:
Generally, a sale contract involves:
For example, when exchanging ribawi items such as gold, silver, or currencies:
Although sale contracts are generally free from Riba, they may still be affected by Gharar (uncertainty or ambiguity). Gharar usually occurs when there is insufficient knowledge or clarity regarding:
Sale contracts consist of many different types and classifications. These classifications explain the features, functions, and mechanisms of each contract. In practice, some classifications may overlap because one contract can possess multiple characteristics at the same time.
The most important group of contracts in Islamic commercial law is the sale contract. Throughout history, sales have played a crucial role in economic activities and commercial transactions. In Islam, sale contracts are strongly emphasized as lawful and legitimate means of conducting business and generating profit.
The Qur’an specifically recognizes sale (Bayʿ) as permissible and distinguishes it from Riba (interest or usury). Allah says in the Qur’an, Chapter 2, Verse 275:
“Allah has permitted trade and prohibited Riba.”
This verse establishes that trade and sale contracts are lawful alternatives to interest-based transactions.
The term Bayʿ in Islamic law includes:
- Sale of ownership of an asset
- Sale of usufruct or right to use an asset
Generally, a sale contract involves:
- Exchange of commodity for another commodity (barter trade)
- Exchange of commodity for money (ordinary sale)
- Exchange of money for money (currency exchange)
- Commodity-for-commodity exchanges
- Money-for-money exchanges
For example, when exchanging ribawi items such as gold, silver, or currencies:
- Equality in amount may be required
- Immediate exchange (spot transaction) may be compulsory
Although sale contracts are generally free from Riba, they may still be affected by Gharar (uncertainty or ambiguity). Gharar usually occurs when there is insufficient knowledge or clarity regarding:
- The subject matter of the sale
- Quality or specification of goods
- Price or consideration
- Delivery terms
Sale contracts consist of many different types and classifications. These classifications explain the features, functions, and mechanisms of each contract. In practice, some classifications may overlap because one contract can possess multiple characteristics at the same time.