THE ULTIMATE

Kembara XTRA 

Published on
Overview of Classification of Contract in Islamic Commercial Law


Contract
Contracts in Islamic commercial law are generally divided into:
  1. Bilateral Contracts
  2. Unilateral Contracts


Bilateral Contracts
Definition
A bilateral contract is an agreement where both parties have mutual obligations and responsibilities.


Work or Services Contracts
Definition
Contracts involving performance of work or provision of services for compensation.


Commission-based contract
Islamic Contract
Juʿālah (الجعالة)
Definition
A contract where a person receives commission or reward for completing a specific task or service.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Client offers reward for completing task.
  2. Service provider performs work.
  3. Reward/commission paid upon successful completion.
Example
Brokerage or reward-based services.


Agency-based contract
Islamic Contract
Wakālah (الوكالة)
Definition
A contract where one party acts on behalf of another party.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Principal appoints agent.
  2. Agent performs authorized tasks.
  3. Agent may receive agreed fee.
Example
Investment agency services.


Safe Custody Contracts
Definition
Contracts involving safekeeping and protection of assets.


Transfer of debt
Islamic Contract
Ḥiwālah (الحوالة)
Definition
Transfer of debt obligation from one party to another.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Original debtor transfers liability.
  2. New debtor accepts responsibility.
  3. Creditor claims payment from new debtor.
Example
Remittance transactions.


Security Contracts
Definition
Contracts that provide assurance or security against default.


Guarantee
Islamic Contract
Kafālah (الكفالة)
Definition
A contract where a guarantor guarantees another person’s obligation.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Guarantor undertakes responsibility.
  2. Debtor fulfills obligation.
  3. Guarantor compensates if default occurs.
Example
Bank guarantees.


Pledge
Islamic Contract
Rahn (الرهن)
Definition
A contract where an asset is pledged as collateral for debt.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Borrower pledges asset.
  2. Creditor holds collateral.
  3. Asset may be sold upon default.
Example
Islamic pawn broking.


Partnership Contracts
Definition
Contracts involving cooperation between parties to conduct business and share profit or loss.


Partnership by reputation
Islamic Contract
Shirkat al-Wujūh (شركة الوجوه)
Definition
A partnership based on reputation or creditworthiness without capital contribution.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Partners obtain goods using reputation.
  2. Goods sold in market.
  3. Profit shared according to agreement.
Example
Trading partnership based on reputation.


Partnership by work and services
Islamic Contract
Shirkat al-Abdān (شركة الأبدان)
Definition
A partnership where partners contribute labor, expertise, or services instead of capital.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Partners jointly provide services.
  2. Income generated from work.
  3. Profit shared according to agreement.
Example
Professional consultancy partnership.


Partnership by capital
Islamic Contract
Shirkat al-Amwāl (شركة الأموال)
Definition
A partnership where all partners contribute capital.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Partners invest capital.
  2. Business conducted jointly.
  3. Profit shared according to agreement.
  4. Loss shared according to capital contribution.
Example
Business joint venture.


Partnership by combining capital and work
Islamic Contract
Muḍārabah (المضاربة)
Definition
A partnership where one party contributes capital and another contributes expertise or management.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Investor provides funds.
  2. Entrepreneur manages business.
  3. Profit shared according to agreed ratio.
  4. Financial loss borne by investor unless negligence occurs.
Example
Investment financing.


Leasing Contracts
Definition
Contracts transferring right to use an asset for rental payment.


Financial lease
Islamic Contract
Ijārah Muntahiyah bi al-Tamlīk (الإجارة المنتهية بالتمليك)
Definition
A lease where ownership may transfer to lessee at end of contract.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Lessor purchases asset.
  2. Asset leased to customer.
  3. Customer pays rental installments.
  4. Ownership transferred at maturity if agreed.
Example
Islamic home financing.


Operating lease
Islamic Contract
Ijārah (الإجارة)
Definition
A lease where ownership remains with lessor permanently.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Asset leased temporarily.
  2. Customer uses asset.
  3. Asset returned after lease period.
Example
Vehicle rental.


Sale Contracts
Definition
Contracts involving transfer of ownership for consideration.


Subject Matter of Sale
Currency
Islamic Contract
Bayʿ al-Ṣarf (بيع الصرف)
Definition
A contract involving exchange of currencies or monetary values.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Two currencies exchanged.
  2. Exchange rate agreed upon.
  3. Immediate possession required.
Example
Foreign exchange transactions.


Rights or intangible properties
Islamic Contract
Ḥaqq Mālī (حق مالي)
Definition
Transfer or sale involving intangible rights or non-physical properties.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Rights legally recognized.
  2. Rights transferred contractually.
Example
Intellectual property rights.


Receivable
Islamic Contract
Bayʿ al-Dayn (بيع الدين)
Definition
A contract involving transfer or sale of receivables/debt.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Creditor owns receivable.
  2. Receivable transferred or settled.
Example
Trade receivable financing.


Tangible asset
Islamic Contract
Bayʿ (البيع)
Definition
A sale involving physical assets with material existence.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Asset ownership transferred.
  2. Buyer pays agreed price.
Example
Property or machinery sale.


Cost or Profit Classification
Discounted-based sale
Islamic Contract
Waḍīʿah (الوضيعة)
Definition
A sale where seller offers asset below original purchase price.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Seller discloses lower sale price.
  2. Buyer purchases at discounted value.
Example
Discount or clearance sale.


Cost-based sale
Islamic Contract
Tawliyah (التولية)
Definition
A sale where seller transfers asset at original cost without profit.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Seller discloses actual cost.
  2. Asset sold at same purchase price.
Example
Friendly transfer sale.


Negotiated sale
Islamic Contract
Musāwamah (المساومة)
Definition
A sale where price is negotiated without disclosure of original cost.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Buyer and seller negotiate freely.
  2. Agreed price finalized.
  3. Ownership transferred.
Example
Ordinary market trading.


Cost plus profit
Islamic Contract
Murābaḥah (المرابحة)
Definition
A sale where seller discloses cost and adds known profit margin.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Seller purchases asset.
  2. Cost and profit disclosed.
  3. Buyer pays agreed price.
Example
Islamic financing facility.


Time of Payment Classification
Future payment sale
Islamic Contract
Bayʿ Muʾajjal (بيع مؤجل)
Definition
A sale where payment is deferred to a future date.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Asset delivered immediately.
  2. Payment made later according to agreement.
Example
Installment financing.


Spot payment sale
Islamic Contract
Bayʿ Naqdan (بيع نقداً)
Definition
A sale where payment is made immediately.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Buyer pays instantly.
  2. Seller transfers asset immediately.
Example
Cash purchase.


Time of Delivery of Object
Future delivery sale
Islamic Contract
Bayʿ al-Salam (بيع السلم)
Definition
A sale where delivery occurs at a future date while payment is made upfront.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Buyer pays in advance.
  2. Seller delivers goods later.
Example
Agricultural financing.


Spot delivery sale
Islamic Contract
Bayʿ Ḥāl (بيع حال)
Definition
A sale where delivery occurs immediately after agreement.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Contract finalized.
  2. Goods transferred immediately.
Example
Retail purchase transaction.


Loan Contracts
Islamic Contract
Qard (القرض)
Definition
A contract involving temporary transfer of money with obligation to repay equivalent amount without interest.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Lender provides money.
  2. Borrower uses funds temporarily.
  3. Borrower repays equivalent amount only.
Example
Qard Hasan financing.


Unilateral Contracts
Definition
Contracts formed through declaration or commitment by one party only.


Will
Islamic Contract
Waṣiyyah (الوصية)
Definition
A declaration regarding distribution of property after death.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Person specifies beneficiaries.
  2. Will becomes effective after death.
  3. Assets distributed accordingly.
Example
Islamic estate planning.


Waiver
Islamic Contract
Ibrāʾ (الإبراء)
Definition
Voluntary release or forgiveness of obligation or right.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Creditor waives obligation.
  2. Debtor’s liability reduced or removed.
Example
Debt rebate.


Donation
Islamic Contract
Ṣadaqah (الصدقة)
Definition
Voluntary charitable transfer of wealth without compensation.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Donor gives asset voluntarily.
  2. Recipient receives ownership.
Example
Charitable donation.


Gift
Islamic Contract
Hibah (الهبة)
Definition
Voluntary transfer of ownership without consideration.
Mechanism of Action
  1. Donor offers gift.
  2. Recipient accepts.
  3. Ownership transfers immediately.
Example
Gift from bank to depositor.

​
Picture
Published on
​Islamic Contract – Bay’ al-Salam: Legality of Salam
Q1: What is the legal basis for the permissibility of salam?
Answer
The legality of the salam contract is established through:
  • the Qur’ān;
  • the Sunnah; and
  • ijmā‘ (consensus of Muslim jurists).
Salam is recognised as a valid exception to the general prohibition of:
selling something that does not yet exist (bay‘ al-ma‘dūm).
This exception was permitted because of:
  • commercial necessity;
  • public interest; and
  • the needs of farmers and producers.


Q2: What is the Qur’ānic basis for salam?
Answer
The permissibility of salam is deduced from the following verse of the Qur’ān:
“You who believe, when you contract a debt for a stated term, put it down in writing…”
(Qur’ān, 2:282)
Ibn ‘Abbās explained that:
  • this verse includes salam transactions because salam creates:
a debt obligation involving future delivery of goods.
The verse also emphasises:
  • proper documentation;
  • specified terms;
  • contractual certainty.
These are important elements in salam contracts.


Q3: What evidence from the Sunnah supports salam?
Answer
Ibn ‘Abbās reported that:
when the Prophet Muhammad (SAW) migrated to Madinah,
people were engaging in salam transactions involving fruits for:
  • one year;
  • two years;
  • or three years.
The Prophet (SAW) then said:
“Whoever pays money in advance for something should pay it for a specified measure or specified weight for delivery on a specified date.”
(al-Bukhāri, hadith no. 2240)
This hadith establishes several important conditions of salam:
  • full advance payment;
  • specified quantity;
  • specified quality;
  • specified delivery date.


Q4: Why was salam permitted although it involves future goods?
Answer
Normally, Islamic law prohibits:
selling non-existent goods (bay‘ al-ma‘dūm)
because it may lead to:
  • uncertainty (gharar);
  • disputes;
  • injustice.
However, salam was exceptionally permitted because:
  • farmers and producers required advance financing;
  • they needed working capital before harvest or production.
Salam therefore:
  • supports economic activity;
  • assists agricultural communities;
  • provides Shariah-compliant financing.


Q5: What is the role of ijmā‘ in salam?
Answer
Muslim jurists unanimously accepted:
the permissibility of salam.
This scholarly consensus (ijmā‘) developed because:
  • salam was widely practised;
  • the Prophet (SAW) approved it;
  • society had genuine commercial need for it.
Thus:
  • all major schools of Islamic jurisprudence recognise salam as permissible.


Case Study 1: Farmer Salam Financing
A rice farmer requires money before planting season.
A trader enters into salam contract with the farmer.
Contract Details
  • Commodity: 20,000 kg of rice
  • Salam price: RM100,000
  • Payment: fully paid immediately
  • Delivery date: 1 December 2028
The farmer uses the money for:
  • seeds;
  • fertiliser;
  • labour costs.


Analysis
  • Full payment made upfront.
  • Delivery deferred.
  • Commodity clearly specified.
This arrangement:
  • helps farmer obtain capital;
  • complies with salam requirements.
Result
✅ Valid salam contract.


Case Study 2: Palm Oil Producer Financing
An Islamic bank finances a palm oil producer using salam.
Contract Details
  • Commodity: 200 tonnes crude palm oil
  • Salam price: RM800,000
  • Delivery period: 8 months
The bank:
  • pays full price immediately.
The producer:
  • delivers palm oil after production.


Analysis
The salam contract:
  • provides immediate liquidity to producer;
  • secures future commodity supply for bank.
Result
✅ Permissible salam arrangement.


Important Principle
Salam is permitted because:
  • it fulfils genuine commercial needs;
  • it assists producers and farmers;
  • it facilitates economic activity.
However:
  • strict conditions apply to minimise:
    • uncertainty (gharar);
    • disputes;
    • exploitation.
These conditions include:
  • full upfront payment;
  • specified quantity;
  • specified quality;
  • specified delivery date.

Picture
Published on
Islamic Contract – Difference Between Bay’ al-Salam and Bay’ al-Istisnā‘
Q1: What is the main difference between salam and istisnā‘?
Answer
Although both contracts involve:
  • future delivery of goods,
they differ in several important aspects such as:
  • nature of asset;
  • payment method;
  • purpose of contract;
  • type of goods involved.


1. Nature of Subject Matter
Salam
Salam involves:
fungible and standardised commodities.
Examples:
  • rice;
  • wheat;
  • sugar;
  • palm oil.
The goods:
  • are usually generic;
  • measurable by weight or quantity.


Istisnā‘
Istisnā‘ involves:
manufactured or constructed assets.
Examples:
  • houses;
  • aircraft;
  • ships;
  • machinery.
The assets:
  • are produced or constructed according to specifications.


Example
Salam
Purchase of:
  • 10 tonnes of wheat for future delivery.


Istisnā‘
Construction of:
  • customised factory machinery.


2. Payment Method
Salam
The purchase price:
must be fully paid upfront at the contract session.
This is a mandatory condition.


Istisnā‘
Payment is flexible.
It may be:
  • upfront;
  • progressive;
  • deferred;
  • upon completion.


Example
Salam
Buyer pays:
  • RM50,000 immediately
    for future rice delivery.


Istisnā‘
Customer pays:
  • progressively during house construction.


3. Existence of Asset
Salam
Goods:
  • usually exist naturally in future,
    such as:
  • future crops or commodities.


Istisnā‘
Asset:
  • must be manufactured or constructed.
Human work and production are essential.


Example
Salam
Future harvest of dates.


Istisnā‘
Manufacturing of aircraft.


4. Purpose of Contract
Salam
Mainly used to:
  • finance farmers;
  • support commodity producers;
  • provide working capital.


Istisnā‘
Mainly used for:
  • construction financing;
  • manufacturing projects;
  • infrastructure development.


Example
Salam
Advance financing for rice farmer.


Istisnā‘
Financing construction of highway.


5. Possibility of Contract Cancellation
Salam
Generally:
  • cannot be unilaterally cancelled after conclusion because price fully prepaid.


Istisnā‘
Some jurists allow:
  • greater flexibility before manufacturing starts.


6. Type of Goods
Salam
Requires:
fungible goods.
Meaning:
  • interchangeable;
  • standardised.


Istisnā‘
Can involve:
unique customised manufactured assets.


Example
Salam
Crude palm oil.


Istisnā‘
Custom-designed luxury yacht.


Case Study 1: Salam Contract
A farmer requires financing before harvest.
Contract Details
  • Commodity: 15,000 kg rice
  • Salam price: RM90,000
  • Payment: fully prepaid
  • Delivery: after 8 months
Analysis
  • Commodity-based contract.
  • Full advance payment required.
Result
✅ Salam.


Case Study 2: Istisnā‘ Contract
A company orders customised factory equipment.
Contract Details
  • Equipment value: RM5,000,000
  • Manufacturing period: 18 months
  • Payment:
    • 30% upfront;
    • 40% during production;
    • 30% upon delivery.
Analysis
  • Asset manufactured according to specifications.
  • Flexible payment allowed.
Result
✅ Istisnā‘.


Simplified Comparison Between Salam and Istisnā‘
Salam
Subject Matter
Fungible commodities.
Payment
Full upfront payment compulsory.
Nature
Forward commodity sale.
Examples
Rice, wheat, sugar.
Main Purpose
Agricultural and commodity financing.


Istisnā‘
Subject Matter
Manufactured or constructed assets.
Payment
Flexible payment arrangements.
Nature
Manufacturing/construction contract.
Examples
Buildings, aircraft, machinery.
Main Purpose
Construction and project financing.


Easy Way to Remember
Salam
➡️ “Pay now, receive standard commodity later.”


Istisnā‘
➡️ “Manufacture or construct customised asset for future delivery.”

​
Picture
Published on
Islamic Contract – Bay’ al-Salam: Meaning of Fungible Goods
Q1: What are fungible goods?
Answer
Fungible goods are:
goods that are interchangeable with other goods of the same type, quality, and quantity.
This means:
  • one unit can replace another identical unit without significant difference in value.
In other words:
the exact individual item is not important,
as long as the replacement has:
  • the same specifications;
  • same quality;
  • same quantity.


Simple Explanation
If you borrow:
  • 1 kilogram of rice,
you do not need to return:
  • the exact same grains of rice.
You only need to return:
  • rice of equivalent type and quality.
That is why rice is:
✅ fungible.


Q2: Why are fungible goods important in salam contracts?
Answer
In salam:
  • the goods do not yet exist at the time of contract.
Therefore:
  • the goods must be standardised and easily describable.
Fungible goods are suitable because:
  • they can be precisely specified by:
    • weight;
    • quantity;
    • grade;
    • quality.
This reduces:
  • uncertainty (gharar);
  • disputes upon delivery.


Examples of Fungible Goods
Agricultural Commodities
  • rice;
  • wheat;
  • sugar;
  • dates;
  • palm oil.


Raw Materials
  • cement;
  • steel bars;
  • flour;
  • crude oil.


Standardised Goods
  • identical bottled water;
  • standard fuel;
  • generic manufactured items.


Example 1: Fungible Goods in Salam
A buyer enters salam contract for:
  • 5,000 kg of Grade A rice.
Analysis
Rice is:
  • measurable;
  • standardised;
  • interchangeable.
The farmer can deliver:
  • any rice meeting agreed specifications.
Result
✅ Suitable fungible good for salam.


Example 2: Crude Palm Oil
An Islamic bank purchases:
  • 100 tonnes of crude palm oil through salam.
Analysis
Palm oil is:
  • standardised by industrial grading;
  • measurable by quantity and quality.
Result
✅ Fungible good.


Q3: What are non-fungible goods?
Answer
Non-fungible goods are:
unique items that cannot easily be replaced by identical equivalents.
Each item has:
  • distinct characteristics;
  • unique value.


Examples of Non-Fungible Goods
  • specific artwork;
  • antique furniture;
  • unique houses;
  • rare collectibles;
  • customised handmade products.


Example 3: Non-Fungible Asset
A buyer wants:
  • a specific painting by a famous artist.
Analysis
The exact painting matters.
Another painting:
  • cannot replace it.
Result
❌ Non-fungible good.


Q4: Why are non-fungible goods generally unsuitable for salam?
Answer
Salam requires:
  • precise standardisation;
  • certainty of specifications.
Unique assets create:
  • uncertainty;
  • disputes over equivalence and quality.
Therefore:
  • salam generally applies to fungible commodities,
    not:
  • unique individual assets.


Comparison Between Fungible and Non-Fungible Goods
Fungible Goods
Characteristics
  • Interchangeable.
  • Standardised.
  • Measurable.
Examples
  • rice;
  • wheat;
  • sugar;
  • fuel.
Suitable for Salam?
✅ Yes


Non-Fungible Goods
Characteristics
  • Unique.
  • Individually distinguishable.
  • Not interchangeable.
Examples
  • artwork;
  • antique car;
  • unique property.
Suitable for Salam?
❌ Generally no


Important Principle
Salam contracts require:
  • certainty;
  • standardisation;
  • precise specification.
Therefore:
fungible goods are ideal because they minimise uncertainty and contractual disputes.

​
Picture
Published on
​Islamic Contract – Bay’ al-Istisnā‘: Types of Istisnā‘

Q1: What are the types of istisnā‘ contracts?
​Answer:
The istisnā‘ contract is generally categorised into two types:
  1. Ordinary Istisnā‘
  2. Parallel Istisnā‘

Q2: What is Ordinary Istisnā‘?
Answer:
Ordinary istisnā‘ involves only two contracting parties:
  • the purchaser (mustaṣni‘); and
  • the manufacturer (ṣāni‘).
Under this arrangement:
  • the purchaser requests the manufacturer to construct or manufacture an asset according to specified descriptions;
  • the parties agree on the contract price;
  • payment may be made:
    • upfront,
    • progressively, or
    • on a deferred basis; and
  • delivery takes place on an agreed future date.
The manufacturer is directly responsible for producing the asset requested by the purchaser.

Case Study 1: Ordinary Istisnā‘
A restaurant owner orders customised kitchen equipment from a manufacturer.
Contract Details
  • Asset: Industrial kitchen equipment
  • Contract price: RM150,000
  • Manufacturing period: 6 months
  • Payment arrangement:
    • RM50,000 upfront;
    • RM50,000 during production;
    • RM50,000 upon delivery.
The purchaser directly contracts with the manufacturer to produce the equipment according to agreed specifications.
Analysis
  • Only two parties are involved:
    • purchaser (mustaṣni‘);
    • manufacturer (ṣāni‘).
  • The manufacturer directly produces the asset.
  • Delivery occurs in the future.
This is an example of ordinary istisnā‘.

Q3: What is Parallel Istisnā‘?
Answer:
Parallel istisnā‘ involves:
  • three contracting parties; and
  • two separate istisnā‘ contracts.
First ContractBetween:
  • the ultimate purchaser (mustaṣni‘); and
  • the seller (ṣāni‘).
Under this contract:
  • the seller agrees to deliver a specifically described asset to the ultimate purchaser.
Second Contract (Parallel Istisnā‘)Between:
  • the seller (who now becomes the mustaṣni‘); and
  • the actual manufacturer (ṣāni‘).
In this second contract:
  • the seller appoints another party to manufacture or construct the asset.
Importantly:
  • the two contracts must remain separate;
  • one contract must not be legally contingent upon the other.
This separation ensures Shariah compliance and avoids combining contractual obligations improperly.

Case Study 2: Parallel Istisnā‘
An Islamic bank provides financing for the construction of a factory.
First Istisnā‘ ContractBetween:
  • Customer (ultimate purchaser); and
  • Islamic bank.
Contract Details
  • Factory construction price: RM5,000,000
  • Delivery period: 24 months
The Islamic bank agrees to deliver the completed factory to the customer.

Second Istisnā‘ Contract (Parallel Istisnā‘)Between:
  • Islamic bank; and
  • construction company.
Contract Details
  • Construction cost payable by bank to contractor: RM4,200,000
  • Construction period: 24 months
The construction company undertakes the actual construction work.

Analysis
  • Two separate contracts exist.
  • The customer has no contractual relationship with the contractor.
  • The Islamic bank acts as intermediary.
  • The bank profits from the difference between:
    • selling price to customer = RM5,000,000;
    • construction cost = RM4,200,000.
Profit Calculation[
RM5,000,000 - RM4,200,000 = RM800,000

The bank’s profit from the parallel istisnā‘ arrangement is RM800,000.

Notes: Differences Between Ordinary Istisnā‘ and Parallel Istisnā‘Ordinary Istisnā‘
  • Involves only two parties.
  • Purchaser directly contracts with manufacturer.
  • Single istisnā‘ contract.
  • Manufacturer personally produces the asset.
Parallel Istisnā‘
  • Involves three parties.
  • Consists of two separate istisnā‘ contracts.
  • Seller may subcontract manufacturing to another party.
  • Commonly used in Islamic banking and project financing.
  • Contracts must remain legally independent.

Important Shariah Principle in parallel istisnā‘:
  • each contract must stand independently;
  • performance of one contract cannot be made legally conditional upon the other;
  • this preserves contractual certainty and Shariah compliance.
Picture
Published on
​Islamic Contract – Bay’ al-Istisnā‘: Determination of the Delivery Date in Istisnā‘ Contracts
Q1: Why is the delivery date important in an istisnā‘ contract?
Answer:
The delivery date is important in an istisnā‘ contract because:
  • the subject matter does not yet exist at the time of contract;
  • the asset will only be manufactured or constructed in the future.
Therefore, determining the delivery timeline helps:
  • remove uncertainty (gharar);
  • avoid disputes between parties; and
  • ensure contractual certainty regarding completion and handover.


Q2: What is the AAOIFI position regarding the delivery date?
Answer
According to AAOIFI Shariah Standard (Para 2/2/1):
  • the delivery date must be determined if necessary.
This means:
  • flexibility is allowed in certain situations;
  • especially where customary business practice sufficiently determines delivery expectations.
AAOIFI adopts a relatively flexible approach depending on:
  • nature of the manufactured asset;
  • industry custom; and
  • practical commercial circumstances.


Q3: What is the BNM position regarding the delivery date?
Answer
According to the Bank Negara Malaysia (BNM) Policy Document on Istisnā‘ (Para 10.2):
the istisnā‘ contract must include the time of delivery.
Under BNM:
  • specifying the delivery date is mandatory;
  • the delivery timeline must be clearly stated in the contract.
This stricter approach aims to:
  • increase legal certainty;
  • strengthen risk management; and
  • reduce future contractual disputes.


Comparison Notes: AAOIFI vs BNM on Delivery Date
AAOIFI Position
  • Delivery date determined if necessary.
  • More flexible approach.
  • May rely on customary business practice.
BNM Position
  • Delivery date must be specified.
  • Mandatory contractual requirement.
  • Greater emphasis on certainty and documentation.


Case Study 1: AAOIFI Flexible Approach
A customer enters into an istisnā‘ contract for handcrafted furniture.
Contract Details
  • Asset: Handmade luxury furniture
  • Contract price: RM80,000
The contract states:
“Delivery shall be made upon completion according to normal industry practice.”
No exact delivery date is specified because:
  • handcrafted manufacturing time may vary depending on artistic customisation.
Analysis
Under AAOIFI:
  • this may be acceptable if:
    • industry custom sufficiently removes uncertainty;
    • parties understand expected completion timeframe.


Case Study 2: BNM Mandatory Delivery Date Requirement
An Islamic bank finances construction of industrial machinery under istisnā‘.
Contract Details
  • Machinery price: RM2,000,000
  • Delivery date: 30 June 2028
The contract expressly specifies:
  • exact delivery timeline;
  • installation completion schedule.
Analysis
Under BNM:
  • specifying the delivery date is compulsory;
  • this ensures:
    • certainty of obligations;
    • enforceability;
    • proper risk allocation.


Q4: What happens if the manufacturer fails to deliver on time?
Answer
If delivery is delayed:
  • the purchaser may:
    • accept late delivery;
    • renegotiate terms; or
    • terminate the contract depending on contractual provisions.
The rights of parties depend on:
  • agreed contractual terms;
  • extent of delay; and
  • applicable Shariah and legal standards.


Example of Delay in Delivery
A contractor agrees to construct a warehouse under istisnā‘.
Contract Details
  • Contract price: RM5,000,000
  • Delivery date: 1 January 2029
The contractor fails to complete construction by the agreed date.
Purchaser’s Options
The purchaser may:
  1. accept delayed completion;
  2. negotiate revised terms;
  3. terminate the contract.


Important Principle in Istisnā‘
Because istisnā‘ involves:
  • future manufacturing;
  • deferred delivery; and
  • non-existent assets at contract formation,
clear determination of:
  • specifications;
  • delivery period; and
  • contractual obligations
is essential to preserve:
  • Shariah compliance;
  • fairness; and
  • commercial certainty.

Picture
Published on
Islamic Contract – Bay’ al-Istisnā‘: Avoidance of Sale and Buyback Transactions (Bay‘ al-‘Īnah) in Ordinary and Parallel Istisnā‘
​

Q1: Why must istisnā‘ avoid bay‘ al-‘īnah?

Answer:
Islamic finance requires istisnā‘ transactions to involve:
  • genuine manufacturing;
  • real ownership transfer; and
  • actual commercial risk.
If the arrangement merely circulates assets between the same parties to obtain financing, it may resemble:
bay‘ al-‘īnah (sale and buyback transaction),
which many scholars prohibit because it may function similarly to an interest-based loan.
For this reason, AAOIFI imposes safeguards to prevent:
  • artificial transactions;
  • circular ownership structures; and
  • disguised financing arrangements.


AAOIFI Position
According to AAOIFI Shariah Standard (Para 2/2/4):
  • the manufacturer cannot be the ultimate purchaser; and
  • the ultimate purchaser cannot own more than one-third of the manufacturing facility.
This ensures:
  • independence between contracting parties;
  • genuine transfer of ownership and risk.


BNM Position
The BNM Policy Document on Istisnā‘ is:
silent on this specific restriction.
However:
  • transactions must still remain genuine and Shariah-compliant.


PART A — Ordinary Istisnā‘
1. Normal Ordinary Istisnā‘ (Permissible)
Structure
Only two parties:
  • purchaser (mustaṣni‘);
  • manufacturer (ṣāni‘).


Example
A hotel company orders customised furniture from an independent furniture manufacturer.
Contract Details
  • Furniture manufacturing price: RM500,000
  • Delivery period: 6 months
The manufacturer:
  • supplies materials;
  • manufactures furniture;
  • delivers completed furniture to hotel company.
Analysis
  • Independent parties.
  • Genuine manufacturing.
  • No buyback arrangement.
  • Real transfer of ownership and risk.
Result
✅ Valid ordinary istisnā‘.


2. Ordinary Istisnā‘ Involving Sale and Buyback (
Bay‘ al-‘Īnah)(Problematic)
Example
A company owns a furniture manufacturing factory.
The same company:
  1. asks its own factory to manufacture furniture under istisnā‘;
  2. then “purchases” the furniture from the factory through financing arrangement.
Ownership Structure
  • Customer owns 90% of manufacturing company.
Analysis
Although two legal entities appear to exist:
  • economically they are substantially the same party.
This creates concern that:
  • no genuine commercial transfer occurs;
  • transaction merely simulates financing.
Result Under AAOIFI
❌ Generally prohibited due to resemblance to bay‘ al-‘īnah.


PART B — Parallel Istisnā‘
1. Normal Parallel Istisnā‘ (Permissible)
Structure
Two separate independent contracts.


First Istisnā‘ Contract
Between:
  • customer;
  • Islamic bank.
Contract Price
RM20,000,000
The bank promises to deliver:
  • 100 buses.


Second Istisnā‘ Contract
Between:
  • Islamic bank;
  • independent manufacturer.
Manufacturing Cost
RM17,000,000
The manufacturer constructs buses for bank.


Profit Calculation
RM20,000,000 - RM17,000,000 = RM3,000,000
20,000,000 - 17,000,000 = 3,000,000
Analysis
  • Contracts are separate.
  • Manufacturer independent from customer.
  • Genuine manufacturing occurs.
  • No circular ownership.
Result
✅ Valid parallel istisnā‘.


2. Parallel Istisnā‘ Involving Sale and Buyback (
Bay‘ al-‘Īnah
) (Problematic)
Example
An Islamic bank enters into parallel istisnā‘ for aircraft manufacturing.


First Contract
Bank agrees to deliver aircraft to Airline A.
Contract Price
RM200,000,000


Second Contract
Bank appoints Manufacturer B to construct aircraft.
Manufacturing Cost
RM180,000,000


Problematic Ownership Structure
Airline A owns:
  • 80% shares in Manufacturer B.
Analysis
Although formally:
  • two separate contracts exist,
in substance:
  • customer substantially controls manufacturer.
This creates risk that:
  • the arrangement becomes a circular financing structure;
  • rather than genuine independent manufacturing.
Concern
The aircraft effectively moves:
  • from customer-controlled manufacturer;
  • back to customer.
This resembles:
sale and buyback arrangement (bay‘ al-‘īnah).
Result Under AAOIFI
❌ Generally impermissible.


Simplified Comparison
Normal Ordinary Istisnā‘
✅ Independent manufacturer and purchaser.


Ordinary Istisnā‘ with
Bay‘ al-‘Īnah
❌ Purchaser substantially controls manufacturer.


Normal Parallel Istisnā‘
✅ Independent customer, bank, and manufacturer.


Parallel Istisnā‘ with
Bay‘ al-‘Īnah
❌ Customer substantially controls manufacturer used in second contract.


Important Principle
Islamic finance requires:
  • genuine commercial activity;
  • real manufacturing risk;
  • independent contracting parties.
Transactions should not merely:
  • circulate ownership artificially;
  • disguise financing;
  • or replicate conventional interest-based lending through formal legal structures.











Picture
Published on
Islamic Contract – Bay’ al-Istisnā‘: Transfer of Ownership of Istisnā‘ Asset Under Construction
Q1: What happens to ownership of an istisnā‘ asset while it is still under construction?
Answer:
Generally, in an istisnā‘ contract:
  • ownership and risk remain with the manufacturer or seller until delivery and possession occur.
This is because:
  • the asset is still incomplete;
  • the purchaser has not yet taken possession.
However, modern Islamic finance standards discuss whether:
the purchaser may take possession of the asset even before completion.


Q2: What is the AAOIFI position regarding transfer of ownership of an under-construction istisnā‘ asset?
Answer
The AAOIFI Shariah Standard is:
silent on this issue.
This means:
  • AAOIFI does not expressly provide rules allowing or prohibiting transfer of possession of the unfinished asset during construction.
As a result:
  • classical general principles regarding possession and ownership continue to apply.


Q3: What is the BNM position regarding under-construction istisnā‘ assets?
Answer
According to the BNM Policy Document on Istisnā‘ (Para 15.6):
  • the contracting parties may agree that the purchaser takes possession of the istisnā‘ asset on an “as-is” basis while construction is still ongoing.
Once possession occurs:
  • ownership risk transfers to the purchaser;
  • the purchaser may subsequently:
    • use;
    • transfer; or
    • sell the under-construction asset to another party.
This provides greater commercial flexibility in modern project financing.


Q4: What does “as-is basis” mean?
Explanation
“As-is basis” means:
the purchaser accepts the asset in its current incomplete condition.
The purchaser:
  • acknowledges ongoing construction status;
  • assumes ownership risks from that stage onward.


Case Study 1: Traditional Position (No Transfer Before Completion)
A developer constructs an office building under istisnā‘.
Contract Details
  • Construction price: RM50,000,000
  • Completion period: 3 years
Before completion:
  • building remains under ownership and risk of developer.
The purchaser:
  • cannot yet sell the exact unfinished building because possession has not transferred.
Analysis
This reflects:
  • traditional istisnā‘ principles;
  • consistent with AAOIFI’s silence on early transfer.


Case Study 2: BNM Approach — Transfer During Construction
An Islamic bank finances construction of an apartment tower under istisnā‘.
Contract Details
  • Total project price: RM100,000,000
  • Construction progress: 60% completed
The contract states:
purchaser may take possession of the project on an “as-is basis” during construction.
The purchaser:
  • accepts current construction status;
  • assumes ownership risks from that point.


Subsequent Sale by Purchaser
After taking possession:
  • purchaser sells the under-construction apartment project to another investor for:
    • RM120,000,000
Profit Calculation
RM120,000,000 - RM100,000,000 = RM20,000,000
120,000,000 - 100,000,000 = 20,000,000
Analysis
Under BNM:
  • purchaser already took possession;
  • ownership risk transferred;
  • purchaser may now sell the under-construction asset.
Thus:
✅ permissible under BNM framework.


Q5: Why is this important in Islamic finance?
Explanation
This flexibility is important for:
  • property development financing;
  • infrastructure projects;
  • large-scale construction financing.
It allows:
  • transfer of commercial interests during construction;
  • greater liquidity in project financing.
However:
  • possession and ownership transfer must be genuine;
  • contractual responsibilities must be clearly documented.


Comparison Notes: AAOIFI vs BNM
AAOIFI Position
  • Silent regarding transfer during construction.
  • Traditional ownership principles continue to apply.
BNM Position
  • Allows purchaser to take possession on “as-is basis.”
  • Purchaser may sell under-construction asset after possession.
  • Greater commercial flexibility.


Important Shariah Principle
The key issue is:
possession and ownership risk.
Once:
  • genuine possession transfers;
  • and purchaser assumes ownership risk,
the purchaser may generally:
  • transfer or sell the asset,
even if:
  • construction is not yet fully completed.

Picture
Published on
Islamic Contract – Bay’ al-Istisnā‘: Late Delivery Charge Clause in Istisnā‘ Contracts
Q1: Why are the terms
gharamah
and
ta‘wīd
not commonly used in istisnā‘ late delivery clauses?
Answer
The terms:
  • gharamah (penalty); and
  • ta‘wīd (compensation)
are more commonly used in:
debt-based contracts such as murābahah financing.
This is because murābahah primarily creates:
  • a debt obligation owed by the customer to the bank.
Late payment in murābahah therefore concerns:
  • delayed settlement of debt.
Hence:
  • ta‘wīd compensates actual losses from delayed payment;
  • gharamah acts as a deterrent penalty against intentional default.


Why Istisnā‘ Is Different
In istisnā‘:
  • the issue is not late payment of debt;
  • the issue is:
delay in completing or delivering a manufactured/construction asset.
Therefore, the late delivery clause in istisnā‘ is usually treated as:
a contractual performance penalty clause (shart jazā’ī)
rather than:
  • debt compensation (ta‘wīd); or
  • debt penalty (gharamah).
This is because:
  • the purchaser suffers loss due to construction or manufacturing delay,
  • not due to unpaid debt.


Q2: What is the AAOIFI position regarding late delivery charges?
Answer
According to AAOIFI Shariah Standard (Para 6/6):
  • a fair penalty clause may be included in the istisnā‘ contract to compensate the purchaser if the manufacturer delays delivery.
However:
  • force majeure situations are excluded.
Examples of force majeure:
  • floods;
  • earthquakes;
  • war;
  • government restrictions.
The compensation must be:
  • fair;
  • proportionate; and
  • linked to actual contractual delay.


Q3: What is the BNM position regarding late delivery charges?
Answer
According to the BNM Policy Document on Istisnā‘ (Para 27.4):
  • the contracting parties may include:
a punitive clause (shart jazā’ī)
against the seller for late delivery.
Unlike murābahah:
  • the penalty amount may be recognised as income by the purchaser.
This is because:
  • the purchaser may suffer genuine commercial losses from project delay.


Q4: What is
shart jazā’ī
?
Answer
Shart jazā’ī means:
a contractual penalty clause agreed upon in advance for breach or delay in performance obligations.
In istisnā‘:
  • it applies when the seller/manufacturer:
    • fails to complete;
    • delays construction;
    • or delivers late.


Comparison Between Murābahah and Istisnā‘ Late Charges
Murābahah
Nature of Issue
Late payment of debt.
Terms Used
  • ta‘wīd
  • gharamah
Reason
Customer delays repayment obligation.


Istisnā‘
Nature of Issue
Late delivery or late construction.
Term Used
  • shart jazā’ī
Reason
Manufacturer delays contractual performance.


Case Study 1: Murābahah Late Payment (Ta‘wīd and Gharamah)
An Islamic bank provides murābahah vehicle financing.
Financing Details
  • Selling price: RM120,000
  • Monthly instalment: RM2,000
The customer delays payment for:
  • 5 months.
Analysis
This concerns:
  • delayed debt repayment.
Thus:
  • ta‘wīd and gharamah may apply.


Case Study 2: Istisnā‘ Late Delivery (
Shart Jazā’ī
)
A contractor agrees to construct a warehouse.
Contract Details
  • Construction price: RM10,000,000
  • Completion date: 1 January 2029
The contract states:
“Contractor shall pay RM15,000 per week for unjustified delay.”
The contractor delays completion by:
  • 6 weeks.


Penalty Calculation
15,000 times 6 = 90,000​

Result
  • Contractor pays RM90,000 to purchaser.
Analysis
This is:
  • not ta‘wīd for debt delay;
  • not gharamah for late payment.
Instead:
  • it is a contractual performance penalty (shart jazā’ī)
    for delayed completion of construction.


Case Study 3: Force Majeure Situation
A construction company builds a factory under istisnā‘.
Contract Details
  • Factory value: RM30,000,000
During construction:
  • severe earthquake damages site.
Completion delayed by:
  • 4 months.
Analysis
Delay caused by:
  • force majeure beyond contractor’s control.
Therefore:
  • penalty clause should not apply.
Result
✅ No shart jazā’ī imposed.


Important Principle
Murābahah
Late charges relate to:
debt repayment obligations.
Thus:
  • ta‘wīd and gharamah apply.


Istisnā‘
Late charges relate to:
failure to complete or deliver manufactured asset on time.
Thus:
  • shart jazā’ī applies instead.
The distinction exists because:
  • the legal nature of the obligation is different.




Picture
Published on
Islamic Contract – Bay’ al-Istisnā‘: Determination and Revision of Price Based on Cost
Q1: Can the price in an istisnā‘ contract be determined using murābahah cost-plus pricing?
Answer
According to AAOIFI, an istisnā‘ contract:
cannot be structured as a murābahah sale based on cost-plus pricing.
This means:
  • the manufacturer is not required to disclose:
    • actual construction cost; and
    • profit margin separately.
Unlike murābahah:
  • istisnā‘ is not a fiduciary (trust-based) sale.
Instead:
  • the price in istisnā‘ is based on:
mutual agreement between the contracting parties.


Why Is Istisnā‘ Different from Murābahah?
Murābahah
In murābahah:
  • seller must disclose:
    • acquisition cost;
    • profit markup.
Example:
  • Cost = RM100,000
  • Profit = RM20,000
  • Selling price = RM120,000
This is:
✅ cost-plus sale.


Istisnā‘
In istisnā‘:
  • parties only agree on:
    • final contract price.
The manufacturer does NOT need to disclose:
  • construction cost;
  • profit margin.
This is because:
  • istisnā‘ focuses on manufacturing obligation,
  • not resale of existing asset.


Q2: What is the AAOIFI position regarding price determination?
Answer
According to AAOIFI Shariah Standard (Para 3/2/5):
  • istisnā‘ cannot be converted into murābahah pricing structure;
  • determining price strictly as:
“cost + disclosed profit”
is not the nature of istisnā‘.
AAOIFI seeks to preserve:
  • the independent contractual identity of istisnā‘.


Q3: What is the BNM position regarding determination and revision of price?
Answer
According to the BNM Policy Document on Istisnā‘ (Para 16):
  • the price of the istisnā‘ asset must be determined through:
mutual agreement (agreed price)
at the time of contract.
However:
  • the agreed price may later be revised if:
    • construction costs increase; or
    • construction costs decrease.
This flexibility reflects:
  • practical realities of long-term construction and manufacturing projects.


Q4: Why does BNM allow price revision?
Answer
Large construction and manufacturing projects may face:
  • inflation;
  • increase in material prices;
  • labour cost changes;
  • design modifications.
Therefore:
  • parties may mutually agree to revise the contract price after contract formation.
However:
  • price revision must relate to:
    • actual construction cost changes;
    • specification amendments.
The price cannot be revised merely because:
  • payment period is extended.
Otherwise:
  • it may resemble ribā-based increase for deferment.


Comparison Notes: AAOIFI vs BNM
AAOIFI Position
  • Istisnā‘ cannot use murābahah cost-plus structure.
  • No requirement to disclose cost and profit separately.
  • Preserves distinct nature of istisnā‘.
BNM Position
  • Price determined by mutual agreement.
  • Price may later be revised due to construction cost changes.
  • Reflects commercial practicality.


Case Study 1: Impermissible Murābahah-Style Istisnā‘ Pricing
A contractor agrees to construct a factory.
The contract states:
  • Construction cost = RM8,000,000
  • Profit = RM2,000,000
  • Selling price = RM10,000,000
The structure explicitly treats the contract as:
“cost plus disclosed profit.”
Analysis
Under AAOIFI:
  • this resembles murābahah pricing methodology;
  • inconsistent with independent nature of istisnā‘.
Result
❌ Not preferred under AAOIFI approach.


Case Study 2: Valid Normal Istisnā‘ Pricing
A developer agrees to construct an apartment building.
Contract Terms
  • Agreed contract price = RM15,000,000
  • Delivery period = 3 years
The purchaser and developer:
  • only agree on final contract price;
  • no disclosure of construction cost or profit breakdown.
Analysis
  • Price determined through mutual agreement.
  • Contract maintains nature of istisnā‘.
Result
✅ Valid istisnā‘ pricing.


Case Study 3: Permissible Price Revision Due to Increased Construction Cost
A contractor enters into istisnā‘ contract to build a warehouse.
Original Contract
  • Agreed price = RM12,000,000
During construction:
  • steel prices increase significantly;
  • parties mutually agree to revise price upward.
Revised Price
RM13,500,000


Price Increase Calculation
13,500,000 - 12,000,000 = 1,500,000


Analysis
Price revision is permissible because:
  • actual construction costs increased;
  • both parties mutually agreed.
Result
✅ Permissible under BNM.


Case Study 4: Impermissible Price Revision Due to Extension of Payment Time
A purchaser requests:
  • additional 2 years to pay construction price.
The contractor increases price solely because of:
  • delayed payment period.
Original Price
RM10,000,000
Revised Price
RM12,000,000
Analysis
The increase is:
  • not linked to construction cost;
  • only linked to payment deferment.
This resembles:
  • increase due to time value of debt.
Result
❌ Impermissible because it may resemble ribā.


Important Principle
In istisnā‘:
  • price is based on:
    • manufacturing obligation;
    • agreed construction value.
It is NOT:
  • a trust-based cost-plus resale like murābahah.
Price revisions are only permissible when linked to:
  • genuine construction-related changes,
    not:
  • mere extension of payment time.




Picture

Author

A writer who is passionate about knowledge 

Author

Write something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview.